Slashdot Mirror


Critics Debate Autism's Role in James Damore's Google Memo (themarysue.com)

James Damore "wants you to know he isn't using autism as an excuse," reports a Silicon Valley newspaper, commenting on the fired Google engineer's new interview with the Guardian. But they also note that "he says being on the spectrum means he 'sees things differently'," and the weekend editor at the entertainment and "geek culture" site The Mary Sue sees a problem in the way that interview was framed. It's the author of this Guardian article, not James Damore himself, who makes the harmful suggestion that Damore's infamous Google memo and subsequent doubling-down are somehow caused by his autism... It frames autism as some sort of basic decency deficiency, rather than a neurological condition shared by millions of people.... This whole article is peppered with weird suggestions like this, suggestions which detract from an otherwise interesting piece.. All these weird suggestions that autism and misogyny/bigotry are somehow tied (as if autistic feminists didn't exist) do unfortunately detract from one of the article's great points.

Having worked at a number of companies large and small, I can at least anecdotally confirm that their diversity training rarely includes a discussion of neurodiversity, and when it does, it's not particularly empathetic or helpful... Many corporate cultures are plainly designed for neurotypical extroverts and no one else -- and that should change. I really do think Lewis meant well in pointing that out. But the other thing that should change? The way the media scapegoats autism as a source of anti-social behavior.

2 of 353 comments (clear)

  1. Re:SJW are weird by AmiMoJo · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Who is? Both the Guardian and The Mary Sue have been accused of being SJWs before, so it's impossible to tell which on you are talking about.

    What specifically do you think was misrepresented?

    --
    const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
    SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
  2. Re:The medicalization of dissent by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    his uncontroversial memo (did you read it? There was nothing wrong with it.)

    There's no point in even discussing the memo with you because you will dismiss out of hand any flaws. There are more than a few, but you won't listen. Keep believing. One question though - are you also a Trump supporter? I'm sure there's not a 100% overlap, but the two seem to go hand in hand more often than chance.