Alternatives to the CBDTPA?

badBillStomper asks: "In the next few days I will be meeting with my Congresswomen to discus the effects of a Sen. Hollings CBDTPA on your average customer/techie. I have read tens (if not hundreds) of comments on the various OSDN sites explaining the very obvious reasons why the CBDTPA would cause a great deal of harm to the technology sector as well as consumers. Unfortunately the only postings/articles I have seen which offer a resolution to online piracy have been limited to ways in which the entertainment industry needs to change its business model. While this may be a valid argument, it does not provide a legislative alternative (something which many on Capitol Hill are scratching for). Therefore my question to the slashdot community is what new legislation would you support which would make those who engage in online piracy easier to track? Most internet users are familiar with the fact that someone with an intermediate amount of network knowledge can tap into data which is sent from one location to another. Vice President Al Gore was the first to link the internet to the idea of the 'information superhighway.' Since Americans are already used to this term, what would the effects of the creation of a kind of 'net traffic cops;' i.e. a law enforcement type of agency which monitors web traffic and fines individuals which break laws, i.e. distribute copyrighted information?"

Comments

Re:Why do we need legislation? *LONG*

[Fizzlewhiff]

Eh artists resent it. I f*cking refuse to pay $16 dollars for a CD worth not more than $2-$3.

Where do you come up with these figures? Break it down for me please because I just don't see how bands that are getting screwed over a $16 CD are going to be less screwed on a $3 CD.

The sad thing is writers take it in the ass a lot harder than recording artists do but no one gives a shit. We don't care because we don't have an easy way to steal their work yet. Once we do and the writers start complaining then I'm sure we'll all come to the table about how the publishing industry is ripping off writers so we can justify ourselves ripping off the publishers.