Slashdot Mirror
Tech Giants Urge Congress To 'Protect Entrepreneurs' From Supreme Court Ruling (theverge.com)
U.S. states can now require online retailers to collect local sales taxes, according to a recent Supreme Court ruling that could affect thousands of third-party sellers on top tech sites. An anonymous reader quotes The Verge:
In fact, Amazon, which last year started collecting sales tax in all 45 states that require it by law, may have a substantial amount of work to do to help its Amazon Marketplace sellers stay compliant. Yet we don't know if that burden will fall primarily on Amazon or if it will be the responsibility of the sellers. More than 50 percent of all sales on the site are conducted via third-party sellers, some of which use Amazon for fulfillment but otherwise operate independent small- to medium-sized businesses... Etsy, eBay, and others are in similar boats. According to the US Government Accountability Office, as much as $13 billion in annual sales tax revenue is at stake....
Etsy is concerned about what it sees as "significant complexities in the thousands of state and local sales tax laws" and that by overruling the Quill decision, the Supreme Court has put the ball in Congress' court. "We believe there is now a call to action for Congress to create a simple, fair federal solution for micro-businesses," Silverman added.
The Verge writes that "the case may be litigated for years to come to figure out how to account for the over 10,000 state jurisdictions that govern sales tax across the country. That is, unless congressional legislation supersedes the state court decisions... Even groups that were in favor of the ruling, like the nonpartisan research institute the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, are imploring Congress to act."
eBay has already mass-emailed many of their users urging them to sign an online petition "to protect entrepreneurs, artisans and small businesses from potentially devastating Internet sales tax legislation." The petition presses state governors, U.S. lawmakers, and president Trump to "support the millions of small businesses and consumers across the country."
Keep reading to see what eBay is urging legislators to do...
Etsy is concerned about what it sees as "significant complexities in the thousands of state and local sales tax laws" and that by overruling the Quill decision, the Supreme Court has put the ball in Congress' court. "We believe there is now a call to action for Congress to create a simple, fair federal solution for micro-businesses," Silverman added.
The Verge writes that "the case may be litigated for years to come to figure out how to account for the over 10,000 state jurisdictions that govern sales tax across the country. That is, unless congressional legislation supersedes the state court decisions... Even groups that were in favor of the ruling, like the nonpartisan research institute the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, are imploring Congress to act."
eBay has already mass-emailed many of their users urging them to sign an online petition "to protect entrepreneurs, artisans and small businesses from potentially devastating Internet sales tax legislation." The petition presses state governors, U.S. lawmakers, and president Trump to "support the millions of small businesses and consumers across the country."
Keep reading to see what eBay is urging legislators to do...
- Keep the Internet as free from government taxation and regulation as possible.
- Protect entrepreneurs, small businesses and artisans from new taxes, audits or collection burdens because they can least afford the added costs.
- Continue to prohibit states and localities from applying and enforcing sales and use tax laws on small, remote local businesses who have no political or voting connection to the taxing state.
- Reject tax policies that raise prices on consumers who shop online with small businesses for artisan, craft, religious, vintage or other niche products because they should not be paying more taxes.
Do you agree with the Supreme Court -- or with the tech companies who want a new federal solution?
Leave your thoughts in the comments...
No, they are delivering to you, where YOU are located. That's where the sale is considered to be completed. Whether you walk into a local store to pick it up, or UPS delivers it to your address, it's where you take possession of the goods that makes the sale a sale in a given jurisdiction. Has always been this way, and this ruling doesn't change that.
Don't disappoint your bird dog. Go to the range.
I work for a small brick-and-mortar and ecommerce business and we worked it out pretty easily.
You "worked out" collecting, tracking, reporting on and remitting sales and use taxes to over 10,000 different jurisdictions all around the country? You've got all of their biweekly, monthly, quarterly, and annual reporting and remittance schedules tracked, know which ones require you to cut checks or file electronically through each of their separate portals? How many hours a day does that take, out of curiosity? And how do you discover when one incorporated town in Mississippi has suddenly decided that one particular product has just shifted from being a food item with no tax to a luxury item at a special rate? How are you dealing with the people who claim to be sales tax exempt in each of those cities, counties, and states - do you have a way to verify the authenticity of their claims and the paperwork they present? Do you get copies of their photo IDs as some of those jurisdictions require? Man, you are REALLY ahead of the game, here.
Don't disappoint your bird dog. Go to the range.