Slashdot Mirror


Online Epic to Release Penultimate Episode

Brokensaint writes "The award-winning 3-year epic 'Broken Saints' is preparing to launch it's 23rd installment in its cult hit saga. Winner of the Sundance Online Film Festival Audience Award for Animation, 'Broken Saints' contains over 10 hours of original flash storytelling in 'cinematic literature' format (think animated comic). Having been seen by over 2 million people worldwide, this free web project will be launching the penultimate episode in the series next week, and will close out its run with a 1 hour finale in June. 'Broken Saints' follows the paths of four protagonists from different cultures that receive an ominous vision of the future - a vision that is somehow tied to the launching of a global telecommunications network. One of the main characters - the Muslim mercenary Oran - was created as a direct protest of the continued sanctions against the nation of Iraq. His role in the story chillingly mirrors the direction of current global events. The 3-person team from North Vancouver, Canada hopes to release a tradition graphic novel and DVD box set of the series by Christmas 2003. They are also in talks with production companies ranging from HBO to the Sci-Fi Network to do a mini-series adaptation of the epic. If you want to help the lads chip away at their mounting bandwidth bills, please consider dropping a dime in their kitty."

148 comments

  1. Speaking of epics... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    That's one long story blurb for the front page of Slashdot...

  2. Broken Saints (First Post?!) by Bodrius · · Score: 4, Informative

    I love Broken Saints, it's one of the best WORKING examples of using the web to deliver dramatic media.

    They're utterly deserving of whatever graphic Slashdot brings to the site.

    However, I don't think "Penultimate Episode About to Be Release Soon, But Not Yet!" is "news", even in the Slashdot sense.

    As a link, cool. The press-release feel of the post is kind of silly, though.

    --
    Freedom is the freedom to say 2+2=4, everything else follows...
    1. Re: Broken Saints (First Post?!) by Black+Parrot · · Score: 1


      > They're utterly deserving of whatever graphic Slashdot brings to the site.

      You refer, I suppose, to a graphic slashdotting?

      --
      Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
    2. Re:Broken Saints (First Post?!) by ShinmaWa · · Score: 1

      Penultimate Episode About to Be Release Soon, But Not Yet!

      -- or even the fact that its not the last episode (might be news)

      -- or the first episode (might be news)

      Its the penultimate episode -- as in the second to last episode (probably not news).

      Then again (Karma burn on) -- we're getting Slashdot stories every time there is a new version of the trailer for the Matrix sequeal too.

      --
      The /. Effect: Thousands of users simultaneously accessing a site to not read its content.
    3. Re:Broken Saints (First Post?!) by CyberWolf · · Score: 4, Informative

      For those of you that do not live in North Vancouver, Broken Saints gets their funding for their site in two ways (that I am aware of).

      1) Donations
      2) Every three to four months, a benefit concert is held in the North Shore (aka North Vancouver) with some (if not all) the profits going to Broken Saints. Most of the bands are indies, but there have been a couple of bands that even I recognized (I mostly listen to country, so I am not up to date on metal/grunge/techno/etc).

      BTW, I believe that another party is in the works, after /. gets thru with their site :)

    4. Re:Broken Saints (First Post?!) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Surprised no one posted this.
      There seems to be a Bittorrent of this on http://207.44.142.96/

      Also, can we please host a Bittorrent of all 10 chapters of Ninjai.
      That one seems to be in high demand as well, ever since they took everything off because of BW problems.

  3. Katz by SuperBanana · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Seriously, that is the biggest description I've seen in the 5-6 years I've been reading slashdot. Reminds me about Katz; just keeps going, and going...

    Speaking of The Man Everyone Loves to Hate, the King Of Pontification...where is the guy? We haven't heard a peep from him in ages(not that this is a bad thing, actually.)

    1. Re:Katz by Flounder · · Score: 1
      We haven't heard a peep from him in ages(not that this is a bad thing, actually.

      Sshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh! You might awaken him! With the lack of school shootings, he's fallen into the slumber of ages. And we certainly don't want him around pontificating about the war.

      --

      No boom today. Boom tomorrow. There's always a boom tomorrow. - Cmdr. Susan Ivanova

    2. Re:Katz by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      He was just supporting NAMBLA, trying to liberate young kid's buttholes. Buttholes were meant to be free, man. Can you imagine a world with only closed, proprietary (ie: smelly) buttholes? I sure can, and I don't like it one bit. Free Katz!

    3. Re:Katz by mink · · Score: 1

      There has not been a "lack of school shootings" as you put it.
      They are still happening, just that the news isnt bothering to report them or if it does as a mere footnote.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  4. Hmm by Evil+Adrian · · Score: 1

    Enough with the anime -- why don't you just start pushing methamphetamines on us nerds instead? You'd make a lot more money that way.

    --
    evil adrian
    1. Re:Hmm by Bodrius · · Score: 1

      Broken Saints is not anime. It's animation.

      First we had to deal with people who thought all animations were cartoons, and so thought anime was about cartoons.

      Now we have to deal with people who think all animation is anime, and so think all animations and cartoons are anime...

      Broken Saints is animated drama. It has more to do with the US/European non-superhero comic media than with anime in terms of style.

      --
      Freedom is the freedom to say 2+2=4, everything else follows...
    2. Re:Hmm by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 0, Troll

      How about a category of "Saddam Sympathizers"? Let's not kid each other, the authors of this flash animation would probably be in the forefront of this Iraqi-flag-waving protest.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
  5. hypocrisy! by larry+bagina · · Score: 0, Offtopic
    If you want to help the lads chip away at their mounting bandwidth bills, please consider dropping a dime in their kitty."

    You are aware, of course, that their bandwidth problems will be exacerbated by your slashdot posting?

