Slashdot Mirror


User: wonkey_monkey

wonkey_monkey's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
8,419
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 8,419

  1. Re:24 fps -- 48 fps shutter projection speed on Hobbit Film Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second · · Score: 1

    This is a bit like TV that has a frame rate of 30 (29.97) but a field rate of 60 (59.94) because it's interlaced.

    Perhaps you're not explaining yourself clearly, but it's not like that at all. Interlaced video really does have twice the temporal resolution (at the cost of vertical resolution) - the eye isn't being made to believe anything that isn't true.

  2. Re:You don't know frame rates on Hobbit Film Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second · · Score: 1

    Faster frame rates require higher shutter speeds, and higher shutter speeds decrease motion blur. This can make footage look stroboscopic-like and unpleasant. I noticed this years ago in televised (American) Football. Some shots appeared smooth, while other shots appeared harsh and stroboscopic.

    As long as the shutter speed is kept the same relative to the frame rate, this won't be an issue. What you may have been seeing were some of the high-speed cameras being used at normal framerates inbetween slow-mo replays - the same thing can be seen at Wimbledon.

    Not sure what they'll do if they decide they need a "downsampled" 24fps version of The Hobbit, though.

  3. Re:48fps with more motion blur? on Hobbit Film Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second · · Score: 4, Informative

    Actually the "motion blur gap" is only half the width you think it is - in the olden days the shutter would be closed for half the time to allow the film to spool on, so each frame is a snapshot of 1/48th of a second.

    Shooting at 48fps, I would expect them to aim for a 1/96s shutter speed. I've worked on motion graphics at 50fps, and 100% motion blur still looks bad at the higher frame rate - 50% looks perfect.

    Increasing motion blur to 1/16s on a 48fps shoot would be a complete mess.

  4. Re:It'll take a little getting used to, that's all on Hobbit Film Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second · · Score: 1

    Exactly what I was about to say. And you can (should!) turn it off.

  5. Re:In film, frame rate = exposure time on Hobbit Film Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second · · Score: 2

    So 24fps would give you 1/48th shutter speed (half open half closed) meaning the motion blur for 48fps digital vs 24fps film should be the same, which explains why they picked 48fps - it afforded them the option to do either 48fps, slow motion or 24fps in post without giving anything up (except disk space).

    Actually, having worked on 50fps digital effects (albeit nothing fancy), you still need to aim for the half-open/half-closed rate, otherwise it's still too much blur. So at 48fps you should be shooting with 1/96th shutter speed.

  6. Re:Uh on Hobbit Film Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second · · Score: 2

    The entire reason they went to 48fps was to try and reduce eye strain during 3D movies. They seem to have forgotten that a 72 refresh rate with a 24 frame rate will do the same thing.

    Yep, you're right, and Oscar-winning directors Peter Jackson and James Cameron are wrong.

  7. Re:That on WW2 Vet Sent 300,000 Pirated DVDs To Troops In Iraq, Afghanistan · · Score: 1, Insightful

    It's nice 'n' all, but... really? Most beautiful?

    What's really beautiful about this situation is the inexorably awkward position he's put the MPAA in. The money won't let them condone, public opinion will never forgive them if they decry.

  8. Re:Huh? on Bionic Eye Patient Tests Planned For 2013 · · Score: 3, Informative
    Replacing "by" with a comma in the last sentence clarifies things:

    This stimulates the retina, sending electric signals along the optic nerve into the brain where they are decoded as vision.

  9. Re:The Weakest Link on Terminal Mixup Implicates TSA Agents In LAX Smuggling Plot · · Score: 5, Informative

    This begs the question

    Raises.

    Sorry. I need help.

  10. Re:Evil, with a capital E on Steve Jobs' Idea For an Ad-Supported OS · · Score: 2

    Ignoring your personal speculation about increasing the ad frequency, how is this a bait-and-switch?

  11. Anyone else find this hard to parse? on Backdoor Found In Arcadyan-based Wi-Fi Routers · · Score: 1
    *Spins around in a phonebox and becomes... Captain Pedantic!*

    A recently reported flaw that allowed an attacker to drastically reduce the number of attempts needed to guess the WPS PIN of a wireless router isn't necessary for some Arcadyan based routers anymore.

    Not necessary for what? That alone took me a while to figure it.

    According to German computer publisher Heise, some 100,000 routers of type Speedport W921V, W504V and W723V are affected in Germany alone.

    Affected by the flaw you've just mentioned above? The one that isn't necessary?

    What makes things worse is the fact that in order to exploit the backdoor,

    I still hadn't seen any mention of a second flaw, so on first reading it seemed like the backdoor is the same unnecessary flaw as mentioned above. I finally realised that there's an old flaw and a new flaw - or at least I think what's trying to be said...

  12. Re:causality on Quantum Experiment Shows Effect Before Cause · · Score: 1

    There is no "the current moment." Time is relative, lunchtime doubly so.

