Slashdot Mirror


User: PhilHibbs

PhilHibbs's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
2,928
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 2,928

  1. Re:Stupid, uninforcable on DVD Zoning Enforced In Law · · Score: 1

    Engage brain? I wish they would. They ordered the American Yahoo! auctions site to prevent people in France from being able to access their auction, after all. All Yahoo! were doing was sending IP packets in response to requests from within France, and the courts told them to stop. How is that different from me sending SS armbands in response to a cheque from within France?

  2. What about steam engines? on Ten Technologies That Shouldn't Have Died? · · Score: 2

    They went out of fashion, like the hindenburg, after an "explosion". A steam car was being used to attempt to break the world land speed record, but the beach was slightly uneven, it had ribs in the sand that set up a vibration that cracked a steam pipe. The damage was minimal and not dangerous, but it let out a great cloud of steam, and was reported in the press as having exploded, and that was that for steam-powered cars. Petrol engines are more practical nowadays only because they've had most of a century of development, and steam has been largely ignored. There's a swiss company that's making steam engines for locomotives, they've got ultra-efficient gas burners, and are 99% insulated, so they stay hot overnight and don't need 2 hours of warm-up in the morning, it's more like 10 minutes. Here's some info I just found: http://www.steam.demon.co.uk/trains/modern10.htm

  3. Re:Stupid, uninforcable on DVD Zoning Enforced In Law · · Score: 1

    So can I sell Nazi memorabilia by post to France?

  4. Re:Stupid, uninforcable on DVD Zoning Enforced In Law · · Score: 2
    There is no reason why Play247 couldn't offer the same service to our French friends over there.
    If they can tell Yahoo! to remove Nazi material from their American auctions or make them inaccessible from France (cut the cables?), then they can tell 247 that they aren't allowed to sell Z1 DVDs into France. Enforcing it is another matter, but at least with physical post like this they can claim that the company knew that they were dispatching to France.
  5. Re:Some thoughts on Open Source Licensing Issues · · Score: 2
    But the viral nature of the GPL means that a line of code that is copied from one project to another contaminates other code that might be used in a third project.
    I don't understand how you have come to this conclusion. If I take a function that I wrote as part of a larger system, and contribute it to a GPL project, that in no way affects my original system. I have granted permission to use that code in GPL projects, without restricting myself as the copyright owner. I could contribute the same code to a BSD project, and there would be no conflict. If either of the contributions were modified, then there may be problems with me taking that modified version back into my code, or across into the other project, but even the GPL accepts the concept of derived works, and presumably the copyright status thereof (that is, belonging to the author of the original). This last point is the real stinger - I believe that could create a program and release it as GPL, wait for the rest of the world to fix all the bugs and add cool new features, then rescind the GPL status and sell it commercially as closed-source.
  6. Re:Should all coders be in Europe? on Ogg Vorbis Update: Thomson Trouble · · Score: 1
    That, more or less, is what happened to the creator of PGP, Zimmerman
    Not quite, Z was in America when he did what he did. If I'm in the UK, can I break US law by posting software to a UK website?
  7. Re:Please don't leave behind ! on Warez and Abandonware · · Score: 1
    The authers seldem have the rights to the software.
    Or if they do, they may not have rights to parts of the code - like 3rd party libraries etc. I'm currently struggling with this issue with an old piece of software that my father and I wrote in the late eighties, one of the .asm files is licenced from another piece of software, so we can't release all the source under the GPL.
  8. Re:Should all coders be in Europe? on Ogg Vorbis Update: Thomson Trouble · · Score: 1
    Is it not simply the U.S. Patent system that is the problem here, and if so why do people continue to let the work they love be subjected to it?
    Interesting point, but that wouldn't help the h/w manufacturers that want to sell Ogg players in the US. Also, if I write some software that violates an US patent (entirely legal over here) and publish it on my website, and someone in America downloads it, have I broken American law? Could I find myself stepping off the plane at JFK for my hols and be handed a fine for $1M or thrown in jail?
  9. Re:Not careful enough on Ogg Vorbis Update: Thomson Trouble · · Score: 2
    Infringing a patent is a criminal act.
    Really? You can go to jail for it? I thought it was a civil matter, requiring a plaintiff to make the claim. IANAL, please correct me.
  10. Re:Market this on Ogg Vorbis Update: Thomson Trouble · · Score: 2
    What this corporatist pion dosnt realize is that Ogg is both libre and gratis it is neither a product for sale - nor a competitor in the 'marketplace'.
    They're rattling their sabres about filing suit against the likes of Diamond Multimedia for adding Ogg compatability to the Rio, and all the other current MP3 hardware manufacturers.
  11. Re:Time to calm down? on Ogg Vorbis Update: Thomson Trouble · · Score: 2
    No it is not time to calm down. It is time to bash down these folks, Monty.
    So what do you recommend? Sue them for libel in saying that Ogg Vorbis infringes their patents? If they're trying to defame the brand, then it could work. All you need is lots of money and good lawyers.
  12. Re:All movies based on games suck on Do-It-Yourself "Dungeons and Dragons" Film Review · · Score: 1
    PLEASE correct me if I'm wrong, but you have your monsters, "classes", etc and so forth, but no real central characters.
    Good point. If they'd done a Dragonlance movie, or Forgotten Realms, or Dark Sun, or may favouirite, Birthright, then they'd have had more characterisation to work with. I haven't seen the film, so this is all speculation based on the comment posted.
  13. Re:Go to a canibal and ask him if he likes you... on BugTraq No Longer Able To Publish MS Security UPDATED · · Score: 1
    Is this saying only Microsoft can report bugs,
    No, it's just that when Microsoft get around to issuing an advisory about a security problem, the text of the advisory is copyrighted, and cannot be republished on another web site. Microsoft aren't even sending out the full text in emails any more, they want people to click the link and see the MS web site with banner ads, hit counters, etc.

