Slashdot Mirror


Mind-Controlled Wheelchair

carnun writes "New Scientist is reporting on the design of a new skull cap control mechanism that could lead to the supplanting of implanted electrodes for controlling wheel chairs. The new non-invasive method has been used to control a simple wheeled robots and could have lots of psychological benefits for quadruplegics."

50 comments

  1. First tinfoil hat post! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny
    Mind control wheelchairs! First, there were ID cards, then biometrics, then chip implants. Now, wheelchairs that control your mind!

    ~~~

  2. First a wheelchair by SLot · · Score: 1

    Next a car. It's not a flying car (which we are all still waiting on) but this has some seriously cool potential.

    Let's hope the auto industry takes note.

    (and it's good news for those that are wheelchair bound too!)

    1. Re:First a wheelchair by jellisky · · Score: 2, Insightful

      No, no, no!!!

      Like it's not dangerous enough on the roads with the crazy people talking on their cell phones, shaving or putting on makeup, yelling at the kids in the back seats, etc. (often all these at the same time). You can just imagine what could happen.

      *A soccer mom with three kids in the backseat is talking on her ultra-new cell phone.*
      "Yeah, Cindy, you take a left on..." *30-ton SUV drifts to the left lane nearly taking out a person next to her.*
      "... Killdeer Street, then a right..." *The SUV swerves back into its original lane, just missing the car that is trying to get around her.*
      "... on Center Court. We're the third house on the left." *Once again, the SUV swerves left, this time, thankfully, missing everyone.*
      "Yeah, and then-- will you kids shut up and stop..." *The SUV slams on the brakes, nearly causing a five-car pileup behind them. She continues on as if nothing has happened.*
      "... fighting! Otherwise I'll have to turn this car around..." *The SUV begins turning to the left, moving precariously close to the dividing, concrete median. Once again, since the command is short-lived, it stops just in time.*
      "... and take us back home! Sorry about that, Cindy. What were we talking about again?" ...

      Okay, maybe I'm a pessimist. *laughs.*

      -Jellisky

    2. Re:First a wheelchair by kmak · · Score: 1

      Ya, seriously, it'll work until they test it.. and realize most people are morons... Just because they have the technology doesn't mean anything.. this reminds me when a certain video game used to have a digicam for highscores (this was in the 80s, so it would've been cool..) it worked wondrously, until the next day, someone dropped their pants in front of the camera. End of story.

      --

      I'm not the devil.. just his advocate.
    3. Re:First a wheelchair by ravenousbugblatter · · Score: 1

      It's much more likely that cars will evolve to drive themselves, not to a point where we control them with our thoughts, which would not be as safe.

  3. X-Men? by IpsissimusMarr · · Score: 0

    Professor Xavier comes to mind?

    --
    "Engineers do the work of man, Physicists do the work of God"
    1. Re:X-Men? by mink · · Score: 1

      I'm thinking Davros from Dr. Who.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  4. Timmah! by floydigus · · Score: 3, Funny

    timmah. Timmah!

    --

    All things in moderation; including moderation

  5. This sounds horrible... by jolshefsky · · Score: 0, Funny

    It's bad enough that someone is in the circumstance of not being able to move, but to force upon them some crazy wheelchair commanding them through mind control is just unconscionable.

    --
    --- Jason Olshefsky

    Karma: Poser (mostly affected by adding this line long after everyone else did)

  6. Hmmmmm..... by Rxke · · Score: 0

    I sure hope they build a good pornfilter into this device, you know, men thinking of sex every xx minutes, could play some havoc with those delicate electronics, relais, the gearbox....

    1. Re:Hmmmmm..... by TheWanderingHermit · · Score: 2, Funny

      men thinking of sex every xx minutes

      Actually, it's every 7 seconds, on average.

    2. Re:Hmmmmm..... by Rxke · · Score: 1

      And actually, it's a myth. Idea was first coined in an (Australian?) commercial for beer. But it was not founded on any research or whatever. Still, it caught on, and now it's a perceived 'fact,' esp. by women ;)

    3. Re:Hmmmmm..... by TheWanderingHermit · · Score: 3, Funny

      I'm sorry, what were you saying? I was busy thinking about that woman I met at the gym today...

    4. Re:Hmmmmm..... by IIRCAFAIKIANAL · · Score: 2, Funny

      I think of Australian beer every seven seconds.

      Fun IIRCAFAIKIANAL Fact: I live in an apartment above an "Australian" bar in Calgary, AB.

      I really should check it out. I'd rather a Mexican bar, but what can you do?

      --
      Robots are everywhere, and they eat old people's medicine for fuel.
  7. That was strange by GuyWithLag · · Score: 1

    I first parsed that as "Mind-controlled Weather" and went WTF?

    And then it passed....

  8. Obligatory Trek Reference by TheWanderingHermit · · Score: 1

    ...And it will blink a light for communication. Once for "yes," and twice for "no" (or is it once for "no," and twice for "yes?).

    1. Re:Obligatory Trek Reference by Verne · · Score: 3, Funny

      or is it once for "no," and twice for "yes?).

