Slashdot Mirror


Wireless Keyboard w/o a Wireless Mouse?

Pampusik asks: "I'm looking for a decent wireless keyboard, but do not need a wireless mouse. Unfortunately, it seems it is nearly impossible to buy a wireless keyboard without having a mouse bundled with it. The only wireless, mouse-less keyboard I've been able to find is an option from Logitech. It is, however, not an impressive keyboard. Are there other options available?"

61 comments

  1. Solution by Acidic_Diarrhea · · Score: 3, Funny
    Here's an option, buy the keyboard and mouse package. Then, superglue a piece of string to the top of the mouse and run that string to the back of the computer and tie it onto something back there. Voila, you've got a wireless keyboard and a wired mouse - just like you wanted!

    It should be clear that no one else needs to post in this article.

    --
    I hate liberals. If you are a liberal, do not reply.
    1. Re:Solution by 0x0d0a · · Score: 3, Informative

      Note that this is not quite as silly as one might think.

      I had a friend that stopped using a wireless mouse because it kept getting lost under piles of stuff.

      With a wired mouse, you always have a cord to follow.

      I, personally, can't figure out the fetish with wirelessness. If you're using a computer monitor, the size is pretty much such that you must be at your desk. If you want to control music or movies, an IR remote is a much better choice -- more comfortable to hold, can be used without a desk, cheap, and the batteries last until kingdom come.

      The only possibly justifiable thing I can think of might be that a wireless mouse doesn't have a cord moving around and knocking things over. A keyboard doesn't really move too much. I found it *particularly* irritating to find a *wired* optical trackball that I liked (eventually went with the MacAlly QBALL). Who would want a wireless *trackball*? You don't move the thing, and there's just no way for the cord to whack things.

      If you *do* go wireless, you introduce all manner of irritations:

      * Security. Obvious. Probably not a huge issue for most, given that attacking your device means physically planting a monitoring device quite nearby. (Perhaps cracking into another nearby computer using a RF or IR sensor might work, but it would still take some doing).

      * Batteries. This is a big deal in my mind. Batteries add weight. They mean that voltage starts dropping off, and devices get less reliable. You have to change the durn little things, and if you come back home and discover that your batteries are dead, you're in for some charging/replacing before you can do anything.

      * Reliability. Logitech's pre-Bluetooth mice "block" each other when used in the same range. Other RF crap going on can muck with your signal.

      * Performance. I remember folks complaining about performance degredation -- not sure whether it was due to latency increases or sampling rate decreases.

    2. Re:Solution by Dun+Malg · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Who would want a wireless *trackball*? You don't move the thing, and there's just no way for the cord to whack things.

      I have my trackball mouse mounted to the arm of my chair. Wireless means I don't have to worry about tripping over the cord. My case is unusual though.

      --
      If a job's not worth doing, it's not worth doing right.
    3. Re:Solution by jovlinger · · Score: 1

      I have the Logitex wireless keyboard and trackball FX (the big marble), and would gladly have paid twice what I gave for them.

      None of the issues you mention are issues. Range isn't great (6ish feet), so anyone eavesdropping is pretty damn good, batteries last pretty much forever (several months, at least), utterly reliable, and while there is some performance loss towards the end of the battery lifetime, with modern batteries, that's when they're completely dead anyway.

      In return, I can easily clear my desk when I need writing space, move the keyboard to a different table and type standing up when I'm walking around, and generally not have any cables snaking from behind the computer.

      milage will vary, but I HIGHLY recommend going wireless.

  2. my suggestion: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    suck it up and deal with it. it's not worth your time to search for the perfect keyboard-only kit, when a combo-kit may is only few bucks more.

  3. Apple Bluetooth Keyboard by jcbphi · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Apple's wireless (bluetooth) keyboard. No mouse included.

    http://store.apple.com/1-800-MY-APPLE/WebObjects /A ppleStore.woa/70702/wo/ul2nAMdvPhM028BKE761R4igMn9 /1.3.0.5.10

    1. Re:Apple Bluetooth Keyboard by Hes+Nikke · · Score: 1

      that URL will soon expire (stupid sessions)

      try this instead:

      http://store.apple.com/1-800-MY-APPLE/WebObjects/A ppleStore?productLearnMore=M9270LL/A

      --
      Don't call me back. Give me a call back. Bye. So yeah. But bye our, well, but alright we are on a shirt this chill.
  4. ergonomic by Hes+Nikke · · Score: 1

    i've run into a similar problem... i want a good ergonomic keyboard, but could care less about wireless, or bundled mouses. alas, i'm stuck with both wireless and a mouse if i want a _conformable_ keyboard :(

    --
    Don't call me back. Give me a call back. Bye. So yeah. But bye our, well, but alright we are on a shirt this chill.
  5. More detail, plz by Txiasaeia · · Score: 2, Informative

    What are you going to use the keyboard for? D'ya want a full keyboard or is a compact okay? What's your price range? What specifically do you need in addition to the normal ~104 keys (volume control, navigation, scroll function, etc.)? The keyboard you linked to is actually a great product - it's cheap, has good tactile feedback and gets the job done.

