Slashdot Mirror


Nest Is Done As a Standalone Alphabet Company, Merges With Google (arstechnica.com)

An anonymous reader quotes a report from Ars Technica: There's a shakeup at Nest today. Following previous rumors back in November, Google just announced Nest will no longer be a standalone Alphabet company; instead, it will merge with the Google hardware team. The current Nest CEO, Marwan Fawaz, will report to Google Hardware SVP Rick Osterloh. Google's blog post says the merger will allow it to "combine hardware, software, and services" between the two companies, which are all "built with Google's artificial intelligence and the Assistant at the core." Nest and Google have been growing closer together even without this merger, with Nest getting a spot at the "Made By Google" Pixel 2 launch event to tout Nest and Google Assistant integration. An earlier report from The Wall Street Journal said that Google and Nest already combined their supply chain teams in 2016. While Google has focused on making the "Google" brand well known in the hardware world with the Pixel phones and Google Home, CNET reports that Google won't be dumping the Nest brand.

45 comments

  1. What's the point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What's the point of this whole Alphabet thing if they're just going to start merging companies into Google anyway...

    1. Re:What's the point? by beelsebob · · Score: 3, Informative

      The point is that Alphabet absorbs the risky propositions, and allows them to cut off money to them if the risk doesn't pan out, while google remains an isolated profit making group that is insulated from risk.

    2. Re: What's the point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Less oversight aka more hookers and booze.

      I predict he can handle the tame life for about 48 hours before the dts hit and he is jerking off under the desk.

    3. Re:What's the point? by quantaman · · Score: 1

      What's the point of this whole Alphabet thing if they're just going to start merging companies into Google anyway...

      Synergies?

      When possible Google wants to split off companies as much as possible to avoid anti-trus^H^H^H^H to let each independent company focus on it's own product.

      But for something like Nest they probably think it can benefit from really close integration with Google's other services.

      --
      I stole this Sig
    4. Re:What's the point? by 4wdloop · · Score: 1

      So for this merger - did the risk pay out or are they are recycling the scraps?

      --
      4wdloop
  2. NEST - HOW TO BREAK YOUR HVAC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    it will. It will kill your heat pump. It will kill your pets. It. Will. Kill. YOU!

    Spies on you, too.

  3. Oh Noes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Prepare for assimilation!
    Your bio--- technological distinction will be added to the starlacc pit that is googles lower intestine.

    Look, you had a good run and hardley anyone asked why your only platform improvement was adding a shitty battery powered wifi camera!

  4. Fragments by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Great! Now we can expect 3 or 4 different competing Google Projects in the near future to make it utterly confusing how to control these home automation devices.

    I can't wait until there are 3 different competing Google apps for controlling my one nest thermostat, each of which won't play nice with one-another.

  5. I predict by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Over the next 3-5 years, every other Alphabet "company" will merge with Google. Then Alphabet itself will rebrand as Google.

    --
    #DeleteChrome
    1. Re:I predict by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just like the government breakup of AT&T and subsequent mergers, which saw SBC become AT&T again. Except this time Google is doing it without government intervention, proving once and for all that Google deserves to replace your government for your own good.

    2. Re:I predict by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No. The government breakup of AT&T in the 1980s has still resulted in a breakup of the old AT&T. The fact that Southwestern Bell and Cingular merged to become AT&T does not mean the old AT&T is back in any way shape or form.

      Trust me - I lived through the Ma Bell hell. It's so much better now even with the corporate mergers.

    3. Re:I predict by omnichad · · Score: 1

      Way to explain the joke. We already got it.

    4. Re:I predict by hawk · · Score: 1

      Grangoogle, so much hardware you have!

      The better to spy on you, my dear . . .

  6. Glad I dumped my NEST System by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, one less part of Google in my life.

  7. This much buzz? by bangular · · Score: 1

    I just don't get it. It's a thermostat. I feel like the nest is Lil' Sebastian and I'm Ben Wyatt.

    1. Re:This much buzz? by AvitarX · · Score: 2

      I purchased one because my free standing radiators take a while to heat up, and then keep hot for a while.

      The nest auto learns how early to turn them on and off to keep my my temperature correct and program functioning year round.

      I think that's a common feature now, but it wasn't five or so years ago.

