Slashdot Mirror


SCO Calls GPL Unenforceable, Void

wes33 writes "Groklaw has a link to SCO's replies to IBM's amended complaints. Some choice bits: '6th Affirmative Defense - The GPL is unenforceable, void and/or voidable, and IBM's claims based thereon, or related thereto, are barred. ... 7th Affirmative Defense - The GPL is selectively enforced by the Free Software Foundation such that enforcement of the GPL by IBM or others is waived, estopped or otherwise barred as a matter of equity. ... 8th Affirmative Defense - The GPL violates the U.S. Constitution, together with copyright, antitrust and export control laws, and IBM's claims based theron, or related thereto, are barred.' Comments are pouring in ... not all of them complimentary to SCO or its legal strategy." Considering that the GPL and the GNU project rely on and affirm the protections of copyright, this seems like a strange argument to pursue.

7 of 1,186 comments (clear)

  1. Obligatory by CSharpMinor · · Score: 5, Funny

    7th Affirmative Defense: The GPL is selectively enforced.

    8th Affirmative Defense: The GPL is Unconstitutional and invalid.

    9th Affirmative Defense: ???

    10th Affirmative Defense: Profit!

    --

    Whatever it is I'm complaining about, I'm sure the Republicans did it. This is /., after all.
  2. Proving freedom of speech by HeX86 · · Score: 5, Funny

    At least he proves that people can run around beeing flaming idiots, thus upholding the bill of rights.

  3. I agree! by Guppy06 · · Score: 5, Funny

    "The GPL violates the U.S. Constitution, together with copyright (laws),"

    Yes! I, too, feel that current copyright laws violate the U. S. Constitution! I'm glad somebody has finally come on-board with this, even if it is SCO. :)

  4. Re:EFF by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    "vis a vis the GPL"

    Considering the GPL is credited to GNU/Stallman, wouldn't that line therefore be transformed into:

    "emacss a emacss the GPL?"

  5. Re:Can you say, "Pump and Dump"? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Job Responsibilities:

    * Administrative needs of CFO and other executives

    Buys Crack.

    * Quarterly budget reports

    Balances crack budget.

    * Travel Arrangements

    What contries do not have extradition treaties with the US.

    * Organizing meetings and phone conferences

    Supervisor of SCO koolaid distribution.

    * Supply inventory

    Do not run out of crack.

    * General office responsibilities

    There is no code but SCO's, and Darl is our prophet.

    * Records minutes of various meetings

    Must be willing to break federal wiretap laws

    * Partner Program database coordination

    Who can we steal from today?

    * Answer investor questions regarding Stock performance

    Answers questions like: why are SCO execs selling all there stock?

    * Packaging of financial corporate communications with the investment community

    Bill, It's SCO, Send more money.

    * Helps prepare written investor communications and plan investor/analyst small-group private and large-group meetings

    Look at the monkey.

    * Handles telephone inquiries from analysts and investors

    Yes, We invented Linux.

    * Oversees scheduling and coverage of front desk

    Must qualify as expert with no less than 3 separate small arms, riot control experience preferred.

  6. Re:Can you say, "Pump and Dump"? by jbolden · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sco's case is factually untrue it doesn't require a great deal of legal understanding to address SCO's claims. If you knew that SCO was suing IBM in a wrongful death suit for Britany Spears:

    a) Britany ain't dead
    b) IBM didn't kill her
    c) SCO ain't intitled to collect even if a and b weren't the case

    You don't need to be a lawyer. There is no "worst case" because SCO has no case.

  7. Re:Here's what you were saying... by Ohreally_factor · · Score: 5, Funny

    Captialism: Man exploits his fellow man.

    Communism: The other way around.

    --
    It's not offtopic, dumbass. It's orthogonal.