Slashdot Mirror


Amiga's president unexpectedly resigns

TuxDaddy writes "Jim Collas has resigned as president of Amiga-however no details are available yet. " Well, let the speculation machine run rampant-is Amiga serious? Is there anything happening with them?Update: 09/01 07:42 by H :Well, they've announced their new president as Tim Schmidt. Collas has left to "pursue personal interests".

25 of 116 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Collas out.. by Sloppy · · Score: 2

    The classic Amiga is doomed in the long run by its tight coupling with NTSC/PAL video and custom hardware tied to that legacy.

    Just one nit to pick... the Amiga isn't tightly coupled with NTSC/PAL at all. Many Amiga users with graphics cards haven't seen an Amiga chipset screenmode in years. Heck, the Draco Amiga clone didn't even have all that hardware. The Amiga does indeed have a few problems with being held back by legacy concerns, but graphics/display isn't one of them.


    ---
    Have a Sloppy day!
    --
    As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
  2. Real Amiga People? by Trepidity · · Score: 2

    Are any of the real (read: original) Amiga people still with Amiga? Are Collas and/or his replacement longtime Amiga people, or were they brought in in the last few years? It'd be nice if they still had some of the original people around. What would really suck is if they make something completely unrelated to the Amiga but slap the "Amiga" name on it just for the hell of it (and because they own the rights to the name).

  3. Precisely! by MenTaLguY · · Score: 2

    Except of course that Jay Miner is still dead... Who else could they get?

    Still dead, you say? Ahh, but that's what Transmeta's really working on!


    Berlin-- http://www.berlin-consortium.org
    --

    DNA just wants to be free...
    1. Re:Precisely! by SoftwareJanitor · · Score: 2

      Still dead, you say? Ahh, but that's what Transmeta's really working on!

      They'd be better off calling the 'Psychic Fraud^h^h^heinds Network then. :-)

  4. This is no TROLL... (Offtopic: Nick) by Sun+Tzu · · Score: 2

    ...for he is tattooed with the number of the BEAST! He just looks like a troll. ;-)

  5. Re:My Lame 2 cents by eponymous+cohort · · Score: 2

    There's no absolute proof that they are using a Transmeta CPU. There's also no proof that Transmeta is even making CPUs, so therefore it must be true!

    Seriously I had read an account that a presentation that Amiga was giving used the name "Transmeta" in it. The people giving the presentation would not comment on it.

    --

    Of all the comments I've ever posted, this is definately one of them

  6. Amiga by drwiii · · Score: 2

    Just FYI, there's an Amiga section currently getting underway on the new osonline.org discussion site.

  7. Re:Collas out.. by SoftwareJanitor · · Score: 2

    Of course, of computers are "doomed to failure in the long run", we'd still be using Altairs & 4040 cpu's (or valves) if it didn't.

    Well, that is true, but then again, when doom came to those products, the companies quit building and selling them.

    But then no-one has said they will develop the Classic hardware, but they will support it as long as it is feasible.

    Actually I've seen more than a few Amiga fans suggest that (at least as an interim step) they more-or-less reintroduce the 'classic' hardware with a few hot-rod type features. Personally I don't think that would be a very commercially viable thing to do since it is unlikely anyone other than a few Amiga diehards would buy one. Especially given the retooling costs, I don't think that they could be built at a reasonable price and still have enough features and performance to be competitive with current PC clone and/or Mac hardware.

    Also, there are several Amiga companies working on PPC systems (although IMHO the early "PowerUP" cards are rather poor), with 68k emulation & porting parts of the OS to PPC.

    That sort of approach would have made sense to do around the time that Apple made their 68K->PPC transition, but it seems a little late in the game to do it now.

  8. Full story here. by mattdm · · Score: 3
    ZDNet has a longer article. Doesn't really say much more though.

    --

  9. Re:Well... by Squid · · Score: 2

    A good self-consistent paranoid conspiracy theory would be an IMPROVEMENT over the information we (don't) have right now...

  10. Well... by belbo · · Score: 3
    --

    --
    "Just believe everything I tell you, and it will all be very, very simple."

