Slashdot Mirror


Top 25 Science Stories of 2002

1.Nc3 writes "Scientific American has released a list of their top 25 featured science stories of 2002. From Cryptography to Entomology to Astronomy, a lot of neat stuff happened this year."

37 of 105 comments (clear)

  1. In other news... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Slashdot releases its top 10 "top 10" stories for dec 31st.

    This replaces all the "top 10" stories released on Dec 25,26,27,28,29 & 30th.

  2. clone by slothdog · · Score: 5, Funny

    ok, so it's not technically a dupe since the previous story referred to an article referring to the article instead of referring to the article itself. It's just an inferior clone. The editors must be having an off day.

  3. Saddened by the loss of 118 by drunkmonk · · Score: 5, Funny

    How many more superheavy elements will be born only to die in their first milliseconds of life before we realize we CAN'T PLAY GOD?! Poor Ununoctium never even had a chance at a normal life. :)

    1. Re:Saddened by the loss of 118 by TheSam · · Score: 3, Funny

      May Ununoctium rest in peace

    2. Re:Saddened by the loss of 118 by plover · · Score: 2
      I just heard some sad news on talk radio - Superheavy element 118 was found missing from the periodic table this morning. There weren't any more details. I'm sure everyone in the Slashdot community will miss it - even if you didn't believe the work, there's no denying its contributions to popular science. Truly an American icon.

      What the hell, I've karma to burn.

      --
      John
    3. Re:Saddened by the loss of 118 by Cap'n+Canuck · · Score: 3, Funny

      Actually, it did have a good half-life.

  4. Dont' forget Raelian Brigitte!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    How could they forget the story that some sexy French UFO babe claims she cloned the first human? Must have been too late for the presses...

    1. Re:Dont' forget Raelian Brigitte!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      She doesn't claim to be the first cloned human and her name isn't Raelian Brigitte. Brigitte is her lastname and Raelean's are the cultist group she belongs to along with the other guy that has been showing up on TV (the millionaire who wears space suits from the TV show My Favorite Martian).

      He (Volhalian or something) was a race car driver and was compelled one day to drive to a volcano where a 4 foot tall green alian came out of a flying saucer and told him that he (raelian) was the brother of jesus and his name was Rael. The race of people is the "Elholeme" or whatever (Hebrew word).

      He and this woman "scientist" founded a sex cult based on the Raelian crap and every few years they come out with some crazy thing to get attention in the news which draws even more idiots into their cult.

      I'm just shocked that all the news outlets are actually giving these people air play. That is really sad. Back in the day, it would have been dumped on the news room floor as "bullshit". I guess that's just sad commentary on today's world. I bet they'd even given Marshall Applewhite fair airtime if he were alive today.

    2. Re:Dont' forget Raelian Brigitte!! by istartedi · · Score: 2

      The only real story there is that the media is making it a story. Really. You can't channel surf without hitting the same redundant material about this chick and her claim. What I want to know is how do I start a crackpot group and get that much media exposure without any credible results at all? I also want to know where the real news is. I know it's out there somewhere. We have troops in Afghanistan, they are doing something, but they aren't telling us squat about it because the bandwidth is saturated with the SAME POINTLESS STORY being rebroadcast every 15 minutes.

      --
      For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    3. Re:Dont' forget Raelian Brigitte!! by spike+hay · · Score: 2


      He and this woman "scientist" founded a sex cult based on the Raelian crap and every few years they come out with some crazy thing to get attention in the news which draws even more idiots into their cult.


      Sex cult you say? Hmmm.

      --
      If you don't understand any of my sayings, come to me in private and I shall take you in my German mouth.
  5. gah! by SweetAndSourJesus · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sexy?

    Man, you need to get out more often. Or stay in more often. Something. All I know is that whatever you're doing, you're doing it wrong.

