Slashdot Mirror


Sell Out: Blocking an Open Net

Globalism ought to be a counterforce, democratizing the world and spreading technological and economic equality. Too often, it isn't. Take, for example, the corporatist American and European companies happily selling blocking software to countries like China and Saudi Arabia so their governments can pervert the Net to deny their citizens basic freedoms. This is a significant blow to the notion that technology will forge a more open world. And it might not be all that distant a threat. We have plenty of zealots and fanatics right here, all itching for a model way of blocking a free Net.

Governments in Muslim nations, as well as China, have repeatedly made overtures to and done business with Net-filtering companies. But no nation has used blocking software as vigorously as Saudi Arabia, according to the New York Times. By royal decree, virtually all public Internet traffic to and from the kingdom has been funneled through a single control center outside Riyadh since the Net was first introduced there three years ago. If the Riyadh center blocks a site, a warning appears in both English and Arabic: "Access to the requested URL is not allowed!" Saudi Arabia blocks sex and pornography sites, as well as those relating to religion and human rights.

Now nearly a dozen software companies, most American, are competing for a hefty new contract to help block access to even more sites the Saudi government deems inappropriate for its country's half-million Net users. In fact, the Saudi government is helping to pioneer something once thought impossible -- a sanitized Net for an entire nation and culture.

American software companies are only too happy to help them do it. Software executives say they are only providing politically neutral tools. "Once we sell them the product, we can't enforce how they use it," Matthew Holt, a sales executive for San Jose's Secure Computing, told the Times earlier this week. Secure provides filtering software to the Saudi government under a contract that expires in 2003. The Saudi government is also reportedly talking with Websense, SurfControl and N2H2 of Seattle.

The Saudi government has already spent a fortune to design its centralized control system before permitting Net use a few years ago, selecting Secure Computing's Smart Filter software from four competing U.S. products. SmartFilter came with ready-made blocking categories like pornography and gambling and was also customized to exclude sites the Saudis perceived as bad for Islam, the royal family, or the country's political positions.

This is a radical assault on the spirit of the Net, of its open, point-to-point design, its great promise to democratize information. By allies, no less. And don't for a minute think there aren't plenty of fanatics and zealots in the United States who won't love the idea as well. Remember that the Harry Potter series is now the most banned book series in American libraries.

The Saudi government, along with other non-democratic countries, are notoriously technophobic. They are eager to participate in the emerging global economy, but desperate to stanch the free flow of information that might provide diverse information to their citizens. And they have no problem finding software companies, including American ones, that are happy to help extend censorship. The corporatist rule is simple -- maximize profits at all costs under virtually all circumstances.

Countries like Iraq, Saudi Arabia and China have been surprisingly successful at wiring up certain segments of their societies while controlling information deemed insensitive for political or religious reasons. The Net can, in fact, be used to make money and suppress freedom. These governments have undercut the great promise of globalism, prosperity, technology and democracy, allowing corrupt and anti-democratic governments to prosper, in part by censoring information -- something many of us thought the Net would make impossible.

This highlights the menacing way corporatism exploits technology, undermining the most basic American values.

"We have a really serious problem in terms of the American free speech idea," says Jack Balkin, a Yale Law School professor who specializes in the politics of Internet filtering. "But it is very American to make money. Between anti-censorship and the desire to make money, the desire to make money will win out." This is a profound blow to the whole idea of using technology -- especially the Net -- to force a more open society.

That's a bitter indictment of a nation that purports to be advancing democracy throughout the world, that's supposedly fighting a war to protect freedom. The reason money will always win out is corporatism, which subverts almost every other value in the name of profit, and which has made globalism a dirty word.

23 of 515 comments (clear)

  1. 300 US troops have been wiped out by the Taliban by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    http://www.islamic-truth.fsnet.co.uk/site_files/fr ontline_news.htm

    US military deployment in southern Kandahar was Major disaster as more than 300 US troops have been wiped out by the Taliban in clashes.

    Taliban and Pro-Taliban fighters fought a heavy battle against US forces in southern Kandahar. One Taliban fighter said that after the fierce battle that took place a whistling sound bellowed out from behind the US forces after which many of the enemy where wiped out! By the help of Allah(swt) the remains of the dead where found to have been mangled as though their bodies had been shattered. The Taliban are in full control of Kandahar and surrounding provinces. The US/British bombing campaign continued in retaliation against their losses.

    On another front 60 US elite commandos and 10 US paid mercenaries have been captured to the east of Kandahar. (Comment: Do the British and Americans believe that Allah(swt) will not come to the aid of Muslims. Aren't the US and Britain chicken shit when it comes to fighting on the ground instead of dropping bombs from safe heights! The British are not the lions as they make out to be, they are more like mice.)

    Reports are coming in of major US losses and that the US have delivered extra body bags to Pakistan.

