Slashdot Mirror
EFF, MuckRock Partner To See How Local Police Are Trading Your Car's Location (eff.org)
v3rgEz writes: The Electronic Frontier Foundation and transparency non-profit MuckRock helped file over a thousand public records requests, looking into how local police departments were trading away sensitive data on where you drive and park, picked up by their use of automated license plate recognition devices. They've just published the results of those requests, including looking at how hundreds of departments freely share that data with hundreds of other organizations -- often with no public oversight. Explore the data yourself, or, if your town isn't yet in their database, requests its information free on MuckRock and they'll file a request for it. "[Automated license plate readers (ALPR)] are a combination of high-speed cameras and optical character recognition technology that can identify license plates and turn them into machine-readable text," reports the EFF. "What makes ALPR so powerful is that drivers are required by law to install license plates on their vehicles. In essence, our license plates have become tracking beacons. After the plate data is collected, the ALPR systems upload the information to a central a database along with the time, date, and GPS coordinates. Cops can search these databases to see where drivers have traveled or to identify vehicles that visited certain locations. Police can also add license plates under suspicion to 'hot lists,' allowing for real-time alerts when a vehicle is spotted by an ALPR network."
Isn't this the point of a license plate?
Nope. The purpose was never to enable full-time surveillance of people's vehicles. It was to permit identification of vehicles in realtime. When license plates were introduced, there were no automatic license plate scanners. Now there are, so things are different.
"You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
Its often not the police collecting the data, the police are often merely subscribers to the commercial private databases. These database are filled by other private sources, bail bondsmen, reposessors, etc. These private entities will literally cruise up and down the isles of parking lots at various public venues -- malls, stadiums, walmart, etc -- scanning/recording plates and waiting for statistics to find them a car/person of interest. As a bonus they also sell all their collected data to the commercial private databases.
To think that this is largely a law enforcement effort or a law enforcement database is to totally misunderstand what has been happening.
No warrant is needed for public information available from a private source. That's the "beauty" of the current system for law enforcement, why they like to merely be a subscriber.
Originally the license plate was there to show your vehicle was registered, enabling you to the full right of way along with other vehicles. Only later did it become a tool of the police.
If the public were to get a system up and running that tracked Law Enforcement vehicles and distributed this information to anyone who wanted to see it in real time, they would pitch an absolute fit about it.
Yet, it's perfectly acceptable to push such technology upon everyone else. :|
I wonder if LE understands it's this hypocrisy that creates such hatred between LE and everyone else.
Not so different that it would legally allow police to sell that information collected. That would be a gross invasion of privacy by law pretty much police are only allowed to collect and present to the courts only, information collected during their duties, other than that, the law pretty much requires they SHUT THE FUCK UP. I really think some police forces need, like unruly guard dogs, taught their place. Honestly those who allowed should be prosecuted where possible and where not, most definitely fired for betrayal of the public trust.
Chaos - everything, everywhere, everywhen
Don't know why the parking tickets guys have such bad luck, when the Repo Men seem to have great success with a giant private license plate scanning network.
"There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley