Slashdot Mirror


User: TheCarp

TheCarp's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
6,321
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 6,321

  1. Re:Follow-up to my own post on Another Software Spy · · Score: 1

    > My second point is that Quake 3 is proprietary
    > software, and as such, you (the user) get
    > what you get,

    You are right...but you miss one point, even
    though you touch on it earlier. You accidently
    left a backdoor in a program that was publicly
    released.

    Ok yea, big mistake....heres a wrist slap, move
    on. However...what if you did it INTENTIONALY?
    Do you think a person who adds backdoors to
    software that are undocumented INTENTIONALLY
    and distributes them can be trusted?

    The program is a game. If I download it and it
    does anything OTHER than be a game, if I buy it
    and it turns out to be a spreadsheet program,
    then the advertising LIED to me. That is a crime
    (its called fraud).

    When I download a program, I expect it to do
    what it is told. I do NOT expect it to contact
    other people COVERTLY and tell them ANYTHING.
    It doing so is DISHONEST.

    It does not matter WHAT it tells them, the fact
    that it contacts ANYONE and tells them ANYTHING
    in a COVERT way, makes it a trojan horse, and it
    makes it FLAGRANT FRAUD.

    If I had used this software myself (I have not)
    I would most definitly NOT be posting this right
    now, as its not bright to talk about ongoing
    suits outside of court...and I would be sueing
    them.

    Fortunatly for ID I have not used it...and
    unfortunaly for computer users in general, not
    many users are like me.

  2. I trusted Carmack on Another Software Spy · · Score: 1

    This, to me, is a slap in the face.

    I have NO problem with running software that
    reports back to the owners with a little
    anonymous data like this. However...
    I should be told.

    This is DELIBERATE and COVERT.

    If they want to require that all users send
    back this info, fine. Just say in big letters
    in the docs and on the web page "If you run this
    it will send data back to us". Thats all.

    Concealing the fact that this is happening is
    what is damning.

  3. BTW "NO PHYSICAL ACCESS" on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    When I said that in the original post I guess it
    wasn't carried over to my request.

    I have recieved several emails about it.
    YES I know how to reboot with rw init=/bin/sh
    (and even how to shutdown properly with it)
    however...
    I can't acess the console...basically...there
    is no monitor and I was too lazy to hook one
    up.

    I supose I will fix that one day... but its in
    an awkward area...

  4. Re:Depends on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    Well....
    I happen to have a firm belief in making
    information and toold freely available.

    If I were a virus experimenter (im not...unless
    you count trying to learn to play core wars) then
    I would do just that...put up commented code
    with explanations and possibly binaries
    (binaries are really only a step away. Big deal
    it stopps those few script kiddies who can't
    assemble a program)

    The point is...I have infomation...I am not going
    to be the judge of who is responsible enough to
    have the information. I am nobodies daddy and do
    not feel any responsibilty to go around saying
    "You are responsible...here is the code"
    "You are irresponsible please go grow up"

    Its a little belief I have called "Personal
    Responsibility". Which means Ill be responsible
    for MY actions, you be responsible for yours.

    Going after clueful ethical coders because some
    idiot could possibly misuse their tools amounts
    to little more than trying to childproof the
    world.

    The ability to do a thing does not imply the
    right to do a thing, any more than becoming able
    to do something or making someone else able to
    do something IS doing the thing.

    This is of course in the case of blindly giving
    things away. If it is given away with knowlede
    that the tool WILL in fact be used in this manner
    then that amounts to conspiracy. However...if its
    given away freely to anyone that wants it...then
    it becomes anonymous.

  5. Re:well, by precedent... on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    A) Isn't it one of the basic principals of
    Gun saftey....
    Guns ARE inherently dangerous and thus MUST always
    be treated with care and respect.

    B) whether ciggarrets ALWAYS do harm is debatable.
    Certainly with chronic use they are damaging to
    health etc...however...
    I would still argue that it is MY body and I have
    the right to decide what is harmfull to it and
    what isn't
    (to which end I have decided tobbacco products
    are harmfull and I wont ever use them...same for
    alcohol...not so for many others ;) )

  6. Re:Depends on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    so if I find virus interesting. and I write them
    on my own systems, never putting one on someone
    elses system...then I would supose thats ok.

    However if I Enjoy playing with them...and I
    write up a web page about them, and post some
    example code and binaries for people who also
    are interested and want to experiment...
    suddenly I have done something wrong?