    --
    Condemnant quod non intellegunt.
    1. Re:More detail, plz by Pampusik · · Score: 1
      Yah, yah... I should've been more clear and less succinct!

      I'm searching for a full-sized (104-ish keys) alternative to my laptop's miniature keyboard for when I have it docked at home. I write a ton and need something that feels like a real keyboard should and won't fall apart too easily. It will be abused.

    2. Re:More detail, plz by Txiasaeia · · Score: 1
      So if it's docked at home, why do you need a cordless? I can understand if you've got your laptop hooked up to a digital TV and you want to type on your bigscreen from your couch, but if you're doing serious typing then a corded keyboard should do the trick. While I'm on the subject, if you *are* trying to use a cordless from your couch, be aware that the max range on some models isn't over a metre or so.

      Cordless keyboards/mice are nifty and convenient (I've got an MX700 logitech), but when they don't work (no batteries, periphrial too far away from receiver etc.) they're a bitch. I couldn't imagine a keyboard that skipped letters when I was typing simply because it doesn't have enough battery power or it was too far from the base station or whatver. Hope this helps!

      --
      Condemnant quod non intellegunt.
  6. Had this setup once by baldass_newbie · · Score: 2, Funny

    IBM PCjr. Infrared keyboard and no mouse.
    Of course, it didn't have a hard drive either.

    --
    The opposite of progress is congress
  7. An easy Google search answers this by dstone · · Score: 4, Informative

    it seems it is nearly impossible to buy a wireless keyboard without having a mouse bundled with it

    The person asking the question (and the editor who accepted it) are not trying very hard. "wireless keyboard" -mouse

    1. Re:An easy Google search answers this by I+Be+Hatin' · · Score: 0, Redundant
      The person asking the question (and the editor who accepted it) are not trying very hard.

      You must be new here... Cliff hasn't been trying hard for the last couple months. Just do what I did: add him to your foes list.

      --
      I know god exists. I read it on the internet, so it must be true.
    2. Re:An easy Google search answers this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      also, cliff is a founding member of the gnaa... so he's usually busy with other duties.

    3. Re:An easy Google search answers this by Kris_J · · Score: 1

      Yeah, and what's wrong with the Logitech offering?

  8. umm ... obvious solution? by ophix · · Score: 1

    there is nothing that says you have to use the mouse...

    i bought a microsoft wireless natural keyboard + mouse combo. i am not 100% certain where the mouse is because i never use it. oddly i use a wireless keyboard and cabled mouse.. go figure.

    1. Re:umm ... obvious solution? by edalytical · · Score: 1
      oddly i use a wireless keyboard and cabled mouse

      That's the strangest thing I've ever heard. Well not really. Unless your typing from across the room I see no need for it. Unlike mice, keyboard just stay put. The only benefit a wireless mouse has is it unconstrained freedom to move around my desktop. I don't think my keyboard has moved since I plugged it in. How does the wireless keyboard benefit you?

      --
      Win a signed Stephen Carpenter ESP Guitar from the Deftones: http://def-tag.com/?r=0008781
    2. Re:umm ... obvious solution? by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      that's how I have it too, corded mouse on desktop, when I'm using the computer from the bed I'll use the wireless mouse as well.

      I used to have the corded keyboard in the computer too that I used while sitting at the desk, but switched that to the other computer(usb makes it really easy to have multiple keyboards and mouses hooked up to one computer).

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    3. Re:umm ... obvious solution? by adamjaskie · · Score: 1

      Well, I could see where a wireless keyboard could benefit you. You could use it while sitting on the couch/bed/whatever. However, that is a bit harder with a wireless mouse, due to the requirement of a flat surface for it. A keyboard you can use in your lap. However, what WOULD be nice, is a wireless keyboard with a built-in trackpad or (preferably) trackball.

