Slashdot Mirror


Russia Suspected In GPS-Spoofing Attacks On Ships (wired.co.uk)

How did a 37-ton tanker suddenly vanish from GPS off the coast of Russia? AmiMoJo shares a report from Wired: The ship's systems located it 25 to 30 miles away -- at Gelendzhik airport... The Atria wasn't the only ship affected by the problem... At the time, Atria's AIS system showed around 20 to 25 large boats were also marooned at Gelendzhik airport. Worried about the situation, captain Le Meur radioed the ships. The responses all confirmed the same thing: something, or someone, was meddling with the their GPS...

After trawling through AIS data from recent years, evidence of spoofing becomes clear. GPS data has placed ships at three different airports and there have been other interesting anomalies. "We would find very large oil tankers who could travel at the maximum speed at 15 knots," said a former director for Marine Transportation Systems at the U.S. Coast Guard. "Their AIS, which is powered by GPS, would be saying they had sped up to 60 to 65 knots for an hour and then suddenly stopped. They had done that several times"...

"It looks like a sophisticated attack, by somebody who knew what they were doing and were just testing the system..." says Lukasz Bonenberg from the University of Nottingham's Geospatial Institute. "You basically need to have atomic level clocks."

The U.S. Maritime Administration confirms 20 ships have been affected -- all traveling in the Black Sea -- though a U.S. Coast Guard representative "refused to comment on the incident, saying any GPS disruption that warranted further investigation would be passed onto the Department of Defence." But the captain of the 37-ton tanker already has his own suspicions. "It looks like the Russians define an area where they don't want the GPS to apply."

12 of 194 comments (clear)

  1. GPS Spoofing by iggymanz · · Score: 4, Funny

    It's all fun and games until a ship runs aground or collides with something, and an eye gets poked out

    1. Re: GPS Spoofing by bestweasel · · Score: 4, Funny

      They thought they were in the Mediterranean but something was wrong with their GPS.

    2. Re: GPS Spoofing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

      Incorrect, the ottoman Empire handed Crimea over in 1783, and Crimea was a separate SSR from 21 to 45, then part of the Russian SSR from 45 to 54, then a part of the Ukrainian SSR from 54 to 91, and then a part of an independent Ukraine from 91 to 2014.

      So. Try to keep up!

  2. Time to add encryption to civilian GPS? by Baron_Yam · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The US military already encrypts GPS for themselves - it can still be jammed, but it can't be spoofed.

    Maybe it's time encryption was applied to civilian GPS as well. It's not like consumer electronics don't have the capability to handle the decryption, and it's not like you'd have to use the same keys as military GPS.

    1. Re:Time to add encryption to civilian GPS? by Nutria · · Score: 4, Insightful

      where sextants and typewriters may be brought out of mothballs before it's all said and done.

      I think the Russians have already done that.

      --
      "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
    2. Re: Time to add encryption to civilian GPS? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

      Wrong. Russia already spoofs GPS signals around Moscow to make it look like you're at the airport - sounds a lot like this. You can google the Moscow GPS events if you want.

    3. Re:Time to add encryption to civilian GPS? by mbone · · Score: 4, Interesting

      The US military already encrypts GPS for themselves - it can still be jammed, but it can't be spoofed.

      Of course it can be spoofed ("meaconned"), even if you assume that the encryption cannot be cracked. An attacker can receive the satellite signal and retransmit it. This signal will arrive at the target late, but it will still be valid - of course the attacker has to manipulate power / jamming etc to convince the receiver that the meacon signal is the valid one. You can be sure much thought has been given to this topic.

      The particular attacks in the original post appear to be related to protecting Putin. I doubt the military attacks get rolled out for such a simple purpose.

    4. Re:Time to add encryption to civilian GPS? by MountainLogic · · Score: 4, Informative

      There is indeed a separate higher resolution encrypted feed for the military. Encrypting for civilian channel use is very impractical as many many devices lack the ability to update keys (no network connection). Encryption also burn clocks and batteries. With billions of devices being made all over the world by thousands of manufacturers keeping the keys private is unrealistic. Further with only one global key to crack by state supported entities it would not last long. (yes, the old /. meme of "imagine a Beowulf cluster" does apply here).

  3. sophistication by phantomfive · · Score: 4, Interesting

    These attacks have been known for a while, and are not hard at all. All you need is a radio that is stronger than the GPS signal. It's been demonstrated multiple times at DEFCON, and there are youtube videos that show you how to do it with a hackrf radio (for example, if you want to move to a particular place while playing Pokemon Go).

    Wikipedia suggests that Russia spoofs GPS whenever Putin is in the area.

    --
    "First they came for the slanderers and i said nothing."
    1. Re:sophistication by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 5, Funny

      Wikipedia suggests that Russia spoofs GPS whenever Putin is in the area.

      No! No hack, no spoof. Putin Strong, like bull. Forceful personality warps space around him. West just jealous they not have such leader.

      --
      #DeleteChrome
  4. AIS or GPS? by Known+Nutter · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Are we spoofing GPS here, or are we spoofing AIS? Just so we're clear... GPS is obviously GPS, but the summary seems to conflate GPS and AIS. AIS is a terrestrial based VHF system which takes GPS data from individual ships adds identifiers and transmits it to anyone who cares to listen, which usually means other ships and shore-side receivers. It sounds to me like it is AIS that is being spoofed -- which would be trivial compared to GPS.

    Keep in mind that AIS is just one of several redundant systems which ships use to navigate waterways and track positions of nearby vessels.

    No investigation has indicated suspicions that Russia did anything. The only one who suspects Russia is one captain of a tanker ship.

    --
    Beware of the Leopard.
    1. Re:AIS or GPS? by Solandri · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Yeah, I monitor AIS to help decide where to take my boat fishing (track where the charter sportfishing boats are going). It's fairly common to see glitches in AIS tracks. Ships traveling at warp speed are pretty frequent too. My guess is AIS glitches and reports the same GPS position for a while (as if the ship is stationary). Then all of a sudden it reports the correct location and it looks like the ship has traveled at high speed to the new location.