Slashdot Mirror
Looking Closely at the Restrictions of Linux on the PS2
Hal-kun writes: "I wrote an interesting article about Sony's upcoming Linux distro for the PS2 and some intellectual property concerns I have with it. It's an intresting look at how Sony limits the ability to have full access to the system, yet being able to keep it under GPL."
This article isn't news, and it doesn't give an interesting, fresh perspective on combining proprietary hardware with Linux.
The article provides the same old (perhaps) mal-informed opinions that the slashdot community mostly hears on the subject.
The author most writes that (1) Linux is free, and that (2) Sony is evil in protecting it's intellectual property and asks(3) why would a company be so stupid to do so, and concludes that(4) in the end, there is freedom.
This is a familiar theme, and instead of exploring details, the author basically says "I am smart and right, and those who protect their property are wrong".
Thanks for the waste of time.
This article shows what Sony has done to limit access to the system, but it doesn't say exactly how Sony has stayed within the GPL, or how it is only staying within the GPL through "shifty" means.
Quick summary? Sure: There are so many limitations to the "Runtime Environment" that I don't know why anyone would want to have one. Basically every hardware interface is disabled, and you're not going to get much hard disk space using that whopping 8MB memory card (so you're limited in how many external programs you can run).
This thing sounds so crappy that I'd doubt that there's even a compiler on the system!
-bigginal
Why would anyone really want to run Linux on a PS2 except to prove to themselves that it's possible? Sony was obviously reluctant to release their distro. They put all manner of hurdles in place to keep you from using YOUR PS2 the way YOU want to. Hell, I wouldn't even buy a PS2 just because of this. When I buy a computer (be it a pc or console) that single box is mine and I'd like to be able to choose what I do with it as long as I don't cause any sort of damage to others. If I choose to void the warranty on my PS2, so be it. Can a company like sony really enforce any restrictions/license when all I do is use the box for my own personal use and nothing else?? I'm no legal expert, but I'd be REALLY disappointed in the state of the legal system if this were true.
Learn from the mistakes of others. There isn't enough time to make them all yourself.
I'd like to know why it seems the visible majority of slashdot seems to think they have a right to get everything for free? Perhaps they don't realize they are helping to burn the economy..
I like my Sony Trinitron TV. 1 point.
I like my Sony Surround Sound Reciever. 1 point.
I like my Sony PS2. 1 point.
I like Linux everywhere. 1 point.
Dislikes:
I hate the DMCA. 1 point.
score: 5 to 1. Sony wins in my house!
Excuse me... Yuna needs me to summon an Aeon now :)
-J