    It's amazing how people suddenly start replying to your post when it suddenly gets modded to the top of the "Highest Scores" order.

  14. Cyborgs discussed this morning on Review: "The Sixth Day" · · Score: 1

    There was an interview on Radio 4 (the BBC's highbrow radio channel) with I think Jeremy Paxman (of the Enigma Machine recovery story). The chap who had a chip implanted in his arm last year was talking about cyborgs and enhanced capabilities, and Paxman was beligerantly saying how credulous he was, and kept going back to the "why not just switch them off" defence against global cyborg domination. It was quite a mess.

  15. Re:Bizaree & Maximum Perversum on SmartFilter: Way Too Extreme · · Score: 1

    That's because there's no such word as "Bizaree", and probably no such website. Have you tried "Bizarre"?

  16. Re:Is it too much to ask to /read/ the damn thing? on BugTraq No Longer Able To Publish MS Security UPDATED · · Score: 1

    Oh come on, it's got to have been said before. It just seemed such an obvious quip when I wrote it. Oh well, I'm glad I brightened someone's day. You could always go over to http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=moderation and ask if anyone's got any spare points to give me!

  17. Re:And this changes things how...? Their site suck on BugTraq No Longer Able To Publish MS Security UPDATED · · Score: 1
    You'll like this then. I was just browsing around, saw an interesting bug, and clicked on a "Details" tab. It filled the frame with a table saying

    Problem Report There was a communication problem
    Message ID TCP_ERROR
    Problem DescriptionThe system was unable to communicate with the server.
    etc

    It took me a good few seconds before I realised I was looking at an error that had just occurred, rather than a description of a vulnerablilty.

  18. Re:Is it too much to ask to /read/ the damn thing? on BugTraq No Longer Able To Publish MS Security UPDATED · · Score: 3
    slashdot cannot be bothered to read their own links, or to be bothered to do even the slightest amount of fact checking.
    That's because the /. staff are all competing with each other to get first post.
  19. It's not as bad on BugTraq No Longer Able To Publish MS Security UPDATED · · Score: 5

    as the article implies, it's just the Microsoft releases that they can't mirror word for word. They'd still reporting the bugs.

  20. Re: What law of Conservation of Energy on The Reactionless Space Drive? · · Score: 1
    As long as you use the sun to brake yourself on the ay back in, no harm is done.
    No, not ig you're coming in from the same direction that you went out in. Bouncing a ball between two plates knocks them further apart, and that's basically what you're doing.

  21. Re: IDEs are generally restrictive on How Can New Programmers Contribute to Open Source? · · Score: 1

    The main problem with IDEs in Windows is that once you create a project using one of them, you're pretty much limited to just using that IDE, or shifting the project wholesale to another IDE. In OSS land, that would never work, you would limit your target developer audience to the fans of that particular IDE. IMO, OSS projects need to be equally accessible to VI, EMACS, KDevelop, etc. users.

  22. Re:What about copyrighted imagery ? on MSN Selling Users' Images as Merchandise · · Score: 2
    What happens if a certain painter or professional photographer decides to put up his own copyrighted works for display ? It then becomes illegal for Microsoft (or anyone besides the artist) to redistribute that content, else they open up to a delicious onslaught of one-way lawsuits.They would be granting MSN permission by uploading. But if they got someone else to do it, who didn't have the right to grant copy rights, then they could sue MSN. The court might take a dim view of this if they found out that the artist was behind it all along. Especially if MSN has bigger lawyers.

  23. Re:Is it really that bad? on MSN Selling Users' Images as Merchandise · · Score: 2
    they spell out in the Terms Of Use that if you upload your property to MSN, they may distribute it, reproduce it, etc., and "no compensation will be paid" to you.
    So if I upload a picture that I didn't take, then they could be sued for handling stolen goods!

  24. Re:Pan Handling on Iridium Saved By the US Dept of Defense · · Score: 2

    AIUI, they're paying the receiver, who will use the money to pay off companies that Iridium owed money to. Not investors, but people like landlords, electric, car leasing, maybe salaries, etc. All people who've lost out through no fault of their own.

  25. Re:Newton laws on The Reactionless Space Drive? · · Score: 2
    No Mr xor_xro, we cannot get rid of all the newton's laws

    Magnetism does not contravene Newton's laws of motion.