Slashdot Mirror


Gentoo Games

TheSurfer writes "Today, Gentoo announced the creation of Gentoo Games, 'a gaming technology company created to deliver innovative Linux-based game technologies to the public'. They also released a GameCD with the full version of America's Army. For more information, see the threads in the forums here and here."

21 of 313 comments (clear)

  1. Cash by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Wouldn't a company of this kind need a lot of money to operate?

    How do they expect to pay for themselves?

  2. I would have read the article by Neophytus · · Score: 5, Insightful

    but I cann't seem to find one! A couple forum threads about the game doesn't really count.

    Anyone got more information about the company?

  3. Is this the answer? by steelerguy · · Score: 5, Insightful

    For some reason I just don't think this is going to make that much of a difference to your Linux user/Gamer. Unless they can get the game developers to actually develop Linux ports at the same time they are doing their Windows design then we will just continue to see a few old games ported over. By old I mean like 1 year of course.

    I think this is a great idea, and I love Gentoo, but I know I will be keeping a Windows partition around to dual boot until more companies like id (read Valve!!!) release for both Windows and Linux at the same time.

  4. America's Army by anarchima · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Anyone else find that America's Army game kind of sick? Sort of glorifies the horrors of war by caricaturing it through a cartoon-like portrayal. Plus, it makes it look like war is a cakewalk for a teenage audience. Reality is people dying, not losing 20 points off your health.

    1. Re:America's Army by Skyshadow · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Of course, you say "die" and you really mean "have to sit out several minutes before I respawn". AA is about as close to the reality of combat as paintball (at least in paintball it stings a little when you get shot).

      --
      Every year during my review, I just pray the words "slashdot.org" aren't mentioned.
    2. Re:America's Army by lscotte · · Score: 2, Insightful

      No, it doesn't make me sick because I know the difference between reality and fantasy. The average teenager is not an idiot and knows this difference too (I have a 15 year old, and I assure you she knows the difference). Sure, there will always be problem people who don't know the difference, but guess what: they have always existed in society, and always will exist. Welcome to the real world.

      How did the parent get modded up as insightful? Oh, /. pushing politics as usual. Sigh...

      --
      This post is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.
    3. Re:America's Army by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Anyone else find that America's Army game kind of sick? Sort of glorifies the horrors of war by caricaturing it through a cartoon-like portrayal. Plus, it makes it look like war is a cakewalk for a teenage audience. Reality is people dying, not losing 20 points off your health.

      Ok, you're way too sensitive. It's a video game and from the sounds of it, you've never played the game.

      The game doesn't glorify horrors of war. It pays attention to teamwork and strategies. If anyone's played the game, you can understand that a win never happens if you go solo, rambo style. It only works if there's teamwork. And even teamwork doesn't work all the time, it pays attention to detail such as back-tracking and obeying rules of engagement.

      You get sent to jail if you kill your fellow man, and usually when you're shot, you're dead. There's no health kit or health bar.

      Funny thing is, I've seen people from as far as Denmark, Germany, France, and the Far East, play this game, all working side by side with your fellow US players.

    4. Re:America's Army by rifter · · Score: 2, Insightful

      America's Army is only propaganda in disguise if you are a complete illiterate and blind as well. For one thing, it is distributed at the Army Recruitment Center. That should be clue #1. Clue number 2 should be the fact that with the possible exception of this anomalous Linux Release, it has always been released with the announcement that this game is made by the US Army for the purpose of portraying life in the US Army to would-be recruits.

      Honestly I think it is a good idea in theory, and the talking heads on CNN had claimed it was meant to dispel some of the myths about the army and the "glory of combat." If it is without blood, I would imagine it is designed with the specific intention of not arousing the ire of the various parent groups who would like to get rid of all violent games.

      There is no real way to get the feel of the horror of war without experiencing it for yourself. And anyway, I don't know why people who want to play Doom 3 are pissed the Army made a game they can get free as in beer. As far as I am concerned, I will continue to play my ultraviolent games and they can have theirs if they like.