    --
    Do you even lift?

    These aren't the 'roids you're looking for.

    1. Re:hypocrisy! by The+Evil+Couch · · Score: 1

      considering that the poster is named brokensaint, I think there's a good chance he's aware for what the brokensaints site can and can't do.

      it could be a crazed fan trying to spread the word, but it's more likely someone from the site trying to get more publicity.

  6. Ninjai by mesach · · Score: 1

    I'm partial to Ninjai for my Flash Drama...

    But alas they also Suffer from bandwith Costs and keep taking thier episodes offline.

    I didnt link as to not drive up thier BW Costs, You can find them if you are so inclined to look them up

    --
    moo.
    1. Re:Ninjai by commonchaos · · Score: 1

      They seem to have removed the episodes for now, because of bandwith issues... but google searches for nj_chapter0X (where X is a number greater than 2) turn up some of the episodes that are hidden on other servers. I really like what I have seen of this so far.

    2. Re:Ninjai by Dylan+Zimmerman · · Score: 1

      Ninjai is AWESOME! If Broken Saints is even half as good, then I'll probably end up getting all of the episodes and sharing them with my friends. Unless, of course, they don't want people to serve them privately, in which case, I'll point my friends to their website.

    3. Re:Ninjai by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, Ninjai is definitely good HOWEVER they've been working on the last 2 episodes for fricken ever. Now don't get me wrong, free content is always great. But making numerous deadline promises and breaking them is a great way to disenfrachise your viewers.

      Hopefully they can take a hint from the Broken Saints people and wrap it up already!

    4. Re:Ninjai by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thanks for the tip.
      Although don't stop with google, I found all of the chapters by using a few different search engines.

      Any interest in a bittorrent of this? It would sure save on BW issues for them.

  7. penultimate by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ok, ok, I know it's petty of me -

    But how often do hype the next to last episode? Not very. I suspect that is was copied in the headline from the text simply because penultimate is such a cool word. And very rarely means what people think it does. (Although to be it was used correctly in the write-up).

    Clearly I have nothing else to bitch about right now.

    1. Re:penultimate by AndroidCat · · Score: 1
      penultimate is such a cool word.

      Yeah, it makes me feel completely enervated!

      --
      One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
    2. Re:penultimate by BitHive · · Score: 1

      I don't know why. It's a perfectly cromulent word.

    3. Re:penultimate by AndroidCat · · Score: 1
      It's a perfectly cromulent word.

      Only if you're a clinchpoop.

      --
      One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
    4. Re:penultimate by Dylan+Zimmerman · · Score: 1

      Or if there happens to be a syzygy outside.

  8. Umm by cethiesus · · Score: 5, Funny

    If you want to help the lads chip away at their mounting bandwidth bills, please consider dropping a dime in their kitty.

    humor

    Also, please consider helping by not posting a link to their site on Slashdot for crying out loud. :)

    /humor

    --


    "Ford," he said, "you're turning into a penguin. Stop it."
  9. What? You've got to be kidding! by teamhasnoi · · Score: 1

    I thought that *was* the episode!

  10. Just watched first chapter... by smoondog · · Score: 1

    Yup, pretty good. Surprised it hasn't been talked about much on /.

    -Sean

    1. Re:Just watched first chapter... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That was possibly the most useless on-topic post ever put in a slashdot discussion.

    2. Re:Just watched first chapter... by Jack+Lint,+412-L · · Score: 1

      Sorry, couldn't make it past about the 10 minute mark. My Pretensiousness Meter went off the scale. "My brain is floating like a dumpling"? Puh-lease.

    3. Re:Just watched first chapter... by smoondog · · Score: 1

      Yeah, pretensious. Cool art tho.

      -Sean

    4. Re:Just watched first chapter... by PowerPlay · · Score: 1

      it may seem pretentious at frist. but after you watch a few chapters it turns out pretty good it deserves a watch.

  11. "Mirroring Iraq" by Nova+Express · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    "One of the main characters - the Muslim mercenary Oran - was created as a direct protest of the continued sanctions against the nation of Iraq. His role in the story chillingly mirrors the direction of current global events."

    So, you mean now he's jumping up and down, cheering, waving an American flag, and chanting "Bush! Bush! Bush!"?

    Speaking of weird movies geeks may like, here's my rather detailed review of Donnie Darko.

    --
    Lawrence Person (lawrencepersonh@gmailh.com (remove all "h"s to mail)

    http://www.lawrenceperson.com/

    1. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This was marked "troll". Speaking against the illegal invasion is not a troll. Hence, I will repost it.

      You mean those 300 hundred or so people visible on television today? Wow. Out of a country how large?

      Here is the result of our war.

    2. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I read your review and it was very interesting. The only thing I didn't like was at that beginning, it sounds like you are using vocabulary words just for the sake of using them- they don't flow/fit very well. But, I only noticed this at the beginning - after that - the article flows very well. Nice work.

    3. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Conspicuously absent is the pictures of the dead people that Saddam killed. I wonder why nobody is posting them? Could it be a hidden political agenda?

    4. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ah, so the solution to Saddam killing people is to kill more people. Wonderful logic there. And in case you think it's over, it's not. Although the government is dead now, and you have people running in the streets, the real threats have long since gone underground. You thought Iraq was a terrorist nation before, you haven't seen anything yet. Give it a week, maybe two. Then we'll see how far we have to take it to really end this war.

    5. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by be-fan · · Score: 1

      Dude. Not even you're dumb enough to belive the US media at this moment. The country is at war. What they're telling you in the media is significantly fudged. Not lies, just edited perspectives. After the original gulf war, we found out that the shit stunk a lot more than we thought at first. It's the nature of any country at war to turn up the propoganda machine a bit. In a year or so, we'll see what's really happening. Not that the American public will know about it then anyway, because we've got the memories of frickin goldfish, but at least the few people who actually care will be able to find out.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    6. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The moron you replied to sits around all day and posts ultra-right-wing rubbish to every story he can find. Just look back through his posts. He probably jerks off to pictures of Dubya.