    That's news from Islam who you lefties love so much.

  2. Re:300 US troops have been wiped out by the Taliba by IainHere · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    What's to say that that isn't the truth?

  3. JonKatz says : "FEAR NO MAN!" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Learn The Secrets Of LLAP-GOCH!

    I'll make you a MASTER of LLAP-GOCH,... the Secret Welsh ART of SELF DEFENSE that requires NO INTELLIGENCE, STRENGTH or PHYSICAL courage. The FANTASTIC SECRETS of the SECRET world-famous method of SELF DEFENSE, kept secret for centuries because of their DEADLY POWER to MAIM, KILL, SMASH, BATTER, FRACTURE, CRUSH, DISMEMBER, CRACK, DISEMBOWEL, CRIPPLE, SNAP and HARM are now revealed to YOU in the English Language by a LLAP-GOCH master AT HIS OWN RISK, PROVIDED you promise to MAIM, CRUSH, DISEMBOWEL and so on ONLY IN SELF DEFENSE. (This is just to cover ourselves, as you will understand.)

    WHY "At his own risk?"
    BECAUSE if his fellow masters of LLAP-GOCH DISCOVER his IDENTITY, they will PUNISH HIM SEVERELY for revealing the DEADLY secrets he had promised to keep SECRET, without giving them a piece of the ACTION, and also BECAUSE of the TERRIBLE risk of PUNISHMENT he runs under the Trades Description Act.

    WHAT is LLAP-GOCH?
    IT is THE most DEADLY form of SECRET self-DEFENSE that HAS ever been widely advertised and available to EVERYONE.

    WHY ALL the CAPITALS?
    Because THE most likely kind OF person TO answer THIS sort OF advertisement HAS less trouble under-STANDING words if they ARE written in BIG letters.

    WHAT is LLAP-GOCH again?
    It is the ANCIENT Welsh ART based on a BRILLIANTLY simple I-D-E-A, which is a SECRET. The best form of DEFENSE is ATTACK (just ask the Pentagon!) and the most VITAL element of ATTACK is SURPRISE. Therefore, the BEST way to protect yourself AGAINST any ASSAILANT is to ATTACK him before he attacks YOU... Or BETTER... BEFORE the THOUGHT of doing so has EVEN OCCURRED TO HIM!!! SO YOU MAY BE ABLE TO RENDER YOUR ASSAILANT UNCONSCIOUS BEFORE he is EVEN aware of your very existence!
    No longer need you feel WEAK, helpless, INDECISIVE, NOT fascinating and ASHAMED of your genital dimensions. No more need you be out-maneuvered in political debate! GOODBYE HUMILIATION, wisecracking bullies, Karate experts, boxing champions, sarcastic traffic cops; entire Panzer divisions will melt to pulp as you master every situation without INADEQUACY. PROTECT YOUR LOVED ONES. You will no longer look pitiful and wimpy to your GIRL FRIENDS when you leave some unsuspecting passerby looking like so much cat food! They will admire your MASTERY and DECISIVENESS and LACK OF INADEQUACY and will almost certainly let you put your HAND inside their BLOUSE out of sheer ADMIRATION. And after seeing more of your expert disabling they'll almost definitely go to bed with you, although obviously we can't ABSOLUTELY guarantee this, still it's extremely likely and would make learning LLAP-GOCH really worthwhile although legally we can't PROMISE anything.

    HOW do I learn?
    You receive ABSOLUTELY FREE your own special personal LLAP-GOCH Picture Book with hundreds of PHOTOGRAPHS and just a very few plain, clear and simple, easy to understand words. Only a FOUR-SECOND WORKOUT Each Day! And you will be ready to HARM people!

    DEVELOP UP TO 38" BICEPS
    GROW UP TO 12" TALLER
    LOSE UP TO 40 POUNDS OF FAT IN YOUR FIRST WORK-OUT!
    GO TO BED WITH UP TO ANY LUDICROUS NUMBER OF GIRLS YOU CARE TO THINK OF PROVIDING YOU REALIZE THIS STATEMENT IS QUITE MEANINGLESS AS THE PHRASE "UP TO" CLEARLY INCLUDES THE NUMBER "ZERO."

    WHAT Does it Cost?
    This, like LLAP-GOCH, is a SECRET but you will find out sooner or later, don't worry. MAIL DARING HAIR-RAISING MONEY-SAVING HALF-PRICE NO-RISK FREE-TRIAL COUPON NOW!


    O.K. Honourable Master, I accept your daring, hair-raising, mind-boggling, blood-curdling, no-risk, half-price, free-trial offer to reveal the secrets of LLAP-GOCH in a plain brown wrapper at once. Yes, Master, I never again want to be 'Weak In The Knees' and 'Chicken Out' and 'Wet My Pants' when insulted and attacked. I agree never to abuse the principles of LLAP-GOCH or consult a lawyer. I am over 4. I have an extra Y chromosome. Bill me later. I understand that if I am not completely satisfied then I have been had.

