Slashdot Mirror


FCC Criticized For Surrendering Power To Punish Verizon After Firefighters Got Throttled During Wildfire (gizmodo.com)

Democratic lawmakers on Wednesday criticized the FCC on its response to Verizon's throttling of firefighters' data speeds as they battled a major wildfire in Northern California. "In a letter Friday, Senator Edward Markey and Congresswoman Anna Eshoo demanded answers from the FCC over what steps it is currently taking to address 'critical threats to public safety,' citing its decision to repeal Obama-era net neutrality protections," reports Gizmodo. From the report: The 2015 Open Internet Order -- overturned by the FCC's Republican majority last winter -- reclassified internet providers like Verizon as common carriers under Title II of the Federal Communications Act, granting the FCC regulatory authority that, in this instance, would have allowed the commission to investigate and potential penalize Verizon for its decision. At Chairman Ajit Pai's direction, the commission abdicated that authority this year. It no longer has the power to establish rules prohibiting Verizon from throttling emergency services, or charging police and fire departments additional fees to maintain their communications at optimal speeds when usage peaks -- say, during a wildfire, or an earthquake, or a mass shooting.

"The FCC has incorrectly suggested that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) could sufficiently fill this void," wrote Markey and Eschoo, whose congressional districting includes portions of Santa Clara. "We strongly disagree with that assertion." In their letter, the Democratic lawmakers urged the FCC to make use of its Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau and investigate the matter, saying that while the FTC may find Verizon's actions exemplify an "unfair and deceptive practice," both agencies should use "all of the tools available" to resolve this public safety matter. "To do nothing is unacceptable," they said.

3 of 161 comments (clear)

  1. Misleading advertising by burtosis · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If they simply had called it a 25gig then throttle plan this wouldn't be confused with net neutrality. Instead it's advertised as the best unlimited everything, the data usage in real time is difficult to track for average users, and no one reads fine print leading to the confusion. In that case I'd agree it's deceptive and in this case led to an unsafe condition. Too bad deceptive advertising likely won't get fixed for the common people.

    1. Re: Misleading advertising by burtosis · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The problem is relying on second rate consumer data plans for critical infrastructure. This was a management failure, not a technical failure. Sending firefighting back to the 1960s is not the answer.

  2. Re:California's fault for poor water management! by PopeRatzo · · Score: 5, Funny

    It's California's fault the firefighters even had to be there.

    Yeah, if California didn't insist on having, you know, trees then they wouldn't have to fight wildfires.

    In fact, we are now learning that President Trump is secretly working with Robert Mueller to prosecute the State of California for having trees as soon as Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama are sent to Guantanamo and executed.

    Subscribe to my YouTube channel.

    #GreatAwakening #thestorm #americafirst #cabal #truth #thedonald #freedom #kag #TrustThePlan #GeorgeSoros #RebelHeart #ClassicalLiberals #BuildThatWall #RedHenRestaurant #thecalmbeforethestorm #MakeAmericaGreatAgain #PresidentTrump #KanyeWest #QAnon #GoldenAge #LawOfAttraction #AbrahamHicks #TheEliteAreCRAPPINGthemselves

    --
    You are welcome on my lawn.