    7. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Ok, I'll bite.

      You said:
      Not even you're dumb enough to belive the US media at this moment. The country is at war. What they're telling you in the media is significantly fudged. Not lies, just edited perspectives.

      So you're saying that, despite the direct reports and footage being provided by embedded print and broadcast-media reporters from a wide variety of companies, it's wrong?

      I suppose my question to you is: what is your source of information for making such a claim, and how do you know that said source isn't "significantly fudged"?

      If you have no current source of information about the "ground truth" over there, then you are no more credible than the parent poster who you are mocking.

    8. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Ah, so the solution to Saddam killing people is to kill more people. Wonderful logic there."

      Saddam won't be killing may more.

      Not like he wasn't killing MILLIONS of his own people anyway.

    9. Re:"Mirroring Iraq" by be-fan · · Score: 1

      My source of information is the original gulf war. We had the same direct reports and footage from that too. Afterwards, we found out that the army was really jerking the reporters around by the bit. It won't be until all the dust settles that we get an actual idea of what's happening. Beyond that, you don't take into account all the factors that are making people behave the way they do. In the US, if you say a couple of hundred people rioting near the whitehouse, would you come to the conclusion that the entire US population has decided it wants to get rid of its government? What about all those people merely acting to make sure they don't piss off their new rulers? History has shown that people, even in countries run by oppressive dictators, do not like foreigners changing their government for them. If this is one of those rare exceptions that actually works out, like Japan was, then yay for the US. But at this point, you're hoping for a miracle rather than operating on logical precedence.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
  12. RealBasic by james_gnz · · Score: 1

    Didn't RealBasic used to be multi-platform? Perhaps I'm thinking of something else.

    1. Re:RealBasic by JanusFury · · Score: 1

      I think you're thinking of another slashdot story. Perhaps one about crossplatform programming languages, BASIC, or John Romero?

      --
      using namespace slashdot;
      troll::post();
  13. How long? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    How long is the story from the beginning?

    1. Re:How long? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Combining all of the episodes?

      Several hours.

  14. Pattern Recognition? by dev_alac · · Score: 0

    Perhaps I'm not fully investigating this (I haven't seen it yet, but will tomorrow when I won't wake people up) but isn't this a bit like the Footage in Gibson's Pattern Recognition?

  15. Bad Storytelling by Monkelectric · · Score: 1, Insightful
    was created as a direct protest of the continued sanctions against the nation of Iraq.

    Uninformed artists unite! Political messages other than universal messages ("be nice to everyone", "love is good" etc.) are a classic sign of poor storytelling. Good storytelling (if it has messages at all) has "universal messages" that can be appreciated after the lifetime of the project. The fact it is dated before it's even out is just a testament to poor judgment.

    Interesting fact, a musical number "The Jitterbug" was cut from the Wizard of Oz because the directors didn't want to date the film, they *hoped* it would be profitable for 10 years... Could you imagine how much less esteem the Wizard of Oz would be held in if they jitterbugged in it? (imagine someone doing a fad dance in the movie like "the bird" or "the cabbage patch")

    --

    Religion is a gateway psychosis. -- Dave Foley

    1. Re:Bad Storytelling by hmccabe · · Score: 2, Interesting

      This is very true, but on the other side of the coin I like a little dating. Carrie Fisher not wearing a bra (and to a lesser extent being coked off her ass) gives the geek of 2003 a better perspective of life in the 70s than any history book.

    2. Re:Bad Storytelling by Flounder · · Score: 1
      Could you imagine how much less esteem the Wizard of Oz would be held in if they jitterbugged in it?

      However, look at The Blues Brothers. Even when the film was released in 1980, the music and dancing was outdated. And that movie rocks!

      Granted, the entire film of The Blues Brothers was the old music. Yes, the Jitterbug bit would have lessened that part of the movie. I certainly don't think it would have ruined the entire movie, though.

      Look at the depiction of computers in early 80's movies (WarGames in particular). Look at the early CGI in Tron and The Last Starfighter. Us geeks look upon those movies with definite nostalgia and respect. Time will tell how future generations will view those movies (but my 6 year old boys love Tron, and they were raised on Pixar movies).

      And the moral of my story is.. don't post when you're bored at work, you have a tendency to ramble.

      --

      No boom today. Boom tomorrow. There's always a boom tomorrow. - Cmdr. Susan Ivanova

    3. Re:Bad Storytelling by BlackPanties · · Score: 1

      The movie "TANK GIRL" had an aweful Cole Porter musical number that, if taken out, would still not have improved the movie.

    4. Re:Bad Storytelling by Monkelectric · · Score: 1

      Thats like taking undigested corn out of a piece of shit ... All you have when you're done is a more pure piece of shit :D

      --

      Religion is a gateway psychosis. -- Dave Foley

    5. Re:Bad Storytelling by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Basing a story on "universal messages" is great if you want to create a saturday morning cartoon. Things like 'be nice to everyone' are great for carebears, but adults generally like fare with more texture.

      Of course I'm sure that since 'Full Metal Jacket' is dated (the Vietnam War is long gone), its message about war is completely irrelevant.

      Keep your platitudes to yourself.

    6. Re:Bad Storytelling by Bodrius · · Score: 4, Insightful

      In this case, this speaks more about the poster than about the artist.

      I don't know if Oran was created as a "direct protest" (this thing has been running for about two years) or to exploit a great dramatic situation. To me, it seemed like the second case.

