Slashdot Mirror


College Student Who Stole More Than $5 Million in Cryptocurrency By SIM Swapping Gets 10 Years in Prison -- First Person To Be Sentenced For the Crime (vice.com)

A 20-year-old college student who was accused of stealing more than $5 million in cryptocurrency in a slew of SIM hijacking attacks is the first person to be sentenced for the crime. From a report: A college student who stole more than $5 million in cryptocurrency by hijacking the phone numbers of around 40 victims pleaded guilty and accepted a plea deal of 10 years in prison, Motherboard has learned. Joel Ortiz accepted the plea deal last week, Erin West, the Deputy District Attorney in Santa Clara County, California, told Motherboard during a meeting on Thursday. The authorities believe Ortiz is the first person to be convicted of a crime for SIM swapping, an increasingly popular and damaging hack.

The prosecutors and agents who have been investigating these hacks celebrated the conviction, and said they hope that this will serve as an example for the other alleged criminals who have already been arrested, as well as the ones who have yet to be caught. "We think justice has been served. And hopefully this is a strong message to that community," Samy Tarazi, one of the agents who investigated the Ortiz case, told me. Ortiz is one af a handful of SIM swappers who have been arrested in the last year for hijacking phone numbers and using them to then hack into emails, social media accounts, and online Bitcoin wallets.

59 comments

  1. From the article by Crashmarik · · Score: 3, Informative

    On July 12, police in California arrested a college student accused of being part of a group of criminals who hacked dozens of cellphone numbers to steal more than $5 million in cryptocurrency. Joel Ortiz, a 20-year-old from Boston, allegedly hacked around 40 victims with the help of still unnamed accomplices, according to court documents obtained by Motherboard.

    https://motherboard.vice.com/e...

    Which sounds a bit more likely but still seems to be missing quite a bit.

    1. Re: From the article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you saw it, you stole it. Is. Not security.

    2. Re:From the article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You sound pretty stupid.

    3. Re:From the article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The other shoe will drop, I expect. These plea deals include commitments to testify against the other parities to the crime.

  2. Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ... because he is a "college kid"?

    A thieve is a thieve regardless of the level of education he/she has.

    1. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      What kind of education teaches that Thief is spelled "Thieve"?

    2. Re: Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, that's exactly how it works.

    3. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by m.alessandrini · · Score: 2

      Maybe he has to build a fire-wall.

    4. Re: Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nah, you're supposed to feel sorry because the 5m he stole turned into 950k.

    5. Re: Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're supposed to feel sorry for the corporate entities that rip us off. So sieg heil the fascist pigs who run the legal injustice system! They're what makes America a Nazi-like police state. I laugh everytime one of them gets shot and killed. hahaha, try calling a limited liability corporation that cares because I don't. LOL

    6. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by serviscope_minor · · Score: 4, Insightful

      No, you are supposed to feel sorry that stealing Monopoly money only agreed upon by a relative few people

      That's a massive, massive misrepresentation of reality.

      *You* clearly don't like bitcoin but that's irrelevant. It has a market cap of 60 billion dollars, about the same as Phillip Morris.

      You can equally well level your accusaions against shares in that company. They are paper money, not many people hold them (i.e. the value is agreed by relatively few people) and the organisation is a deeply hateful one.

      It doesn't matter though. The money can be got in and out easily and it's REAL money. The guy stole 5 million real dollars whether or not you personally happen to like that kind of value.

      If nothing else, feel sorry for the tax dollars being spent on keeping this guy out of society for ten years rather than slapping him with a huge fine and forcing him to work it off.

      Your previous argument has no bearing on that. The relative merits of prison vs non custodial sentances is irrelevant to you not liking the money he stole. Shame really because your second point is a much more interesting one, but it's realy overshadowed by the first.

      --
      SJW n. One who posts facts.
    7. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Calydor · · Score: 1

      It's not that I don't like Bitcoin, I just think it's a silly thing that has grown much bigger than it really ought to have.

      --
      -=This sig has nothing to do with my comment. Move along now=-
    8. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by bloodhawk · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I don't care whether it is real money or monopoly money or lollipops, The guy is a thief, he stole what others valued and obviously what he himself valued and he did not do this once, but at least 20 times He deserves everything he got.

    9. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Meanwhile, the "Wall Street" mob is still free ...