  13. Re:Time delay - info from the future? on Quantum Experiment Shows Effect Before Cause · · Score: 1
    From the GP:

    Only when Victor told them which particles were entangled could they sort their data sets into entangled and non- and see that in fact the entangled set showed the expected correlation.

    So no, it sounds like he can't send messages back in time.

  14. Re:How come everyone in the movie is white? on Travelling Salesman, Thriller Set In a World Where P=NP · · Score: 2

    They're all male too - why didn't you pick up on that, you misogynist clod!

  15. Re:Paradoxical on Quantum Experiment Shows Effect Before Cause · · Score: 1

    Wouldn't it be more interesting for Victor to entangle when Alice and Bob's polarizations aren't correlated? What would that mean?

  16. Re:Methane is bad stuff on Massive Methane Release In the Arctic Region · · Score: 2

    Sorry, are you attempting to refute the possibility of such a feedback loop by pointing out that it hasn't happened yet?

    Why not argue that bullets can't kill you because you've never been shot?

  17. Re:learning != being spoon-fed on Startup Claims C-code To SoC In 8-16 Weeks · · Score: 1

    "SoC", to me, was utterly without meaning. For the want of half a second of typing, an editor could have given those of us who don't know all the acronyms under the Sun at least an inkling of what the article was about. If "SoC" was a secondary term in a quote from a source, or something (such as "ANSI C" in the summary), I'd be less peeved, but when it's exactly what the article is about, I don't think it's too much to ask.

    Just take a look at the Sport pages on the BBC News website - not as niche as Slashdot, but you'd tend not to go there unless you had an interest in sport. And yet we see snippets such as this all around:

    Chelsea striker Fernando Torres
    Premier League footballer Steven Pienaar
    Liverpool's Luis Suarez

    I wouldn't have the first idea of who these people played for out of context, but the BBC have made it simple and clear with just a few extra words.

    It just seems obvious to me that it would be good journalistic style to go that little extra millimetre to make something which you want people to read easy to read, rather than turning one's nose up at anyone too dumb to understand an article about an unexplained acronym.

    Also, if you really feel that a subject line should tell you whether or not you need to read something

    As a matter of fact, that is exactly what I feel a good subject line should tell you.

  18. A better question on Startup Claims C-code To SoC In 8-16 Weeks · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Or can we expect our ANSI C code to be automagically implemented in a SoC in such a short time?

    How about you tell us what SoC stands for first? Once again, editors, we don't all know everything about everything in the tech world. Some of us come here to learn new things, and you guys don't make it easy. TFS should at least leave me with an impression of whether or not I need to read the TFA.

  19. Could've saved us all some time on Did Microsoft Simply Run Out of Time On Windows RT? · · Score: 5, Insightful
    ...and put this part in bold so I'd have known not to bother reading the rest of TFS:

    This is pure speculation on my part

  20. Brought to you by... on Newspapers Pollute Less On E-Readers and Tablets · · Score: 2

    ...the Department of the Bleedin' Obvious.

  21. Re:more kickstarter ads on Elephants Dream Director Readies Blender-Animated Tube · · Score: 1

    The GP refers to slashvertisements for Kickstarter, not an appeal for funds through Kickstarter. Not that I agree with the GP; The article is Slashdot-worthy anyway, and the Kickstarter reference is relevant. But his beef is with what he perceives to be an ad, not an appeal.

  22. Re:Umm yeah, Wikipedia on Survey Finds No Hint of Dark Matter Near Solar System · · Score: 1

    So when's your Nobel Prize due to arrive?

    And what Wikipedia actually says ("says" as in "reports", not "states as fact") is that

    In 1959, Louise Volders demonstrated that spiral galaxy M33 does not spin as expected according to Keplerian dynamics

  23. Re:They haven't lost it on Millions of Brits Lose Ceefax News Service · · Score: 1

    There may still be those being cable-fed with modulated analogue versions of digital channels from a distribution cupboard (happens at my place if you don't have satellite, because there's no terrestrial reception behind the hill), and other cases where 888 subs are relied upon.

  24. Re:What's the problem? on Europe Agrees To Send Airline Passenger Data To US · · Score: 1
    What's wrong with them installing a camera in every room in your house and monitoring you 24/7, taking a direct line into your plumbing to monitor the chemical composition of your bowel movements and storing meticulous notes on your sexual activity in a database (depersonalised in six months, made dormant in five years)?

    The US DHS get my details and my fingerprints when I go through immigration so what's wrong with them getting that stuff 10 hours earlier?

    As others have pointed out, it's not clear that they won't be getting this information even if you're not going anywhere near the US.

  25. Re:Balloon Images? on Google Earth Incorporates Crowdsourced Balloon Images · · Score: 1

    He didn't say it was his wife.