Slashdot Mirror


User: crrieger

crrieger's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
3
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 3

  1. Using Khan as a supplement on Khan Academy: the Teachers Strike Back · · Score: 2

    I teach AP Chemistry and I know several of my students need all the help they can get. I created a class website, making sure to include several pages to the best quality chemistry podcast-type videos I could find. While Khan isn't perfect by any means, I find his videos to be an excellent backup explanation to the topics we discuss in class. I separated his videos into categories that reflect the different units we cover so its was easier for the kids to find a link that meets their needs. I know one of my seniors last year found his website invaluable to pass a college algebra class that switched teachers mid-year, leaving the kids without the best instructor. Sometimes it's nice to have a second voice explaining a topic (we even swap students for tutoring between teachers for this reason), so I think his efforts are on the right track. There are three sets which are of very good quality for AP Chem - the NMSI AP Chem videos, Khan, and a site called Chemguy.com. Even college students in their 100 and 200 level classes would benefit from his offerings.

    One huge thing I have concerns about is the concept of the "flipped classroom" where kids are expected to go home and watch some online video and then expected to go into to class tomorrow well-versed on the topic and ready for some activity. Many higher-order topics need that interactive teacher-student discourse to full understand the topic. I've spent entire periods just covering a single free-response question, making sure to cover a number of tangential topics and showing the full spectrum of the question. Two guys named Bergmann and Sams are pushing the flipped classroom in the sciences, but haven't ponied up the numbers to show progress.

    In an nutshell, Khan and anyone else who produces quality educational chemistry videos is a resource I will encourage my kids to use. I want it to help support discussion and learning in the classroom, but not replace it.

  2. Experimental design is the answer on Chemistry Tasks For the Computer Lab? · · Score: 1

    I teach high school chemistry at one of the highest scoring schools in the state, but I routinely see the same lack of fundamental math skills and investigative thinking that are the basis of science. My colleague has proposed this same question to me, and I was fairly against the use of computers as part of labs for the sake of integrating "technology." They can use a computer to type up the lab report and maybe plug in an Excel graph. I have used statistical packages as part of professional analytical lab work and I can safely say that the concepts behind the math and the significance of the numbers is years beyond a high school curriculum. Computers are great research tools and have great importance in data collection, but these same tasks can be done much more easily with traditional tools.

    I have a full classroom set of the Vernier probeware that integrates with the TI calculators, but I won't even think of using this stuff until I have an Advanced Placement class that shows the maturity and attentiveness that it requires. Instead of flashy toys, I prefer to incorporate investigative labs where you are developing your own procedures with as little assistance from me as possible. I really like labs that recreate classic experiments and have the kids use the same basic tools that chemists used 200 years ago. They love the electrochemistry lab where they use Alessandro Volta's tools to figure out the best combination of metals and acid to use to make a battery powerful enough to charege a capacitor. The cap discharges into an old flashbulb to convert chemical energy to electrical energy to thermal energy and light.

    Spend more time on the fundamentals of scientific math and scientific thinking - the rest will come much more easily since the groundwork has been laid. I did very well in school because I was shown how to think, not just how to use computers and punch a calculator.

  3. Re:if it breeds discontent, so be it. on Paying for Better Math and Science Teachers · · Score: 1

    I'm certainly hoping that it passes. I finished my Master of Arts in Teaching through a private university here in Kentucky last spring, but have currently elected not to use my degree as most of the positions in the local county are of very poor quality. Beginning teachers get thrown into the worst performing schools and are expected to magically turn these places around with little assistance and marginal resources. Many of my classmates began teaching under emergency certifications while they were acquiring their degrees, all of them placed in schools that are amongst the worst in the state. While many of these individuals were very intelligent an talented, they were no match for the kids who awaited them.

    When it came time to job shop, I was very disappointed with the offerings in the local school district. Their method of hiring gives the lowest performing schools first choice of the new crop. Most of these new teachers are early 20-somethings people fresh out of college and desperate to take any position no matter where it may take them. I have wanted to teach for a log time, but I wanted both some age difference from the kids plus I wanted some actual industry experience. I've spent 10 years in positions that have given me practical working knowledge of medicine, chemical laboratories, and environmental science. The kids in my student teaching were shocked at some of the things I have done. I was the same age as some of the seniors when I working in an emergency room. All of their other teachers went straight from college to the teaching profession with no actual science-related work experience.

    So here I am, certified to teach high school biology with a Rank II and working on picking up my chemistry certification. I dropped $110 over the weekend to take the Praxis exam to finish the state requirements for that certification. Money would be an incentive, but I'm more concerned that I will be able to teach in a supportive learning environment. That's a pipe dream, for sure. I had thought about the local Catholic schools as they definitely have a better learning environment and actually enforce discipline, but the pay and benefits don't even compare to the public schools. Most teachers that have jobs in the better quality public schools acquired them mid-semester while they were substitute teachings. Once you're in a school, you're there forever if the principal likes you. I've elected to keep my options open and wait till one of those positions becomes available so I don't waste several years in a school I hate, thus avoiding that time burning out my desire to be a teacher.

    I'm certified, qualified, and have a genuine desire to be a quality teacher - now I just want to see a school worth my time that can give me kids who actually want to learn.