The part about tribal behavior is true enough. It happens often that people are trying to top each others comments. That always result in a skewed/exaggerated view on the topic. He's not lashing out on anyone. Just using this tendency as an argument for not reading the stuff. It's understandable. When you put alot of work into something, bad feedback hurts alot, even if it's skewed or exaggerated. I'd also rather obtain feedback elsewhere. Just to be sure that it's valid...
It's the same thing with musicians. They always say that their newest album is the best...EVER. I look forward to playing Doom 3, and I'm sure you guys did a brilliant job again. But I think you should let the game age a little before putting out such statements. Not because it isn't true, but because it's difficult to take seriously. You might just be out selling your new product;)
Slashdot Mirror
The part about tribal behavior is true enough. It happens often that people are trying to top each others comments. That always result in a skewed/exaggerated view on the topic. He's not lashing out on anyone. Just using this tendency as an argument for not reading the stuff. It's understandable. When you put alot of work into something, bad feedback hurts alot, even if it's skewed or exaggerated. I'd also rather obtain feedback elsewhere. Just to be sure that it's valid...
It's the same thing with musicians. They always say that their newest album is the best...EVER. I look forward to playing Doom 3, and I'm sure you guys did a brilliant job again. But I think you should let the game age a little before putting out such statements. Not because it isn't true, but because it's difficult to take seriously. You might just be out selling your new product ;)