Slashdot Mirror
Review: Harry Potter & the Chamber of Secrets
Most of the cast is back again for the sophomore film. If you liked them before, you'll like them again, even if the boys voices have started changing and everyone is a little taller than they were last november.
The most substantial new character this time around is Gilderoy Lockhart played over the top and on the money by Kenneth Branagh. Alan Rickman's Severus Snape is practically a bit part here, but Richard Harris's Dumbledore gets a lot of scenes.
The general plot is as follows: Harry Returns to Hogwarts for his second year of wizarding school. He keeps getting signals and warnings that there will be trouble, but he ignores them and goes right on in anyway (Wouldn't you if you had his home life?). Anyway, at school students keep turning up petrified and the legend of the Chamber of Secrets revealed. Beyond that there's a little quidditch, rivalry with the other houses, and a mystery needing solving.
Generic, yes. But it's solidly produced and entertaining. Course I'm right in line for next year because I think the next 2 books are superior to the first 2.
As for the FX, I think they're a bit better than last time around. Especially during the Quidditch matches. The first films game sequences looked bad. Everything looked CG. This time around things are much more convincing. They also tackled Dobby the house elf and did him as a full CG character. The rendering on Dobby is just beautiful. Any still shot from his scenes would convince you that they just filmed a house elf right on set. And the fabric moves really well. Unfortunately the motion is all off. His weight feels wrong. His interaction with the set seems like he's a muppet. Hopefully they can nail him down before Goblet of Fire when there are many house elf scenes.
Anyway, I think this film is weaker than the first one, but I think that mostly this is because the book really doesn't add as much to the larger story. It's a solid movie and it stands well on its own feet, but knowing the bigger things yet to come gets me drooling for the next one. I'm hoping that handing the series off to someone besides Chris Columbus will give it a shot in the arm.
I feel much better being a fan of JRR Tolkien.
first post!!!
second post
I'm not embarassed to admit that I'm 26 years old and a fan of Harry Potter.
But are you embarrassed to admit that you still live in your parents' basement?
explaination of the giant gaping plot hole?
Ok, then, present it
Note to M1-ers: a curt but otherwise insightful message is not "Flamebait" or "Troll".
nt
Why isn't there a story about the MPAA Copy Protection on the New SE dvd set?
You sir, are my favorite type of biter. The 'well, this is probably a troll, but... (I can't help but share my valuable opinion with the rest of the world)'. Anyhow, keep up the good work, and keep biting!
How do I h4x0r te Lunix?
Its DUCT tape.
Its not DUCK tape.
And you probably wouldn't use DUCT tape on glasses to hold them together.
Ironically the thing DUCT tape is worst at is what it was named after...its lousy for taping DUCT work.
DUCT DUCT DUCT DUCT!!!
"Indeed, we can look to the fundamentalists own book to see that they're slavering hypocrites, because there are parts of the Bible which are "unsuitable for children" because they are so violent."
Why is it that anyone who read's the Bible (Jews, Catholics, Protestants, etc.) are painted with a broad brush; and are considered fair game.
No one ever read the Bible and then proceeded to crash a 767 into a building.
slavering hypocrites indeed.
"Thoughts are more powerful than any weapon, and I don't even let my people own guns." --Joseph Stalin
Actually most people CAN'T read. Look anywhere for literacy stats, it is disgusting.
Some stats show that
High school graduates tend to have public school reading levels. Adults out of school are even worse."
Witness the spelling and grammar on Slashdot. Which seems odd to me since geeking about on computers is mainly interaction with text. So it would seem that a high percentage of the Slashdot crowd should know their way around the written word.
Though maybe it's all that command line syntax that ruins it all.
Note: I accept any and all spelling and grammar flames. I'm not perfect either.
YOU SICK BASTARD!!!
is it that young? i thought it was:
old enough to bleed/ old enough to breed
maybe that's something else, then?
thinking of a little r kelly action there, perhaps?