Slashdot Mirror


Dutch Surgeon Wins Landmark 'Right To Be Forgotten' Case (theguardian.com)

AmiMoJo shares a report from The Guardian: A Dutch surgeon formally disciplined for her medical negligence has won a legal action to remove Google search results about her case in a landmark "right to be forgotten" ruling. The doctor's registration on the register of healthcare professionals was initially suspended by a disciplinary panel because of her postoperative care of a patient. After an appeal, this was changed to a conditional suspension under which she was allowed to continue to practice. But the first results after entering the doctor's name in Google continued to be links to a website containing an unofficial blacklist, which it was claimed amounted to "digital pillory." It was heard that potential patients had found the blacklist on Google and discussed the case on a web forum. The surgeon's lawyer, Willem van Lynden, said the ruling was groundbreaking in ensuring doctors would no longer be judged by Google on their fitness to practice. "Now they will have to bring down thousands of pages: that is what will happen, in my view. There is a medical disciplinary panel but Google have been the judge until now. They have decided whether to take a page down -- and why do they have that position?" Van Lynden said.

2 of 250 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Yelp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    OK, remember it when they misdiagnose you because they are pressured to "rule out" certain conditions because medical fashion dictates we no longer do proven-to-work safe surgeries. Then when the mistreated condition becomes chronic and "doesn't show up" on scans because scans are actually remarkably insensitive and low-resolution.

    https://www.wbur.org/commonhea...

    Now go to your run-of-the-mill pill-pushing antibiotic-shill "doctor" and try to explain your condition.

    And remember, the health you enjoy now in a first-world country has very little to do with doctors beyond simple 19th century precautions like washing your hands. Your health is due to easy access to safe food, refrigeration, indoor plumbing, air conditioning and heating, and garbage removal.

    Doctors are fools.

  2. Re:Good example of what is wrong by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    ... but perhaps I just don't understand the average European.

    I think not. I have many European friends, and I am occasionally surprised by their lack of concern about individual rights that are taken for granted in America. They are way more willing to accept censorship to suppress "hate speech", burqa bans, etc.

    With such a wide gap in perspectives, conversations are almost pointless, so I just try to avoid talking about these issues with Europeans. Even with Americans, before discussing individual rights, I aways ask "What do you think of motorcycle helmet laws?"