Bob Young says Linux won't rule the desktop

Wee writes "I just came across this interesting Yahoo interview with Bob Young in which he says that Linux won't rule the desktop but will instead focus on replacing legacy Unix systems and enhancing Linux's embedded presence. He makes some pretty good points. The oddest quote: "So our opportunity is not to replace Microsoft on the PC. If you've got a perfectly good working PC, why you would go through the angst of replacing it?". Not sure where to start answering that one. My wife (a dedicated Win32 user) liked his car analogy. I need to get her to read 'In the Beginning was the Command Line'..."

Comments

Hehehe

[AjR]

Had to do it once in my life...

--

Metamod slapped - so why behave!

Re:Hehehe

[Anonymous Coward]

You posted this to a predominantly male forum. I responded. Draw your own conclusions.

Re:Hehehe

[Anonymous Coward]

Oh my, thank you for that! That's the funniest thing I've read all day.

--SC

ok

[clinko]

No Shit Sherlock.

I'm totally serious. And I love and use linux.

Re:not sure the movie...

[Anonymous Coward]

Hear hear!

I second that...

[Anonymous Coward]

You, sir, get the award for the best comment in Slashdot's history. I wish I had mod points right now.

PLP!

[Anonymous Coward]

This comment has violated the postercomment compresssion filter, which is just bullshit. The filter doesn't work and Malda should just give up on using it to filter trolls and crapflooders. This is a public service announcement brought to you by the Troll High Council and the Crapflooder Cooperative. Page lengthening posts will continue to be posted until Rob Malda gives up trying to censor us and eliminates the lameness filters stopping us from posting ASCII art and other similar crap. Fucking censors. This is why we do the page lengthening posts and get used to it, fucksticks. They're here to stay until major reforms are made to Slashdot and Slashcode. Stop bitching, and deal with it, jackasses. Fuck Jamie McCarthy, Michael Sims, and Rob Malda.

1

5

7

0

6

4

1

8

9

2

2

6

0

3

3

0

1

8

4

5

9

1

5

7

0

6

4

1

8

9

2

2

6

0

3

3

0

1

8

4

5

9

1

5

7

0

6

4

1

8

9

2

2

6

9

2

1

6

4

3

2

9

0

1

8

5

3

6

7

1

7

9

2

0

2

6

0

3

3

0

1

Fucking Slashdot!

[Anonymous Coward]

What's wrong with this, IMO, interesting submission?!

Things are looking both up and down for NASA, with lots of recent activity, especially budget and focus related. A computer glitch shuts off Alpha guidance system while a glitzy new orbiter to make X-ray flicks of sun is all set to go. NASA budget cuts human flight, pushes nukes in space after Bush blasts NASA on the shuttle program. In related news, Japan faced another setback during a recent launch.

GWB's speech at Pittsburg University

[October_30th]

"Bombers coming over the North Pole to attack America!"

What the hell fuck is wrong with this guy?!

Re:Well he would say that, wouldn't he?

[Anonymous Coward]

"The stupid young stag challenges the dominant male at every opportunity, and gets his young antlers broken. The wise young stag waits until his antlers are strong, and knows he can win."

Your ideas intrigue me, and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.

Go to China

[October_30th]

GWB can do it too.

With the largest boost in the military funding in two decades he can do anything. He can go to China with nuclear missiles.

Who cares about the health care, transportation, education and the rest of the national infrastructure... as long as the "homeland security" is guaranteed everything will be all right.

Re:Bob Young on Linux and the desktop.

[Enahs]

Sheesh, the cultural illiteracy of some moderaters.

And the lack of English skills among some posters.

Bob Young is a faggot!

[Anonymous Coward]

Windows-lovin' loser! Goddammit, he can
bite my dick!

Re:Bob Young is a faggot!

[Anonymous Coward]

He is some type of evil communist.

Fucking Slashdot!

[Anonymous Coward]

What's wrong with this interesting (IMO) submission?!

Things are looking both up and down for NASA, with lots of recent activity, especially budget and focus related. A computer glitch shuts off Alpha guidance system while a glitzy new orbiter to make X-ray flicks of sun is all set to go. NASA budget cuts human flight, pushes nukes in space after Bush blasts NASA on the shuttle program. In related news, Japan faced another setback during a recent launch.

Re:Bob Young on Linux and the desktop.

[Lemmy Caution]

I'll happily accept the onus of an occassional lapse in orthography in lieu of an ongoing ignorance of history, politics, and culture.

