Hospital Prices Are About To Go Public in the US (ajc.com)

Prices hospitals charge for their services will all go online Jan. 1 under a new federal requirement, but patient advocates say the realities of medical-industry pricing will make it difficult for consumers to get much out of the new data. From a report: A federal rule requires all hospitals to post online a master list of prices for the services they provide so consumers can review them starting Jan. 1. The health care industry nationally has a reputation for having little price transparency, which can make it difficult for consumers to price compare. But the hospital's master list prices, sometimes called a chargemaster, is also not a complete look, consumer advocates say. That's because the final bill a patient receives is almost never the same as the sticker price for the services they received. Insurance companies negotiate discounts on the sticker prices. Co-pays, co-insurance, deductibles also add other layers of complexity that bring discounts or increased costs before a final charge is determined.

Comments

Re:Extra charges

[saider]

Hopefully this is the first step in getting rid of insurance companies. The hassle of all this is what the insurance companies use to stay in business.

1. Billing errors are almost always in their favor. You either spend your valuable time haggling with them to correct it, or it gets paid because you don't notice it or don't have time to deal with it.

2. The time you spend correcting their mistakes also requires people working in the insurance company to correct them. Insurance companies are regulated by the state, and so they often need to justify their rates. The customer service people serve that purpose. The rates are often negotiated such that they are allowed to make a 10-30% profit on their "service". More expenses means more profit. This behavior, which would normally kill a business, becomes something that strengthens it because of the way government has their fingers in this industry.

4. Doctors now have full time people who do nothing more than haggle with the insurance companies to get paid. This further drives up the cost of care, which again benefits the insurance companies.

5. Because we have turned healthcare into an "insurance" product, you decouple a service from its price because everything is handled in aggregate. Remember from Finance 101, insurance products are designed to "make you whole" if an unlikely event occurs. Healthcare is a certainty, so paying for it as an insurance product makes no sense. That'd be like having "food insurance" or "housing insurance" to pay for your groceries and rent/mortgage. It is unnecessary and only adds cost. Then the added cost becomes a barrier and the insurance companies sell themselves as helping to overcome the barrier that they erected.

6. Healthcare is a giant jobs program. All those people haggling over costs would be out of a job things changed significantly. This is the main reason the system won't change.

7. Individuals cannot change the market because they do not purchase the insurance. Their employers do. Therefore, health insurance companies' customers are not the people receiving the service. Insurance companies provide just enough service to entice HR directors to choose them. Employers are interested in a healthy workforce, but at the end of the day it is a dollars decision that the employee does not get to make. This serves to distort the market.

Personally, I think the solution is to eliminate health insurance, and take the premiums that companies pay and just deposit that into the employee's health savings account. Then let the employees buy whatever they need. If they want insurance they can choose the plan that is right for them. Kinda like buying car insurance They can also just save the money and pay providers directly - but they need the up-front pricing information to make those decisions. For those that need assistance, the government or charities can deposit money into people's HSA is they need assistance. Then the market will return to something more normal simply because *** the people making the decisions are the people receiving the service. ***