Slashdot Mirror


FTC Investigates Submarine Patents

Schnake writes: "An article on USAToday talks about how the FTC is investigating Sun Microsystems, Unocal, and Rambus to determine whether they illegally kept patents secret while helping set industry standards! And a quote from the ZDNet article: "It noted that all three companies had filed patent infringement lawsuits against firms they say owed them royalties. But the litigation backfired when those firms countersued, charging them with concealing their patents, and complained to the FTC.""

15 of 119 comments (clear)

  1. whee by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    this can't possibly be...

  2. WTC by Simm0 · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I'm pretty sure there's one of Sun Microsystems main offices in the WTC. Could anyone possibly confirm which brach of sun was located in there.

    1. Re:WTC by PhilHibbs · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      They all survived ( http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2001/09/12/sun .htm )

    2. Re:WTC by elmegil · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      It was a field office. I believe there were sales, service, and education personnell there.

      --
      7 November 2006: The day Americans realized corruption and incompetence weren't addressing 11 September 2001
  3. 10. Get a Life by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    if you're going to post crap, please include a goatse link

  4. taleban.com Hacked by ScumBiker · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    The Taleban website, appears to be continually hacked. Every time they fix their site, within minutes it's defaced again. WAY TO GO!!!!!! I'll make a mirror of the hack for prosperity. I don't feel so completely helpless anymore! There has to be more that we as a community of geeks can do, other than giving blood (VERY IMPORTANT!), or donating cash. I'm sure that the lowlife communicated electroniclly, maybe have secure or hidden websites. Think about a cell based organization, picking up and dropping off information anonymously via FTP. I'm almost positive that info is out there. LET'S FIND IT!

    --
    --- Think of it as evolution in action ---
  5. Mod Parent Down by nivelo9 · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Do I need to say any more?

    --
    another "quality" nivelo9 comment
  6. Kill All Moslems. Death to Islam. Exterminate Them by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    The list of honor:
    1. Kill all Arabs.
    2. Kill all Towel Heads.
    3. Kill all Mohammedans.
    4. Kill all Muslims.
    5. Kill all Camel Jockeys
    6. Kill all Islam.
    7. Nuke their countries to an ash heap.
    8. Nuke them again.
    9. Death to Islam.

    I urinate on Mecca. I wipe my ass with the Koran. I spit upon Mohammed.

  7. Suked in America! WH is next! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    BAHAHA.... !
    * g o a t s e x * g o a t s e x * g o a t s e x *
    g g
    o / \ \ / \ o
    a| | \ | | a
    t| `. | | : t
    s` | | \| | s
    e \ | / / \\\ -- \\ : e
    x \ \/ --~~ ~--| \ | x
    * \ \-~ ~-\ | *
    g \ \ .--------.__\| | g
    o \ \_// ((> \ | o
    a \ . C ) _ ((> | / a
    t /\ | C )/ \ (> |/ t
    s / /\| C)america| (> / \ s
    e | ( C__)\__/ // / / \ e
    x | \ | \\__// (/ | x
    * | \ \) `---- --' | *
    g | \ \ / / | g
    o | / | | \ | o
    a | | / \ \ | a
    t | / / | | \ |t
    s | / / \/\/ | |s
    e | / / | | | |e
    x | | | | | |x
    * g o a t s e x * g o a t s e x * g o a t s e x *