      --
      /usr/games/fortune
    4. Re:umm ... obvious solution? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do you really use your mouse that often? I use keyboard shortcuts whenever I get the chance, and when I'm slacking off across the room, in bed writing some code, changing the music, or surfing the web, I use my keyboard (not wireless, but with a crazy long cord).

    5. Re:umm ... obvious solution? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      here is a keyboard that has a built-in track point. The link is to a gateway branded unit, but I have an identical one (except all black) that I got years ago (at best buy, I think) The one I got was branded as "air board" Its IR not RF so it needs line of sight but it did seem to work from a fair distance (10+ feet) The track point was a little too sensitive for my tastes but I got used to it

  9. Why Wireless? by Starla1979 · · Score: 1

    Just curious why you would want a wireless keyboard but no wireless mouse since it actually moves and the wire actually gets in the way.

  10. just don't use the mouse. by gl4ss · · Score: 1

    really.

    the mouse doesn't really cost that much extra(for you), do you really think that they would sell the things for much cheaper than what they're selling right now even if they didn't have a bundled in mouse? that's just not how low-end combo pc hardware pricing goes.

    even in Finland you can get a combo for just 38 euros, with some normal cord keyboards costing more than that(I bought one with optical mouse, rf type, for around 50e in december, I don't 'really' need the mouse but it's handy to have anyways).

    or if you absolutely don't want to buy a mouse buy just the keyboard from me with 50% price and i'll give you only the keyboard.

    also you could consider some of the pc remote controllers if you just need to press some combo of buttons every now and then.

    --
    world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    1. Re:just don't use the mouse. by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      what I meant of course was 150% price.

      and what the froogle link from another commenter will tell you is that just keyboards tend to cost a good deal more than combos.

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    2. Re:just don't use the mouse. by Alizarin+Erythrosin · · Score: 1

      Quite right. I bought a Logitech wireless kit (the black one with the play/stop/volume/etc buttons on it) and I still use my Intellimouse Optical rather then the optical wireless mouse that came with it (and eats batteries like ). Aside from a useless mouse sitting in my closet, no complaints from me. The on-keyboard controls work with Winamp, and that's pretty much all I ask.

      --
      There are only 10 kinds of people in this world... those who understand binary and those who don't
  11. Easy solution by i.r.id10t · · Score: 1

    Buy the combo, sell the rat on ebay.

    That is of course assuming it isn't permamently attached to the kbd, and both are capable of operating without the other or parts thereof.

    --
    Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos
    1. Re:Easy solution by tigersha · · Score: 1

      They always use the same transmitter!

      --
      The dangers of excessive individualism are nothing compared to the oppressiveness of excessive collectivism
    2. Re:Easy solution by Chess_the_cat · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Huh? So what? Unless the transmitter for the keyboard is in the mouse why can't he dump the mouse? If you're thinking no one will buy it on ebay because it doesn't come with a transmitter then you don't really understand ebay. If a dude will buy a ghost in a jar or a can of used shaving cream why wouldn't someone buy a transmitterless mouse?

      --
      Support the First Amendment. Read at -1
  12. Best and Worst by Michael.Forman · · Score: 3, Informative


    I must warn you not to purchase the IBM Wireless Navigator Pro Keyboard (SK-8810) . Although it has a great layout and an integrated mouse, it has usable range of about a meter. Beyond that it starts dropping letters. Nt vry usefl for typng meangfl contnt and evn wrse for the cmmand lne.

    If you are fortunate enough to have invested in Apple hardware, I cannot recommend enough the new Apple Bluetooth keyboard and mouse. They're flawless.

    Michael.

    --
    Linux : Mac :: VW : Mercedes
    1. Re:Best and Worst by toast0 · · Score: 1

      looks like it's just doing compression... it's only dropping vowels, and you don't need those :)

  13. Just buy the combo... by phillymjs · · Score: 1

    ...and toss the mouse in a drawer. That's what I did.

    Picked up the OEM edition of the Microsoft Wireless Optical Desktop from newegg.com for a little over $50. I use a corded Logitech mouse.

    I stuck the Microsoft mouse in the drawer within arm's length of my desk, so when my right-handed friends are visiting and want to check their e-mail, they don't have to suffer the mental anguish of mousing with their left hand. They just grab the wireless out of the drawer, use it, and toss it back in when done.

    I liked the MS keyboard so much, I bought a second one for use at work, where the keyboard and mouse cords were always getting in the way of something-- and there, I do use the MS mouse.

