Slashdot Mirror


Turkey Rolls Out Domestic Rival To WhatsApp, Raising Surveillance Concerns (reuters.com)

Turkey has launched a domestic messaging app to rival Facebook's popular WhatsApp Messenger service, raising concerns among government critics that Ankara (capital of Turkey) could use the new platform to tighten surveillance and bolster an 18-month-old crackdown. From a report: The app, called PttMessenger after Turkey's Post and Telegraph General Directorate (PTT), was introduced in a limited roll-out to state institutions and some private companies this week. It is expected to be publicly available in six months. PttMessenger will provide a "system safer than WhatsApp," government spokesman Bekir Bozdag told a news conference. "Since no data is stored with the host, it will be impossible to access these data. A system safer than WhatsApp has been developed." Critics cast doubt on the suggestion PttMessenger data could not be retrieved, fearing it will give authorities greater ability to monitor dissent, pointing to the widespread crackdown that was launched after a failed military coup in July 2016.

5 of 36 comments (clear)

  1. Totally trust this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Governments have never lied to their populace about surveillance...

  2. I believe the critics. by robkill · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Almost 20 years ago, my company gave a brief presentation to visitors from the Turkish National Police. They wanted network traffic monitoring tools to expose people visiting "illegal websites". I'm sure the mindset hasn't changed since then.

    --
    DMCA - Chilling free speech since 1998.
  3. Re:oh, get over it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    There was never a real coup - you think the military would launch a coup without even knowing where the head of state was?
    His plane was supposedly intercepted by conspirators in jets, who were 'persuaded' to return to being loyal... all in time for Erdogan to arrest more than 50,000 opposition supporters, shut down all opposition media and arrest their reporters, eliminate opposition supporters from schools, and purge the military of anyone not personally loyal to Erdogan.
    Despite all that, he still runs at less than 50% popularity. Even after the 'coup, he barely broke 60%, and it's been back done for a long time. But hey - maybe if he manages to genocide the Kurds, his popularity will rise again - most Turks really hate the Kurds.

    The West should take note: This is how a civilized first-world nation descends into a third-world dictatorship. 1918 and 1933 were the last times we saw this. At least there aren't 6 million Kurds for him to kill...

  4. Re:Istanbul, not Constantinople by rickb928 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Turks emigrated to Europe for 20 years or more, they could do it again. Since choosing where you live is a big deal, they will choose.

    If they are allowed to.

    --
    deleting the extra space after periods so i can stay relevant, yeah.
  5. It is a Signal fork by stikves · · Score: 4, Interesting

    They even admit it on Twitter. It was a fork of the open source Signal software, meaning there is a big potential violation of GPLv3 terms by the government:

    https://twitter.com/PTTKurumsa...

    "PttMessenger, signal tabanl açk kaynak kod kullanlarak gelitirilmitir. PttMessenger, tüm gelitirme haklar ile PTT A..'ye aittir.

    Zebrachat, PttMessenger'n gelitirme aamasnda kullanlan proje ve ürün addr."

    roughly:

    "PttMessenger is developed based on the open signal sources. All rights of PttMessenger belong to the PTT A.S.

    Zebrachat is a code name for a development snapshot of PttMessenger."

    I could not find the source code to neither PttMessenger nor Zebrachat. If they are indeed based on Signal (which has very good security btw.), this might become one of the highest profile open source copyright infringements.