  7. hmmmm offtopic but... on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    How is it wrong?

    I think terror *IS* the MOST effective means to
    achive political goals. You ever see "The Seige"
    ya know...if a few terrorists setup in NYC...
    things would go down much like the movie...with
    the exception that there would be no quick happy
    ending.

    Personally I even extend "Terrorism" to describe
    the actins of the peopl ein power in the US. Which
    is a dirty mix of politicans and media whores.

    Whenever there is something that they want to
    change...the media naturally focuses on what gets
    them ratings...and that is FEAR. They report
    whatever stories will most likely tap into peoples
    most basic fears. Murders, violence. The more
    random the better.

    Congress works similarly. They recently have been
    working on an "Anti-Date Rape" act...named after
    a girl who suposedly died after being slipped a
    "Date Rape Drug" GHB.

    The real cause of her death was later found to be
    quite differnt (I believe it was a previously
    unknown congenital heart defect but I do not
    remember). However congress keeps harping on.
    Forget that Date rape is already illegal...its
    not about that. Thats just what they want to use
    to scare people with...the only real "Date Rape Drug" is alcohol...and unlike some others...it is
    used EVERY DAY.

    They just work the media to instill fear in people
    because when people are in fear they are irrational
    so...then when congress passes a law...they seem
    like heros fighting the good fight, when in reality
    its usually new legislation that was already
    covered by old legislation or it just advances
    their own political agenda.

    If you ask me...thats a form of terrorism...and
    its sickeningly effective.

  8. Exploits have no legal use until.... on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    until someone comes running to you "Help we lost
    the root password on our server and we can't
    bring it down for maintenance right now! Let
    us throw money at you to help!"

  9. oh... on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    Since I mentioned it...
    anyone have a good few program recomendations
    for root-ing a Debian install (fairly standard
    install..no X) thats about 6 months old...never
    been upgraded?

    Its my fathers box...I set it up for him and gave
    him the root password...all he uses it for is
    as a masquerading firewall...however we would like
    to setup SAMBA on it as a domain controller.
    ...and he lost the root password (I let him have
    it and told him to keep it safe...forgot to make
    myself a uid 0 acount before I left)

  10. but.... on Who is Responsible? The Developer? The User? · · Score: 1

    Isn't that liks saying the people who were suing
    gun manafacturers for "Making a dangerous product"
    have merit?

    If an author writes a program that can crash
    windows machines...he has every right to do that.
    He has every right to crash every WIndows PC he
    owns with it and every one other people own and
    give him permission to crash.

    Software is a tool. It is a mistake to hold the
    maker of a tool responsible for the outright
    misuse of the person who USES a tool.

    If I buy a lock pick thats fine. If I pick my way
    into my house...thats fine. If I decide to use my
    lock pick(s) to get into someone elses house..
    that is _MY_ fault not the person who made the
    lockpicks.

    Hell even things like Winnuke HAVE been used
    legitimatly. One day I had a windows machine I left on and left some stupid program running
    that was doing things on the network I needed
    to stop (mostly it was an application whose server
    only allowed one session at time)....so...
    I winnuked it from a linux box (stupid microsoft mail anyways)

    man im glad I don't work with windows antymore.
    As far as non-windows stuff....anyone else ever
    been faced with a machine you can't easily get
    phsyical acess to...hasn't been upgraded in a
    while...the owner has LOST the root password...
    and needs you to work on the system for him?

    Sure...most people id just laugh at and tell to
    piss off under those circumstances but...at least
    once it happend and I had to try to root the box.
    Wasn't sucessfull....but its a legitamite use for
    such tools.

  11. A possible method on On the GPL and Releasing Source Code · · Score: 1

    What you could try is this:
    1) Post the code that you midified that is not
    directly from the distribution you use on the
    website.
    2) contact another company (like cheapbytes) who
    already sells copies of CDs with GPL software,
    and thus already has to honor the GPL for stuff
    they are already selling.

    You migh tbe able to get a mutually beneficial
    contract going where you refer customers to them
    to get the original distribution source code

    Since you have a contract with them, they are
    providing it to your customers for you. As long
    as the price is nominal (which it is for
    some like cheapebytes) then it should still
    satisfy.

