Slashdot Mirror


User: colinrichardday

colinrichardday's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
4,799
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 4,799

  1. Is creationism a scientific theory? on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    With such a big concept as creation vs. evolution, why can they not just be made to teach that these are the two primary theories in existence

    Aside from the number of creationist theories, how scientific is creationism?

  2. Re:True of False? on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    Evolution is incompatible with Communism/Socialism, because those religions ensure survival of the weakest and push the fittest? True

    No. Some of the Soviets accepted evolution, at least of the Lamarckian variety. Indeed, this is how Lysenko made his reputation. They did so not so much to aid the strong, but as a means of obtaining better future subjects. As Hegel might have said, they sought to synthesize evolution and intelligent design.

  3. Is ID particularly philosophical? on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    Does ID lend itself to decent philosophical discussion?

  4. Re:The faithfull zelots from both sides .... on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    "Water boils at 100c and freeze at 0c" this is scientific fact.

    No, "Water boils at 100c and freezes at 0c." is a statement of (alleged) fact. Also, I guess antifreeze isn't big in your world.

  5. Re:People don't really believe in Noah's Flood on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    Some rock formations in the western US could have only formed by rapid, high water erosion and not erosion over millions of years.

    And which rock formations are they?

  6. Re:on curricula and the burecreauts writting them. on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    You are assuming that the paying customers (parents) value cognition as much as you do. What if parents want their children taught religious dogma as science? Given the political popularity of not teaching evolution, I suspect that at least some parents would pay to not have it taught.

  7. Re:Compromise on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    Don't be glib. Division is an integral part of math.

    Would that make integration a divisive part of math? Well, maybe between the supporters of Newton and Leibniz.

  8. Re:Who said anything about the bible? on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    Science is not simply a set of results, it is a means of obtaining them. When we explore our world we find fossils, we see the development of embryos/fetuses, we compare the features of different animals and plants. None of these, nor all of them combined, is a proof of evolution. But science does not deal with proof in the mathematical sense. It deals with collecting evidence and from that trying to find the best explanation. There may be alternatives that we cannot exclude by logic alone, but that is not how science works.

    Who are these creators? How did they come to be?

  9. Re:What's the attack on science? on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    There were many interracial children on plantations in the antebellum South. Also, why would you call them mutants? How is being biracial a mutation?

  10. Re:Cue the following: on Texas Vote May Challenge Teaching of Evolution · · Score: 1

    And by what means do you propose to achieve this "daring and adventurous progress in the sciences"? If humans had to develop quantum mechanics just from what we perceive, with no intervening theory, we would never have developed it. Theories do not merely describe the world, they provide a way of further cognition. Even an incorrect theory may have epistemological value, and not just utilitarian-instrumental value.

  11. Re:Not needed for server apps on Microsoft Launches Free Web Software Eco-System · · Score: 1

    So IIS is low cost? As low as Apache?

  12. Re:Copy Editor on Places Where the World's Tech Pools, Despite the Internet · · Score: 1

    You mean Cambridge isn't in Boston? It's in the Boston area, but not Boston itself. Also, no mention of the old(?) Route 128? Wasn't Bletchley Park better known for computerized decryption?
    Taiwan is only 2,000 miles from US soil? More like 5,000.

    Also, "Alumni" is plural.

  13. Re:and with that same philosophy on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    And who said anything about it being a business site?

  14. Re:Or maybe you're pulling that from your ass on Did the Netbook Improve Windows 7's Performance? · · Score: 1

    Both Linux and OSX are far worse than Windows on backwards compatibility.

    In the case of Linux, is that source or binary backward compatibility?

  15. Re:It will happen on No Business Case For IPv6, Survey Finds · · Score: 1

    If they NAT through the 10.*.*.* address space, wouldn't it be closer to 2^24 or approximately 16 million?

  16. Re:been said already... on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    Why scrape them off? Just put SuSE stickers over them.

  17. With apologies to Orwell on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    But East Redmond has always been at war with Cupertino-Oceania

  18. Re:Ballmer, open an Apple machine on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    God's gift to every person in the world that does not really love Microsoft

    Richard Stallman does not really love Microsoft, but I suspect he'd consider GNU/Linux (0r even GNU Hurd) of greater value than Apple.

  19. Re:and with that same philosophy on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    But what about the time by not having to scavenge for GNU emacs, C/C++, TeX/LaTeX, python, and other programs? As far as configuration goes, if a piece of hardware is Linux supported, it's easier to install in Linux than in Windows.

  20. Re:and with that same philosophy on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    Web developers who run Linux need to test their sites on Windows Internet Explorer, a Windows OS component that's still the majority web browser on PCs.

    I need to test my site on IE? The hardest part is MathML, which I am not going to fudge for the sake of Microsoft.

  21. Re:It seems ironic... on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    I am posting this from a five-year old Averatec laptop, which is sitting next to a seven-year old HP desktop.

  22. Re:Hardly surprising... on Ballmer Scorns Apple As a $500 Logo · · Score: 1

    Where's the outrage by end-users for not being able to load Linux as a replacement OS?

    http://www.ubuntu.com/

  23. Star Fleet Academy on Want a Science Degree In Creationism? · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Hey, let's start Star Fleet Academy in Texas!

  24. Warning: The above is from a Kent Hovind shill. on Want a Science Degree In Creationism? · · Score: 1

    Why don't I trust Kent Hovind?

  25. Re:Disappears in a Poof of Logic. on Want a Science Degree In Creationism? · · Score: 1

    since we cannot prove anything with 100% certainty, then nothing is knowable.

    The fault is not entirely theirs, much of Western epistemology would say the same thing.