      The artists are very much on the left, no doubt, but the characters are no simple strawmen for their political arguments.

      I disagree with their political stance on Iraq, as with a lot of their politics in general (feels too Salon-ish for me), but Oran is one of my favorite characters. The Iraq situation provides him with a lot of background and a great hook to put him in the story, as compared to others whose plots feel more contrived.

      Broken Saints is a drama with a political voice. You may or may not agree with it, but it's very well done. Like all political fictions, it manipulates its world to express a political message, to use it as an model of ideas.

      Oran, like all other characters, "speaks" about the political argument idealized in the fictional world.

      You may even agree with the argument within the context of the fictional world, but find there's no connection between the fictional world (and the argument) with reality.

      Or you may not agree with the argument at all, but find the fictional world so well done it's deserving appreciation as fiction.

      You don't have to fear Big Brother is about to take over the world to appreciate "1984", believe the banality of American consumerism is the end of civilization to like "Brave New World", or have an anachronistic appreciation for chivalric tradition to understand "Don Quixote".

      Or, perhaps closer to the media, you don't have to believe the world is being taken over by the secret societies operating under the UN and corporations to bring a New World Order to think Deus Ex had a great plot.

      --
      Freedom is the freedom to say 2+2=4, everything else follows...
    7. Re:Bad Storytelling by Monkelectric · · Score: 1
      actually you radicaly misinterpereted my comment :) I said a *political message* was bad story telling :) and I stand by that. But I said nothing about dramatic situations :) The Iraq situtaion could have been just as compelling without having been "created as a direct protest...". that being said I dont think we actually disagree on any points :)

      As for the article reflecting my own beliefs, I cant argue with that I suppose... to speak otherwise would make me a troll :)

      --

      Religion is a gateway psychosis. -- Dave Foley

    8. Re:Bad Storytelling by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1

      Why is it, if a Leftist politcal agenda is advanced in a work of "art", the creators are credited with depth, greatness, and strength of character, and yet when a Rightist political agenda is advanced, the creators are jingoist, reactionary, and fascist?

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    9. Re:Bad Storytelling by Screaming+Lunatic · · Score: 1
      Uninformed artists unite! Political messages other than universal messages ("be nice to everyone", "love is good" etc.) are a classic sign of poor storytelling...blah, blah, blah

      Uninformed posters unite! I had the pleasure of attending a "Violence in video games" roundtable at the Vancouver chapter of the IGDA. Brooke Burgess, a producer/director/writer of Broken Saints, was part of the roundtable. He is a very intelligent, informed, eloquent speaker.

      Maybe you should look in the mirror before calling someone uninformed. Or maybe you could do some reasearch. You know...maybe to "inform" yourself.

    10. Re:Bad Storytelling by barryfandango · · Score: 1

      Yeah, just look at George Orwell's "Animal Farm." Nobody reads that book anymore. [/sarcasm] Why can't art reflect on real events? In my opinion a true artist doesn't give a damn about the long-term profitability of their work.

      --
      In all matters of opinion, our adversaries are insane. -Oscar Wilde
    11. Re:Bad Storytelling by Wespee · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Animal Farm
      The Moon is a Harsh Mistress
      Oliver Twist

      Yep... lousy storytelling, all of 'em.

      Good storytelling has a good story. You're giving a personal requirement for "art" and claiming it as a universal prerequisite of a craft. Not to mention that a well told story, even one with a specific and timely political message, becomes an instantiation of a universal. It's not necessarily the message that makes a classic, it's the way in which the message is presented. You also seem to be assuming that "good" is equivalent to "will last a long time". I don't see that that necessarily follows.

    12. Re:Bad Storytelling by efflux · · Score: 1

      Basing a story on "universal messages" is great if you want to create a saturday morning cartoon.

      Universality is a staple of literature. This is generally held true by critics. In fact, it is often used in the very definition of literature/art.

      --
      Do I contradict myself? Very well, then I contradict myself, I am large, I contain multitudes. -- Walt Whitman
    13. Re:Bad Storytelling by be-fan · · Score: 1

      Um, try reading something sometime. Or watching a movie. Anything. Most art is created to comment on the human condition. A huge part of the human condition is politics. Do you even remember all the books that you had to read in high school?

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    14. Re:Bad Storytelling by be-fan · · Score: 1

      Try reading anything by anyone Irish after Britain occupied it. Then tell me how "political messages" make for bad story telling.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    15. Re:Bad Storytelling by be-fan · · Score: 1

      Damn. I gotta harp on this idiot again. Here is a little reading list for you. These are all famous, very specifically political novels. These are just the ones I remember from an English class years ago.

      1) John Updike -- Grapes of Wrath. 1920's populism.
      2) Joseph Conrad -- Heart of Darkness. European colonialism.
      3) Arthur Miller -- The Crucible. 1950's McCarthyism.
      4) Upton Sinclair -- The Jungle. 1900's meat industry.
      5) James Joyce -- Portrait of the Artist as a Young man. Irish nationalism.

      Okay, that last one is debatable. I think Joyce is being political in his emphatic rejection of Irish nationalism. Either way, he still references lot's of contemporary politics like Charles Parnell's affair and subsequent political scandel.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    16. Re:Bad Storytelling by Bodrius · · Score: 1

      Not really, unless you're just following crappy magazine critics or community-college professors, most of whom happen to be "from the Left" in the US since the 60s. I'm sure we'll be complaining about the same imbalance in a generation or two when they're all "from the Right".

      Art, however, is judged on its own depth and character regardless of the political bias of the author(s).

      Borges has been accused of everything you say, specially in his own Argentina, but he's still considered a master of fiction by any critic with two neurons. The same can be said of Dostoyevski. Heck, Nietzche, as misinterpreted as he's been, still fits the bill, but the artistic and philosophical importance of his work is not contested.