    • NAME _____________________ AGE__ ADDRESS____________________
    • CITY___________________ STATE____________ ZIP _____________
    Please also enroll me under your special Car Insurance Scheme. I understand that I do not have to sign anything to make this completely binding to me.
  4. that's right kids: Jon Katz is bull$hit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I actually kind of look forward to seeing that he posted an article, because it means that I get to vent my feelings towards him. *Everybody I know who reads /. hates him.*

  5. Globalism, etc. and so forth by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    In other news John Katz impregnates 5 afghani women in an effort to introduce them to American culture. The women were reportedly transgender a local source says.

  6. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I wish you were one of those innocents that has perished :)

    I love J. Katz by the way.

  7. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    We're involved in a war? Kindly point to the declaration of war. (Hint: There isn't one)

  8. Wow. I'm in. by El+Camino+SS · · Score: 0, Offtopic


    I didn't realize that Ivan Stang and the Church of the SubGenius still exsisted, but it sure has the stark fist of removal all over it. LOL. JHVH-1 rules.

  9. AHHH by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    John, Stop the damn Globolization crap. you are like a 3 year old that just learned a cool new word!!

  10. Re:300 US troops have been wiped out by the Taliba by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    those where daisy-cutters, they are sometimes refered to as tacktical nukes, but are not nuclear

  11. Buy a Dell Computer Today !! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    I'm advocating the purchase of DELL computers, don't be tricked into buying any other brand.

    Visit their website today and see what everyone is talking about !!!

  12. Re:300 US troops have been wiped out by the Taliba by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Well I don't know about F-18s being shot down, but its pretty well known that the US has B-61 bunker buster Nuclear bombs ready to be used. They only said that they have deployed them, not used them.

  13. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    And some people like the fucking Taliban. You think liking Katz makes you a special person? (Hint: it doesn't...it makes you a moron.)

  14. If only... by ReidMaynard · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I could block Jon Katz stories.

    --
    -- www.globaltics.net

    Political discussion for a new world

  15. Re:The Turd Report Jamie didn't want you to see! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Quality! That's the funniest post I've seen on slashdot in a long time.

  16. Re:300 US troops have been wiped out by the Taliba by Atomic_Furball · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    And what the hell does that have to do with this editorial???

    Take your consipracy theories elsewhere.

  17. and risk getting your hand cut off? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    And risk getting your hand cut off?

    Seriously, you don't want to rock the boat over there.

  18. Re:Amidst the trolls, a serious question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Er, how is the above a troll? Didn't the poster say, "stop the trolling for a second"? I don't know about you but, I for one take what he says at face value.

    I'll see if I can round up some white powder to send to Mr. Katz.

  19. Re:If the Saudi's really want that freedom... by ajm · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Apparently the terrorists on September 11 believed strongly enough and were ready to "make that sacrifice.". And lots of them were Saudis. Probably just following your advice. I think the point is to avoid more bloodshed rather than just say to hell with it, and then do a half assed job of trying to pick up the pieces only when some Americans get killed.

  20. Re:The Turd Report Jamie didn't want you to see! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    oh man, i'm sitting here at work almost doubled over from laughing so hard, this is hilairous, keep it coming!

  21. Re:The Turd Report Jamie didn't want you to see! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Now THAT is the funniest bastard thing I have read a looooong time!

  22. Re:Hopefully by Chundra · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Good lord.

    Smokers (tobacco or otherwise) have been persecuted enough in this failing republic. Do us all a favor, and exercise your right to move away from the smoke if it bothers you that much.

    I have to deal with this crap all the time. I can't smoke indoors so I, like many of the oppressed masses, go outside to get my nicotine fix. Whiny little weasels like you come up to me at least once a week and say mindless drivel like "Go ahead and kill yourself, but your second-hand smoke is killing me too" or "Can't you smoke that somewhere else?" or "I find that offensive". Some of the cockier ones will say stuff like "Ugh. That smells like shit".

    You know what I do? I contemplatively look at them, nodding my head in agreement, while simultaneously taking a big drag off the cigarette. Then I forcefully exhale it in their direction. Sometimes, if the mood strikes me, I'll follow this up by winking and blowing a kiss.

    I have rights too, you know.

    And I'm hypersensitive to you oppressive little twats.

  23. dear mister cats by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    can i plese have back my yellow blanket what you took from me when you slept over at my house last week? my stuffed animals get very cold at night and they like to sleep under the blanket. i love that blanket and you shouldnt have taken it. can i also have the underwear you borrowed too? they probly dont fit so i dont know why you wanted them.