  11. Collas out.. by greywire · · Score: 2

    Well this is either real good, or real bad. Maybe both. Collas was big on the linux thing and the consumer-multimedia-box thingy, while the rest of us hardcore Amigans want a computer with a powerfull AmigaOS. Perhaps they decide to lean more towards the computer side and Collas got pissed and left? Maybe AOS 3.5 is a hit. Maybe they just really, really underestimated the Classic Amiga. Maybe they're real scared of IWin and the BoXer and Phase5 and QNX taking all the Amiga's "mindshare" away...

    Or maybe they just fucked up and are about to bankrupt again...

    --
    -- Senior Software Engineer, Attorney appearance services, locallawyerapp.com.
    1. Re:Collas out.. by SoftwareJanitor · · Score: 2

      Just one nit to pick... the Amiga isn't tightly coupled with NTSC/PAL at all.

      Many of the custom chips in the 'classic' Amigas are built to operate on frequencies derived from NTSC/PAL signals that don't make sense if you are running with a PC style video card. This is true even for things like the Zorro bus timing, sound and floppy disk control.

      Many Amiga users with graphics cards haven't seen an Amiga chipset screenmode in years.

      One of the few niche markets that the Amiga was moderately successful in was video production, where NTSC/PAL video modes make sense. Unfortunately for Amiga, as I point out, NTSC/PAL are going to get phased out in favor of HDTV in the next few years so that will be a dying market.

      Heck, the Draco Amiga clone didn't even have all that hardware.

      And how compatible was it with the typical hardware-hammering software of the 'classic' Amiga period?

      The Amiga does indeed have a few problems with being held back by legacy concerns, but graphics/display isn't one of them.

      Unfortunately for the Amiga, if you are going to use a graphics chipset designed for a x86 PC clone as most of the Amiga video cards do, you lose one of the major differentiators of the Amiga hardware, which was all of the video coprocessors. Also unfortunately for the Amiga, its custom video hardware isn't all that impressive compared to the current state of the art in the x86 PC world.

    2. Re:Collas out.. by SoftwareJanitor · · Score: 2

      I think perhaps the argument with fewer 'maybe's is more likely to be correct.

      The classic Amiga is doomed in the long run by its tight coupling with NTSC/PAL video and custom hardware tied to that legacy. NTSC and PAL are soon going to be dead as they are replaced by HDTV. The Amiga is also aflicted by goofy hardware driven by compromises Commodore made to be 'cheap' that only made sense in the 80's (like the bizare floppy drive hardware), but don't make sense today. And also by the essentially dead (68K, RIP) processor architecture it was tied to.
      A lot of these things could have been overcome if someone had been working continuously on them (as Apple overcame many of the same problems -- proprietary floppy->standard and 68K->PPC). Unfortunately for Amiga, they essentially stood still from about 1993 until recently. Six years is practically three lifetimes in the computer business.

  12. Hey! by Gleef · · Score: 2

    Does this mean tomorrow we're going to find him working for MSN too?

    ----

    --

    ----
    Open mind, insert foot.
  13. Re:The Curse Of the Amiga by SoftwareJanitor · · Score: 2

    Wow...the "curse of the Amiga" takes yet another victim.

    Hmmm... I am not sure who is victim and who is villan here, according to what some people have said about this guy.

    Even if they were to bring product to market today, would anyone have enough faith in the company to purchase it?

    No way. I never trusted Commodore enough to buy anything from them. I trusted Escom even less. I've been wondering if Amiga will somehow end up killing Gateway since they bought the corpse of Amiga.

    Somewhere, Mehdi Ali is laughing at all of this...

    Laughing while he counts his ill-gotten gains, no doubt. On the other hand, hindsight being what it is, I don't see that things would have been that much different in the long run had Commodore and Escom had less incompetent and/or corrupt management.

