Slashdot Mirror


Should the US Air Force Bomb Forest Fires? (popularmechanics.com)

An anonymous reader quotes a report from Popular Mechanics: Earlier this summer, the Swedish Air Force dropped a laser-guided bomb on a forest fire to help suppress the flames. Now there's a proposal for the United States to do the same, using the might of the U.S. Air Force to fight America's raging forest fires via bombs and sonic booms. F-15 Strike Eagle Weapon System Officer Mike Benitez, writing in War on the Rocks, proposes using B-1 bombers stuffed to the gills with bombs to battle wildfires on the American homefront. The idea here is to snuff out fires the way you'd blow out birthday candles at the base. In Sweden, the shockwave from a single bomb snuffed out flames within a 100-yard radius of the impact point. So, Benitez reasons, why not load up a heavy strategic bomber with up to 84 bombs and do some serious firefighting?

Benitez chose the B-1 for his hypothetical scenario not only because of its bomb-carrying capability, but for the same reason the heavy bomber became a close air support platform of choice in Afghanistan: its long range translated into persistence over the battlefield, enabling the big bomber to hang around above friendly forces and bomb the Taliban for hours. The B-1 could do donuts in the skies over a wildfire as firefighters on the ground work out the best way to tackle it. The B-1 wouldn't carry just any bomb, either, but ordinance that was designed for firefighting. Most bombs use a steel casing that fragments into deadly shrapnel, but this would be unnecessary (and dangerous) when fighting fires. A firefighting bomb would use a combustible casing that would disintegrate on impact. Ideally the bomb would use a thermobaric warhead, one that kills via overpressure, as it generates even more powerful blast waves than traditional high-explosive bombs.

4 of 342 comments (clear)

  1. KMFDM said it by Stormwatch · · Score: 5, Funny

    Kill everything, kill everything, bomb the living bejesus out of those forests.

    1. Re:KMFDM said it by Etcetera · · Score: 4, Funny

      Exactly, imagine being caught in a forest fire somewhere without anybody's knowledge and that you have managed to find a sweet spot to stay alive and then the bombs come at you. Now you really get the battlefield experience!

      Seriously, wild forest fire areas are hard to clear of human presence in advance due to their unpredictable nature. One might also think of animal casualties.

      https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708838/quotes/qt0341840
      [Odell has complained about "lightning bolts" falling from the ceiling]

      Danilo Odell: Yeah, what the hell was that thing?

      Lieutenant Worf: Automated fire system. A force field contains the flame until the remaining oxygen has been consumed.

      Danilo Odell: Ah, yeah, w-what if I had been under that thing?

      Lieutenant Worf: You would have been standing in the fire.

      Danilo Odell: Yeah, well, leaving that aside for the moment, I mean, what would have happened to me?

      Lieutenant Worf: You would have suffocated and died.

  2. Re:Maybe once it's out in the middle of a forest by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 5, Funny

    The Swedes were able to bomb their fire because it was on a bombing range.

    Then just declare the entire existing fire area a bombing range - problem solved!

    --
    #DeleteChrome
  3. Will someone please think of the ents? by Jesus+H+Rolle · · Score: 5, Funny

    How long before the first ent wedding gets accidently bombed?