What if Harry Potter 5 Was an E-Book?

hakkikt sent a link to a highly speculative what if story on Harry Potter 5 as an E-Book. The suggestions are pretty extreme- going so far as to saying that this one book could change the fates of the publishing industry, book stores, and could even make E-Books more then a pipe dream. Personally I'd love to see it available digitally, but I still want a real hardcover copy, and I can't imagine hundreds of thousands of kids staying up late at night with laptops under their covers instead of the far more traditional book & flashlight. Food for thought, but I can't really take it seriously.

Comments

Re:Whoops, sorry

[Nurf]

"In any case, you won't be getting any newly released books published (officially :-) in any format you can actually use."

www.baen.com has a bunch. You can get the titles BEFORE they hit the shelves. They come in several formats including plain HTML, and I own over 40 titles.

I love these people. I am horribly biased. They give me access to great books in many different convenient formats, and they trust me to be reasonable in what I do with them. No draconian anti-piracy crap.

Re:The worst kind of discrimination

[Deanasc]

Do we really want this as a trend in our society? Knowledge only for those who can afford it.

It's called college. And yes I only want knowledge clustered around the wealthy. They tend to vote republican and I intend to run for public office some day. I want the rest of the country to be dumb as a bucket of wet hammers. It makes it easier for the TV to tell them to vote for me.

Re:The Death of the Book? Not quite

[swillden]

I can categorically state that the e-book is now, and forever will remain, a bastard child.

I categorically disagree ;-)

I posted this a couple of weeks ago, but it seems appropriate... Is it karma-whoring if you're capped? Whatever.

e-books Rock!

There are some devices out there that were designed to be electronic book readers, and they are *far* superior to PCs, Laptops and PDAs for this function. IMO, they're far superior to paper books as well in many ways (though not every way).

I have a Rocket e-Book, for example. It's a device that is just slightly larger than a paperback book, with a screen that is almost exactly the size of a paperback page. The screen is a very high resolution LCD with a backlight that can be turned on and off. It has 16MB of flash memory for storage of books and the (tiny) operating system. It connects to a computer via either a cable or infrared to download books, which are written in a simplified version of HTML and then run through a tool that packages and compresses them for download. The e-Book reader also has a high-capacity battery that allows it to run for as much as 18 hours on a charge. The UI is well-designed, with thin progress bar down the side to give you an idea of where in the book you're at, support for different font sizes, different orientations, etc., easy-to-use menus (which you almost never touch, other than to switch books).

This is a superb way to read. What do I like about it, as compared to paper?

• Hands-free reading. I can read while eating, working out, typing or just about any other situation where there's some kind of surface I can set the reader on. I only have to be able to reach out every few minutes to hit the page down button.
• Reading in the dark. The adjustable-intensity backlight means I can read in bed without disturbing my wife.
• Portable library. I can easily take a dozen novels and a few of technical books with me on a business trip, all in one very compact package. If somehow I run out of reading material, I can store a vast amount of literature on my laptop hard drive. Or, if I really need to, I can always go on-line.
• Reading in wet, dusty, etc. environments. I've discovered that by placing my e-Book in a sealed plastic baggie, I can read in the tub, on the beach or just about anywhere. The screen can be ready easily through the plastic and there's no trouble manipulating the buttons. For that matter, I don't even have to take it out of the baggie to download e-Books to it, since I use IR from my laptop.
• No bookmarks required. The reader always keeps track of where I left off, so normally I can just turn it on and read. If I want, I can add other bookmarks, highlight passages, add marginal notes, etc. which is actually something I *don't* do in paper books, because I like to keep them pristine. With e-Books, I can always strip the markup with a single command.
• Other enhancements. I always keep the free Random House Dictionary loaded in my reader, so whenever I come across a word I don't know I can just poke it with my finger, hit a couple of on-screen menu buttons and a pop up window gives me a definition. Well, that's the theory, anyway. I have a pretty good vocabulary, and the Random House dictionary isn't that great, so usually if I don't know the word the dictionary doesn't either, but that just means I need a better dictionary. The feature is still very nice.

What I don't like:

• Poor selection of e-Books. There's just not that much available. The selection was getting better for a while, but the PC-based e-Book reader software seems to have taken the wind from the sails of devices like the Rocket.
• The charger is too bulky. I don't really have to charge the reader that often, but it does need to be charged enough that I can't take it on a week-long business trip without the charger, and it could be a little smaller, or at least slimmer so that it would fit better in my small laptop case.
• Books are TOO expensive. I refuse to pay even the same price for a downloaded book as I do for a paper book. That's actually a funny attitude, I suppose, because I *like* the e-Books better and prefer them, but it just seems wrong to charge more for a purely electronic book, for all the reasons mentioned in the article. There are, however, a number of small publishers that publish electronic versions of new authors' works, for very low prices. The quality is mixed; I've found some really awesome stuff from a couple of sci-fi and fanstasy authors who haven't yet made it but are clearly destined to be big, but I've also run into crap that I deleted after the first three chapters. Most of these books can be purchased and downloaded for less than $3, though. There are also lots of classics available for free from Project Gutenberg, and I find that I read a lot of them these days, just because they're available on e-book.
• Airplane reading. They always make me turn the thing off during takeoffs and landings. OTOH, the compact size of the reader is ideal for cramped airline seats.
• No loaning of books. Most books that you purchase are encrypted for your device (although there's a huge selection of Project Gutenberg texts that have been placed in e-Book format, and they're not encrypted). The DRM technology used is pretty well-done (I do security/cryptography stuff for a living, and I know good from bad), not like the Adobe crap, and breaking it would almost certainly require hardware hacking. So, if I buy a book and I like it, the only way I can give it to you is to loan you my whole reader. There are a number of ways to fix this, though, and some of them have been implemented on newer devices (mine's 3+ years old). Note that if your e-Book gets lost or broken, you can have all of your purchased books recoded for your new device. And, actually, I don't object to loaning being impossible, but if it is that's yet another reason why the price of an e-Book must be *lower* than the paper version.

As you can see, the upsides are more numerous and more compelling than the downsides. The biggest downsides really have more to do with the fact that publishers haven't decided how to approach this e-Book thing. Here's to hoping they get it. soon.