Slashdot Mirror


User: Wonko+the+Sane

Wonko+the+Sane's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
2,379
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 2,379

  1. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 1

    I was a little short because I thought that somebody was about to bring up that incompetent failure of a submarine officer Chris Brownfield's book. He spread some disinformation about that incident.

  2. Re:Umm... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 1

    so what's your point?

    The point is that happened decades ago and the US Navy no longer does it, nor have the crews trained how to do it.

    The institutional knowledge would need to be rebuilt almost from scratch.

    I'm not talking about the skills of operating the sonar equipment to track a contact but the day-to-day skills of how to operate the boat without making any accidental noises that would give your position away for days or weeks at a time plus the motivation that it takes to make the crew care enough to make sure they don't make any mistakes. That culture is long gone.

  3. Re:Not the only way on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I guarantee you that the Chinese SSBNs are loud enough to be tracked with them

    All the ones that we know about are too loud.

    How many container ships leave China for the port of LA every week? Is SOSUS sensitive enough to distinguish the noise of an SSBN that is following one closely enough?

  4. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 4, Funny

    Were you aboard the Hartford during the grounding incident in Sardinia?

    Yes

    What was that like?

    Bumpy

  5. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 1

    What about a technician repairing those launch circuits though?

    No.

    I've never been on an SSBN but I can tell you what is involved with launching a Tomahawk cruise missile.

    First of all, the missiles are not kept powered on all the time. There is a process that you must go through to do that.

    Second, the physical process of launching the missile involves a number of systems that involve people directly manipulating valves, pumps, tanks and other non-electronic hardware.

    There is absolutely no way for this process to happen by itself accidentally.

  6. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Surely we have the assets to track three SSBNs, particularly when at least one of them is in port at any given time?

    I was in the Atlantic fleet, but to the best of my knowledge the US Navy doesn't do that kind of thing anymore, at least not all the time.

    I can tell you that fast attack submarines in general did not train and practice for this kind of mission and the officers in general did not take the threat posed by another nuclear navy seriously at all while I was there.

    The institutional knowledge and skills to successfully pull off the kind of sub-on-sub tracking that they did in the cold war did not exist anywhere that I could see.

  7. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 2, Informative

    SLBMS are intercontinental. The whole point of an SSBN is that it can be anywhere in the ocean and still hit you.

  8. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 4, Informative

    Wonko, you were (are?) a bubblehead, right?

    USS Hartford May 2000 - February 2006

    It's my understanding that the Chinese are at least a generation or two behind us in terms of submarine technology. Even if they've received assistance from the Russians it would seem unlikely that they could construct an SSBN that could travel all the way across the Pacific without being tracked by the US Navy. If they did manage such a feat then I certainly hope that heads are rolling at Pearl Harbor and the Pentagon....

    You don't understand how big the Pacific ocean is.

    The only way that you stop an SSBN is to maintain a large fast attack fleet and track each and every one of them as they leave port and follow them until the return.

  9. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The possibility of an SSBN sneaking up on the American coast was never discounted. This type of attack has always been deterred by US second strike capability.

  10. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 1

    God, please tell me that it's impossible for the Navy to just sorta go "whoops" and launch something like this. This was done by someone with a plan and authorization, or something is seriously wrong.

    A person could not accidentally launch a Trident missile bu bumping into the launch button any more than a NASA janitor could bump into something and accidentally launch the Space Shuttle.

  11. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 1

    Trident missiles are not like Estes model rockets. Getting one to the point where a launch is even possible isn't something that happens accidentally and it's not plausible that the US Navy would be conducting the kind of exercises where an accidental launch was even possible in that part of the ocean without taking precautions like NOATMs

  12. Re:Hmmm .... on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 4, Funny

    maybe somebody spilled coffee on a sub's weapons control console.

    SLBM launches don't work like that.

    It would make just as much sense for you to spill coffee on your keyboard and accidentally install Windows Vista.

  13. Re:FAA NOTAM on Mystery Missile Launched Near LA · · Score: 1

    Check those dates and compared to the date of the event in TFA.

  14. Re:And so what? on Income Tax Quashed, Ballmer To Cash In Billions · · Score: 2, Informative

    A capitalist will commit fraud and manipulate the law to make it legal. Or will use eminent domain or asset forfeiture to get the government to take it from you.

    What you described is not capitalism. Just because a bunch of statist pricks have hijacked the term doesn't mean the meaning of capitalism has changed.

  15. Re:And so what? on Income Tax Quashed, Ballmer To Cash In Billions · · Score: 3, Insightful

    There's nothing socialists hate worse that failing to get their hands on someone else's money.

  16. Re:Flash? on Firefox 4 Beta For Mobile Now Faster and Sleeker · · Score: 1

    Unfortunately there's no mention of what mobile devices it supports

    Android and Maemo

  17. Re:Flash? on Firefox 4 Beta For Mobile Now Faster and Sleeker · · Score: 1

    Why would they mention it?

    Because it doesn't work, at least on Android with the previous beta.

  18. Re:Flash? on Firefox 4 Beta For Mobile Now Faster and Sleeker · · Score: 1

    The plugin is included with newer versions of Android but Firefox does not use it.

  19. Flash? on Firefox 4 Beta For Mobile Now Faster and Sleeker · · Score: 1

    Unfortunately there's no mention of Flash support.

  20. Re:Irrelevant. on 2010 Election Results Are In · · Score: 1

    Well Ben Bernanke just announced a 20% inflation tax on the USD so that should make you happy.

  21. Re:Should be good for the economy on 2010 Election Results Are In · · Score: 1

    The bankers at the top knew. Executives have testified under oath that they knew and even without that testimony the fact that their trading desks were shorting the same securities that the mortgage securitization desks were selling proves that they knew what was happening.

  22. Re:Irrelevant. on 2010 Election Results Are In · · Score: 1

    Any inflation reduces the 'real' amount of outstanding debts.

    That sounds great in theory until you are the person whose income is remaining constant or declining while the cost of living is going up.

    Of course, the real answer is for people with unserviceable debt to go through bankruptcy and clear it but you can thank Congress for making that more difficult.

  23. Re:The British are now like the Terrorists... on UK Pressures the US To Takedown Extremist Videos · · Score: 2, Insightful

    All governments have a love-hate relationship with freedom. Human livestock is more productive the more freedom you give it, but at the same time with more freedom comes more recognition that the farmers aren't necessary.

    Ideally governments want to give their livestock just enough freedom to maximize profits and no more.

  24. Re:Fear & Ignorance on 2010 Election Results Are In · · Score: 1

    The stockholders would have been wiped out. Some of the bondholders would have been wiped out.

    Smaller regional banks would have taken the business, borrowers who were underwater would have been foreclosed on and probably went through bankruptcy, clearing the debt overhang.

  25. Re:Should be good for the economy on 2010 Election Results Are In · · Score: 1

    We never recovered from the pets.com debacle.

    That's true. Historians a century from now will probably pinpoint 1999 as the beginning of the Depression.