Slashdot Mirror


Lindows Ordered To Stop Using Lindows Name

TheSpoom writes "InfoWorld reports that Lindows, a distribution of Linux and other software designed to emulate Windows, has been ordered to drop their name after Microsoft won a preliminary injunction yesterday from judges in Finland and Sweden."

18 of 922 comments (clear)

  1. The rest of the story: by shystershep · · Score: 5, Informative

    Here's another article at the Reg about this, and one at Newsforge about Lindows new website, ChoicePC for taking donations to help Lindows European resellers fight this.

    --
    The bigotry of the nonbeliever is for me nearly as funny as the bigotry of the believer. - Albert Einstein
  2. +5, Ironic by locknloll · · Score: 5, Interesting

    ...that it's just Finland, the cradle of Linux, where this happened...

    --
    -- Power corrupts, but PowerPoint corrupts absolutely.
  3. Doesn't stop them by Cyclopedian · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I'm not sure, but I think this doesn't stop Lindows from selling it in the United States. The market for Lindows is greater in the US than outside of it, so this isn't as if the sky is falling.

    Right?

    -Cyc

    1. Re:Doesn't stop them by Talthane · · Score: 5, Insightful

      You're looking at it the wrong way round. Which could Microsoft lose more from, being deprived of licences in Europe or deprived of licences in the US?

      Current population of the US = 270m-ish. Current population of Europe = 730m. And Europe has a relatively low rate of piracy.

      Factor in that the EU has shown (in the Windows Media Player case) that it's quite prepared to crack down hard on MS - in contrast to the US government - and it's no surprise that Microsoft is more concerned about European investments than American ones right now, and doing whatever it can to attack competitors' interests.

      No, the sky isn't falling, but if you think that events in Europe can't affect those in America and it can't possibly affect you what Microsoft does over here, I suggest you talk to those people who narrowly avoided having their businesses crushed by a massive trade war over steel tariffs the other week.

      Not to sound too nationalistic, but Europe is much bigger than the US - it's just more disorganised, and hamstrung by the French. ;-)

      --
      "This is why men never share their feelings; because women always remember." -Just Shoot Me.
  4. Wrong impression by dew-genen-ny · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Lindows as a name gives the wrong impression about where linux wants to be anyway.

    They should concentrate on marketing their product as a decent OS and not a cheap and inferior copy of windows.

    --
    tom-george.comBecause geeks rate higher t
  5. didnt know? by jeffy124 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    i read an article on this earlier (dont remember if it was the one linked)

    a spokesperson for Lindows says that the company was unaware of the suits filed by microsoft in Finland and Sweden. This means Lindows didnt have opportunity to defend themselves. IANAL, and certainly not one overseas, but who's job is it to inform a defendant of a lawsuit? The court? The plaintiff (MS in ths case)? or (remember this isnt the US) does MS simply have to make their argument for preliminary injunction without the judge being presented counter arguments?

    --
    The One Rule Of Chess You'll Ever Need: Don't play someone who carries a kit in their bookbag.
  6. Re:New names for Lindows... by Kardamon · · Score: 5, Funny

    What about "Gates"? They could have a slogan like "Why stare through the Windows if you can walk through the Gates..."

    --
    -- Qu'est-ce que la propriété intellectuelle? It is thought control.
  7. In Other News... by BigBlockMopar · · Score: 5, Funny

    In other news, Ford has recently demanded that Microsoft stop using the name "Explorer", as in Windows Explorer and Internet Explorer. Ford cites the 1990 introduction of the Explorer as evidence that they had the name first.

    The many reliability and safety problems with Windows Explorer and Internet Explorer cause confusion among Ford Explorer customers who are themselves accustomed to these traits, a Ford spokesman said Friday.

    --
    Fire and Meat. Yummy.
    1. Re:In Other News... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I don't agree with the decision but clearly you can see the difference between an Operating System and a car. It is a lot harder to tell the difference between one operating system and another especially when one is specifically designed to mimic the other. It is pretty obvious that Lindows intentionally named their product for just this sort of attention. It is not all that clever or catchy of a name by itself.

    2. Re:In Other News... by unclethursday · · Score: 5, Informative
      It is pretty obvious that Lindows intentionally named their product for just this sort of attention.

      You may be right, but Lindows is using a tactic in their US court case that may work. May.