    --

    --
    the strongest word is still the word "free"
    1. Re:gah! by rppp01 · · Score: 5, Funny

      I'm still shaken up from that pic. Don't ever do that again. Please. I won't beg, I'll just send you mod points when I get them.

      --
      They stuck me in an institution, said it was the only solution, to...protect me from the enemy, myself
    2. Re:gah! by Sgt+York · · Score: 2, Funny
      goatse would've been better than that.

      The pain...the PAIN

      --

      There is a reason for everything. Sometimes that reason just sucks.

  6. Spiders replace Kevlar by 403Forbidden · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Article Link Here

    It says that Yet pound for pound, the sturdiest spider silks are stronger than steel and stretchier than nylon.

    I heard that while back the Army made a vest out of Spider Silk rather than Kevlar and it was able to stop even small rifle bullets O_o.

    This could be very revolutionary. I wonder how it compares to silk?

    1. Re:Spiders replace Kevlar by drunkmonk · · Score: 5, Funny

      I can see it now...

      "Whether you're in New York or Nablus, the Strip or the Gaza Strip, the Victoria's Secret Naughty Protector (TM) spider-silk teddy is for you. It feels like silk to you and eighteen inches of steel plate to stray rifle rounds!"

    2. Re:Spiders replace Kevlar by sczimme · · Score: 3, Funny


      I heard that while back the Army made a vest out of Spider Silk rather than Kevlar and it was able to stop even small rifle bullets

      The hard part was getting the 11-Bravo (infantry guy) to stand still long enough for the spiders to weave the vest.

      An 'army of one' indeed...

      --
      I want to drag this out as long as possible. Bring me my protractor.
    3. Re:Spiders replace Kevlar by wytcld · · Score: 4, Interesting

      able to stop even small rifle bullets

      The Mongol Hordes wore silk vs. the European's armor. Being lighter they could move much faster, and when an arrow struck it would penetrate the skin but take the silk with it, so by pulling on the silk they could pull the arrow out cleanly.

      --
      "with their freedom lost all virtue lose" - Milton
    4. Re:Spiders replace Kevlar by airuck · · Score: 2

      Naw, the silk is being manufactured from milking herds of engineered African Pygmy Goats. And I thought venomless bees were cool.

      Finally, people are getting serious about forward engineering life. When can I get a chairdog?

      --
      First entomology, then virology, and finally bioinformatics systems. Bugs follow me wherever I go.
  7. Re:Premature! by Dannon · · Score: 2, Funny

    I'm guessing they rushed to make the presses in Kabul (where it is, according to my world-clock, 12:43am).

    --
    Good judgment comes from experience.
    Experience comes from bad judgment.
  8. BEC the winner! by airrage · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I really think the winner is the SCIENTIFIC METHOD, and in such, that no matter how much you falsify and market your claims, i.e. fusion in coca-cola, cloned humans, flying pigs, altering gravity, you eventually have to publish and MORE IMPORTANTLY you have to have someone be able to REPRODUCE your results.

    To wit, I think those good-old boys who spent many a Saturday night figuring out how to get atoms to realize "damn it's cold" and stop and all huddle together at the bottom of a beaker -- well that takes the prize for me. Because it's little breakthroughs like this which fork into other areas of research and discovery. You take all the others and rip up the Noble Prize submission form, this one takes the cake.

    --
    "This isn't a study in computer science, its a study in human behavior"
  9. what? by tps12 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    No Segway?

    --

    Karma: Good (despite my invention of the Karma: sig)
    1. Re:what? by /dev/trash · · Score: 2

      Vaporware doesn't count.

    2. Re:what? by Idarubicin · · Score: 2
      Moderators seem to be confused about the meaning of the word insightful.

      The Segway is an engineering story; it doesn't belong on a science story top twenty-five list.

      Incidentally, the parent post was probably meant to be funny.

      Happy new year, everyone!

      --
      ~Idarubicin
  10. They are having a great day! by DAldredge · · Score: 3, Funny

    The managed to spell most of the words the correct way!