      Considering that crypto-currency is not a legal form
      of currency, (IOWs, I can't pay my mortgage in bit-coin)
      what was the statue that was broken?

      CAP === 'domicile'

    10. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't pay my mortgage in cars either, so what statute did the car thief break? (Bitcoin has value - and can be sold for money much like used cars. Also, a bitcoin owner may want to keep his oddball money, even if you think it is junk. Private property and all that.)

    11. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by ToTheStars · · Score: 4, Funny

      The singular of "cats" is "cat", and so the singular form of "thieves" must be "thieve"! I don't see any trouble here.
      Now if you'll excuse me, I've just rearranged my boxen, so I need to update the indice of the coordinates of their vertices...

    12. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Applehu+Akbar · · Score: 2

      Even if what you steal is Monopoly money, the value basis for classifying a crime is the amount in local fiat, dollars in this case, that it trades for.

    13. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by bluefoxlucid · · Score: 1

      It doesn't matter though. The money can be got in and out easily and it's REAL money. The guy stole 5 million real dollars whether or not you personally happen to like that kind of value.

      And we can make him give it back and work on rehabilitation.

      Making an example of him won't work: criminals aren't deterred by punishment, but rather by the perceived likelihood of getting caught. Harsher punishments don't reduce crime.

      Even if it did, harsh punishment as an example to others is inflicting harm upon someone for purpose other than their own transgression, which is the opposite of justice, so much as one could call punishment "justice" in the first place. It's like gangraping some guy's wife because he didn't pay back a loan, except that not only did she not commit the crime, but the punishment is targeted at crimes not yet committed but supposed to be committed by folks who should take the demonstration as a warning to not do those things.

      The relative merits of prison vs non custodial sentances is irrelevant to you not liking the money he stole.

      Also punitive versus restorative justice. People are products of their environments, and crime is essentially a result of society. Schools and prisons serve the same functions: they help people to become thriving members of society.

    14. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, you are supposed to feel sorry that stealing Monopoly money only agreed upon by a relative few people to have value at all...

      All money is monopoly money. That's how it works.

    15. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by The-Ixian · · Score: 2

      It doesn't matter though. The money can be got in and out easily and it's REAL money. The guy stole 5 million real dollars whether or not you personally happen to like that kind of value.

      And we can make him give it back and work on rehabilitation.

      He should be sentenced to do the hashing math of mining new bitcoins by hand until he has mined enough to repay his debt ;P

      --
      My eyes reflect the stars and a smile lights up my face.
    16. Re: Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I modded you, "Troll", even though you are an AC,

      I didn't want anyone to think that your pigshit post was in any way acceptable.

    17. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Meanwhile, the "Wall Street" mob is still free

      And the wall hasn't been built
      And we haven't sent a man back to the moon
      etc

    18. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by jythie · · Score: 2

      He stole millions in something that can be exchanged for money. Doesn't matter what it was, and the severity of the crime should not be minimized simply because it was something the speaker does not value. If he had stolen gold bars or stacks of cash hopefully it would produce a similar sentence.

    19. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Calydor · · Score: 1

      But why lock him up for ten years instead of trying to have him be part of society? It's not like he killed or maimed someone, he took some NUMBERS that a bunch of people claim have value - originally based on some guy (whose identity is still a mystery) saying, "Because I say so."

      --
      -=This sig has nothing to do with my comment. Move along now=-
    20. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm confused about what instigated your post. What part of the story or slashdot summery gives you any impression that someone wants you to feel sorry for anybody for any reason?

    21. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Ogive17 · · Score: 1

      My son is learning to read English and Japanese right now. While Asian "alphabets" seem daunting to us Westerners, the grammar rules for Japanese are actually quite simple compared to English. (not that every language doesn't have it's own intricacies)

      Trying to explain to an inquisitive 5 year old why English sucks isn't easy. I hate telling him "well, that's just the way it has always been".

      --
      "Action without philosophy is a lethal weapon; philosophy without action is worthless."
    22. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by fat+man's+underwear · · Score: 1

      "not that every language doesn't have it's own intricacies"

      Yeah, about that...

    23. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by angel'o'sphere · · Score: 1

      And more importantly: the value has nothing to do with the punishment.