      The fact that the house can take three hours plus to hear up makes the online feature nice when on business trips of indeterminate length too.

      --
      Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
    2. Re:This much buzz? by omnichad · · Score: 1

      Their Google Home Mini sold huge numbers last November and December. All of a sudden, the Nest is off in a corner in its own company and not together with the other home automation/control/assistant tech.

      The Nest brand is also security cameras, smoke detectors, and a doorbell.

    3. Re:This much buzz? by kamapuaa · · Score: 1

      It saves you money, and everybody likes money.

      --
      Slashdot: providing anti-social weirdos a soapbox, since 1997.
    4. Re:This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "I purchased one because my free standing radiators take a while to heat up, and then keep hot for a while.
      The nest auto learns how early to turn them on and off to keep my my temperature correct and program functioning year round.
      I think that's a common feature now, but it wasn't five or so years ago."

      sounds like:
      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

      and they have been around since the 1920's. the difference between the Nest and a PID controller is that the Nest is connected to the Internet which allows for two way connections. Meaning that you can use your phone to check your thermostat and set it but at the same time Google also gets this information as well as information that is collected from the sensors on board.

      You would have been better off with just the PID controller.

    5. Re:This much buzz? by vux984 · · Score: 1

      Every room in the upper level of my home has its own electric radiator that is independently controlled by its own thermostat. Most years I don't even turn them on. We like our rooms a little cooler, and enough heat rises from downstairs. So buying a nest wouldn't help them.

      The lower levels of the house are heated by a gas furnace; and a pretty basic thermostat operates it just fine. When i go on business trips I imagine the rest of my family and pets wish to remain their usual temperature. When we go on vacation together... either I'll lower it before I go, or i won't worry about it; the last thing I'm going to want to do on vacation is to micromanage my thermostat at home to save less money than I'll spend on a glass of wine for lunch. If I get home and its chilly... i turn on the fireplace or grab a space heater out of the garage or put on a sweater for a couple hours. I just personally can't fathom the value of an internet connected thermostat.

      Although im sure it has its niche use cases, and you seem to like yours, it just doesnt seem like the 'next big thing' to me and home automation in general just seems like a waste of cash.

      Nearly everyone i know who tries it regrets it... 10 years later they're replacing bits here and chasing gremlins there, and dealing with compatibility issues. Meanwhile the boring old manually operated windows and doors and blinds and lights in my house all work flawlessly; and are inexpensive and trivial to maintain.

    6. Re: This much buzz? by AvitarX · · Score: 1

      That all seems harder to setup then connecting two wires to a thermostat that does it for me. For one thing, a multi stage boiler would be far more expensive a retrofit than a thermostat, sure, a variable power boiler would be cool.

      I suppose instead of controlling the boiler fire, you could control the water temperature, but again, that's a pretty expensive retro fit to gravity fed system. I'm actually not aware of any boilers that work by controlling the water temperature and pumping continuously (for a small home), generally they heat the water to whatever, and pump it until it's whatever - 20 degrees,heating it again then. But if the thermostat tells it to go off, they stop pumping (and heating).

      Why they didn't use systems like that I don't know, I'm also upset that most American systems I've seen don't have room thermostats on each radiator, but that's life.

      With the Nest, I can sleep with the house in the low 60s and still wake up to the high 60s, before nest, it could take anywhere from an hour to three (depending on outside temperature) to get to the upper 60s.

      --
      Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
    7. Re: This much buzz? by AvitarX · · Score: 1

      I don't micromanage my thermostat when away, I set it to 55 when I leave, and when I get on the plane to come home set it to 65.

      I will agree, large freestanding radiators are a corner case (un updated east coast urban houses), but they are one where the nest really shines. It makes it possible to use a program at all.

      You say you have a furnace, if that were the case for me I'd be fine with anything, as forced air doesn't over shoot or take as long to heat up.

      It's auto program was useless btw. It was too aggressive at programming because I got home late one night. Though the interface to manually program it was nice.

      --
      Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
    8. Re:This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nest Thermostat works on existing wires. There will be no compatibility issues.
      Turning on the AC by shouting "OK Google, turn on the AC" still feels like magic, although not that useful. Starting the AC 30 minutes before I get home is nice when it's 90+ degree outside.