    Since whoever is selling CDs already has to honor
    the GPL and provide the source for 3 years for
    their normal sales, I am sure that at least one of
    them would be willing to do it for you in exchange
    for the publicity they would generate
    (ie the offer would basically be advertising
    to all of your customers)

    just a thought

  12. Realizing Consequences on 'Kyle's Mom' is Dead at Age 38 · · Score: 1

    One thing that I am thinking now, almost as an
    afterthought of this now old discussion....
    A person who is actually contemplating suicide
    is not in the same "State of Consciousness" as
    most people are in on a daily basis.

    You can't reason easily from one state of thinking
    into another without understanding some things.
    Thinking of this I am drawing on my experiances
    as "Trip Sitter" for a friend who took some acid
    and became convinced he was going to die.

    There is a phenominon known as the Negative
    thought loop. In this the mind gets caught in
    a loop it seemingly can not escape. It is common
    with both depression, "Bad Trips" and other
    situations.

    THink of the situation like this. The person
    decides they can't go on with "The pain"
    (depression basically) so they need to end it.
    They realize that thgeir fammily does not
    understand and can not. They KNOW their decision
    will hurt the people that care for them. This
    makes them feel even worst. This brings them
    further into depression and makes the pain worst
    and even more unbearable.

    This depression was summed up very humerously
    in "Office SPace" when the main character
    said "Each day is progressivly worst. So every
    day that you see me, it is the worst day of my
    life"

    Anyone still interested in this subject or not
    sure what to think I would direct to :
    http://www.xanthia.com/ash
    this is the webpage for alt.suicide.holiday
    it is a group where several suicidal people
    regularly speak to eachother. They often speak
    of how they plan to kill themselves etc...yet
    at the same time...this talking is almost like
    a therapy. One has to wonder how many people did
    not kill themselves because of this group.

    I would warn anyone vehimently against suicide
    that you are not welcome there. They are quite
    tired of people trying to "Sasve them" and tell
    them "How great they are". It just makes them more
    bitter and helps noone.

    I would recomend the FAQ. It has some very thought
    provoking portions. The methods file may not be
    for the weak of heart but...it has some dark
    humor that is just the kind of humor I like.

  13. Re:SQUID Sensors on The Dismounted Soldier Problem · · Score: 1

    On the subject...
    I would LOVE any info on these "Squid sensors"
    I saw a documentary where someone had some...
    I would imagine they would not be hard to make
    for a person with a marginal background in
    electronics and the right equipment.

    I wanted to experiment with them myself at home..
    never found any info. Any documentation on how
    they work and would be setup would be great.

  14. nausea on The Dismounted Soldier Problem · · Score: 2

    Well yea it would feel weird walking without
    feeling like walking"

    The brain would get confused fast. It is giving
    signal to walk, it sees the motion of walking
    but...the inner ear isn't detecting motion.

    When the inner ear and brain loose sync...the
    natural reaction is to begin "Stomac pump
    procedue".

    I had an interesting discussion about this with
    someone onece. It apears that this may be an
    evolutionary "Defence mechanism". Loss of
    proper signal from the inner ear can often be
    caused by certain chemicals, say the chemicals
    in an amniata muscaria mushroom (big red caps)
    or something in the nightshade fammily (other
    than tomatoes)

    Basically the idea goes that the brain stops
    getting the right signals from the inner ear
    so as a defence it induces vomitting so that if
    this was caused by some poison, it may stop
    absorbtion of the rest of it.
    (which is why nausea is very common with alot of
    drugs)

    anyway...I would think that ALOT of people would
    react very badly to any such setup.

  15. Re:Very sad on 'Kyle's Mom' is Dead at Age 38 · · Score: 1

    Well, it does depend ont he person and the
    circumstances. I have a freind who was arrested
    a few years ago for something stupid. However
    because a numbe ro fyears previous to this he
    had attempted suicide, the police decided he
    needed to be kept in a cell, alone, with no
    clothes or bed sheets (and a metal bed) all night.

    I have also read several writtings by suicidal
    people and many have said that getting caught
    made their lives much worst.

    Of course...there are billions of differnt people
    and everyone who does it has their own reasons.
    Some find the "recovery process" to be life
    inspireing, others just get more severely
    depressed.

  16. Re:Very sad on 'Kyle's Mom' is Dead at Age 38 · · Score: 1

    > I don't believe you have outlined any suicides i would consider acceptable

    Well I must say I wasn't trying to. All I ever
    said was "Mental Anguish" which, in my mind,
    covers everything from severe depression to
    Chronic pain with no cure.