  5. Errr... by Davak · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I really hope this is better than it looks.

    20 or so posts in a forum plus a logo doesn't form the foundations of a great company. Especially when half the posts are discussing installation and politics of America's Army.

    Yeah, we have America's Army... but surely the fledging company was helped by the Army's obvious goal of getting the game out to as many people as possible...

    That being said, I don't know how many of us geeks they want to recruit onto the front lines... (pizza boxes under the bunk beds, wars would have to be scheduled between 3pm and 2am, Simpson's battle crys, etc.)

    Anyway, I hope this is more than it now appears.

    Davak

  6. Re:The description is very vague by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    They're going to do what every other commercial linux vendor does.

    Repackage other peoples shit as their own and sell it to morons.

  7. Re:Recruiting Tool by cjackson0 · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Seems to be a cunning ploy of the US Army to indoctrinate todays youth in the fun and games of killing people for your country. How wonderful technology is.

    As opposed to the way it is today where todays youth enjoys the fun and games of killing demons from hell on mars or killing Germans in World War II ect.... Kids are already killing people in there games; this is an ATTEMPT to show a slightly more realistic view of this and do a little recruiting while at it. What's wrong with that?

  8. Re:Recruiting Tool by Elderly+Isaac · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I don't know about "cunning ploy." They are pretty open about the purpose of the game, especially as they have to justify the cost of its creation to the taypaying public. Recruiting is needed to run a volunteer army the size of America's; this is not any markedly different from TV or mailing campaigns.

    I suspect the government (and parents who buy their kids the game) see it this way: if kids are going to play violent games anyway, why not get the kid a game where violence is at least being carried out for a "positive" goal, as opposed to games like Postal or Grand Theft Auto which depict criminal acts, or games like Quake and Unreal where the violence is mindless and the only point. There are other objectives in America's Army, and, while there may be some discrepencies, it is not a totally inaccurate and unrealistic idea of military service [i.e. you can't take 40 hits before dying]. Most Americans respect members of the armed forces, whether you agree with it or not, and see it as having a positive influence. Any good parent would have a serious talk with their child about the armed forces before their kid decides to march into the local recruiting office based on a video game.

    I suspect most of those who play are quite immune from the propagandizing effect anyway, and simply enjoy the game.

    --

    Care to be asshole buddies?
  9. Re:In intent by TopShelf · · Score: 2, Insightful
    puh-lease... I get so sick of people ripping on parties that promote something by characterizing it as lying and mischaracterization. What is the army supposed to promote? "Come dig latrines and peel potatoes behind the mess hall, then get blown up by a suicide bomber while manning a checkpoint in a foreign land! Come be all you can be!"

    Reminds me of the morons who object to liquor or tobacco ads, because they don't present "the whole picture". Why should they?

    --
    Stop by my site where I write about ERP systems & more
  10. Re:Games on Linux by Glock27 · · Score: 4, Insightful
    What I don't get is why spend time/money on games like America's Army. Is the game free software?

    Free as in beer. I don't think it's open source. It is well-done, from what I've seen.

    And why such blatant propaganda for militarism?

    It's the American Way. (The American Way apparently consists of lots of violence along with minimal sex.;)

    Flamebait: I wonder what Joe Lieberman thinks about the US Army being involved in creating violent video games. Of course, far be it from a Democrat to actually take a stand on something. :)

    America's Army takes the wimpy way out - no blood etc.

    It really ought to use Doom 3 type graphics to really educate people about war and the military - but no.

    As to Lieberman...who cares? ;-)

    --
    Galileo: "The Earth revolves around the Sun!"
    Score: -1 100% Flamebait
  11. Re:But Gentoo? by checkyoulater · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Gentoo is great, but I don't particularly care to 'emerge ut2006' and wait 6 hours while it compiles.

