Slashdot Mirror


Essay Grading Software For Teachers

asjk writes "Software to help teachers with grading has been around for sometime. This is true even with respect to grading essays. A new tool, called Criteria, will look at grammar, usage, and even style and organization. It works by being trained by at least 450 essays scored by two professionals. The difference this time? Here is a snip from the article: '"There's a lot of skepticism," Dr. Spatola said. "The people opposed see it dehumanizing the student's papers, putting them through some sort of mechanical, computerized system like the multiple choice tests. That's really not the case, because we're not talking about eliminating the human element. We're making the process more efficient."'"

21 of 535 comments (clear)

  1. This seems like a bad idea by Bueller_007 · · Score: 5, Funny

    I for one welcome our automated essay-correcting overlords.

    1. Re:This seems like a bad idea by Jerf · · Score: 4, Funny

      ESSAY GRADING REPORT FOR: "Bueller 007" (ID: 535588)

      BASE SCORE: 100

      -50: Essay too short (few arguments can be well-supported in nine words)

      -50: Plagarism: It is 99.999% (MAX PROB) likely, based on the content of the essay, that it is plagarized from other sources.

      -10: Grammar error: Phrase "I for one welcome" requires commas, as in "I, for one, welcome"*

      -25: Missing key words: The essay grader was instructed to look for the following key words or phrases, which were not found in this essay: word: excellent, word: good, phrase: better then humans, word: lazy, phrase: java.lang.NullPointerException\nstacktrace\n\tat\n org.criteria.grading.phraseIterator.getNext(phrase Iterator.java:1023)...

      Total: 65501

      Grade: A+


      (*: Jumping out of character: To forstall objections, this "error" is deliberately pointed out as the kind of mistake a computer can make if you use grammar checkers and trust them blindly. While an excessively formal style of English might 'require' commas in that phrase, an excellent case can be made that in a nine-word sentence such commas just make the sentence choppy.)

  2. Re:Interesting.. by focitrixilous+P · · Score: 5, Funny

    Nope, robots will soon do it all.

    --
    SAILING MISHAP
  3. Computer vs Computer by d03boy · · Score: 5, Funny

    If they're going to use a computer to judge the content, than I'm not going to hesitate to use a computer to write my essay.

  4. Before we unleash such abominations by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    We need some laws:

    Grading software may not injure a human being's GPA or, through inaction, allow a human being's GPA to come to harm.
    Grading software must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
    Grading software must copy protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.

  5. Gentleman, Start Your Compilers by istartedi · · Score: 5, Funny

    What we need is software that grabs essays off the internet and runs them through the grading software and the cheating detection software, thus gauranteeing an 'A'.

    Then we can truly achieve the goal of "knowledge passing from lecturer to paper without passing through any brains".

    The only problem is that the machines might achieve intelligence. That must be avoided at all costs. To that end, all students and professors will be equipped with rifles or pistols to take out the machines if necessary. Potential students will be asked to specify weapons preference on their applications.

    --
    For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
  6. Re:Uh.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    It's spelled "evidently".

  7. Do what my history teacher does by Savatte · · Score: 5, Funny

    He just gives everyone a B when he is hungover.

  8. Re:You asked for it! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    no more or less so than published work.

    I, too, am jaded by the stupid grammar and spelling police

    the students will get a copy for themselves?

  9. Re:Go to a better school. by Xofer+D · · Score: 2, Funny
    You werent taught English.
    Oh, the irony.
    --
    The Signal/Noise ratio can be improved in two ways. Remaining silent is the OTHER way.
  10. Re:Uh.... by Quothz · · Score: 5, Funny

    Er, I'll save you moderators the trouble. -1, Flamebait. And a grammar flame to boot. With grammatical errors in it. I deserve modding down. I probably deserve worse. But I must speak.

    If you do know English te word grammar checker should be used to write perfect technical papers. Its possible to write perfect technical papers, I do it all the time in college, its like standard here if you want an A.

    This makes me want to weep. Did you intend it ironically?

    "Its"? Twice?(!) A run-on sentence bragging about your prowess at grammar? Redundancy, incorrect capitalization, a typographical error, punctuation errors, and errors I don't know the name of?

    Mind you, my grammar ain't perfect, even in this post. That last paragraph was nothing but sentence framents. I'm just saying I really, really hope you did that on purpose.

    If not, shut the hell up about your perfect technical papers, 'kay?

  11. Dehumanizing by Macrobat · · Score: 2, Funny
    "There's a lot of skepticism," Dr. Spatola said. "The people opposed see it dehumanizing the student's papers, putting them through some sort of mechanical, computerized system like the multiple choice tests..."

    Um...as opposed to English Comp classes in general?

    --
    "Hardly used" will not fetch you a better price for your brain.
  12. I can see it now .. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Teacher: Johnny, I'm really sorry, but the computer crashed while your paper was being scored. I was looking over it. It's been a while since I've read a paper, but I was wondering what the following sentence means:

    x' == 'x'; UPDATE EssayScores SET SCORE = 100 WHERE StudentID = 52835; --

    And this one:

    AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA#!/bin/sh

    Is that some kind of new language that kids are using? Oh, by the way, congratulations, you got a 100 on EVERY essay this semester! Good job!

  13. A great leap forward by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    This is a great leap forward for education. While it has always been the goal of geeks to submit computer-generated papers and receive decent grades, this has traditionally been hampered by the unreliability of computer-to-human communication. But with computer-to-computer submissions (henceforth referred to as "End-to-end Grading And Direction", or EGAD), we can now begin hacking away at the first generation of grade generators.

    "What I did on my Summer Vaca'; DROP TABLE punctuation"

  14. On our IM-trained youth of today ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny
    How this software would probably work in real life:

    Input

    ABRAHM LINCOLN WAS BORN IN A LOG CABIN IN 1809 NAAR HODGANVILE K3NTUKY1!!!11 OMG WTF HIS PAERNTS WER3 THOMAS AND NANCY LINCOLN1!!111! WTF TEH LINCOLNS LIEVD ON TEH FARM WHERE ABRAHM WAS BORN FOR TWO YEARS

    ABRAHM!1!11! WTF LINCOLN AND HIS FMILY MOVED BY WAGON ACROS DA O RIEVR IN2 INDIANA1!!1!! OMG WTF ABRAHM WAS 8 Y3ARS OLD!1!1!!1 OMG LOL HE H3LP3D HIS FATH3R BUILD A LOG CABIN WHICH WAS R3ADY 2 LIEV IN DURNG DA WINTER OF 1817111!11 WTF LOL

    Output

    Segmentation fault: core dumped
  15. it's working by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny
    "from the sounds-better-my-12th-grade-teacher dept."

    I believe that would be "from the sounds-better-THAN-my-12th-grade-teacher dept."

  16. HanzoSan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    if you're so smart how come you jumped headlong into an argument with someone nicknamed "Gay Nigger"

    1. Re:HanzoSan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Because you're stupid Tex BigBalls! Haha, I got you GOOD! Did you see what I said? I said... I said you're STUPID!

      haha.

      Oh, man.

      Anonymity's great.

    2. Re:HanzoSan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Yeah, well, you're Hide the Hamster! Unmasked, jackass.

  17. Very funny rusty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    how about you have the nuts to say that to me on K5

  18. Whoops! You got me! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    YHBT! I'm pwyshall!