Airbnb Drives Up Rent Costs In Manhattan and Brooklyn, Report Says (cnet.com)

According to a report from New York City's comptroller, Scott Stringer, Airbnb is causing rent prices to increase significantly in Manhattan and Brooklyn (Warning: source may be paywalled: alternative source), where the majority of the company's rentals are concentrated. The New York Times reports: In Manhattan's Hell's Kitchen and Chelsea neighborhoods and the Midtown Business District, which accounted for about 11 percent of all Airbnb listings in New York City in 2016, average monthly rents increased by $398 between 2009 and 2016, of which $86, or 21.6 percent, was a result of Airbnb's presence, the report said. In Greenpoint and Williamsburg in Brooklyn, the study said, rents went up 18.6 percent in those years because of Airbnb listings. Airbnb makes it easy to rent apartments to tourists, taking units off the market for full-time residents, the report said. The report said that Airbnb's influence cost New Yorkers $616 million in additional rent in 2016 as a result of price pressures.

Comments

...and?

[MightyYar]

Every type of economic activity increases rents... like, all of them. New restaurants - increase rents. Jobs increase rents. So you flood an area with tourists and the rents go up? OK, in isolation that sounds bad - but what did all of that tourism money do to the local economy? If rents go up, doesn't that also encourage investment in the neighborhood? How can you just look at this one statistic in isolation? Cities were murdering each other to get the new Amazon headquarters... what would that do to rents?

Re:...and?

[Actually, I do RTFA]

. So you flood an area with tourists and the rents go up?

There's no reason to think there are more tourists visiting NYC. Occupancy rates in hotels are down, year-over-year.

You are right that you have to look at mutliple factors, but you probably would want to compare rents, inflation and wages. After all, the important thing to the average renter is what percent of their money goes to rent.

Re:...and?

[BlueStrat]

Yes. Hotels have daily housekeeping. No Airbnb place I have stayed at does. The market has spoken: Many people don't want to pay for that.

However, if Airbnb is popular because they don't pay a hotel tax, for example, then that is tax evasion, not free-market competition.

Why can't there be a middle-ground?

It's rather silly to expect homeowners to pay the tax rates of a multinational hotel chain to rent out their home or apartment for a couple of months while they go on a cruise or something, but there are legitimate concerns and problems that do in fact need to be addressed.

How about creating regulations such that in areas that have a population density higher than a set amount, property owners who wish to participate in AirBnB-style activities must be licensed. Make it cheap, like $25 or less for a year so that people will comply. Place restrictions on how many weeks/months out of a year the property may be rented out. If your property is not in a high population density area, then no restrictions or license necessary.

Strat

I got mine

[fluffernutter]

It shouldn't be called the gig economy, it should be called the "I got mine" economy. I'm also partial to the "screw you" economy.

Short term rental should have restrictions

[mark-t]

Rental periods of less than a single calendar month in length should force the entire building to be qualified as a hotel, and require that there be no long term rental or ownership of any units anywhere within the entire building, beyond at most what is necessary for any dedicated management and/or maintenance staff.

Just IMNSHO....

Here's a scary thought

[rsilvergun]

AirBnB turns your tourists into part of your Urban Sprawl problem. The Hotels are usually in a district (especially nice ones) near the city's major amenities. AirBnB breaks that. If folks are staying where ever and driving a few hours in a rental (fine since they're on vacation) expect to see traffic shoot up.

Comment removed

[account_deleted]

Comment removed based on user account deletion