Slashdot Mirror


User: chl

chl's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
124
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 124

  1. Re:missing countries on Fusion Reactor Project Largest After ISS · · Score: 1
    This new project is fussion.

    Great, I'm all confussed now.

    chl

  2. Re:IIS? on Fusion Reactor Project Largest After ISS · · Score: 2, Informative
    largest thermonuclear disaster

    From a disaster point of view, fusion devices are extremely boring. If the reactor vessel was breached, the inrushing air would be to the plasma as the inrushing ocean on a candle flame. A magnetically confined plasma is about a factor one million less dense than normal air. It is also about one million times hotter than normal air, so you actually have a plasma pressure of one atmosphere.

    This means that the energy content of the plasma and the confining magnetic field is just enough to wreck the experiment, but not much else. The radiological risk is also negligible, because the radioactive inventory of a fusion reactor is of the order of tens of kilogrammes, enough for less than a second of operation (compared to hundreds of tons for fission reactors, which have enough for years of operation). Also, the tritium, even if it escaped the reactor building, would be gone after 120 years through decay, which is a pretty short time compared to other radionuclides.

    And yes, IAAPP (I am a plasma physicist).

    chl

  3. Re:Neutron Source on Fusion Reactor Project Largest After ISS · · Score: 1
    And what can be done with a high flux of neutrons?

    Breed fissionable reactor fuel from thorium to keep the fission plants running until we can switch to all fusion? Although I doubt the ITER team can afford to waste money and effort on this. Also, the earth's uranium resources are not going to run out until long after the ITER timeframe.

    Then, there are the neutron diagnostics for the solid state physicists, but they can usually make do with conventional fission-based neutron sources.

    chl

  4. Re:Neutron Source on Fusion Reactor Project Largest After ISS · · Score: 1
    The tritium must be regenerated because it is rather expensive.

    Tritium also has a half life of about 12 years, so that even if it did grow on trees, it would be practically gone after 120 years, so it does not accumulate in nature the way coal, oil etc. do. Breeding tritium on a JIT basis therefore is the best way.

    chl

  5. Re:Can't be done on Company Files Motion to Stop IE Distribution · · Score: 1
    We'll immediately be plunged back into the recession we're slowly starting to climb out of.

    Now that's an argument against software patents if ever I heard one.

  6. Re:Bog them down with litigation on Charter Cable Sues To Quash RIAA Subpoenas · · Score: 2, Funny
    you'll have to stop listening to the radio too. They do get paid each time a song is played.

    Pssst. They are not supposed to know about that backchannel in every radio set that we use to spy on them. They must continue to think that their radio consumption is private.

    chl

  7. Re:free speech has a cost on Geer Comments On Firing From @Stake · · Score: 1
    Yes, they are both theories. There is nothing scientifically factual about evolution whatsoever.

    What do you mean by that? Scientific theories deal with the facts as they are, because there is nothing else to work on. They are factual by the very definition.

    Do you mean to say the evolution is not 'a fact', that it need not be true? That may very well be. Natural scientists do not have the luxury of a higher authority that simply tells them what's true. At most, they can have theories that explain all of the observable facts (non-verifiable accounts of irreproducible events, like the creation, count neither as observable nor as facts). In that sense, it does not matter if 'evolution' or 'the Maxwell equations' are true in the sense that some creator specifically built them into the universe. They are viable theories that haven't been disproven so far and that's all that natural science can give you.

    Granted, religion is more satisfying because it gives you absolute certainty. On the other hand, creation as a scientific theory does not explain how species change over time and become extinct. Also the postulation of a super-natural being kind of defeats the whole purpose of a natural science.

    chl

  8. Re:I lived in the Midwest... on U.S. Court Blocks Anti-Telemarketing List · · Score: 1
    You'd think the morons would recognize the fact that if someone wants to sign up for this list, that means THEY WON'T MAKE A SALE BY CALLING THEM.

