Slashdot Mirror
Internet Luminaries Urge EU To Kill Off Automated Copyright Filter Proposal (theregister.co.uk)
A large group of Internet pioneers have sent an open letter to the European Union urging it to scrap a proposal to introduce automated upload filters, arguing that it could damage the internet as we know it. The Register: The European Parliament's Legal Affairs (Juri) Committee will vote on the proposal contained in Article 13 of the Copyright in the Digital Single Market Directive next week. The proposal would see all companies that "store and provide to the public access to large amounts of works" obliged to "prevent the availability... of works... identified by rightholders." Despite the inclusion of language that says such measures need to be "appropriate and proportionate," it has caused many to worry that the law will lead to a requirement for all platforms to introduce automated content filtering, and shift liability for any copyrighted material that appears online from the user that posts it to the platform itself.
"By inverting this liability model and essentially making platforms directly responsible for ensuring the legality of content in the first instance, the business models and investments of platforms large and small will be impacted," warns the letter [PDF] signed by "Father of the Internet" Vint Cerf, world world web inventor Tim Berners-Lee, as well a host of other internet luminaries including Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales, security expert Bruce Schneier and net neutrality namer Tim Wu.
"By inverting this liability model and essentially making platforms directly responsible for ensuring the legality of content in the first instance, the business models and investments of platforms large and small will be impacted," warns the letter [PDF] signed by "Father of the Internet" Vint Cerf, world world web inventor Tim Berners-Lee, as well a host of other internet luminaries including Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales, security expert Bruce Schneier and net neutrality namer Tim Wu.
How about getting rid of writable media tax first?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
My invitation must have gotten lost in the mail.
You are welcome on my lawn.
How about we get rid of the Berne Convention?
Support my political activism on Patreon.
You're kidding right? Google, Micrsoft and Facebook would LOVE nothing more then having their tech licensed for such things. That is why they created it after all.
This story was paid for propaganda, something for them to point at later and say "we tried" perhaps?
Even if they win this argument and individuals are liable for their own copyright infringement, the next argument will be then as a website you have to be able to identify the person who uploaded to your service so the infringing person can be prosecuted. I foresee the days of anonymity gone soon (10 years or less) in the EU's internet.
"world world web inventor Tim Berners-Lee"
If you host anything of relevance in the EU, you must have a death wish.
I'm really hoping that if this passes some big internet corporations restrict services in the EU. The only way things are going to get better is if more people realize what an abomination Brussels has become.
I have faith in the Internet to perform its most basic function: to resiliently get a packet from point A to point B.
Governments and corporations are welcome to erect whatever barriers they see fit to raise, but they will be effective only until they become onerous. Then, as has happened before, an enterprising geek will find a way to rip, decss, vpn, tor, p2p, IPV6 their way around or through the barriers.
The Internet is not regulated, the Internet can not be effectively regulated and serve its intended purpose.
Average Intelligence is a Scary Thing
But where are we supposed to host things anymore? Between Net Neutrality going away in the US, the EU and UK wanting to clamp down hard on controlling what can and can't exist on the internet, which well-connected territory should we look towards for hosting today?
-=This sig has nothing to do with my comment. Move along now=-
So essentially, this proposed law would make fair use of copyright media on the internet effectively impossible.
Piracy will repeal any attempts to harm their community or they will sell virtual hot-dogs for btc as usual.
In the USA you are free to talk, publish. Free after publication. Free to tell a joke in visual form. Talk about politics using a cartoon, photo, a quote.
In the EU all such use of art and creativity is not legal. Quoting text? Using an image to comment on the news?
The EU will use new legal powers to stop publication and comment. No quotes from publications.
Quoted from a text? Thats a good time to place an EU tax on a public comment.
What the EU cannot make illegal under freedom of speech it will use a new tax on to go after all political speech.
The EU wants a digital Stamp Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... on the all text of the US internet.
Any comment on the web will have to be EU approved. Pay a per word text tax to the EU for your creativity and ingenuity.
EU fines on people who quote EU publications?
Domestic spying is now "Benign Information Gathering"
The EU is about restoring the a Roman Emperor and the monarchies. Not blatantly but effectively. Don't think so? All countries except England were not democratic until the US won WW2 and basically humiliated them into it. France not until the 1960s. So, not long after an EU parliament turns up and acts effectively like the ancient Roman Senate. No one really gets a look in.
Greek elections are overturned by Germany, in return France works a 20 hour week and Germany pays its bills. EU Laws prevent English farmers from growing the potato they grew for centuries because the big vote holders in the EU senate want to force England to subsidise their farmers for them. And no one has any interest in knowing anything about the Vatican Bank but everyone else has to reveal every last detail of themselves, including exactly where this photo came from.
Their demands are not much different to the Tea Tax.
Sounds like a great plan. Make it illegal to have any media on the internet.
But where are we supposed to host things anymore?
North Korea!
They're (nuclear) tanned, rested and ready!
This was one of the under-reported issue of the Trump / Kim summit . . . along with supporting ZTE in China, the USA will now promote Internet hosting in North Korea!
As to halting its nuclear ambitions . . . Kim is "currently implementing plans to size the effort" . . .
Schroedinger's Brexit: The UK is both in and out of the EU at the same time!
As Usual you show yourself a ninkenpoob, this time with regards to the EU laws in comparison to the USA.
Please do continue destroying your own credibility, it is very entertaining for the rest of us to see you dig your hole of misinformation and bad logic deeper and deeper.
There's even a small "pool" going around wondering if eventually you'll end up digging your way to north Korea or to the, by then flooded, Marshall Isles....
The way I read the heading at first, I thought that the automated copyright filters somehow interfered with the operation of some IoT light fixtures and those started sending messages by themselves to EU structures asking to disable the filters.
Internet users tired of the EU being a collection of idiots, urges EU to kill itself off...
Canada
Will $CURRENT_YEAR be the year of the Linux Desktop?
Look everyone - it's a Soros NGO troll!