      This is no different from considering Garcia Marquez one of the best authors alive. Few contest that. Even among those who consider his politics flawed and/or hypocritical.

      Perhaps there is a true imbalance, a demographic imbalance, that justifies the misperception among popular critics: most people who train themselves "in the arts" have left-leaning politics these days, form left-leaning circles, and end up as left-leaning professionals.

      I have seen few good examples of "conservative art" these days. I have seen more than enough "leftist art" with no value, depth or character, and it's usually recognized as such and thrown away... But I have seen almost no recent competent art with a "rightist message" these days. It doesn't help when Ayn Rand is used as an example of high-quality literature.

      Perhaps you can put the blame on postmodernism's effects on the critic as a professional. Any pretense of objectivity can be thrown away, and analysis can be reduced to whatever the critic likes. It seems some English-List/Liberal-Arts majors spend their college years deconstructing their skills so they can write just like they did in 9th grade.

      I'm thinking of Salon's "this movie is really bad but I got a crush on the actor/actress and I just had some apple pie so go see it" reviews in this case.

      --
      Freedom is the freedom to say 2+2=4, everything else follows...
    17. Re:Bad Storytelling by Bodrius · · Score: 1

      Actually, my point is that "The Iraq situation" is as compelling as it is, whether it was "created as a direct protest" or not. The original motive of the author is irrelevant. In a year or two, no one will remember it.

      Either it's good art and stands by itself, or it doesn't.

      If the drama is not compelling, it has to do with the bad art, not with the motive. True, "direct political protests" tend to create bad art, but that's because *ANY MOTIVATION AT ALL* tends to create bad art.

      There are too many people trying to use art as a form of political expression and too few people with talent.

      The motivation and background adds value for analysis later, if the art is really that good, for historical purposes. It helps to understand it, as art, better.

      On the other hand, recommending a fiction book because "it was a protest against X" shows the same artistic taste as recommending a book because "it talks about puppies, and I like puppies". Rejecting a fiction book for similar reasons falls into the same trap.

      --
      Freedom is the freedom to say 2+2=4, everything else follows...
    18. Re:Bad Storytelling by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1

      Art is judged regardless of the artist's politics? WTF? Artists have to spout a certain political viewpoint, or they don't get shown, period.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    19. Re: Bad Storytelling by Black+Parrot · · Score: 1


      > Why is it, if a Leftist politcal agenda is advanced in a work of "art", the creators are credited with depth, greatness, and strength of character, and yet when a Rightist political agenda is advanced, the creators are jingoist, reactionary, and fascist?

      Maybe because artists tend to be leftist, so that most rightist "art" must perforce be made by someone other than artists?

      --
      Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
  16. 'animated comic' by p3tersen · · Score: 1

    ...'cinematic literature' format (think animated comic).

    I remember back in the day when we used to call these 'cartoons'. Maybe we should all read a little less of Wired magazine?

    1. Re:'animated comic' by Skevos+Mavros · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually, "animated comic" is a far more accurate description of Broken Saints (BS) than "cartoon". Cartoons usually have a lot more animation than BS does. Cartoons usually have spoken dialogue, not animated text balloons. I think you get the idea.

      Have you watched/read any Broken Saints episodes? I'm not sure if "cinematic literature" or "animated comic" are the right terms for it either, but if you have seen any BS then you'd understand the grasping for terms. "Flash comic strip" is the best I can manage, but it's too web-specific and will not really apply when the series is transferred to DVD.

    2. Re:'animated comic' by p3tersen · · Score: 1

      Now that I'm at work (=> broadband) I have, and you're right, it's nothing if not an 'animated comic'. I stand corrected.

    3. Re:'animated comic' by Skevos+Mavros · · Score: 1

      Hey no problem, I wasn't trying to put you down or anything. I'm a late comer to the series myself, so my "catch-up" took MANY hours, so I can imagine that you've got a lot of viewing to do if you want to watch them all before the big finale! :-)

      My one complaint about BS is that it has no transport controls to jump to and from scenes. Guess I'll have to buy the DVD for that.

  17. anime category by asv108 · · Score: 0

    I have the anime category checked so I don't have too see any of this crap, please put all anime submission under the anime category..

  18. Wazat?! by foo+fighter · · Score: 4, Funny
    ...this free web project will be launching the penultimate episode in the series next week [leading to its finale in June].


    Holy shit, someone used the word "penultimate" properly! On /. no less.

    --
    obviously no deficiencies vs. no obvious deficiencies
    1. Re:Wazat?! by mbourgon · · Score: 1

      Hell, I thought this was going to be some sort of extra module for Neverwinter Nights. I'm on part 5 of Penultima and figured this would be the Penultimate Penultima. And considering the puns they toss around, I could see it.

      --
      "Sometimes a woman is a kind of religion, she can save your soul & set you free from all your sins" - Bad Examples
    2. Re:Wazat?! by wannabe_wannabe · · Score: 1

      Hear hear! Let surge the tide of proper usage!

  19. Having been seen by over 2 million people??? by Flounder · · Score: 1

    I feel so left out. Why didn't anybody call me??

    --

    No boom today. Boom tomorrow. There's always a boom tomorrow. - Cmdr. Susan Ivanova

  20. limit by sstory · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    A word-count limit on the size of post summaries would be nice.

    1. Re:limit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, I'm sure the 225 words in the summary are going to result in a massive bandwidth charge to you.

  21. Re:JESUS GEEKS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That site is so funny, 99% of the posts are trolls! I love it!