    I thought the trick was to coerce unsuspecting callees into buying stuff they do not need. So the DNC list does hurt their "business."

    chl

  9. Re:terrorist on College Freshman Builds Fusion Reactor · · Score: 1
    Nevertheless, SCO cannot demand any money from the customers that use neutrons -- after all, they are free of charge.

    Actually, they have lots of charge -- only it all cancels out.

    chl

  10. Re:I'd only point out that. . . on Orson Scott Card on mp3 File Sharing · · Score: 1
    If I fix someone's car I don't expect to derive continuing income from it. More to the point, I certainly don't expect that my descendents should derive an income from it.

    On the other hand, why should the price of my creation depend on how long I live?

    chl

  11. Re:Kind of scary. on Space Elevator Going Up · · Score: 1
    b) Not really. Airborne traffic is smart enough to deal with comms towers, skyscrapers and hurricanes. This thing does not move - all you need to do is fly around it.

    *cough* Sep 11 *cough*

    chl

  12. Re:Dumbing down degrees on CS Master's Degrees - US vs. EU Programs? · · Score: 1
    Will it stay this way, or will Germany be "harmonized" to conform to the Bologna agreement?

    All the physics departments fight to keep up the level of their degrees, i.e. they want to keep the current curriculum with minimal changes to acommodate the bachelor after three years. Currently, if you leave after three years, you have nothing, so they basically add an extra bachelor examination (for the quitters who do not want a "real" degree).

    The old Diplom degree that you got after five years would then also be the Masters degree.

    The politicians see every year in school as "wasted time" and want to water down the requirements for every degree.

    chl

  13. Re:Dumbing down degrees on CS Master's Degrees - US vs. EU Programs? · · Score: 1
    Thus a U.S. associates degree looks to me like the equivalent of a European bachelors degree, a Europen masters degree becomes the equivalent of the U.S. bachelors degree, and the European PhD like a U.S. PhD candidate.

    No. A five year programme in e.g. Germany is five years of full time study devoted to a single subject. After five years of physics, including writing a one-year thesis, I am at least worth a US physics master.

    chl

  14. Problems of German society? on Deep Linking Legal in Germany · · Score: 2, Interesting
    You might now think that Germany is the land of the sane and bright, but this isn't true.

    As a German, I cannot really disagree with that. Still, I find Germany a nice country to live in because enough of us are sane and/or bright.

    In fact in some German states ISP are required to use censorship filters to filter content which is showing disrespect to human dignity like infamous rotten or neo nazi propaganda. [...] Germany has a long list of incidents of restricting the peoples right to access information and entertainment by claiming to protect youth and society.

    Historically, some forms of hate speech are forbidden out of a desire not to repeat certain experiences that happened in the 1930s and 1940s. Our allied-approved constitution still says "There is no censorship". Of course it was very silly that KISS have a different logo in Germany because it is forbidden to use the runic SS script, which is also a symbol for the SS murderers.

    So sales of Doom, Quake and Command and Conquer 3 are extremely restricted like hardcore bukkakke porn.

    They may not be advertised nor sold to minors. This is hardly extreme. It is also practically useless in stopping minors to get such stuff.

    The public rights are slowly getting more and restricted. In this picture it fits that the limits for consumed alcohol before driving are steadly lowered, speed limits are spreading like salmonella, the weapon laws are more and more restricted and smoking is made illegal in more and more places.

    How are drunk driving and poisoning people public rights? There still is no general speed limit on the motorways and I have no sympathy for people who complain about getting caught for speeding.

    I agree, however, with your sentiments for the new weapon law. It is practically impossible to legally own a firearm for self defense in Germany. I can only guess that the public allows this because most people do not feel threatened enough by criminals that they feel in need of a gun. And our violent crime rate is relatively low.

    chl

  15. Re:someone doesn't understand radiation... on RFID Industry Confidential Memos · · Score: 1
    Signal strength (from a point source) does not fall off exponentially -- the example you give is the right answer. The signal intensity from a point source that emits into all directions falls off with the square of the distance, i.e. twice the distance gives a quarter of the signal strength for any given fixed antenna area.