    However "Chronic pain with no cure" is a minority
    of real suicides. Most are to end a severe
    depression. Having felt depression at a point in
    my life, even if not so severe that suicide was
    even more than a passing thought, I can certainly
    empathise in that I can understand how a person
    could be depressed to the point where killing
    themselves seems like a "Viable solution"
    (interesting use of "viable" huh?)

    Suicide definitly does have alot of both emotion
    and social taboo. Your not suposed to talk about
    it. It reminds me of the movie "Seven" where the
    serial killer says to the police officer
    "Its very comfortable for you to label me as insane."

  17. Re:Very sad on 'Kyle's Mom' is Dead at Age 38 · · Score: 4

    While I can't say that I have lost a fammily
    member to suicide, I don't see it as quite
    so sad.

    Those who commit suicide are dead because they
    want to be. They have gotten what they want, a
    final end to their mental suffering.

    What is really sad is how our society treats
    suicide. Those who fail and are discovered are
    likely to live life much worst off than they were
    before. They get to live not only with their
    mental anguish, but with being constantly watched,
    their actions always questioned as they might be
    getting ready to try again.

    The real sadness, is that because of this attitude
    most people who are thinking about suicide never
    come out and talk about their feelins, as they
    know there is no "safe" place to do that...doing
    it is almost surely going to take away their
    ability to commit suicide, as now people will be
    prepared to "intervene". Which in turn means that
    a useful outlet for working through their problems
    is effectively shut off...and thus they are more
    likely to "just do it".

    I have always found suicide an interesting topic.
    Its interesting to ask yourself "Could I do it?"
    Most people say no but why?
    I bet many would answer that its out of love for
    this person or obligation for that... but I think
    its allot mor ebasic than that.

    Actually taking the final step of pulling the
    trigger or swallowing the pill is not easy.
    Both from my own thoughts about the subject, and
    reading the writtings of people who actually
    are suicidal (I am not...I am just fascinated by
    the subject) it takes an extreme amount of mental
    will power to do it. Which of course makes me
    think that anyone who says people who commit suicide are weak, truely have no concept of what
    is really involved.

    I for one couldn't do it. It takes alot of will
    power to force yourself to "catch the bus" and
    find out once and for all whether all those
    religious people who were thrusting pamphlets into
    your hands on the street corner were right.
    (I for one certainly hope not :) ...else I shall
    have a quite warm eternity)

  18. What your saying... on 'Kyle's Mom' is Dead at Age 38 · · Score: 2

    is basically, YOU don't like it, so you want to
    see everyone elses fun taken away.

    Please do not forget, you have the option to
    NOT watch it.

    Your words convey the idea that perhaps you suffer
    from the paranoid fear that someone, somewhere
    might be having fun.

  19. The US on DVD Situation Takes New Turn · · Score: 2

    Under US law there is no such thing as
    "Intellectual Property"

    Its COpywrite law that you mean. IP is a term
    invented by lawyers of big companies to make
    it sound like they have more rights than they do.

    anyone looking for further comment on the subject
    should check out www.gnu.org

  20. RIAA and Schools on CMU Cuts off Net Access for 71 Students Over MP3s · · Score: 1

    I currently work for a large University as
    a Sysadmin/Programer, and it seems every few
    weeks we get an email from the RIAA telling us
    that a student is running an MP3 site and that
    we need to shut them down.

    On a personal level, it pisses me off. I see
    nothing morally wrong with what the kids are
    doing, and I know my collegues express the same
    feelings, but we shut them down anyway, even if
    it gives me a sick feeling in my stomac.

    However, surprize inspections and cutting off
    computer access is way extreme. Here we ask the
    student to remove them. Then they are reported to
    someone or other. Basically, you do it, you get a
    slap on the wrist.