      They're saying that "Windows" is a generic computing term, especially in GUIs (which it is). You are not supposed to be allowed to trademark generic terms.

      If that part works, then Microsoft will lose their trademark on "Windows" by itself. They could still have thier trademark on the phrase "Microsoft Windows", but they would no longer be allowed to have the word "Windows" itself trademarked, like it is now.

      They're also going after the fact that Microsoft has failed to try and protect their trademark in the past, and that the only reason they are doing so now is because the Lindows.com "LindowsOS" is a competitor. (Trademark laws state you can and will lose your trademark if it is not actively defended.)

      So far, it seems US courts seem to be agreeing with Lindows.com on the issue.

    3. Re:In Other News... by LamerX · · Score: 5, Funny

      Be vewy vewy qwiet. I'm pwogwamming Winux. Eheheheheh.

  8. But is Lindows on sale in Sweden? by pesc · · Score: 5, Informative

    I live in Sweden, and I'm not aware that Lindows is available for sale here. I don't think the general public (outside of Slashdot) knows anything about it. So if they would like to market it here, just give it a new name first. No big deal.

    And seriously, I kind of agree with the judges. "Lindows" is a bit too close to "Windows". They should try to build their own name by themselves.

    --

    )9TSS
  9. Re:Copyright/Trademark Extension? by jsav40 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sheesh.... Before you know it someone will patent point & click online shopping.... ;)

  10. Quite Correct by racer7890 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This ruling is quite correct. I am no Microsoft fan but the Lindows name was clearly intended to play off the Windows name. It is my theory that Lindows purposefully chose this name to get the publicity it is getting now. Other attacks at Microsoft (such as the Lindows offer for Californian residents based on the anti-trust settlement) play into this.

  11. Re:New names for Lindows... by Tooxs · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Shades" We've got your Windows covered.

  12. Re:i sorta agree by ScottSpeaks! · · Score: 5, Funny
    lindows did sound a bit dumb. i propose Winux, sounds better and conveys the same idea.

    Thewe's one pwobwem howevew, and that's that "Winux" sounds wike its the opewating system that Ewmew Fudd's hackew bwothew uses.

  13. Longhorn by big-giant-head · · Score: 5, Funny

    In another court action today, the US District Court in Austin handed down an injunction against MS for using the code name longhorn, requested by the University of Texas. The school nickname is the longhorns and the schools mascot is a drugged neutered bull named Bevo, who wanders aimlessly about and craps all day.

    UT Students were getting confused since both MS longhorn and Bevo's BM are both Stinking piles of crap. Further more UT football players, trained to lay down and play dead at the site of BEVO (witness the Arkansas and OU games) were now getting confused and doing the same thing in their computer lab. This has resulted in half the team being ineligilble for the Poulan-weedeater-holiday-trailmix bowl.

    UT coach Mack "Roscoe P. Coltrane" brown had the following statement:

    "IIII Know ol Bill Gates really did'nt mean any harm to us, but since the wind kept shifting directions the players were confused which crap there were smelling longhorn crap, Bevo crap or my crap". "I really thought we could keep them focused on thier school work, as soon as that Windows Start up screen came on, there they went, locked up, feel straight over, with that same glassy eyed look they get in the cotton bowl every year."

    --

    So Long and Thanks for all the Fish.
  14. Drop the name? That's not all! by bfg9000 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Lindows was also ordered to stop crashing so bloody much, as that is obviously another attempt to copy the winning Microsoft formula.

    Said a Microsoft spokesman, "Stealing our good name is one thing, but stealing our functionality is clearly another. Our regular crashes are part of the "Microsoft Advantage"(TM), and our astronomically flukey market share is evidence enough that the people want lots of crashes, and we aim to deliver. We give the people what they want. If Lindows starts copying our patented "Crash-n-Burn Technology(TM)", we are liable to lose marketshare, and that is completely unacceptable and is punishable by immediate and lethal MS military action. We WILL defend ourselves against encroachments on our instability monopoly. Word. Oh, yeah, if those Apple guys are listening, I hear they had a security hole or two last week. Better watch it Steve, I don't remember you licensing insecurity from us...."

    Apple quickly backed off by patching their security holes as ordered by Microsoft, in what was an obvious attempt to pacify Microsoft's legal department and rectify what Apple still claims was an "accident".

    --

    I'm not normally an irrational zealous dickhead, but I figure "When in Rome..."