      Don't worry. I'm sure it's one of the two. You could always ask it "is it twice for yes?" and it'll blink twice. :)

      --


      There are only two things in this world that smell like fish. And one of them's fish...
  9. Help - I want to get off by henrygb · · Score: 5, Funny
    At the moment the user can choose between three different commands: for example, "turn left", "turn right" and "move forward".

    "Stop" might be a useful upgrade.

    1. Re:Help - I want to get off by merdark · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Probably stop is implied by *not* issuing a command.

      If you don't think, it don't go.

    2. Re:Help - I want to get off by Patrik_AKA_RedX · · Score: 2, Funny
      If you don't think, it don't go.
      Hmmm, how about implenting this technology in the next generation browsers/email clients? That would make trolling a lot tougher.
    3. Re:Help - I want to get off by Verne · · Score: 2, Funny

      ooo... kinda like the pink elephant game?

      "ok... whatever you do, DON'T THINK ABOUT GOING FORWARD"

      yeah, like that'll work...

      --


      There are only two things in this world that smell like fish. And one of them's fish...
    4. Re:Help - I want to get off by merdark · · Score: 1

      hehe

      exactly :)

  10. this is great, but make sure... by DrEasy · · Score: 2, Funny

    ... you don't drink and drive!

    --
    "In our tactical decisions, we are operating contrary to our strategic interest."
    1. Re:this is great, but make sure... by IIRCAFAIKIANAL · · Score: 2, Funny

      Operating a motorized wheelchair while impaired is actually against the law (at least in Canada). People can and have been arrested for it.

      Course, it would probably be worst in a wheelchair controlled by your mind. You'd think about vomitting and the wheelchair would tip forward and vomit you into the street. :]

      --
      Robots are everywhere, and they eat old people's medicine for fuel.
    2. Re:this is great, but make sure... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's what the mind-control functionality is there for!

    3. Re:this is great, but make sure... by Igmuth · · Score: 1

      I hope thats not a law in the US, I would think that the ACLU would pounce on something like that. A law like that would basically prevent people confined to wheelchairs (electric ones at least) from drinking.

      If it is a law does that New York City law about confiscating people's cars apply?

  11. Wow by gazbo · · Score: 1
    Y'know, it could've been, like, mind controlling wheelchairs, and that'd totally freaky, 'cause I'd be all like "They're controlling my thoughts! Aieee!".

    Whoa. That's like mobility Daleks or shit like that.

  12. Bah, that's nothing. by DeadVulcan · · Score: 4, Funny

    Why don't people work on making more of Stephen Hawking's exoskeleton?

    --
    Accountability on the heads of the powerful.
    Power in the hands of the accountable.
  13. Firefox and Otaku dreams by MagikSlinger · · Score: 3, Funny

    In the novel that the movie was based on, the Firefox was developed from a project to create a mind-controllable wheelchair. So how long before we get jet fighters we can control with our minds?

    Then it can advance to jet fighters that transform and can only be controlled by mind-control and a giant mega-fortress with a really annoying J-Pop singer.

    THEN, we can have giant Evangellion robot warriors that you synch with that has a 1 in 10 chance of killing you (or driving you insane) just in time for the Second Impact!!

    *Phew*

    I think I'll go lie down now... :-}

    --
    The bitter lessons of a veteran coder: http://bitterprogrammer.blogspot.com
    1. Re:Firefox and Otaku dreams by juhaz · · Score: 1

      AFAIK, there has already been some research in mind-controlled jet fighter area...

      Not in steering systems like this wheelchair, but the actual firing mechanism, you might save whole second if time from though to actually pressing the trigger could be eliminated.

  14. That is how the ninjas do it. by admorgan · · Score: 1

    I have always wondered how the ninja was supposed to be able to know where you were going ot move and what you were going to do. Now we know... he can read the patterns in the air and see what your brain wants to do. You know this gives big brother a whole new dimention to play in.

  15. I need one for my mouse by neosake · · Score: 1

    So that i can have my hands free to do... ... other things :-)

    --
    "When a ball dreams, it dreams it's a frisbee"
  16. Forget about Xavier, this is shades of Davros by monopole · · Score: 1

    Of course Davros from Dr. Who (http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/doctorwho/alien/davros. shtml)
    developed a variant of his mind control wheelchair to host what the kaleds race would mutate into after their protracted exposure to nuclear, biological and chemical (NBC) warfare agents, creating the Daleks.

    This is particularly disturing in that he as more than a passing resemblance to Rumsfield.

    1. Re:Forget about Xavier, this is shades of Davros by MonTemplar · · Score: 1

      This is particularly disturing in that he as more than a passing resemblance to Rumsfield.

      That's not fair - Mr Rumsfeld is far more wrinkled than Davros, plus he can't pass off dud comments at press conferences by claiming his Voice Modulator acted up... :-)

      --
      -MT.
  17. I wonder what happens... by stupidsocialscientis · · Score: 4, Interesting

    when the user dreams they are moving? Similar neural areas may become active, and thus activate the wheelchair. If so, could an add-on be used to detect REM activity and incapacitate the device when the user is sleeping?