  8. FTC Notices by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    ...piss off *everyone* (excpet corporate america) Japan espically... about a year ago, Japanese television had an hour long program about how some patents for robotic assembly and inspection had been granted over 20 years after the patent had been accepted. If I recall correctly, there were some very devistating consequences for Japanese industral conplex. If Japan had a military, it was the kind of issue that might start a ware. The point that seemed to fall on deaf Japanese ears was that the paten office is inherently a political tool of the unitied states government and corporate america. This particular patent had been "submarined" for the direct purpose of secrewing the patent filer out of roalties. So, just remember, patents don't protect the inventer. Patents exist to the benefit of corporate america and the us government... and in a country where the patent generators a systematically screwed as a routine, generic part of the culture, it seems a little disingenuious and completely unnecessary to submarine a patent. [ Reply to This | Parent ] Patents not secret (Score:5, Interesting) by Ed Avis (epa98@doc.ic.ac.uk) on Thursday September 13, @05:24AM (#2291243) (User #5917 Info | http://www.doc.ic.ac.uk/~epa98/) The whole point of the patent system is openness. You only get a patent monopoly in exchange for full disclosure. So it should be easy (in principle) to find out what patents cover something you are working on. But in practice the sheer volume of patents out there is too large. I think that a legally binding 'patent challenge' might be the answer. You should be able to send a letter to Rambus or whoever saying 'I am developing the following... please disclose whether you have any patents or patent applications which cover this area'. The company receiving the letter then has to disclose what they have patented. If they lie or keep quiet, they lose the right to sue you later on. Obviously you couldn't do this for internal R&D, but for standards bodies (where the process is open anyway) this could be a useful tool to reduce threats from submarine patents. The only question is whether it places an unreasonable burden on the patentholding company. [ Reply to This | Parent ] Re:Patents not secret by Asic Eng (Score:3) Thursday September 13, @05:43AM Re:Patents not secret Thursday September 13, @06:06AM Re:Patents not secret by Asic Eng (Score:1) Thursday September 13, @06:25AM Re:Patents not secret Thursday September 13, @05:53AM Re:Patents not secret by Ed Avis (Score:1) Thursday September 13, @06:00AM Re:Patents not secret Thursday September 13, @06:24AM Some others worth investigating perhaps ? (Score:1) by emmavl on Thursday September 13, @05:33AM (#2291255) (User #202243 Info) What about all the patents related to jpeg2000 and mpeg4 ? It seems most (or at least some) of them were requested and granted just when the relevant technology/algorithms got accepted into the standard. (See also this article [advogato.org]) As the article on advogato mentions : why can't ISO/ANSI/whatever enforce policy stating that no patented work should be included in standards released by it ? [ Reply to This | Parent ] Re:Some others worth investigating perhaps ? by flegged (Score:1) Thursday September 13, @06:19AM WTC (Score:1) by Simm0 (simm0 AT ii DOT net) on Thursday September 13, @05:33AM (#2291258) (User #236060 Info | Last Journal: Saturday August 18, @10:33AM) I'm pretty sure there's one of Sun Microsystems main offices in the WTC. Could anyone possibly confirm which brach of sun was located in there. [ Reply to This | Parent ] Re:WTC Thursday September 13, @05:35AM Re:WTC by PhilHibbs (Score:1) Thursday September 13, @05:43AM Re:WTC by PhilHibbs (Score:3) Thursday September 13, @05:46AM Another link by PhilHibbs (Score:1) Thursday September 13, @05:48AM Everyone Work Together and... (Score:-1, Flamebait) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 13, @05:34AM (#2291260) 1. Kill all Arabs. 2. Kill all Towel Heads. 3. Kill all Mohammedans. 4. Kill all Muslims. 5. Kill all Camel Jockeys 6. Kill all Islam. 7. Nuke their countries beyond the abyss of hell. 8. Nuke them again. 9. Death to Islam! [ Reply to This | Parent ] Mod Parent Down by nivelo9 (Score:1) Thursday September 13, @05:45AM Wheee (Score:0) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 13, @05:37AM (#2291266) Coming next on the U.S tragedy bandwagon jumping special: Head of the FBI discuss why tapping each and every internet connection and mobile phone call would stop terrorists in their tracks. George W. Bush on why disasters are useful for making lame duck corporate puppets look like real presidents. Richard Stallman on why the use of the GNU GPL and open protocols would have prevented the terrorist attack Eric S. Raymond on why arming all airplane passengers would create a safer environment because they could shoot hijackers. [ Reply to This | Parent ] Re:Wheee Thursday September 13, @06:00AM taleban.com Hacked (Score:1) by ScumBiker (scumbiker@SPAM_SUCKS_jwenger.org) on Thursday September 13, @05:44AM (#2291277) (User #64143 Info | http://www.jwenger.org/ | Last Journal: Tuesday September 04, @10:03AM) The Taleban website [taleban.com], appears to be continually hacked. Every time they fix their site, within minutes it's defaced again. WAY TO GO!!!!!! I'll make a mirror of the hack for prosperity. I don't feel so completely helpless anymore! There has to be more that we as a community of geeks can do, other than giving blood (VERY IMPORTANT!), or donating cash. I'm sure that the lowlife communicated electroniclly, maybe have secure or hidden websites. Think about a cell based organization, picking up and dropping off information anonymously via FTP. I'm almost positive that info is out there. LET'S FIND IT! [ Reply to This | Parent ] Re:taleban.com Hacked by PhilHibbs (Score:2) Thursday September 13, @05:55AM Hey Muslim Pigs (Score:-1, Flamebait) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 13, @05:57AM (#2291300) hahaha you dirty, filty, smelly, circumsized, muslim pigs who are running this useless website. Look at this picture and get ready to piss in your pants along with your Mohammed(piss be upon him) and your dirty QUEERAN, that tells you that you will have 72 houris and 28 gay boys for sex in heaven. by the way the israeli's like to kill muslims and so do WE, hey pathan gay power, WE HINDU'S ARE THE MANLIEST, READ THE ARTICLES ON THIS WEBSITE ABOUT THE MUSLIM GENOCIDE, AND HOW WE LOVE TO HARASS AND RAPE MUSLIM WOMEN, We created pakistan for you bastards and we will not rest till each and every muslim motherr fuker is wiped out of INDIA. JAI HINDU RASHTRA(brahmans, dalits, kshatriya, vaishnav's, buddhists, jain's, sikhs) WUAHHAHAHAHA wuahahhahahaha later loserssss!!!! [ Reply to This | Parent ]