    ~Philly

  14. What about Safety by seigniory · · Score: 1

    I remember reading that wireless keyboards were very prone to sniffing and that it was trivially easy for most wannabe haxz0rz to grab your keystrokes passively.

    Is there any proof behind this and/or does anyone have experience trying to do this? How easy/hard was it?

    1. Re:What about Safety by austad · · Score: 1

      The apple wireless keyboard uses encryption to prevent this sort of thing. For $69, it's one of the nicest keyboards you can get. I love mine.

      It's not ergonomic though, which kinda sucks if that's what you're looking for.

      --
      Need Free Juniper/NetScreen Support? JuniperForum
    2. Re:What about Safety by gl4ss · · Score: 2, Informative

      afaik all logitechs newer keyboards at least support some advanced cryptography or another.

      at least they come with a funky app which you can use to turn it on(involves writing some stuff on the keyboard the program says, pressing buttons). the very least thing you have to do is to pair the receiver to the keyboard(by pressing a button simultaneously on device and the receiver, dunno if this includes crypt of any kind).

      most older keybs used to be IR so that solved it naturally right there.

      if you're skeptic just keep the corded keyboard hooked up and use that while at the desk, and the wireless one when watching movies from tv or whatever reason you find the wireless keyboard necessary for.

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    3. Re:What about Safety by iantri · · Score: 2
      Unless the wannabe haxz0rz are hiding under your desk, I don't think it will be a problem.

      But just give the space under your desk a little kick to make sure. If you hear an "Oof!", there may be a security breach.

      ;)

    4. Re:What about Safety by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My cheap portable phone works from my balcony, not to mention every room in my apartment. Unless you buy a house out by the hicks, you shouldn't bet on all your neighbors being out of range.

  15. Solidtek ACK-580 by FreeForm+Response · · Score: 1

    This keyboard is IR wireless, small enough to set comfortably on your lap, and even includes a rocker-thumb-mouse thing. I use mine all the time to control my NES computer.
    Caveats are the PS/2 connection and some teensy keys (Control, Alt). Other than that, though, I highly recommend it.

    They go for about $30; I selected the store featured in the link above at random from a Google search for "Solidtek ACK-580".

    1. Re:Solidtek ACK-580 by yomegaman · · Score: 1

      I have one like that, a Motorola SK-7100. The cool thing about IR keyboards over radio ones is that my Sony RM-VL900 remote can learn the keystrokes, so I can use it to control the PC too.

      --
      ...wearing a skin-tight topless leather jumpsuit, with cutaway buttocks and transparent crotch panel.
  16. MacAlly / PCAlly makes really good stuff by CokeBear · · Score: 1

    Check out the wireless keyboards (and mouses sold separately) by MacAlly and their partners in crime PCAlly. Both make high quality peripherals.

    --
    Reality has a liberal bias
  17. Can you give me just 4 nuggets? by sig · · Score: 1

    Take the 6 nuggets and throw 2 of them away. I'm jus t wanting the 4 nugget thing.

    I'm trying to watch my calorie intake.

    1. Re:Can you give me just 4 nuggets? by smart.id · · Score: 1

      Take two of the nuggets, and shove them up your ass! I'm watching my figure.

      --
      blog & fiction: jd87
  18. Buy with a friend by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Buy a package with a friend who wants only the mouse.

    1. Re:Buy with a friend by tigersha · · Score: 1

      they share the receiver!

      --
      The dangers of excessive individualism are nothing compared to the oppressiveness of excessive collectivism
  19. IR no solution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    most older keybs used to be IR so that solved it naturally right there.

    IR is a spread signal. Put an IR-sensitive video cam in a room with such a keyboard and you'll see the problem is not 'solved naturally'. An IR sniffing receiver can be made nearly invisible and placed well behind or slightly to the side of the targeted (user-aware) receiver. Alternatively, IR light reflects off many surfaces just like visible light. A sensitive sniffing receiver could be placed in many other places in the room, taking a weakly reflected signal off walls, windows, mirrors, etc.

    1. Re:IR no solution by kinema · · Score: 1

      Put an IR-sensitive video cam in a room with such a keyboard

      Actaully a video camera wouldn't work for this. A video camera is only capable of ~30 frames per second and the baud rate of just about any IR keyboard (maybe even the one with my old IBM PC Jr) is going to be higher then that. IIRC according to some theroms on sampling you would actually need a sample rate quite a bit higher (assuming that you can't sync the sample rate with the baud rate) then the rate at which the keyboard emits it's signals.