  22. Flash bad for long form animation? by DoorFrame · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Yuck. Ok, maybe I don't know how to control flash properly, but is it even possible to pause, or jump around, in a flash animation? If I'm going to be watching a half hour episode of a long series of animated featurettes, I want to be able to pause them when the phone rings. Or, missing that, I want to be able to quickly and easily jump around the animation with an easy to use slide bar (or some equivalent).

    Expecting me to sit still for thirty minutes without these options is something that I'm not willing to tolerate for the sake of an anti-war cartoon series.

    Now, short animations in flash are fine. Anything longer than five minutes really needs to make the transition out into another format. Give me mpeg, give me avi, give me divx, give me quicktime... give me ANYTHING that I can pause.

    Does this bother anyone else? Am I missing an easy way to jump around in flash?

    1. Re:Flash bad for long form animation? by conway · · Score: 2, Informative

      You can't jump around, but you can pause it by right-clicking on the flash animation, and unchecking "Play".

    2. Re:Flash bad for long form animation? by c.emmertfoster · · Score: 1

      That bothers the hell out of me as well... and to top it off, it spawns an unresizeable window to hold the damn thing in.

      I believe it would be possible to create such a "slide-bar" within Flash itself, but the authors simply chose not to do so.

      *scurrys off to watch the quicktime animatrix shorts instead*

      --
      We can neither love nor pity nor forgive. If you make a slip in handling us you die!
    3. Re:Flash bad for long form animation? by The+Evil+Couch · · Score: 2, Informative

      how else are you going to get high quality movies that are 10-30 minutes long to fit in a 10-20 meg package? you can pause flash animation by right clicking and unchecking play, but I don't know of an easy way to navigate around, which is why several of their longer episodes were released in several pieces, so you didn't have to try to watch them all in one sitting. there might be a more efficient way to do it, but their method works fairly well

    4. Re:Flash bad for long form animation? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not in these ones - you can't.

    5. Re:Flash bad for long form animation? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's why I unplug the phone when the new Chapter gets released.

  23. NEVER DO THAT by Doktor+Memory · · Score: 4, Funny

    You said his name three times! Are you insane?

    I'd sleep in aluminum body armor tonight if I were you.

    --

    News for Nerds. Stuff that Matters? Like hell.

  24. This isn't anime. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    What part of "The 3-person team from North Vancouver, Canada" did you not read? Anime, in the terms commonly used by American fanboys, refers to Japanese Animation. This is hardly Japanese; hell, it's hardly even Anime-styled.

    Perhaps slashdot should create a generic "animation" catagory so all you people who whine about anything that might be anime don't have to see stories like this.

    1. Re: This isn't anime. by Black+Parrot · · Score: 1


      > What part of "The 3-person team from North Vancouver, Canada" did you not read? Anime, in the terms commonly used by American fanboys, refers to Japanese Animation.

      This is canime?

      --
      Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
    2. Re: This isn't anime. by mink · · Score: 1

      To referance Super Troopers use of "Afganistanimation" this must be "Canadianimation".

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  25. Ninjai? by wuchang · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Broken Saints is all fine and good, but when is the next episode of Ninjai coming out?

    1. Re:Ninjai? by Artifex · · Score: 1

      No kidding! I just went there after visiting Broken Saints, to remind myself of a really good flash story, and was surprised at the hits they're showing on the front page. 57 million hits and counting?!? And all without ad support!

      Broken Saints looks like it goes in a bit for the cheap scare in the opening flash, and the "classic" trailer doesn't inspire much more confidence, either. At least Ninjai is funny sometimes, as well as sad. I thought the "little bird" was a bit too Disney, but still worth a few (at $13? sure) t-shirts. And Ninjai never tried to create artificial interest in itself by calling itself a 'publishing event' - like labelling comics as collector's editions, you know - or by announcing itself to Slashdot.

      --
      Get off my launchpad!
  26. Interesting that... by Zathras11 · · Score: 1, Insightful

    they chose to create a character for THAT reason
    instead of creating one as a direct protest to the
    brutal treatment the dictator of Iraq subjected
    his people to, while spending the countries oil
    wealth money on things for his own pleasure
    (including the torture and murder of Iraqies).
    It sure shows where their priorities are, and
    for that matter how out of whack with reality
    they are. Loons... Screw 'em!

    "One of the main characters - the Muslim mercenary Oran - was created as a direct protest of the continued sanctions against the nation of Iraq."

    1. Re:Interesting that... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, Oran's character saw his father die as a result of an American plane dropping bombs on the town. Before that, he was raised by those who hate Americans.

      Not everyone in Iraq hates Saddam, you know.

    2. Re:Interesting that... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Also keep in mind that just because you're against American foreign policy in Iraq, that doesn't necessarily mean that you're for Saddam.

  27. Benefits of Slashdotting by AEton · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Since Brokensaint isn't a slashdot user, I guess the article author will remain anonymous. It's hard to tell whether their intentions were good or bad; I pulled down 131mb of zipped episodes (1-22, plus trailer) from http://bs.brokensaints.com/av/downloads/ just now, and so in a sense I guess that's a bit of bandwidth hurt.

    It seems kind of odd that the second-to-last episode, and not any of the others (like, say, the first) would merit a Slashdotting, but really now is a good time since there's more to see--better late than never.

    But if even nine other people do what I did then that's 1.31gigs of data transfer; someone's got to pay for that. With any luck there'll be a benevolent user somewhere among the mix who's willing to contribute. The benefits of willfully Slashdotting are thus mixed at best: greater exposure but probably a low click to pay ratio.

    At any rate, the comic is good. Hooray for pseudo-animation.

    --
    We recently had heard in the office over one of the Yellow Machine that's made by Anthology Solutions.
    1. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by ctar · · Score: 1

      Read my SIG!

    2. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by c.emmertfoster · · Score: 1

      That was an April Fool's Day joke.