  9. How do I post? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Windows has stopped. Press CTRL+ALT+DELETE to restart your computer.
    $!
    Windows is now restarting...
    $Abort$, Retry$ , Ignore$, Fail$?$
    reading $
    writing $drive $device $Please insert volume $&File allocation table bad, drive %1
    $ serial $Write protect error$
    Invalid unit$
    Not ready$Invalid device request$Data error$"Invalid device request parameters$Seek error$Invalid media type$Sector not found$Printer out of paper error$Write fault error$Read fault error$General failure$Sharing violation$Lock violation$Invalid disk change$FCB unavailable$System resource exhausted$Code page mismatch$
    Out of input$Insufficient disk space$hYou can now safely turn off your computer.
    If you want to restart your computer, press CTRL+ALT+DEL.
    $dCannot run Windows on this computer.
    Windows requires a computer with a 386 processor or better.
    $nVMM32.VXD is required to run Windows.
    If this file is not in your PATH, you may need to reinstall Windows.
    $JHIMEM.SYS is invalid.
    Install HIMEM.SYS from your Windows Setup disks.
    $OHIMEM.SYS is missing.
    Make sure that the file is in your Windows directory.
    $BThis version of Windows does not run on MS-DOS 7.00 or earlier.
    $pInsufficient conventional memory to run Windows.
    Reconfigure your system to have at least 335KB free memory.
    $C
    This version of Windows does not run in real or standard mode.
    $
    Starts Windows.

    $WIN [/D:[F][M][S][V][X]]

    $H/D Used for troubleshooting when Windows does not start correctly.
    $k :F Turns off 32-bit disk access.
    Equivalent to SYSTEM.INI file setting: 32BitDiskAccess=FALSE.
    $e :M Enables Safe mode.
    This is automatically enabled during Safe start (function key F5).
    $u :N Enables Safe mode with networking.
    This is automatically enabled during Safe start (function key F6).
    $H :S Specifies that Windows should not use ROM address space between
    $. F000:0000 and 1 MB for a break point.
    $J Equivalent to SYSTEM.INI file setting: SystemROMBreakPoint=FALSE.
    $L :V Specifies that the ROM routine will handle interrupts from the hard
    $ disk controller.
    $C Equivalent to SYSTEM.INI file setting: VirtualHDIRQ=FALSE.
    $O :X Excludes all of the adapter area from the range of memory that Windows
    $$ scans to find unused space.
    $G Equivalent to SYSTEM.INI file setting: EMMExclude=A000-FFFF.

    $S
    One or more of your disk drives may have developed bad sectors.
    Press any key to run ScanDisk with surface analysis on these drives...$
    SCANDISK.EXE could not be found. You may have problems on your disk(s) that
    require repairing. Press any key to continue starting Windows...$
    There was an error running SCANDISK.EXE, or it was canceled. Run ScanDisk
    for Windows, as you may still have errors on your disk(s). Press any key to
    continue starting Windows...$You are already running Windows.