    Given that cell phones (GSM anyway) have less than 2 Watts and can be received by a base station kilometers away, I would say that even power levels of tenth millionths of watts are easily detectable.

    chl

  16. As a physicist on Top Physicist Advocates Scientific Self-Censorship · · Score: 2, Funny
    I must say that "transform[ing] the entire planet Earth into an inert hyperdense sphere about 100 meters across" just by colliding some elementary particles sounds so uebercool that I probably wouldn't very much mind being dead afterwards.

    chl

  17. Re:Unsigned Code on Testing an Orange SPV 'Smartphone' · · Score: 1
    Well, all you have to do is make someone run your nifty program that keeps dialing the 0900 number you set up for $40 per minute.

    chl

  18. Re:Irresponsible? on Controversy Surrounds Huge IE Hole · · Score: 1
    If Linux had an exploit that allowed someone to ssh into your box, su to root, then fsck your harddrive, and a patch wasn't released yet, would you be pissed off that bugtraq posted the code to exploit the bug?
    If I got the advisory on what to disable in order to defeat the exploit at the same time the exploit was posted,then, no, I would not be "pissed off."

    With this particular exploit, I would need to actively follow a link or read some mail, so it would not even matter if the exploit was posted while I slept.

    chl

  19. Re:Soybean + Corn = Plantiality? on Drug Making Genes Added To Corn Jump To Soya · · Score: 1
    Low and behold, some genetically altered 2nd generation corn gets into the soybeans. Big deal.
    If the genetically altered corn is full of the drugs that it was designed to produce in the first place then, yes, that is a big deal.

    chl

  20. Re:Wow on Google Complies with Law, Excludes 'controversial' Sites · · Score: 1
    Remember there are pro-abortion sites that advocate murder of unborn babies.

    Remember that abortion does not count as murder where abortions are legal, so you do not advocate murder by advocating abortion in that jurisdiction. So the law against advocating crime does not hold. And since there are no other applicable reasons for censorship in Germany, pro-abortion sites usually can not be stopped.

  21. Re:They're all ready slipping down the slippery sl on Google Complies with Law, Excludes 'controversial' Sites · · Score: 1
    You say: In fact there is, by definition, no censorship in Germany. and then say:

    This was actually a kind of joke. The constitution literally says: There is no censorship. I wanted to point out that you need as much as a trial if you want to silence some speech.

  22. google.com blocked? on Google Complies with Law, Excludes 'controversial' Sites · · Score: 1
    As a matter of fact they can't. Access to google.com is restricted.

    I do not know what you can do, or what exactly google does for access control, but all googles seem to have the same ip number:

    www.google.de CNAME www.google.com

    www.google.at CNAME www.google.com

    www.google.com A 216.239.51.101

    "Just" enter the bare ip number...

    But, as I wrote elsewhere, the two sites mentioned in the article do not seem to be delisted from google.de anyway.

  23. Re:They're all ready slipping down the slippery sl on Google Complies with Law, Excludes 'controversial' Sites · · Score: 1
    Anti-abortion sites are censored, what about pro-Catholic? After all, Catholics oppose abortion.

    Anti-abortion sites are censored when they give names and addresses of abortion doctors who should be killed. Abortion is a delicate subject in Germany and the subject as such is not censored. In fact there is, by definition, no censorship in Germany. Any restrictions must be justified either by yells of "think of the children" or by some other law, e.g. Holocaust denial is a punishable act specifically mentioned in the Strafgesetzbuch ("book of punishments").

  24. Re:It costs the cellcompany the same amount of mon on CDMA, Cell Phone Standards And Who "Wins" · · Score: 1

    > What happens in England if a land line person calls a cell
    > phone? Do they have to pay
    > for the cell phone charges?

    Yes.

    In Germany at least, the "area code" indicates if you are calling a free 0800, $$$ 0900, semi-expensive cellphone number etc. Billing information is easily transmitted across several carriers.