  11. Wrong name - by uberstool · · Score: 2

    I thought it was called Unobtainium?

  12. Scientist Report Card by nakaduct · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sequencing of genome this or DNA that: A
    Detection of ice and dirt way out in space: B+
    Detection and fanciful naming of really old bones: A
    Armies of telekinesis-powered robots: B
    Detection of life-ending asteroids: F
    Thinking one thing, then thinking the opposite thing: A
    Faster porn delivery: B
    Flying cars: F
    Teledildonics: F
    Collies that can cook, play poker, and/or defend you with mouth-mounted lasers: F
    A laptop that feels like a desktop: D-

    FINAL GRADE: C-

    1. Re:Scientist Report Card by sconeu · · Score: 2

      Collies that can cook, play poker, and/or defend you with mouth-mounted lasers: F

      Sharks with frickin' <FINGERQUOTES>"Lasers"</FINGERQUOTES> attached to their heads: F

      --
      General Relativity: Space-time tells matter where to go; Matter tells space-time what shape to be.
  13. The REAL scoop .... by mustangdavis · · Score: 4, Funny

    Here are some original opinions (hopefully ou agree) about the so called "Top 25 stories" of the scientific community:

    25.) Controlling Robots with the Mind - Are these in stores yet? When do I get to do this? Did anyone else hear about this?

    24.) Scientists Sequence Genomes of Malarial Parasite and Mosquito - Big news for people in Africa ... but I think they have a bigger problem ... its called AIDS!

    23.) Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation's Polarization Detected at Last - Oh goody ... raditation old enough to collect social security!

    22.) Mouse Genome Sequenced - those poor hairless mice .... how are they gonna pick up a mouse chick if they don't even have their hair when they are young? Considering m own personal situation, I can say I feel for them ('m loosing my hair!)

    21.) Astronomers Discover Icy World Far Past Pluto - 'bout time all that investment into telescopes got us something! We now have 10 planets!!! .... *yea*

    20.) Stamp-Size Plastic Chip Provides New Approach to Cryptography - A new mountain for te hackers to climb! Sounds pretty cool though ...

    19.) Meet the Oldest Member of the Human Family - This is depressing ... this helps to further prove that you and I are nothing more than a chimp!

    18.) Attacking Anthrax - Yea! Eat that bin Laden!! That idea won't work on the U.S.!

    17.) Crafty Crow Rivals Primates in Toolmaking - Proves you can teach an old bird new tricks ... nothing neat hear ... move on

    16.) New Findings Fan Debate over Origin of Vinland Map - Just sell the damn thing on Ebay and debate this later .... face it fokes, its a fake :)

    15.) Avoiding the Impact - Ok, this is news ... people!! wake up! We need to defend ourselves as a race, as a planet, from this kind of ,really bad shit! This should be in the top 3!!!

    14.) Element 118 Dropped from Periodic Table - I needed some of this stuff next week ... again, nice to see how "real" some of these so called findings are, but even better to see that someone was honest enough to retract their false findings! Way to embarass the community!!

    13.) First Humans to Leave Africa Weren't Necessarily a Brainy Bunch - I disagree! They won't get infected with AIDS!

    12.) Study Casts Doubt on Cell from Hell's Role in Fish Kills - *yawn*

    11.) Light's Information-Carrying Capacity Doubles - So now more senceless data from Microshaft can travel at "the speed of light" ... great!

    10.) Study Shows How Far GM Pollen Spreads - and three eyed fish will roan the seven seas .... right ... nothing here .. move on!

    9.) Gladiators: A New Order of Insect - They're going to get us, just like in Starship Troopers!! We're all gonna die!!! Seriously, this is worthy of its position in the top stories of the year.

    8.) Scientists Sequence Rice Genome - Don't need the Chineese anymore!