  14. Re: Hmm. First Amiga Goes Silent... by Squid · · Score: 2

    3.5 ain't even OUT yet. I was kinda hoping they'd release it before the $#!+ hit the fan, so at least we'd get SOMETHING from them before they implode... at this rate, the only actual thing ever done at Amiga Inc. (which isn't even true, they OUTSOURCED it) will probably never be released.

  15. Re:Schmidt appointed new Amiga president by mattdm · · Score: 2
    "Pursue personal interests" is a euphemism if I've ever heard one. They always say that when someone gets the axe.

    --

  16. My Lame 2 cents by BadlandZ · · Score: 3
    He left because they have nothing exciting going on, and everyone was looking for something new and amazing from them. He's bailing out before he gets pined as the guy in charge when they fall flat on thier face. :-)

    Gotta admit, there is no basis for this guess, but what basis do you have for Amiga using a Transmeta Super CPU, and becoming the ultimate graphic workstation of the year 2000? People seem to believe that with no evidence, why not just accept they are doing nothing exciting at all?

  17. Now I get it! by G-Man · · Score: 3

    All this time I thought they wanted to produce an alternative to Apple products for multimedia content creation. Maybe they just want to be an alternative to Apple in the "corporate soap opera" arena. With things pretty stable in Cupertino, they must see an opening. Of course, they're gonna need to lose a whole lot more money first.

    Maybe they should hire Gil Amelio. He can hire on an original Amiga founder, get dumped, and the other fella can take over as iCEO...

    1. Re:Now I get it! by SoftwareJanitor · · Score: 2

      Maybe they should hire Gil Amelio.

      Hey, Gil is still available I think. :-)

      He can hire on an original Amiga founder, get dumped, and the other fella can take over as iCEO...

      Except of course that Jay Miner is still dead... Who else could they get?

  18. Re:Get out while the getting is good... by webslacker · · Score: 2

    Actually, I think Compaq and Dell are in different markets. Right now Apple's drawing concentric red circles on SGI and Intergraph.

  19. This is becoming a freaking soap opera... by MenTaLguY · · Score: 5

    Last time, Amiga was released from the hospital after a miraculous recovery from total paralysis and amnesia to be reuinted with Jim, her husband. The couple decided to adopt the little orphan Linux. Now, on their first night together after the car accident that separated them, she finds Jim cold and distant...

    [Amiga] What's the matter, Jim? Don't you love me?
    [Jim] No... Amiga... I'm sorry, but you're just not the same woman I fell in love with ... not since the accident...
    [Amiga] It's that hussy Apple, isn't it?! Her and those flashy G4s...
    [Jim] I ... I ...
    [Amiga] ADMIT IT!@#$
    [Jim] I can't lie to you ... your vaporware just can't compare to her firmware ... yes, yes, I'm having an affair with Apple!
    [Amiga] You bastard! GET OUT#(@$&*(@# GET OUT OF MY HOUSE(#@*($#@
    * Jim slams the door
    * Amiga sobs

    Tune in tomorrow for another episode of As The Workbench Turns...


    Berlin-- http://www.berlin-consortium.org
    --

    DNA just wants to be free...
  20. The Real Story by jd · · Score: 3
    Jim Collias is to replace David Duchovny in the X-Files. The show will be re-launched as the A-Files, with Skinner being played by Mr. T.

    In other news, Sapphire and Steel (the British version of the X-Files) will also be returning, this time as the new joint presidents of the Amiga. Apparently, mixing the old and the new was causing a timebreak, and will require the sacrifice of AmigaOS and two christmas party hats.

    The new Amiga was last seen in the Bahamas, in the company of Gillian Anderson. Rumours of an electronic affair were denied, but reports suggest Gillian may be getting a surgically-implanted network port for her left arm.

    --
    It's a small world and it smells funny; I'd buy another if it wasn't for the money; Take back what I paid (SoM)
  21. Schmidt appointed new Amiga president by rrogers · · Score: 2

    Here's the news just 1 hour later from ZDNN:

    Amiga said Wednesday it had appointed Tom Schmidt as it's new president to replace Jim Collas who unexpectedly resigned from the company. A spokesman for the company said Collas had resigned to persue personal interests.