Slashdot Mirror


What You Can't Say

dtolton writes "Paul Graham has an excellent article posted on the subject of things you can't say. His article explores what ideas are generally considered heresy, and whether or not those ideas might be true nonetheless. He also presents advice for handling heretical ideas. Considering that many of the ideas in technology in general and Open Source specifically are near heresy, it's well worth a read."

10 of 1,999 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Best examples of heresy I can think of by MBCook · · Score: 1, Flamebait
    YES, feminism has ruined our country. If you'd like to see the evidence of things like feminism and political correctness gone wrong, read "The New Thought Police" by Tammy Bruce. If you want to know how feminist ideals have been used to cause serious damage to generations of boys, read "The Way Against Boys" by Christina Hoff Sommers, it's facinating and at the same time quite disturbing.

    As for other things you can't say, here are some that I'm going to say...

    • Blacks are more racist than whites - There are blacks who make their living doing nothing but turning everything into a race issue (Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, etc)
    • Homosexuality IS NOT NORMAL - That's why the work "queer" was used to describe it, becuase it's not normal. I'm not saying that I hate homosexuals or anything (that's not true). Just that it's not normal. Which leads us to...
    • Kids are best parrented by a mom and a dad - Not two moms, not two dads, not one of either, not a daycare, not a nanny, A MOM AND A DAD.
    • "Tolerace" means tolerate - It does NOT mean that I must accept your weird way of thinking as correct, it just means I will put up with you.
    • Prayer is schools is harmless - We had it for years and years, but now because we must "tolerate" one or two crackpot parents, we can't do this, despite the good it does.
    • The Democratic party hates Blacks - Despite what they say, they don't like Blacks. They are nothing more than a group they can ask for votes from. The first "Black President" had very few Black people around him and appointed very few minorities, but Bush has appointed tons. Dems are always saying they'll "look out for Blacks", but after 50 years, what's changed for them?
    • Black is not a racial slurr - African-american is offensive to me, because you think that you're BLACK first, then American when you say that. It should be the other way around, as with everything. I can understand things like the N* word, but this is rediciulous. Read "The New Throught Police".

    I'm sure I could think a TONS more if I had the time. There are many things that you just can't say (despite the fact that they are true).

    --
    Comment forecast: Bits of genius surrounded by a sea of mediocrity.
  2. G. W. Bush should be tried for his war crimes... by TheMidget · · Score: 0, Flamebait
    ... and executed if found guilty, just like Hitler's henchmen.

    (Note: Hitler himself had a least the good sense to commit suicide. And he was a better orator than Bush too!)

  3. Re:Best examples of heresy I can think of by corebreech · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Got a link to the Washington Post story?

    See this post for links.

    Also, arguing that only one Israeli died indicates that Israel warned "its citizens" (and, therefore had a hand in the attack) is pretty ridiculous.

    No it's not. Consider how many Israelis normally work in those building... estimates I've seen put the number north of a thousand.

    The fact that 5 Israeli's were reportedly seen 'high fiving' also indicates nothing.

    I disagree. Apparently you aren't well versed in this story, because the owner of the moving company they worked for fled to Israel very shortly after this incident.

    You're grounds are, so far, that the Washington Post (supposedly) claimed an Israeli company was warned in advance of the attacks.

    You should read the news more.

    Evidence that Al-Qaeda were involved includes Osama Bin Laden saying that they did, as well as more evidence (trail of funds, trailing the hijackers, etc).

    Excuse me, but this is pure shit. Are you referring to the video tape of bin Laden admitting to 9/11? Nobody will even host that video anymore, it is so obviously a fake! The trail of funds likewise is not conclusive at all, as FBI Director Mueller himself admits, there is no evidence implicating the 19 hijackers in 9/11... indeed, many of these hijackers have been found alive.

    Forgive me while I still consider your post flamebait.

    I'm not really interested in what a retard like you has to say, I mean, c'mon, this is the first you've heard of this? Please.

  4. Re:The Manufacturing of Consent by mesocyclone · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Chomsky... the man who thinks outside the box so much that he is utterly predictable.

    His theories are simply well written applications of Marxism, mixed with a lot of hate-America sentiments.

    I don't know why anyone takes him seriously, given how wrong he has been about so many things.

    But then, a lot of people thought communism was great too, until they saw what it really did, at which point they either shut up or said something lame like "nobody ever did it right."

    --

    The only good weather is bad weather.

  5. Re:A quick list by ifwm · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    You should have killed her. Then it's only one side, and with your ass all beat up (maybe do youself a little more damage first) the cops only have you to believe. Make up a plausable story, and as they say, dead men (and women) tell no tales.

  6. Re:Best examples of heresy I can think of by Uma+Thurman · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    That position on the drugs is just about the best thinking of the 14th century that I have ever heard. Thanks, you jerk, for being part of the problem. Sort of like your buddy Rush.

    --
    This is America, damnit. Speak Spanish!
  7. Re:Best examples of heresy I can think of by creidieki · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    > Kids are best parrented by a mom and a dad - Not two moms, not two dads, not one of either, not a daycare, not a nanny, A MOM AND A DAD.

    Actually, the only conclusive studies we have say that children do better with two parent monogamous heterosexual parents than with single heterosexual parents.

    A lot of people conclude from this that "traditional" family structures are inherently better than "nontraditional" family structures. I don't know whether that's true, but it's not yet supported by the research. I don't know of any conclusive research on monogamous married heterosexual parents versus monogamous married homosexual parents.

  8. 2000 *was* rigged by JimmytheGeek · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Thousands of eligible voters purged, thousands of valid votes not counted, hundreds of invalid Bush votes counted, hundreds or thousands of invalid Republican absentee ballots.

    None of it is a surprise when the Bush state campaign chair is, essentially, the election referee. The Florida election was stolen.

  9. Re:Best examples of heresy I can think of by Uma+Thurman · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Don't pay attention to this man. He wants to make you comfortable around him. You'll invite him over, he'll get comfortable. He'll pretend to be your friend, and might even let on that he has some modern ideas about drug use.

    And then, you'll offer him a joint, which he'll accept. Then, he'll pretend to go to the bathroom, but he'll really call the police on you, then leave you to your fate. And, he'll say that you deserved it too.

    This is the hypocrisy of the right wing.

    --
    This is America, damnit. Speak Spanish!
  10. Re:I'm not uncomfortable with speaking my mind by Uma+Thurman · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Are you all out of your own ideas? Conservatives always need someone to tell them what to think. All the oxycontin in the world won't give you an original thought.

    --
    This is America, damnit. Speak Spanish!