      It gets simpler if the crime is more complex:
      a) I break into your house (door not locked) and steal an apple - same as stealing a watch
      b) I break into your house --- door locked, I break a window or something --- steal an apple, or a watch, harder crime than a)
      c) I break into your house, point a weapon on you and rob (hint rob versus steal versus burglary) an apple, harder crime than a) or b)

      It does not matter *what* you take ... how valuable it is ... it matters *how* you take it. Stealing a bicycle is the exact same crime as stealing a car. No difference in severity just because the car is more valuable. The difference is: is one locked or not, did you break a window or not, was the engine running and key inside, or not.

      --
      Cost free eBook I read (by iBook/Kobo/Amazon/ObookO/Gutenberg etc.): "The Green Odyssey" by Philip Jose Farmer.
    24. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by angel'o'sphere · · Score: 1

      But why lock him up for ten years instead of trying to have him be part of society?
      Because it is in gods own country.

      Their criminal laws are just ridiculous.

      he took some NUMBERS that a bunch of people claim have value - originally based on some guy (whose identity is still a mystery) saying, "Because I say so."
      That is irrelevant. The value or perceived value of what he took has nothing to do with it.

      He frauded dozens or hundreds of people with SIM swapping. Does not matter at all for what purpose he did that. And it does matter even less how valuable the stuff is/was he took.

      If I steal your most loved teddy bear from your birth year or your mothers jewelry when I enter your house, same crime, no difference.

      --
      Cost free eBook I read (by iBook/Kobo/Amazon/ObookO/Gutenberg etc.): "The Green Odyssey" by Philip Jose Farmer.
    25. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Applehu+Akbar · · Score: 1

      In the US there are degrees of larceny (theft) that depend on the value stolen. Remember the old Westerns, where stealing a horse got you strung up? The distinction survives today as “grand theft auto” being a more serious clime than stealing smaller amounts of money-equivalent or items less critical to daily existence.

    26. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The guy is a thief, he stole what others valued and obviously what he himself valued and he did not do this once, but at least 20 times He deserves everything he got.

      I wonder how many people with patience got away unmotivated by excessive greed or an adrenaline rush.

    27. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'll feel sorry for anyone heading to prison after the amount of reading I've done on prison conditions. I even feel sorry for the people who deserve it.

      You have seen the brain development research that shows that a 20-year-old can't be expected to have the same level of responsibility as a 25-year-old?

    28. Re:Am I supposed to feel sorry ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nobody deserves Bureau of Prisons "medical" "care".

  3. One step in a useless direction by deimios666 · · Score: 0

    Laws don't solve problems, they create them. Technology solves problems.

    As such, what would be a good solution for this problem? Abandon SIM cards entirely? Is IMEI falsifiable?

    --
    I think, therefore you are.
    1. Re: One step in a useless direction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nor any more or less than the number 42 is falsifiable... What are you smoking?

    2. Re:One step in a useless direction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is not a failing of simcards, and removing sim cards from the equation will not solve the problem. The problem is the failing of telecom companies to properly authenticate a "customer" making these kinds of changes like moving a line of service to another sim card.

      The problem would still exist if only IMEIs were used to authenticate the phone or some other ID system in the place of the sim cards. The SIM card is a majorly consumer positive development in the cell phone industry. The SIM card lets you change devices whenever you please without your telecom providers blessing. Use devices that your telecom provider might not sell. So long as is it compatible with the SIM card, the radio frequency and modulation scheme. It lets you swap your SIM between a phone, a USB cellular modem, or a mifi type device and it just works so long as you have the proper services provisioned on your account.

      Before the advent of the SIM card you could only use devices that your provider sold, if you wanted to change devices you had to jump through whatever hoops contacting customer service or visiting the brick and mortar store to register the new phone on their system and probably wait for some time for the new device to provision on the network.

      Considering how infrequently most customers need to move their line of service from one sim to the other, telecom providers should just outright ban this practice via phone or online systems and require you to visit a store and show valid ID. I have only had to change out my sim card once in the last decade of service with my provider.

    3. Re:One step in a useless direction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're going to break your neck trying to suck your dick.

  4. Again with the repeating by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Again, three times the same thing before starting to get some background.

    msmash, you fail editing. Get your useless butt back^Wto editing school.

  5. wassup wassup wassup by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    heyyyyyyy bitconneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

  6. Suicide solution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    He'd be better off pulling a Swartz and corpseifying himself. Supposing he lasts 10 hours, let alone 10 years, in prison without dying as a result of brutalization, he will end up a human toilet. Out of prison the human toilet will never find a job and will have to exist in abject poverty. Better off swartzed.