    9. Re:This much buzz? by DigiShaman · · Score: 1

      The next thermostat will essentially be another Google Home device, a yet another touch point to activate Google Assistant.

      Don't worry, I'm sure Google security cameras will be watching you...for analytical reasons. You know, making sure you're in good health while banging your SO.

      --
      Life is not for the lazy.
    10. Re: This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Damn common 5 years ago actually. My home has had it (with a darn basic, cheap as you can get Honeywell thermostat) since it was built in 2006.

    11. Re:This much buzz? by vux984 · · Score: 1

      "Nest Thermostat works on existing wires. There will be no compatibility issues."

      The compatibilty issues I was referring to was the software and apps and so forth between different evolving home automation solutions.

      "Turning on the AC by shouting "OK Google, turn on the AC" still feels like magic, although not that useful."

      OTOH telling google when nobody is home seems like a bad idea.

      "Starting the AC 30 minutes before I get home is nice when it's 90+ degree outside."

      I just have it set for when I'm usually home. Beyond that I spend maybe 3 minutes over the course of a year thinking about the temperature in my house. The idea of thinking about it 30 minutes before i get home on a daily basis and doing something about it each time just seems dreadful.

      Plus I have a bunch of people in my household and 4 people fiddling with the thermostat is 4 people too many.

    12. Re: This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Nest thermostat sold in the UK is opentherm enabled. Opentherm thermostats communicate with boilers that are opentherm capable and help control the heating system better...
      I know of one opentherm boiler in the USA and another by the end of the year.

      Hopefully they will include opentherm in the USA version of the nest in the future.

    13. Re:This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's not even a terribly good one, assuming you have a house with more than one room.

    14. Re:This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I bought one for three reasons: I needed remote access since it was for a vacation home; it talks to the Big Ass Fan we installed (though now the ecobee will too); and, not least, it looks cool.

      Two years in, it does what I bought it for.

    15. Re:This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Too soon, RIP Lil' Sebastian

    16. Re:This much buzz? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It really doesn't. The cost vs savings is pretty much equal.

      You are better off buying a low cost reprogramable Honeywell thermostat and get the exact same results and savings for 15% of the cost of a Nest thermostat.

  8. What's our aimless strategy today Brain? by Chas · · Score: 1

    The same thing is it every day Pinky!
    It's BETA AND UNSUPPORTED UNTIL WE KILL IT!

    --


    Chas - The one, the only.
    THANK GOD!!!
  9. Android phone takes photos of dessert, the Nest.. by BigBlockMopar · · Score: 1

    The point is that Alphabet absorbs the risky propositions, and allows them to cut off money to them if the risk doesn't pan out, while google remains an isolated profit making group that is insulated from risk.

    You take pictures of dessert with an Android phone, or get into a Waymo car, and your Nest thermostat will know that you're coming home and adjust the temperature for you.

    It's both genius (they/'ve perfected the programmable thermostat like the way a PVR has perfected the VCR) and scary, given the building damage it could cause if it were hacked or crash-prone and caused frozen pipes.

    I recently posted about how to install an old thermostat in parallel with the new programmable one, just to keep it as a backup.

    --
    Fire and Meat. Yummy.
  10. Reinventing the Chronotherm and Multistage Heat... by BigBlockMopar · · Score: 1

    That all seems harder to setup then connecting two wires to a thermostat that does it for me. For one thing, a multi stage boiler would be far more expensive a retrofit than a thermostat, sure, a variable power boiler would be cool.

    A multistage boiler would be nice.... but no point until you need to replace it (and even then, only if your fuel costs justify the added expense over the life of the unit).

    A 1987 Honeywell Chronotherm programmable thermostat (probably still works!) will learn, over a few days to weeks, how long it takes to heat or cool your home. You set the temperature you want when you get home at 5:PM, and it will average out the time it took to heat or cool the home, so it will figure out to turn on the AC at 3:45PM and the heat at 4:15PM.

    This technology has been used in the HVAC industry for decades now.

    I suppose instead of controlling the boiler fire, you could control the water temperature,

    Which is the idea of a multistage boiler...

    but again, that's a pretty expensive retro fit to gravity fed system.