    2. Re:IR no solution by gl4ss · · Score: 2, Insightful

      if you have access to the room, YOU'RE PRETTY MUCH SCREWED ALREADY.

      thinkgeek for example sells these nifty little devices that go between the computer and the keyboard and record the keypresses.. not to mention if you can put a camera in the same room(or a ir sensor, just a camera wouldn't have enough fps to cope with the signal)

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
  20. Mice w/o keyboards by k4_pacific · · Score: 1

    I've seen wireless Mice for sale without the keyboards. Just write to the company that sells the these wireless mice and see if they'll send you a keyboard for the cost of shipping. After all, they probably just throw them away otherwise.

    Karma: desrever

    --
    Unknown host pong.
  21. Go Wireless Where Possible by miyako · · Score: 1

    I've noticed that no matter how organized you attempt to be, the sheer number of wires can be one of the biggest problems to deal with. I've found that wireless solutions can make things much neater and more managble.
    Just going wireless on the keyboard/mouse and network can save quite a bit of wiring mess.
    The twist tie option can work, but in my experience this tends to work well behind the tv (console cords, dvd player, stero etc), but no so well with computer wires, as the wires tend to be of various sizes and don't need the same length, and ineveitably things just dont fit right.
    Cabling snakes do not seem like a very good solution for home use, but YMMV.
    Another handy trick to keeping wires from looking clutterd is to run them up against the trim snugged down into or against the carpet (this depends of course on the type of carpet and if you have trim), and works well for phone cords/cable etc.
    A proper desk can also help with cabling, if you can get things situated correctly you can often run wires down behind the desk into the back of the computer and the wires stay hidden unless you are looking for them.
    Another thing to consider is the color of the cables, while often times you don't have a choice, a homogenusly colored cable group tends to look better than a mix of various colors.
    Another thing to remember is that no matter what, cables are ugly, and they are also a requrirement, and there is only so much you can do, but you can minimize their impact by blending them into the envorionment (running them along the floor by the trim, using a single color that matches your computer case and/or the theme of the room) where possible, and hiding them behind things where not.

    --
    Famous Last Words: "hmm...wikipedia says it's edible"
  22. Security by kinema · · Score: 1

    This is kind of off topic but I was currious if any of the wireless keyboards out there are even slightly secure. I haven't read the Bluetooth spec, does it include any sort of encryption (even if it does I'm not sure that I would feel comfortable trusting a vendor to properly implement it).

    1. Re:Security by rainman_bc · · Score: 1

      Hmmm... That's a strange question. Is it any more secure than someone standing over your shoulder watching you type? The Bluetooth spec has a small, limited range. Someone / some device would have to be placed within a few feet of your work area. I mean, shoot, put a wireless webcam up and get the monitor as well... Really, why go to the trouble to place a bluetooth sniffer in place when you can set up a wireless webcam instead?

      --
      09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
  23. Wireless Mouse Refund Day? by Endive4Ever · · Score: 1

    Maybe we need to hold a 'Wireless Mouse Refund Day' rally, and DEMAND that the vendors not force us to buy an un-needed mouse when we just want a keyboard. Demand a refund for the un-needed mouse. Stand up for your rights.

    Should we get the DOJ involved?

    --
    ---
  24. Apple's bluetooth keyboard by obi · · Score: 1

    think it's only $79.

    And lot's of people seem very happy with it.

  25. Clutter. by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 1

    2 cables less in your desk are two cables less.

    And now there are some options in which you connect a little key, similar to memory sticks, to your USB port that communicates with your kb and/or mouse, no cables anymore.

    When you have a printer, scanner, mouse, keyboard, phone, organizer, camera and who knows what else, the less cables the better.

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
  26. Rotten cherry prize to the silliest question ever. by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 1

    Buy the combo with your favourite keyboard and do not use the rodent.

    How difficult is that?

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
  27. Wireless Keyboard by r1csm1th · · Score: 1

    There are several available at a decent price at www.ebuyer.com They range from GBP5.99 - GBP60 + VAT & P&P
    Richard
    www.sccc.biz

  28. Sakar/Yahoo wireless keyboard by UNIX_Meister · · Score: 1

    I have one of these and like it pretty well. It doesn't have a separate mouse, but has a mouse-like controller on it, but can be ignored. It doesn't require line of sight, and has a nice range. I bought it for use in a media station type application. My one reservation is the hackability of the unit - security is supposedly an issue (listening in on your typing).