    Then bite the bullet and invest in broadband. It only took me about an hour to "compile" ut2002, and 58 minutes of it was for the download of the binary.

    --
    Is that a real poncho? I mean, is that a Mexican poncho or is that a Sears poncho?
  12. Re:But Gentoo? by mark_lybarger · · Score: 2, Insightful

    just quit yer beeching already.

    first off, gentoo makes building complex apps EASY!. if you've ever built kde from source, you know what a lot of tar xvfz's; ./configure && make && make install's there are. gentoo simplifies all that crap.

    next, commercial games don't come as source, they come in binary format. try to build tuxracer from scratch and see how long it takes or gltron or BillardsGL. some more than others, but they go fairly quickly.

    finally, if and when the 1.4 version of gentoo goes final, they're plannign on releasing a binary version as well as the source based. IIRC, they're calling it a reference platform. so, you will be able to install gentoo 1.4 in under an hour just like all the other distros. upgrading might take a while, but isn't that the case will all other distros?

  13. Re:then RTFM by Bastian · · Score: 2, Insightful

    and try an 'emerge -b ut2006'

    duh.

  14. Possibly a very good idea by DougDew · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Recently, I gained a first-hand understanding of the frustration of having to explain to a child that the game that was just bought for the child won't run on the child's computer due to some software incompatibility.

    Before now, I had always assumed that by paying attention to logos on boxes, etc. it would be possible to avoid such problems. However, a child doesn't care about things like logos when shopping for games. Instead, a child cares about things like pictures on boxes. Once a child makes up his/her mind in a store that he/she wants a particular game, as a parent it's difficult to argue against a chosen game on the basis of lack of logos. Instead, it is sometimes easiest to just take a chance and buy the game (even if un-logoed) and hope that it will work.

    Of course, a parent quickly learns that taking a chance often ends in the game-won't-work frustration that I mentioned earlier. What's a parent to do?

    Enter consoles.

    Consoles are great at solving this problem. During the shopping trip, a parent can simply say to his child "you can have any game as long as it's from the PlayStation section." When the child picks a game from the PlayStation section, the parent can be assured that the game will run and that there won't be any frustration.

    Does this relate to Gentoo Games? Yes.

    Bundling pre-integrated, no-install-required Linux in with a bootable game cd basically changes the experience of using a general purpose computer into the experience of using a gaming console. Just pop in the game cd and run, the same as when using a PlayStation. In both cases, the OS is invisible and irrelevant. Perfect.

    Granted, there could still be considerable hardware incompatibility issues. However, at least the software incompability issues would be gone as they would have been resolved beforehand by the game developer. Given the pain that average computer users have when installing software on Linux, this could be a big advantage.

    Perhaps Gentoo's compile-upon-install model could be leveraged to eliminate many of the hardware incompatibility issues by compiling some stuff to the needs of the hardware upon startup. On a network-enabled computer, the startup routine could even include a fetch of necessary drivers, etc.

    Anyway, as a new buy-games-for-children parent, I appreciate anything that would make the experience of gaming on general purpose computers be more like the experience of gaming on consoles.

  15. Booting games from CD? You're kidding, right? by Cereal+Box · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Wow, how many years has it been since we had to have a "boot disk" in order to run games? That's not something I want to go back to.

    Also, how could Linux geeks be in favor of rebooting their machine to play a game? You guys think dual-booting Windows for playing games is absurd, yet don't have any problem rebooting to play the game in Linux? Huh?

  16. Re:Excellent! by GlassHeart · · Score: 1, Insightful
    they are competent coders and they know what the average Linux user wants, because they ARE your average Linux users.

    I don't think that's accurate. Average Linux users don't want to build everything from source. They use binary distros.

  17. Re:But Gentoo? by Unregistered · · Score: 2, Insightful

    ut2003 installs faster than it does on any other distro since it's a binary(no compiling) and gentoo knows where to dl it. I assume ut2006 will be the same