    7.) Climate Warming Causes Collapse of Antarctic Ice Shelf - So put less stuff on it! (end bad joke) This is VERY serious! However, this may be a natural phenomenon. No need to panic .. yet

    6.) Chinese Fossil May Be Mother of All Placental Mammals - Grandma!

    5.) Scientists Spin Spidery Silk - in other news, silk prices bottom out! New silk that doesn't have to be washed in the "gental" cycle is now available!

    4.) Physicists Create a New State of Matter - Sorry, call me short sighted, but I just don't see how this is useful

    3.) T. rex Not Fleet of Foot, Study Shows - Time to remake Jurasic Park!

    2.) Scientists Succeed in Transplanting Cloned Cow Tissue Moo! Moo! (in sync ... Moo!!!!)

    ... and finally ...

    1.) Mars Odyssey's Measurements Reveal a Wet, Red Planet - This is huge! See #15!! If we get hit by a large rock from space, the ability to have the human race move forward would be nice. However, in order for humans to live, we need water! Also, if we get too stupid and nuke most of the planet, we still might have a second chance! I agree that this is the #1 story ... and that is about all that I agree with when it comes to their rankings.

    The end.

    If you don't agree, please post ... don't moderate!


    1. Re:The REAL scoop .... by RatBastard · · Score: 5, Interesting
      24.) Scientists Sequence Genomes of Malarial Parasite and Mosquito - Big news for people in Africa ... but I think they have a bigger problem ... its called AIDS!

      And scientists and medical researchers are already researching AIDS. The AIDS problem in Africa is not scientific, it's cultural and political.

      19.) Meet the Oldest Member of the Human Family - This is depressing ... this helps to further prove that you and I are nothing more than a chimp!

      And? We are animals. Nothing more. We are not special. Deal with it. Yes, we are the top of the food chain for now and we are the most competent tool users and the most comunicative species ever to walk the earth, but we are still animals. You and I are special to our friends, family and loved ones. Is that not enough?

      18.) Attacking Anthrax - Yea! Eat that bin Laden!! That idea won't work on the U.S.!

      Bin Laden didn't have anything to do with the anthrax attacks. That was the work of home grown American nutjobs.

      17.) Crafty Crow Rivals Primates in Toolmaking - Proves you can teach an old bird new tricks ... nothing neat hear ... move on

      There is something "neat" here. Corvids (crows, ravens, magpies) are the smartest birds on the planet. The fact that they may be smarter (in some areas) that chimpanzees could radically change how we view animal intellegence.

      14.) Element 118 Dropped from Periodic Table - I needed some of this stuff next week ... again, nice to see how "real" some of these so called findings are, but even better to see that someone was honest enough to retract their false findings! Way to embarass the community!!

      No. Being honest is not an embarrassment. The embarrassment would come from the scientists refusing to retract their work. I respect and trust a scientist who has the integrety to admit a mistake.

      11.) Light's Information-Carrying Capacity Doubles - So now more senceless data from Microshaft can travel at "the speed of light" ... great!

      Please. Grow up. This kind of crap is cool if you are 14-years old.

      4.) Physicists Create a New State of Matter - Sorry, call me short sighted, but I just don't see how this is useful

      Many new discoveries are not useful at first. It was hundreds of years after Leonardo first thought up the helicopter before anyone could build one that actually worked. It took a better understanding of aerodynamics, better building materials and a lightweight, yet powerful engine in order to do it. Each piece of the puzzle found by someone else. Many inventions are made not by inventing the thing out of whole cloth, but by piecing together the discoveries of others into something new. Usually something never invisioned by those who discovered the pieces. That is the beauty of Abstract Knowledge: you never know what the pieces you've found will eventually make.

      --
      Boobies never hurt anyone. - Sherry Glaser.
    2. Re:The REAL scoop .... by frank_adrian314159 · · Score: 2
      how are they gonna pick up a mouse chick if they don't even have their hair when they are young?

      You're asking the wrong crowd, dude. They'd probably try to whip out their Linux Business Card to impress them!

