HTC, Motorola Say They Don't Slow Old Phones Like Apple Does (theverge.com)

After Apple confirmed last week that it reduces the performance of older iPhones to improve battery life, it has left many wondering whether or not other smartphone manufacturers do the same. HTC and Motorola are the two most recent OEMs to say they don't throttle their phones' processor speeds as their batteries age. The Verge reports: In emails to The Verge, both companies said they do not employ similar practices with their smartphones. An HTC spokesperson said that designing phones to slow down their processor as their battery ages "is not something we do." A Motorola spokesperson said, "We do not throttle CPU performance based on older batteries." The Verge also reached out to Google, Samsung, LG, and Sony for comment on whether their phone processors are throttled in response to aging batteries. A Sony spokesperson said a response would be delayed by the holidays, and a Samsung spokesperson said the company was looking into it. The responses begin to clarify whether or not throttling processor speeds is typical behavior in smartphones -- as of last week, we knew that Apple was doing it, but not whether it was common practice among competitors. HTC and Motorola's responses start to suggest that it's not.

Comments

Apple's problem

[DontBeAMoran]

The big problem with Apple is that they take decisions on behalf of users because most of them don't know any better.

However, what they should be doing is giving us options and making their decision be the default setting.

Example:
When your battery becomes older, it will not hold a charge as long as when the phone is new. When that happens, would you like to:
[x] Keep using the phone for the same amount of time as much as possible to the detriment of processor speed and screen brightness
[_] Keep using the phone at the same processor speed and screen brightness with a shorter daily battery life

That's a bit verbose, but you get the idea.

Another example: in the older OS X versions, Preview was able to save files in SGI, SGI, TGA and other older formats. In the most recent versions (at least 10.9 and above), those older formats are no longer listed when trying to save an image. However, if you hold the [Option] key, you get them back. But you have to know that holding this key will magically give you the list of all formats supported by Preview. Why can't they display "(Hold [option] for more formats)" next to the pull-down menu?

Re:nothing to see here

[DontBeAMoran]

All they had to do was inform the user of it, and/or allow it to be disabled.

And they did neither of these, which is why people are now complaining.

Wrong.

[david_thornley]

After Apple confirmed last week that it reduces the performance of older iPhones to improve battery life

This is incorrect. It has nothing to do with battery life, and nothing to do with older iPhones per se. Put a new battery into an old iPhone and the slowing will go away. It's a matter of the battery degrading over time (which they do), and limiting the maximum power drawn from it. This means that the phone can't operate at top performance, since it can't get the power. The alternative was to risk the phone crashing at such times, not to let the battery drain faster.

Apple had the choice between limiting current draw, allowing the phone to crash, or changing the laws of physics.