      --
      We can neither love nor pity nor forgive. If you make a slip in handling us you die!
    3. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by DarkZero · · Score: 3, Funny

      I pulled down 131mb of zipped episodes (1-22, plus trailer) from http://bs.brokensaints.com/av/downloads/ [brokensaints.com] just now, and so in a sense I guess that's a bit of bandwidth hurt.

      You "guess" that 131MB of tranfers to one user in one day during a Slashdotting is, "in a sense", "a bit of a bandwidth hurt"? That's like saying that you might have, "in a sense", killed your next door neighbor "a bit" when you "stabbed him in the chest forty-two times".

      Seriously, though... downloading 131MB of files from a site that is currently on the front page of Slashdot is not cool. Practice a little restraint next time by bookmarking the page and coming back to it in a couple of days or something.

    4. Re: Benefits of Slashdotting by Omniscient+Ferret · · Score: 1

      Do you want suggestions? It would be nice to point toward alternate sources... You could post a mirror, or post some bitzi tickets for those episodes.

    5. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, there are a couple of mirror sites out there. They're technically fan sites, though, as the fans made them on their own and then advertise on the site's forums that such sites were made. I don't remember all of the URLs off the top of my head, but two good ones are brokensaints.it, and evilsponge.com/bs.

    6. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 1

      But if even nine other people do what I did then that's 1.31gigs of data transfer; someone's got to pay for that. With any luck there'll be a benevolent user somewhere among the mix who's willing to contribute.

      How about you, greedy-ass?

    7. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by phorm · · Score: 1

      Unless, of course, you are posting them up as a mirror (though I think in this case permission would be a good thing too).

      I'd donate mirroring for B. Saints myself, but I think that my meager 8GB bandwidth limit would stuff itself within an hour or two after a good slashdotting.

    8. Re:Benefits of Slashdotting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They know that they will be slash doted. They should have taken down the download section for the day, or scripted it to allow only so many large downloads during a time span.

      The better analogy would be your neighbor standing in the street when he knows 5 million blind people with knifes randomly swinging around are about to run down the same street. They may not intend to cause you harm, and there is a chance that they will all miss you, but it would probably be best to take some precaution.

  28. DVD Release? by conway · · Score: 0, Flamebait
    ...hopes to release a tradition graphic novel and DVD box set of the series by Christmas 2003.

    They plan to release this on DVD???
    I mean, I can put up with this PBS-like pan-and-zoom animation, with subtitles on a flash presentation, but watching it on a TV would be just torture.
    On the other hand, from what I've seen of anime (which is not much, so please correct me if I'm wrong), its all done in this "we're too cool to actually have things move" style.

    1. Re:DVD Release? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Then don't buy the DVD...

      Problem solved!

    2. Re:DVD Release? by mink · · Score: 1

      it isnt anime, manybe thats the problem your encountering... Expecting one thing (cartoons from Japan) and getting another (cartoons from canada).

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  29. Possessive "its" by YetAnotherName · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    "it's" == "it is"
    "its" == something belonging to "it"

    Come on /. editors---use that editorial power---for great justice!

    1. Re:Possessive "its" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Slashdot "geeks", lacking common social and personal hygiene skills, deliberately cultivate anti-social habits (such as chronic disdain for basic literacy) because, paradoxically, it makes them feel "clever".

      Mature readers will recognize in this attitude the hallmark of teen-age rebelliousness. The difference between a computer "geek" and a normal person is that a normal person eventually grows out of adolescence and learns to express his individuality without constantly antagonizing others. The "geek" on the other hand never develops sufficient self-confidence and therefore spends his life testing social limits through varying degrees of irritating behavior in the mistaken belief that this will somehow promote his self-interest.

      The geek is wrong.

      Learn to spell, pathetic geeks.

  30. Re:dime in a kitty? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I woke up this morning with a bad hangover
    And my penis was missing again.
    This happens all the time.
    It's detachable.

    This comes in handy a lot of the time.
    I can leave it home, when I think it's gonna get me in trouble,
    or I can rent it out, when I don't need it.
    But now and then I go to a party, get drunk,
    and the next morning I can't for the life of me
    remember what I did with it.
    First I looked around my apartment, and I couldn't find it.
    So I called up the place where the party was,
    they hadn't seen it either.
    I asked them to check the medicine cabinet
    'cause for some reason I leave it there sometimes
    But not this time.
    So I told them if it pops up to let me know.
    I called a few people who were at the party,
    but they were no help either.
    I was starting to get desperate.
    I really don't like being without my penis for too long.
    It makes me feel like less of a man,
    and I really hate having to sit down every time I take a leak.
    After a few hours of searching the house,
    and calling everyone I could think of,
    I was starting to get very depressed,
    so I went to the Kiev, and ate breakfast.
    Then, as I walked down Second Avenue towards St. Mark's Place,
    where all those people sell used books and other junk on the street,
    I saw my penis lying on a blanket
    next to a broken toaster oven.
    Some guy was selling it.
    I had to buy it off him.
    He wanted twenty-two bucks, but I talked him down to seventeen.
    I took it home, washed it off,
    and put it back on. I was happy again. Complete.
    People sometimes tell me I should get it permanently attached,
    but I don't know.
    Even though sometimes it's a pain in the ass,
    I like having a detachable penis.

  31. BS really does rock by Findel · · Score: 1

    Just posting my support for the Brokensaint guys. this project really does rock, and I recommend it to anyone. however, the best bet is to download a "keeper" of episode so that you dont have to download them again and knock up their costs.

    --
    "I love deadlines. I like the whooshing sound they make as they fly by."
  32. waggly cocks by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    donnie dorko was a fucking wretched movie.