    Students HAVE lost all computer access over it,
    but only the ones who openly ignored us and
    continued their activities. I think pulling
    any network acess from a first time violator is
    extremely harsh (even if it is just "Home Access")

    I certainly hope these students complain and are
    heard. "Surprize inspections" are just wrong.
    (Then again...so is using University computers for
    MP3 distribution...keep it on your own machine
    god damnit)

    Then again...I supose the upside is that when I
    get the RIAA notice, I can check the site to see
    if they have anything good before they get shut
    down (I am not in charge of shutting them down
    myself...im mostly just a programer)

  21. Articles partially clueless on Mainstream Media on Slashdot and Microsoft · · Score: 1

    After readint the 3 articles

    I MSNBC one was the worst. It was based almost
    entirly on a few slashdot comments, very little
    original thought. Big deal, they can take random
    comments from people who don't necissarily have
    any credentials. Its basically a Man on the street
    opionon without leaving your cushy office.

    II The wired article had a stupid title, but was
    the most substance of the 3. The title was
    something to the effect of "Judge says linux wont
    last". No. He said linux is not going to be a
    threat to windows in the short term.
    This is true. There are not so many people
    migrating to linux that its going to hurt MS
    anytime soon. However...the future is open.

    III The judge was stating fact as it is now and
    has been for years. There is nothing to say that
    sanctions against microsoft wont change this
    and give linux a boost (afterall, isn;t the
    poin tof this antitrust stuff to break the
    monopoly stranglehold on competition?)

    IV The 3rd article was almost as bad as the
    MS article. It seems this author was more
    interested with peoples comments on the trial
    and how juvenile people can be (which isn't bad...
    I like juvenile as much as th enetx guy).
    Big deal...there is a general dislike of Microsoft
    in this community...we are rejoycing at their bad
    fortune (which they brough on themselves).

  22. Re:not much time left... on Why DVD Encryption Crack was a Cinch · · Score: 1

    hmmmm buy red meat and goto the police and confess
    you could already do that...

    Your brain produces DMT naturally. DMT is a
    schedual 1 hallucinogen. Thus, you are not only
    in posession of DMT, you are manafacturing it.

    Many states already make GHB posession illegal...
    GHB is what is found in meat..and again
    already in your brain.

    If I were you, I would go turn myself in now.

  23. Fun coils - flawed Ideas on Lightning On Demand · · Score: 1

    I love Tesla Coils...however...

    They do not produce "Lightning", they can NOT be
    used for "Lightning suceptability tests".

    Lightning is STATIC electricity Discharge from clouds. Lightning CAN be simulated by a Van De
    Graff Generator.

    Tesla coils put out discharges of High Frequency
    Alternating Current. There are some MAJOR differences.

    Alternating current exhibits a skin effect.
    You can put your hand in the discharge of a tesla
    coil (assuming its built right). The energy is of
    such a high frequency that it goes AROUND your
    skin, and does not penetrate the body deeply
    enough to activate pain receptors, much less
    stop your heart.

    If the power output of the Tesla coil is high
    enough, it still wont stop your heart...instead
    it will cause RF burns (kind of equivalent to
    sticking your hand in a microwave).

    Static electricity on the other hand will never
    give you and RF burn. It will however also not
    exhibit a skin effect, and will happliy travel
    through your pain receptors, heart, and wherever
    else it damned well pleases.

    This is not to say that their facility will be useless. It certainly could be used to test
    aircrafts suceptability to high energey, high
    frequency energy discharges.

    Afterall, these things CAN transmit real power.
    (There is a story of a person who was working on
    a tesla coil in his basement...and a coat hanger
    upstairs turned out to make a nice antena, and a
    weater ont he hanger started to smolder, luckily
    someone upsteairs smelled it and caught it in
    time).

    hmm... I have to wonder...
    With a Tesla coil, capable of creating husge plasma discharges...an laser... I wonder if a
    small laser could ionize the air enough to get
    the tesla coil to do the rest of the work of
    turning it into a conducting path....and then
    a van de graf or taser to send a disabling
    pulse....

  24. or... on Lightning On Demand · · Score: 1

    Goto Home Depot near Boston...
    Thats where I met the guy who MADE the Tesla coils
    at the MOS (one of them)...got to go to his
    basement and see some of his cool stuff.
    (Half wave coil, tube coils he was working on,
    an Electical pole transformer....)

  25. Re:Hmmm... on U.S. Military Grapples With Cyber Warfare Rules · · Score: 1

    Hurting civilian populations is how a war is won.
    You make the war so hard on the people, that they
    can no longer suport their countries war effort.

    The only REAL advantage of cracking machines is to gain strategic information or to disrupt communications.

    Taking out a power plant is silly, they can get it
    back online too easy. Much better to bomb it to
    rubble.