      As for hair, I take comfort in knowing that Dr. Evil doesn't need hair when he has his Sharks with Lasers(TM).

      --
      That is all.
    3. Re:The REAL scoop .... by juuri · · Score: 4, Interesting

      There is something "neat" here. Corvids (crows, ravens, magpies) are the smartest birds on the planet. The fact that they may be smarter (in some areas) that chimpanzees could radically change how we view animal intellegence.

      Lots of birds can use tools. However I recall that it is now wildly believed that the kia bird of New Zealand is by far the world's smartest bird. They not only have great independent intelligence but have some amazing learned group behaviours. Unlike most birds that can use tools for a single purpose, kia birds can use tools "stacked" together.

      --
      --- I do not moderate.
    4. Re:The REAL scoop .... by cp99 · · Score: 3, Informative

      That would be the kea.

      The kea is pretty dam smart, but is there an objective scientific test for intelligence which would let us rank species? I'm pretty sure that their isn't.

      --
      Warning: Some ideologies on the Net are smaller than they appear.
  14. Troll Report Card by NoMoreNicksLeft · · Score: 4, Funny

    To sum up the performance of Slashdot's 2002 trolls... (*wink* you know who you are)

    Natalie Portman. C-
    In Soviet Russia. A+
    First post! B
    All your base. D
    Stephen King dead. F
    Goatsex man. F
    #3 Profit! B

    Overall summary:
    Trolls, your quest has only become more challenging, with more lameness filtering, competition from thousands of troll wannabees, and PR smearing you as juvenile retards with no sense of humor and vandalous personality. Even so, I'm afraid I can't give you a passing grade, when dozens of articles go by with not even one goatsex link or poorly written "all your base" parody. You keep chasing ancient Yakov Smirnoff jokes, which can only lead to trouble. You need to work harder so you can be accepted into either Comedy University or your local mental health facility.

  15. Probably not by Nurlman · · Score: 2

    Unless he's had a banner day on other stories, getting modded from 1 to -1 twice in one day has probably gotten him IP banned for the next 72 hours.

    Happy New Year indeed.

  16. Vinland map by Audacious · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I noticed that they got two separate returns on their investigations. It got me to thinking....

    Maybe someone in the early 1900s got hold of some parchment from the 1400s and inked the map using ink from the 1900s. It would explain the two contradictory reports and would, as the article states - be one heck of a forgery.

    Makes me wonder if they could lift fingerprints off of the map and try matching them to those of known forgers. Probably wouldn't make a lot of difference since fingerprinting wasn't always done in forgery cases until after the great depression (when forgery really took off as a method to make money) but you never know. They might actually get the original artist's fingerprints. Which would be neat if nothing else.

    --
    Someone put a black hole in my pocket and now I'm broke. :-)
  17. How could they miss this? by rfischer · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The biggest story is obviously the sad tale of Jan-Hendrik Schon, and his falsified data. This one really rocked the science world because it calls into question the whole peer-review process.

    1. Re:How could they miss this? by Idarubicin · · Score: 3, Interesting
      This one really rocked the science world because it calls into question the whole peer-review process.

      I don't know about that. Peer reviewers, presented with convincingly manufactured data, failed to catch a careful, deliberate forgery prepared by a fellow expert in the field. Short of actually repeating all the work, sometimes it can be very difficult to review the veracity of a manuscript. Peer reviewers are looking for well-designed experiments and interesting, useful results. They check for errors of methodology or theory--most probably don't look for deliberate fraud unless they catch an obvious flaw.

      The scientific method as a whole seems to still work--once the work was published, it was tested, challenged, and eventually withdrawn. Schon is utterly disgraced in the scientific community, and any future claims will be met with careful scrutiny.

      Just like any other field, there are bad apples. In science, I suspect that fraudulent work is less likely to be presented and more likely to be caught simply because other people will test it.

      --
      ~Idarubicin