    Press ALT+ENTER to switch this MS-DOS prompt between
    windowed and full-screen display.
    $' Type Exit and press Enter to quit this MS-DOS prompt and
    return to Windows.
    Press ALT+TAB to switch to Windows or another application.
    $1You are already running Standard mode Windows.
    $-You are already running Real mode Windows.
    $#You are already running Windows.
    $The MS-DOS Protected Mode Interface (DPMI) is running on this computer.
    You cannot start Windows when it is running. To exit to your DPMI program,
    type Exit and then press Enter.
    $
    You are currently running in MS-DOS mode. Do you want to
    return to normal mode, to run Windows applications again [Enter=Y,Esc=N]?$~
    You are still running in MS-DOS mode. To return to normal
    mode, exit the application you are running, or type WIN again.
    $
    Press any key to continue...$*Load all Windows drivers [Enter=Y,Esc=N]?$Windows is still running one or more MSDOS-based programs.
    You need to exit your program(s) before Windows can be restarted.
    $Internal structure overflow

  10. Important news from George W Bush by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    %1 file(s) %1 bytes free
    Invalid drive specification
    &Code page %1 not prepared for system
    +Code page %1 not prepared for all devices
    Active code page: %1
    NLSFUNC not installed
    Invalid code page
    Current drive is no longer valid!Press any key to continue . . .
    Label not found
    Syntax error
    Invalid date
    Current date is %1 %2Invalid path or file name
    Insufficient disk space
    Return code (ERRORLEVEL): %1
    )WARNING: Reloaded COMMAND.COM transient
    Out of environment space
    File creation error
    Batch file missing

    Insert disk with batch file
    Bad command or file name
    9Cannot find WIN.COM, unable to continue loading Windows
    Locking operation failed
    Access denied #File cannot be copied onto itself
    )Content of destination lost before copy
    $Invalid filename or file not found
    %1 file(s) copied

    %1 file(s) %1 bytes free
    Invalid drive specification
    &Code page %1 not prepared for system
    +Code page %1 not prepared for all devices
    Active code page: %1
    NLSFUNC not installed
    Invalid code page
    Current drive is no longer valid!Press any key to continue . . .
    Label not found
    Syntax error
    Invalid date
    Current date is %1 %2
    SunMonTueWedThuFriSatEnter new date (%1): Invalid time
    Current time is %1
    Enter new time: , Delete (Y/N)?All files in directory will be deleted!
    Are you sure (Y/N)?Windows 98 [Version %1]!Volume in drive %1 has no label
    Volume in drive %1 is %2
    Volume Serial Number is %1-%2
    Invalid directory
    Unable to create directory
    6Invalid path, not directory,
    or directory not empty
    Must specify ON or OFF
    Directory of %1
    No Path
    Invalid drive in search path
    Invalid device
    FOR cannot be nested
    %Intermediate file error during pipe
    &Cannot do binary reads from a device

    BREAK is %1
    VERIFY is %1
    ECHO is %1
    LFNFOR is %1
    off
    SunMonTueWedThuFriSatEnter new date (%1): Invalid time
    Current time is %1
    Enter new time: , Delete (Y/N)?All files in directory will be deleted!
    Are you sure (Y/N)?Windows 98 [Version %1]!Volume in drive %1 has no label
    Volume in drive %1 is %2
    Volume Serial Number is %1-%2
    Invalid directory
    Unable to create directory
    6Invalid path, not directory,
    or directory not empty
    Must specify ON or OFF
    Directory of %1
    No Path
    Invalid drive in search path
    Invalid device
    FOR cannot be nested
    %Intermediate file error during pipe
    &Cannot do binary reads from a device

    BREAK is %1
    VERIFY is %1
    ECHO is %1
    LFNFOR is %1
    off

  11. My own patents. by GoodWIL · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    These cases are very similar to the one I'm currently fighting. You see, I own the patent on the English language. I kept it under my hat while helping to develop it, so I'm in the process of suing anyone and everyone for their unwarranted use of it.

    Don't worry /., you've been good to me, so I'm willing to settle out of court with you. :)

    1. Re:My own patents. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      FUCK U

      I'm 37337

      Slashdot requires you to wait 20 seconds between hitting 'reply' and submitting a comment.

      It's been 14 seconds since you hit 'reply'!

      If you this error seems to be incorrect, please provide the following in your report to Source Forge:

      Browser type
      User ID/Nickname or AC
      What steps caused this error
      Whether or not you know your ISP to be using a proxy or some sort of service that gives you an IP that others are using simultaneously.
      How many posts to this form you successfully submitted during the day
      * Please choose 'formkeys' for the category!
      Thank you.

    2. Re:My own patents. by Hard_Code · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      But seriously, the new Slashdot is really fscked up. Oh Slashdot is down sorry. Oh we logged you out randomly sorry. Hold on cowboy it's been 4.5 Gazillion Jabillion years and 12345 nanoseconds since your last post! Lameness filter rejected your message - Slashdot is too lame to accept it. Please follow this broken link with arbitrary spaces in it for further assistance.

      --

      It's 10 PM. Do you know if you're un-American?