  33. Lynn Valley 4 Life by rizawbone · · Score: 1

    Good to see other north shore kids do well.

    1. Re:Lynn Valley 4 Life by CyberWolf · · Score: 1

      That is true, I used to see their fliers everywhere until I moved out of Lynn Valley (Hoskins Rd.) and into oblivion (Chilliwack).

      I was never able to meet the Broken Saints creators, but I know a couple of guys that do, and the Broken Saints guys are focused and good people. I hope that they are not lured by the dark side.

  34. I hope they sink like a rock now... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What I want to do is help sink their 'iraq protest' into oblivion - so I hope they fail.

    If they had any sense at all, they'd be adding a brutal Saddam like character to protest the killing and death HE has visited on his own people.

    It never ceases to amaze me how stupid apparently intelligent people can be.

    1. Re:I hope they sink like a rock now... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You do realise that they started this whole thing over 2 years ago, right? Before Saddam's evilness became so mainstream. Before there was a war, let alone talk about a war.

      We've been bombing the country for years, that alone is enough to make some people there hate us. Oran happens to be one of those people.

      Adding an "Evil Saddam" character now would only cheapen the whole thing. I'd prefer not to see Broken Saints sell out in such a way.

  35. P2P source? by smalltalker · · Score: 2

    Has anyone yet added these to a P2P net? Seems like an obvious relief on thier bandwith costs, paticularly as the site is not generating revenue through ads.

    --
    Steve Cline http://www.clines.org, http://www.objectbap.com
  36. Everybody loves Oran! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In the last newsletter there was even a link to an entire cult based on Oran's Ass!

    www.evilsponge.com/~cora

    There it is! The Cult Of Oran's Rugged Ass! They need an under construction sign badly, but at least it looks OK in Mozilla.

  37. Can someone post a spoiler/review? by MickLinux · · Score: 1

    Quite simply, a lot of the stuff that gets approval on slashdot is beyond what I find acceptable for my own viewing [goatse comes immediately to mind...]

    Same goes for movies: I seldom go to one, but if I do, I've first read the reviews.

    Nonetheless, this might be good. Could someone, as an "anonymous coward", perhaps, post a spoiler. [Moderators: please don't vote up the spoiler -- let it remain hidden to those who don't wish it spoiled]. What's the basic plot? What's the basic premise? How deep is the theme? [For an idea: Stephen King is actually quite deep. His Randall Flag is symbolic for "grand ol flag".]

    I'd also like to get some idea of what the content is, as well. Swearing I can handle. Cartoons hacking each other apart I can handle too. However, sometimes nudity, and definitely sex, are a problem for my Y chromosome to handle. So if this is generally for me to avoid, please say so. If there is just one scene for me to avoid, please say that.

    --
    Correct Horse Battery Staple: 72 bits of entropy. Enter "Correct H" into google. When it generates the phrase, that's
  38. melodrama queens by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    gotta love the proclamations of those awaiting graduation from art school...

    Its no Ninjai.

  39. Not for everyone... by James+Lewis · · Score: 1

    I watched the first episode... well almost, I couldn't bring myself to finish it. If you watched the last episode of Evangelion and hated it then this type of thing is not for you.

  40. bad idea to get a tiered account by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Why do these morons get accounts that charge extra for extra bandwidth? When I bought rack space for my server I specified "if my site gets a lot of traffic, you can just slow everybody down, not charge me money", so I'm only allocated 256Kb/s. I can't get crushed by a $3000 ISP bill.

    Hell, I'd host the crap if they'd make it work when javascript is disabled in the browser.

    As for Ninjai, it was way better than this Broken Saints thing. Broken Saints manages to discard the big advantage of a graphic novel (ability to read at your own pace and/or dwell on an image) and completely avoid the big draw of flash (animation; zooming/panning and fade in/out don't count as animation).

    Of course, I've only seen some of the first episode, so maybe the technique gets better later on.

    I think Camp Chaos's Bounty Girl (warning, cheesecake) is the best implementation of a graphic novel in flash I've seen.

    1. Re:bad idea to get a tiered account by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, but if you slow everybody down, then each Chapter takes forever and a day to load.

      Which will annoy people and send them away.

  41. visible reality VS actual by phorm · · Score: 1

    a) Those are the people that the media is focussing on, because it makes the "war" look good

    b) What would you do if a bunch of soldiers with guns and tanks were rumbling through your city, give them the finger?

  42. Another Online Epic... by Alan+Holman · · Score: 1

    Oh, and they still don't post articles about the teleplay project at www.bananachan.com -- that online epic deserves recognition too (it's a much better story than broken saints. Yeah, Broken Saints is pretty, but c'mon) :)

    I guess if I were to post an article about Banana Chan, I'd say that their next major epic begins on May 3rd.

  43. Needs some work by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    Watched the intro - hmmmm - soft music puctuated occasionally by a loud scream. How utterly annoying when people do that. I think I'll pass on the episodes since their intro is done so amaturish.

  44. Mirror, mirror... by wirelessbuzzers · · Score: 1

    I've set up a mirror for Broken Saints (of everything on the site that I could find except the forum) to help out with their "mounting bandwidth bills." It redirects to my computer, as I don't have the 400MB to store all that stuff on my account. Furthermore, if you want to set up a mirror to help out too, go to http://[my ip address]/bs/totalbs.tgz for a tarball of the whole thing.

    My site (on my computer, currently 140.247.87.50) is pretty neat too, and I've set up a fun hitcounter script too, which logs things like code-red attacks as well.

    Please don't hack me.

    --
    I hereby place the above post in the public domain.
  45. Broken Saints Update by CyberWolf · · Score: 1

    Just an update, they just had a benefit concert this past month to raise funds to go to the Cannes film festival.

    Just wanted to let you guys/girls know.