Slashdot Mirror


User: Big_Al_B

Big_Al_B's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
554
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 554

  1. Re:I agree, mod parent up! on Ten Technologies That Refuse to Die · · Score: 1
    Generalizations are bad.

    That's true, generally...

  2. Re:OT: Throwing the ESL rock back on Nit-Pickers Guide to Deviations in Jackson's LotR · · Score: 1
    Thank you for gracefully acknowledging the information.

    Hey, you presented it well and you gave me an opportunity to blow some dust off an aging journalism degree. Thank you.

    My father was a college English teacher, so I was fortunate enough to get a well-rounded education. I learned the English because I had to and the math and science because I wanted to.

    What an interesting mirror! My dad, a professor, taught K-12 math in a college lab school and math education courses in the college. He wrote a few K-12 textbooks too, so I learned the math because he liked having a guinea pig. I learned the English because I loved writing. Still, I ended up in network engineering. Go figure.

  3. Re:OT: Throwing the ESL rock back on Nit-Pickers Guide to Deviations in Jackson's LotR · · Score: 1
    (original) Is English you're second language, troll?

    I don't correct people's grammar mistakes in their regular posts on Slashdot because that's rude. I do, however, correct mistakes in people's arrogant attempts at correcting other people.

    Yes. I can relate...

    In particular please note the gerund.

    Heh. I am smirking, because you are correct about the gerund phrases. Thank you for the much deserved correction.

    ...but I am bothered at your calling it a run-on sentence...Indecision(subject) is(verb) different(predicate adjective).

    Nicely parsed. If I had read a little more carefully, I would have digested the meandering clauses much better. That doesn't mean that the sentence was well-written.

    Please know better before correcting someone else.

    You found two mistakes, but you acknowledged two of my points, and you acquiesced regarding my "your v. you're" correction. Empirically speaking, I have risen to the definition of "better". I fell short of the definition of "perfect" though, so I take your point.

  4. OT: Throwing the ESL rock back on Nit-Pickers Guide to Deviations in Jackson's LotR · · Score: 1
    Is English you're second language, troll?

    Hmm. Your glass house may have a whole lot of holes. You're going to have to practice your English. FYI, to and two are different too.

    What does Sam wanting to kill Gollum have to do with Frodo wanting to keep him around?

    "Wanting" is a verb; you're under the impression it's a noun. Your hypocritical desire to criticize someone's English is another noun, and it's the subject of this sentence too.

    You know, where a character speaks?

    Just where, I ask, is the subject located in this sentence? You know...It's the place where you identify what you're talking about. Complete sentences make English easier to understand, don't you think Yoda?

    She only does that towards the end of the RotK. And indecision about the best course for the fellowship is just tiny smidgeon different than wondering whether or not to fulfill the destiny you have been working toward your entire life.

    Summarily, we have a meandering, nonsequetorial, and run-on sentence, beginning with the word "And" no less. And it's posed as the rebuttal of another writer's nonsequitor. Does it get worse? While it's become acceptible to begin a sentence with "and," that sentence must be directly related to the preceeding sentence for it to make any sense. See?