Slashdot Mirror
Designers - Are You Influenced By What You Read?
Silent_E asks: "A student of mine is writing a paper on how Stephenson's _The Diamond Age_ offers a good educational model for distance learning. She has been asked by publishers to justify looking at fiction as a way of talking about 'the real world.' That dialogue made me wonder whether Slashdot folks currently or recently coding or doing hardware design are, or have been, directly inspired by what they've read in Science Fiction?"
Did you see this post from yesterday? I was very impressed and surprised at how well neural inputs work today.
Actually, it goes back a bit further than that. I wish more computer people would understand their history. At least it might keep them from repeating mistakes...
That is all.
Any Linux admin knows this will write dits and daws in ascii text to the primary hard disk.
You can't judge a book by the way it wears its hair.
Yes, I have found various Science Fiction works (as well as other fiction) to be inspiring. But all of the discussion here up-to-now seems to emphasize the technology. I think that the larger influence is when good scifi forces me to rethink the social implications of alternate or future worlds.
Take the original question's reference to The Diamond Age as an example. I read it soon after it came out, enjoyed it, and put it on the shelf; I rarely re-read anything, but felt like I might enjoy it again some day. A year later, my son was diagnosed with autism. As I learned about the disorder and made plans for helping him, I kept finding that my thoughts returned to Nell and her Primer (from the book, if you haven't read it). For me, it didn't matter that the actual technology of the Primer was out-of-reach, but rather, I was inspired by the general idea of technology being used to reshape the education of an underprivileged child. I re-read the book again, and during this second reading, I developed several, specific ideas for helping my son. I cannot say my solutions were direct implementations of Stephenson's work, but they were certainly inspired by it.
Four years later, when I left my regular, paid engineering position to form a non-profit which develops technology for disabled children, I still found myself inspired by some of Stephenson's ideas. For example, I believe one of the interesting ramifications of The Diamond Age is that Nell was actually being raised by Miranda, with the Primer serving only as a conduit for their relationship. I've found that idea recurring in some of my designs which have emphasized the importance of a live mentor to augment the technology.
This is but one example among many. I call on ideas from fiction every day, at least to the degree that great fiction has shaped my personality, my aspirations, and my values, while (less-frequently) specific ideas from fiction seem to reinforce and inform my concrete designs.
There must be wider phenomena at work here, because all of the great engineers I have worked with have all been voracious readers.