  7. the most shocking bit of this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Just yesterday I was reading an article about a man in Washington, DC who violently sexually assaulted unknown women on the street. He was finally caught moments after one red-handed with the scratches on his face from his fighting back and her phone in his possession. He confessed to the other crimes. Zero question of his guilt.

    He got 10 DAYS in jail. Which they let him serve in 2 day stints so that he wouldn't lose his job as a chef.

    1. Re:the most shocking bit of this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Yes I know. we live in an odd world, but then always has been. The left wants to believe no one should be in prison and the right wants to profit from it. I was talking to someone from Iran (not Muslim) and we were talking about punishment for murder. His response was there can only be one punishment, you took a life, you forfeit yours. I'd say castrate the guy in this case and I don't mean chemical. Og and I'd say it starts in schools now. Friend told me about a girl how pulled a knife on another girl at his school. She was sent home but was back the next day. No suspension, nuthin.

  8. Subsidized education by null+etc. · · Score: 1

    10 years in prison is just long enough for this kid to get a Ph.D. in telecommunications technology, and spend a few years working on and patenting a method for allowing phone calls without being so hilariously insecure and vulnerable to tampering. Capitalism at its finest. Guard the kingdom with a wooden fence, and make it a capital crime for approaching the fence.

  9. Fools by fluffernutter · · Score: 1

    This guy is a thief, no doubt about that; but if I was going to invest millions into something I would make sure it wasn't something that a college kid could steal with a "SIM hack". Just saying. A fool and his money are soon parted.

    --
    Laws are rules for the court, but merely a bottom bar to hit for life. Think beyond laws in your actions always.
    1. Re:Fools by jythie · · Score: 1

      Sounds like he took much smaller amounts from a large number of people. So he did something on par with installing a card skimmer and emptying people's bank accounts.

  10. And Then by JimSadler · · Score: 1

    So what do we get by putting this young man in prison for ten years? Maybe he will find Jesus and come out of prison with a glowing and honest personality. Well don't bet on that ! a man put away for ten years is much more likely to come out of prison with a serious does of rage and anger and a single minded dedication to destroying the system. Now we can make it worse very easily by using boredom, menial labor assignments and rather nasty and threatening living conditions to make certain that when he is not hacking away in the future he doesn't also slit a throat now and then to release his rage. Seriously ! Think about it. The American justice system is a ruptured duck supported by idiots.

  11. Cryptocurrency without crypto by bill_mcgonigle · · Score: 1

    Nobody holding their private keys had this problem. Nobody using cryptographically-secure 2FA had this problem.

    He's obviously a thief but I do wish centralized exchanges were obsolete already.

    --
    My God, it's Full of Source!
    OUTSIDE_IP=$(dig +short my.ip @outsideip.net)
  12. Outlaw bitcoin by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But seriously, you need both laws and security. One without the other is useless.

  13. when data is not an option by epine · · Score: 1

    When data is not an option, loud optics about "messaging" are a flatfoot's best friend.

    Messaging in law enforcement is the body language of professional sports.

  14. Deterrence by Woeful+Countenance · · Score: 1

    The prosecutors and agents who have been investigating these hacks celebrated the conviction, and said they hope that this will serve as an example for the other alleged criminals who have already been arrested ....

    Seems to me it's a bit late to deter people from committing crimes after they've already been arrested. But surely the "prosecutors and agents" know what they're doing.

  15. Good thing it was prosecuted by California by John+Jorsett · · Score: 1

    If this had been a federal rap, he'd do almost all of the ten years, but being California, it'll end up being a fraction of that, especially since it's a "non-violent" crime.

  16. This has gone too far by Drunkulus · · Score: 1

    Come on, now! Bitcoin is a computer game at best. No one holding it has any intention of ever using it as a currency, it's been pure speculation for years now. I have all the sympathy for a Bitcoin hack victim as I do a kid whose Minecraft castle got attacked by his neighbors.

  17. 10 years is too much by Baki · · Score: 2

    Yes he is a thieve and deserves a punishment. 10 years however is insane. It may fit with the other extremely harsh sentencing culture in the US, but that doesn't make it right. In the Netherlands, he would get 1 year, at most. Yet the crime rate is much lower, the prisons are emtpy, and the whole prison system is much cheaper and mainly directed towards rehabilitation. A system that locks away people for so long is sick IMHO.