Slashdot Mirror


Sen Hatch Would Like To Destroy Filetraders' PCs

CBackSlash writes "Sen. Hatch is interested in technology to remotely destroy computers. But it would only be used if you're downloading copyrighted material, and only the copyright owner should be able to wield this awesome power, since having the feds do it would be against the law. Here is the AP story from Yahoo!."

11 of 1,372 comments (clear)

  1. In related news... by oscast · · Score: 1, Troll

    In related news, they said that the software is only compatible with Windows.

    We Mac users never get any of the popular software...

  2. Two words: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    frickin' Mormons

  3. Re:Why would he do that? by kableh · · Score: 0, Troll

    Signed into law with an anonymous vote by a Republican controlled congress. Not that it matters, because it was a silent majority.

  4. Not as bad as it sounds by CausticWindow · · Score: 1, Troll

    Please read the article before you spout your negative comments.

    Of course nobody are talking about literaly blowing up your computer. As the article clearly states, it would be a temporary lock out, that could easily be lifted.

    This is not so much different from for example revoking your drivers license if you are caught speeding. I know most Slashdoters are more attached to their computers than to their cars, but you still take it for granted that the government can revoke this right if you break their rules.

    Of course, I see this is not an ideal solution. In the long run there must come a shift of paradigms in technology which can establish a digital media market, secure for both the content provider and the buyer. Laws like this are for dealing with acute problems, not long term solutions. In the long term, the market should sort itself out.

    --
    How small a thought it takes to fill a whole life
  5. Re:Later in the discussion... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll
    He's effectively saying that if you download copyrighted material, someone can be sent by the company that owns it to break both your legs.
    That's a great idea. It'd certainly stop those pimply little thieves whining about "fair use" if they were crippled for life. Where can I vote for this?
  6. MOD DAT SUMBITCH DA FUCK UP! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    do it now, fucknutz!

  7. Enough! It's Lets Strip Hatch of his Temple Card! by mrs+clear+plastic · · Score: 0, Troll

    I wonder if the elders of Mr. Hatch's church;
    the Mormon Church; know about this tendency
    toward violence?

    Perhaps they might want such an animal to
    represent the Church in Congress.

    It's time to strip him of his temple recommend
    and make him take off his temple garments!

    MCP

    --
    Cleara
  8. Re:Hatch has finally lost it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    You filthy cunt. I hope you get inoperable cancer and that your parents are dead.

  9. Re:I borrowed your analogy... hope you don't mind! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    I sent this via hatchie's web site:

    Hello Mr. Hatch!

    I am very concerned for your mental health! Judging from your comments which appeared on the Washington Post's web site today - concerning illegal downloading - it would seem you have, as so many elderly inevitable do, began the downward slide from senescence to senility.

    When the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee says that destroying someone's computer "may be the only way you can teach somebody about copyrights" it's time for the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee to begin a nice cozy retirement in a sunny place with lots of lemonade and shuffle-board and high-fiber snacks.

    You see - you are apparently insane. If the world worked according to the skewed logic you evidently employ, law enforcement would be obligated to develop ways to remotely destroy the cars of speeders. How else could they possibly learn??? Although, perhaps your logic has some redeeming qualities as it also implies technology should be developed to remotely destroy the yachts of white-collar criminals. I'll have to think about that one...

    Anyway, given the recording industry's sordid history of price-fixing/collusion/gouging/corruption it is shameful, although not entirely surprising, that it is they with whom you choose to ally yourself.

    Of course, maybe you were off your meds when you made your cyber-terror-advocacy comments...

    -M.H.

  10. Re:Why protect a dead industry ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    I see you post drivel like this every time this subject comes up, which is often. I know how you think, you think it should be legal to download copyrighted material because it doesn't take away anything blablabla. JUST FUCKING SHUT UP ALREADY. You've established that you're 15 years old or completely clueless. Just stop. Please.

  11. HOW THE FUCK DO YOU PEOPLE KEEP MODDING HIM UP?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    HanzoSan is a complete idiot. How you people keep modding him up for spending 10 minutes writing this tripe is beyond me.