Slashdot Mirror


Power-over-Ethernet: IEEE 802.3af Draft

SkewlD00d writes "Want power (~10W) and your fat 10/100Mbps pipe (1Gbps maybe) on the SAME jack. Surf the web and recharge your handheld w/o finding its clunky base/transformer, home automation, and control systems are just some of the possibilities. Using suitable hubs/switches or dongle, power can be provided over unused pairs, or possibly raise the signal offset above DC, X10-style (no link, u know why). See IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force. Maxim (not that one :o) already has some goodies. They have schematics for 8.25W/12.5W single-output and 14.2W triple-output 802.3af PSU. Try FindChips if you're looking for them; they're in production and are NOT vapor-ware!"

15 of 172 comments (clear)

  1. FireWire already does this... by wario78 · · Score: 4, Informative

    The latest firewire standard can do 800Mb and provide up to 45W of power

    1. Re:FireWire already does this... by afidel · · Score: 2, Informative

      Firewire does it over 10m, POE does it over 100m with Cat5 cabling (well at 10W maybe even over Cat3). I know when I was working with the Cisco/Aironet guys that they had a customer who was having some problems with POE, turns out they were trying to use 100m drops of ancient barely Cat3 cable to power their AP's in some location, problem was that this was there wasn't enough power for the boot cycle, if we attached a power module and booted it then removed the power then it would use the POE just fine but the bootup sequence used more than the average power and the Cat3 was just too lossy.

      --
      There are 4 boxes to use in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, ammo. Use in that order. Starting now.
    2. Re:FireWire already does this... by theLOUDroom · · Score: 2, Informative

      The latest firewire standard can do 800Mb and provide up to 45W of power

      But does it work over several hundred feet? Nope.

      Also, are you sure about 45W? That's 9 amps at 5V. You're going to see sparks if you yank that cable out. They would need to have designed a new connector too. I doubt the original firewire connector was rated for that much current. I know a USB connector can only handle 2 amps and they are a very similar design.

      --
      Life is too short to proofread.
  2. Been there, done that... by stevenbdjr · · Score: 4, Informative

    I use this extensively with my Lucent/Orinoco wireless APs. Been doing it for about 2 years now. It's also part of 3Com's Ethernet switch/jack technology, and has been implemented for VoIP.

    I've found it to be a godsend for my wireless APs, as I can mount my APs near the ceiling (away from students), and not have to worry about finding an outlet, or having them unplugged by the cleaning crew!

  3. Re:OK I'm not smart by Black+Perl · · Score: 4, Informative

    - why no links on X10 ?

    Because they are misinformed. They are thinking of X10-the-company, which is notorious for pop-under ads. But what they really mean is X10-the-protocol [scroll down a bit for a good introduction], which is used by many companies.

    - which maxim is obvious ?

    Maxim is a "gentleman's magazine" that has been pushing the limits of how much semi-porn you can include without getting banned from shelves. Recently this and competing magazines went too far for Walmart.

    --
    bp
  4. Re:Hardware is available by spacefight · · Score: 3, Informative

    Quote from your link:
    "Powerline communications (PLC) technology uses the existing local electric wires to provide digital communication services such as high-speed Internet access, voice over IP (VoIP), video, and in-home networking."

    We're talking about power-over-ethernet here, not ethernet-over-powerline.

  5. Tesla Coil by drwtsn32 · · Score: 3, Informative

    If you want wireless power, just hook up a good ol' tesla coil.

  6. Re:Hardware is available by Cyberdyne · · Score: 2, Informative
    Ethenet-over-power, short range for home and long range for ISPs, currently being deployed in the U.S. Check it out.

    That's the other way round from the article! It isn't Ethernet over power, it's data over powerlines; this article is about sending electrical power over Ethernet wiring. Both are interesting, but have very different applications; power over Ethernet is already being used to power low-power devices, such as VoIP telephones and wireless access points.

    Power over Ethernet is limited to a matter of watts - much less power than a normal light bulb needs - but can deliver full speed Ethernet data (100 Mbps or better). Data over powerlines isn't limited by power - you can run the house off such a powerline - but has limits on the data speed (a couple of Mbps, depending on distance and wiring condition).

  7. TI also has chipset by asmithmd1 · · Score: 3, Informative

    here is a link to TI's PDF datasheet only $1.25 in qtys of 1000 for the device side, much cheaper than a wall wart

  8. Re:Cisco already does this... by Zak3056 · · Score: 3, Informative

    It can be annoying because if you want to run several phones on one drop, they need power supplies if you don't want to use an expensive inline power capable switch.

    Have you looked at these?

    They're basically four-port switches that you mount in place of your normal wall jack. They cost about a hundred bucks, support power over ethernet, and there's even a managed version.

    --
    What part of "shall not be infringed" is so hard to understand?
  9. Chips Available at Linear by Syris · · Score: 5, Informative
    Linear Technology makes some Power-Over-Ethernet IC's. Like this one.

    The Linear typical app seems to be much smaller, with fewer external components because it's actually optimized for the application.

    The Maxim chips appear to be generic hot-swap IC's not optimized for power-over-ethernet. Using slashdot is an interesting way to publish an app-note and get some publicity.

  10. Re:Hardware is available by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Ethernet only cares about the voltage difference on a pair. This was done for noise immunity.

    This means that if:

    Striped, pair 1: +12 VDC
    Solid, pair 1: Ground

    Striped, pair 2: +38 VDC
    Solid, pair 2: +50 VDC

    Occurred, the ethernet card is supposed to register it as +12 and -12 VDC on each pair. A device hooked up only to the solid wires of each pair, though, would see +50 VDC of usable power.

    Although, perhaps having this differential there might be dangerous to crappy ethernet cards, I'm not sure. A balun would probably take care of that, though.

    But I'm not an EE, so why not find out for yourself? ;-)

  11. Re:Power on bus generally a Bad Idea by adolf · · Score: 4, Informative

    Have you tried plugging an RJ45 in backwards (or sideways, or shifted one row to the left, or...)?

    It is essentially impossible, approaching non-issue status. And nevermind that ethernet is specified to withstand multi-kilovolt fuckups between random pins, unlike massively-parallel/easy-to-crossconnect SCSI - ethernet devices don't mind seeing voltage potential where it doesn't belong.

    Here's a larger problem that standardized POE solves:

    User has two cables running to desktop IP phone. User unplugs cables to re-arrange desk, and upon plugging things back in, their IP phone smells funny and their external modem won't work.

    Upon investigation, it turns out that the 12VAC power supply for their Sportster is not interchangable with the 13.6VDC PSU for their IP-600 phone.

    Therein lies the problem with multiple incompatible, anonymous-looking power supplies at the desktop.

    (In other news: Licking light sockets can be hazardous to your health. Also, this just in: Consuming too much water may cause accidental drowning.)

  12. Re:What's with the high voltage? by afidel · · Score: 3, Informative

    There are two reasons for not going for lower voltage, number one is loss, over 100m of cabling you get a lot of power loss at lower voltages. The second is that +44 is a common telco rack voltage so a lot of telecom equipment is already setup to use it.

    --
    There are 4 boxes to use in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, ammo. Use in that order. Starting now.
  13. 9 Hours and not even ONE... by Hercynium · · Score: 2, Informative

    ...mention of the BOFH!!!

    Another relevant fave found here.

    The whole shebang.

    --
    I'm done with sigs. Sigs are lame.