Slashdot Mirror


User: reve_etrange

reve_etrange's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,511
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,511

  1. Re:Haleluja ... on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    Dark matter and dark energy are both indirectly observable, via gravitation and the time dependency of the FLRW scale factor/red shift of distant objects, respectively. Either indirectly observable things are "still technically observable" or they aren't - you can't have it both ways.

  2. Re:Tip of the iceberg on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    These same aliens also put all our 'siblings' on this planet

    They could still just leave one thing, though. See a nice planet, launch some archaea into the atmosphere, check in in a few billion years...

    Or maybe even just some amphiphiles and oligonucleotides, they will probably do fine without any supervision.

  3. Re:understanding evolution? on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    simple self replicating single celled organisms

    Not even, just oligonucleotides and amphiphiles.

  4. Re: Haleluja ... on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    At least not anymore.

    Also, if there are no draconian Islamic theocracies enforcing capital apostasy laws within, say, the next 100 years, then they will have beaten Catholicism in that race by several hundred years.

  5. Re:Haleluja ... on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    Even if you could somehow prove that the beginning wasn't a massive but happy accident, you would still have zero proof that the "uncaused cause" had anything to do with a personal god. And anyway, why can your "uncaused cause" not need a cause but everything else does? You can't have a logical argument when you're willing to break your own rules to justify your beliefs.

    I think there are few more critical assumptions you didn't mention, which also should be unpacked. First, is the one you allude to, which is that infinities are necessarily illogical and self-contradictory, which is patently false. Second, that the cause of the universe can be regarded automatically as the cause of life on Earth, rather than as merely establishing the conditions for that cause. I don't think that's at all clear given that "causes" apparently require a background such as the universe in which to occur.

  6. Re:Haleluja ... on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    what other being could make a statement as being an absolute truth, then change their mind and state categorically that the opposite is true?

    A man, obviously. Oh, was that supposed to be a rhetorical question?

  7. Re:Haleluja ... on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    That's the whole point. It cannot be turtles all the way down, at some point reality must have some base that is uncaused

    That's one hell of an assumption. That any form of infinite regress is necessarily impossible is just an assertion without an argument. Contra the Greeks and other until Cantor, infinities do not entail logical inconsistencies and are in fact realized in the universe.

  8. Re:Haleluja ... on Pope Francis Declares Evolution and Big Bang Theory Are Right · · Score: 1

    the assumption must be made that our ability to observe the universe is absolute.

    It doesn't follow. If there are things which are only observable to us indirectly, the argument fails.

  9. Re:I run Gentoo on Building All the Major Open-Source Web Browsers · · Score: 1

    I thought there were options to install pre-compiled versions of the packages. Are they not all available, or am I just mistaken?

    (Obviously I'm not a Gentoo user. Mostly Debian).

  10. Re:Only usefull for wine? on Direct3D 9.0 Support On Track For Linux's Gallium3D Drivers · · Score: 2

    Even the new Il-2 Battle of Stalingrad still uses DirectX 9. You'll be able to play every current flight sim I think.

  11. Re:Straw Man on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 1

    So in your eyes, anonymous FTP has equivalent security to two-factor authentication over HTTPS.

  12. Re:US Military Uses Oil Like a Smaller Country on Pentagon Unveils Plan For Military's Response To Climate Change · · Score: 2

    Just to be pedantic, I think that's "clean" or "zero-emissions," since we probably don't actually want a nearby supernova to refresh our uranium supply.

  13. Re:Systems perpetuate themselves on Pentagon Unveils Plan For Military's Response To Climate Change · · Score: 1

    we don't win against nature on these things.

    Tell it to the Dutch.

  14. Re:Systems perpetuate themselves on Pentagon Unveils Plan For Military's Response To Climate Change · · Score: 1

    if we got serious we could do it in a decade without trouble

    I agree - and actually since the economy is demand constrained, shifting energy sources will be expansionary.

  15. Re:Climate change is degrading the military on Pentagon Unveils Plan For Military's Response To Climate Change · · Score: 1

    Are you proposing restrictions on what military personal can do with their wages?

  16. Re:For everything there is a season on Pentagon Unveils Plan For Military's Response To Climate Change · · Score: 3, Informative

    you should be worried.

    Not really. Even without any containment measures, an infected person passes the disease to only 1 other person. If there was a disease as deadly as Ebola, where that number was ~20 people (as it is with measles for example), then I would be worried.

    The low transmission rate is why the outbreak has fewer than 10,000 people after several months.

  17. Re:Sounds like a planned PR stunt to me. on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 1

    I think that "copyright infringement" and "theft/larceny" are essentially legal terms with specific meanings, while "sex crime" is not. Unauthorized access and distribution of these photographs is sexually motivated, which makes it reasonable to describe the crimes in question (i.e. unauthorized use of a computer and copyright infringement) as "sex crimes."

  18. Re:Straw Man on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 0

    a reasonable expectation of privacy

    You do not understand the meaning of this phrase. It makes no reference to the existence of technological barriers, of any kind, to the breach of privacy. You have a reasonable expectation of privacy for a sealed envelope, even though it is trivial to read the contents of that envelope.

  19. Re:Straw Man on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 2

    what goes onto the Internet

    How is talking about "the internet" here even relevant? There is a huge difference in the privacy and security of data transfers made through different web services alone, let alone all extant networking protocols.

  20. Re:But that was not the same! on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 1

    Someone ought to warn your date that consent means nothing to you.

  21. Re:Read below to see what Bennett has to say. on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 1

    Isn't this exactly the fallacy described by TFA? There are both risks and benefits to storing data online, while you're remark suggests there are risks only.

  22. Re:Sounds like a planned PR stunt to me. on The Correct Response To Photo Hack Victim-Blamers · · Score: 0

    Under current US law, obtaining unauthorized access to privately served files is clearly criminal. Nude photographs are of note solely due to their sexual content.

    Can you explain why you think it is incorrect or illogical to describe crimes pertaining to sex or sexual content as "sex crimes?"

  23. Re:OracleVSGoogle: Judge can program, you still fo on Interviews: Ask Florian Mueller About Software Patents and Copyrights · · Score: 1

    -1 Has Never Written a Range Check

  24. Re:Height is complicated on Nearly 700 Genetic Factors Found To Influence Human Adult Height · · Score: 1

    Any time a trait has continuous variation, there are going to be a large number of genes involved.

  25. Re:Not news: GWAS Often Fail on Nearly 700 Genetic Factors Found To Influence Human Adult Height · · Score: 1

    At least one result of the study is obvious from first principles - the large number of genes involved in determining height. (Because height varies continuously).