    --
    Well, as far as Sig's go, Freud was a doozy.
    1. Re:I wonder what happens... by Igmuth · · Score: 1

      Thats why these things tend to have off switches...

    2. Re:I wonder what happens... by Blaskowicz · · Score: 1

      You could say the same thing about our actual muscles. But when dreaming you actually don't move at all (although you can move in other phases of sleeping)

      IANAN (neurologist) but I think there's some inhibition of the motive neurones. I believe mind-controlled devices are also driven by motive neurons, and maybe they would be inhibited as well. So your mind-controlled wheel chair would stay motionless

    3. Re:I wonder what happens... by stupidsocialscientis · · Score: 1

      there is actually a neurochemical inhibitor that stops motor-activity while dreaming, but the associated areas of the motor-cortex continue to be active

      --
      Well, as far as Sig's go, Freud was a doozy.
  18. sounds cool by chloroquine · · Score: 2, Insightful
    This seems to be one of those technologies that has a good first impression but the more you think about it, the more you see the problems. Of course that's what I said about cloning an entire organism about ten years ago.

    Getting a hig quality EEG from a moving person who is presumably travelling over uneven ground sounds like it might be a touch difficult. Are there other brain visualization techniques that are small and portable and are associated with phenomenon that people can consciously control? I'm not a neurologist. Anyone have any ideas?

    I guess this is the first step to making a real cyborg.

    1. Re:sounds cool by stupidsocialscientis · · Score: 3, Informative

      as a psychologist - I have seen software that is designed to train people to elicit a certain type of brain wave pattern (e.g., beta, alpha). These devices use fairly crude caps. I suppose the wheelchair-makers may be using broad patterns such as these, rather than very neuroanatomically localized patterns, which I believe would be more subject to increased artifact as a function of movement.

      --
      Well, as far as Sig's go, Freud was a doozy.
    2. Re:sounds cool by chloroquine · · Score: 1
      But don't I remember something about "biofeedback" where people were trained to alter heart rate and body surface temperature at will? Could this be also used to control a machine? or is that not enough variables and not rapid enough a response time?

      I'm probably also not thinking about the kinds of disabilities the people involved might have.

    3. Re:sounds cool by stupidsocialscientis · · Score: 1

      probably the most common bio-feedback that can change quickly and be monitored crudely and quickly is galvanic skin response (GSR). this is a measure of the conductivity of your skin, and is measured pretty easily with two electrodes to assess resistance. i bet that might be "malleable" enough and respond quickly enough. good thought

      --
      Well, as far as Sig's go, Freud was a doozy.
  19. Falling asleep at the wheel... by momerath2003 · · Score: 1

    ...takes on a whole new meaning.

    Whoa!

    Imagine the crazy dreams that might make your wheelchair go...well...crazy. Imagine the safety implications if there were a cliff or something nearby.

    Except this time, you don't wake up before you hit the ground. Or at least you hit the ground when you wake up. Hrm. I'm confused.

    --
    I had but a simple dream, to destroy all humans.
  20. The first cars didn't have brakes. by purduephotog · · Score: 1

    In fact, they were stopped by running into a curb. So therefore, to progress the wheel chair properly, you may stop it on the following items:

    Curb

    Wall

    Neighbor

    Steps

    Pedestrian (moving target bonus)

    Car (again moving target bonus)

    Cat (what else are they good for- makes good doorstops)

    The Micael Jackson (Just think Left, Right, Left, Right)

    Etc. See, stop is highly overrated.
    Curb

    Curb

    Curb

  21. What about replacing the mouse? by tyroneking · · Score: 1
    Could this be used to replace the PC mouse and point'n'click? The article talks about detecting a person's desire to move in a particular direction by monitoring alpha brain waves. This is surely something that could be easily applied to mouse control.

    Differentiating between EEG patterns could be advanced by neural network based analysis.

    The possibilities are endless.

    BTW, the Swiss institute mentioned in the article also analysed a Bin Laden tape and decided it was fake.

    1. Re:What about replacing the mouse? by v_1matst · · Score: 0

      Already exists (mind controlled mouse that is). It looks pretty expensive and only works with Windows at the moment, however it still looks pretty cool. Check out http://www.officeorganix.com for more information.

    2. Re:What about replacing the mouse? by tyroneking · · Score: 1

      Looks 'interesting' - not sure what drives the 'Brainfinger' signals it uses to control mouse movements though, and you;re right about the cost - way out of my league! Even with the free 'Cybergel' ;)

  22. So... by Boyceterous · · Score: 1

    if I get blasted with Delta rays do I get one of these cool chairs plus a trip to Talos IV for a date with my favorite green Orion slave-girl? Beep once for yes!

  23. Now what if you get scared? by burbilog · · Score: 1

    Now what if someone get scared while driving such chair in the middle of the crowd and the chair starts uncontrollably rolling back and forth hitting people?

    1. Re:Now what if you get scared? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Now what if you get scared while walking in the middle of a crowd, and your arms start uncontrollably flinging back and forth hitting people?