Fucking Slashdot!

[Anonymous Coward]

What's wrong with this submission that's IMO kind of intersting and generally "news for nerds?"

Things are looking both up and down for NASA, with lots of recent activity, especially budget and focus related. A computer glitch shuts off Alpha guidance system while a glitzy new orbiter to make X-ray flicks of sun is all set to go. NASA budget cuts human flight, pushes nukes in space after Bush blasts NASA on the shuttle program. In related news, Japan faced another setback during a recent launch.

* 2002-02-05 18:59:37 State of the NASA Nation (articles,news) (rejected)
* 2002-02-05 19:05:17 State of the NASA Nation (articles,news) (rejected)
* 2002-02-05 19:11:33 State of the NASA Nation (articles,news) (rejected)
* 2002-02-05 19:19:18 State of the NASA Nation (articles,news)

This is why you should replace it

[Anonymous Coward]

Grab the next motherfucker marmaduke who refuses to submit to these pelvic ostentations.

I've stumbled upon a brain fart which melts away your molds!

wide

[Anonymous Coward]

Sites just as bad as Slashdot
Unfortunately, Slashdot is not an isolated phenomenon; there are many sites out there that, in attempting to be alternatives to Slashdot, have become mere imitators, as bad as (or even worse than) the original. I'm still trying to figure out what factors lead a site down that path (a population of vocal libertarians appears to be a major factor)
Adequacy.org
Purporting to be "news for grown-ups", this site's banner calls it "the most controversial site on the web". In fact, this purely a troll site, started by ex-Slashdot and ex-Kuro5hin trolls who wanted more time and space to scream at each other like idiots (and draw people into screaming like idiots at them). I came across this site as a referrer in my weblogs; apparently there's a fanatical Microsoft devotee who links to this page religiously as a rejoinder to Linux advocates. I wonder if he's got any clue that
I use Linux (and other Unix flavors) almost exclusively whenever I need to get work done
The University of Washington lives in Microsoft's backyard, and our computer science department has strong ties to Microsoft Research. Yet we run most of our important systems (this web server, for example) on Unix.
Let me be quite clear: I do not hate Slashdot because I hate Linux. I hate Slashdot because I hate inanity. Adequacy.org manages the remarkable feat of beating Slashdot's record on that count.
Alternatives to Slashdot
You may be wondering, "Where will I get the links and news that I've been getting from Slashdot?" I'll admit that Slashdot does post some nice links once in a while---however poorly edited and poorly moderated the site as a whole is. However, I've found that for all useful content on Slashdot, there exists another source that will point me to it.
Reading other sites decreases your need for a Slashdot fix, and also makes the quality deficit at Slashdot all the more obvious. Here are my suggestions:
(Note: the following list is a work in progress. For example, the Register used to be on this list; now, after further investigation, I've moved it to the "just as bad" list.)
Science/Technology news
This depends on what kind of news you're interested in, of course. Here's a sampling of sites that will give you more targeted, more carefully selected news:
Ars Technica
An amateur (in the best sense of the word) PC user news site. The editors have a broad grasp of technical issues that is rare to find in an enthusiast site; as a result, their takes on tech tend to be uncannily on the money.
bottomquark
When Quit Slashdot! got posted to memepool, somebody (whose name I omit, to protect him from Slashdot groupthink flames) suggested bottomquark for science news. A brief skim suggests that bottomquark provides decent links for lay science enthusiasts, with no screaming 14-year-old boys.
Science Now
Daily news edited by the people who bring you Science, the premier all-sciences academic journal. Requires a (non-free) subscription, but your institution may already have one.
Wired News
Wired has its own annoying preoccupations, such as its obsession with tech stocks and Napster, but it tends to get the stories off the wires promptly and give a more clueful interpretation than, say, CNN. On the other hand, you should definitely not trust Wired News's reportage of political issues. The entire Wired organization is deeply steeped in libertarian groupthink and feels no qualms about distorting stories and quotes to advance their right-wing agenda. Caveat lector.
NewsForge
All open source news, all the time.
http://bbspot.com/toys/slashtitle/index.html
Yes, even "Slashdot" is better than Slashdot.

Re:Bob Young on Linux and the desktop.

[Enahs]

I'll happily accept the onus of an occassional lapse in orthography in lieu of an ongoing ignorance of history, politics, and culture.

I won't, especially in something so scathing in nature. For something so unforgiving to contain such an unforgivable error is, well, you know. ;-)