    And won't work, gravity fed water systems and octopus hot air systems only work by the temperature gradient, the working fluid has to be hot enough to rise, and as it cools down, becomes dense enough to sink back down. It's a chimney.

    Unless you add a pump (hot water) or a fan (octopus/gravimetric furnace like in the basement of Home Alone), your heat won't create enough draft to get distributed throughout your home. Your boiler or furnace would end up cycling constantly but the radiators/floor vents would remain cool.

    I'm actually not aware of any boilers that work by controlling the water temperature and pumping continuously (for a small home), generally they heat the water to whatever, and pump it until it's whatever - 20 degrees,heating it again then. But if the thermostat tells it to go off, they stop pumping (and heating).

    Why they didn't use systems like that I don't know, I'm also upset that most American systems I've seen don't have room thermostats on each radiator, but that's life.

    With the Nest, I can sleep with the house in the low 60s and still wake up to the high 60s, before nest, it could take anywhere from an hour to three (depending on outside temperature) to get to the upper 60s.

    In most parts of North America, we have a more extreme climate than in most parts of Europe and the rest of the world. I live in Ottawa, Canada. It was -30C for our first week in January, -40C equivalent when you factor in how fast the wind cools warm objects like people and houses.... and it easily reaches over 30C every summer.

    Our HVAC systems are pretty robust. You have an old house with a gravimetric system. You cannot have multistage (though you did just reinvent it) without finding some way to replace convection with a pump or fan.

    --
    Fire and Meat. Yummy.
  11. We are Google... by Hallux-F-Sinister · · Score: 1

    You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile.

    --
    Our reign has gone on long enough. Indeed. Summon the meteors.
    1. Re:We are Google... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      As if I would trust the HVAC in my home to an Internet homed device. LOL, enjoy your frozen house when you come home, courtesy of Joe Hacker, or pets killed when they overheated your house during summer.

    2. Re:We are Google... by iamhassi · · Score: 1

      As if I would trust the HVAC in my home to an Internet homed device. LOL, enjoy your frozen house when you come home, courtesy of Joe Hacker, or pets killed when they overheated your house during summer.

      Exactly. And when security flaws are found do you think google will push free updates for years? Of course not. You're getting ready for New Years party and notice it's awfully cold. Check the Nest and it's set to max AC. App and Nest isn't responding, and now you're scrambling to fix it when you need to leave in 5 minutes because you're already fashionably late. I just don't trust handing everything in our lives to corporate overlords. Even when they screw up horribly lawsuits don't phase them and they never serve jail time. They could kill thousands and blame a bug or user error and walk away paying one hour of profit to the class action lawsuit

      --
      my karma will be here long after I'm gone
  12. Re:Reinventing the Chronotherm and Multistage Heat by AvitarX · · Score: 1

    I wish they (Honeywell) advertised it more heavily on the package, perhaps I could have saved hundreds.

    I replaced a $50 or so programmable with the nest, it did not vary heat up time with outside temperature (an hour swing day to day, new windows are next, but cost more than a thermostat), and it did not cut off a few degrees (and much time) before the desired temperature knowing that having all of the radiators fully hot will lead to another hour or so of heating even with the boiler off.

    Any of the thermostats I'd used in the past (all of the places I've lived had large free standing radiators) didn't really get those two concepts (start heating hours early, and cut off an hour or so early). Though, it's not even something I knew existed until nest advertised it pretty front and center. So maybe it was in the small print of things I was looking at.

    --
    Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
  13. Price/performance by Locke2005 · · Score: 1

    I have a $50 Cadet electric heater in every room... what's the point of putting a $200 thermostat on each one? You don't need to put a user interface on every device -- everybody already has a user interface in their pocket, it's called a "smart phone"!

    --
    I've abandoned my search for truth; now I'm just looking for some useful delusions.
  14. The wrong solution by Locke2005 · · Score: 1

    If you really want to save money on energy, give me servos to open my windows when it's hotter inside than outside in the summer, or colder inside than outside in the winter.

    --
    I've abandoned my search for truth; now I'm just looking for some useful delusions.
    1. Re:The wrong solution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Two words: Attic fan

      Opening one or two windows and running an attic fan for 10-15 mins can suck the heat out of your house and lower it to the outside temperature with minimal energy usage.