Slashdot Mirror


Own a Piece of An Apple-Based Supercomputer

Graff writes "Now that Apple has come out with the Xserve G5, Virginia Tech has been swapping out parts of their 'System X' supercomputer for the more compact 1U Xserves. MacMall is selling some of those System X component G5 systems with an approximate $200 savings and an extra 512 megs of RAM over a normal G5. You can read more about it at MacCentral."

12 of 296 comments (clear)

  1. Some of us *should* be bitter about this... by Bones3D_mac · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Only 6 months of use out of these things and VT is tossing them out like yesterday's trash. Gee, thanks for doing this after delaying my order for 6 weeks back when the G5s were originally supposed to be shipping to the rest of us. Apparently you didn't need them that badly after all.

    --


    8==8 Bones 8==8
    1. Re:Some of us *should* be bitter about this... by Emil+Brink · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Hardware that has seen use for six months in a super-computer, i.e. probably been run 24/7 and really stressed, sold for $200 below the price of new is considered to be priced as "trash"? Your trash must be worth its weight in gold, then. I think it sounds expensive, but then it's Apple hardware so I shouldn't be surprised. ;^)

      --
      main(O){10<putchar(4^--O?77-(15&5128 >>4*O):10)&&main(2+O);}
    2. Re:Some of us *should* be bitter about this... by Bones3D_mac · · Score: 5, Insightful

      VT isn't the one selling these systems... Apple is. VT is tossing them back at Apple for shiny new Xserves. Apparently being the 3rd fastest computer in the world isn't good enough anymore.

      --


      8==8 Bones 8==8
    3. Re:Some of us *should* be bitter about this... by assemblyline · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Virginia Tech wanted Xserves in the first place. Apple didn't reveal them until January. Look at the benefits. Smaller case, less heat generated, less power consumed, error corecting code memory; all things which would be extemely useful in a supercomputer like this. From what I have read, the upgrade will use 25% less power and take up a third less space. If I were Tech, I would throw the current G5s back too.

  2. So, why did the sale happen so early? by Coutal · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Why couldn't VT hold their horses?
    my bet is... they could.
    no one likes building any cluster (not to mention a supercomputer) out of desktops, esp. ones configured like desktops (gfx, no ecc, ...)
    but apple really wanted the PR of having the computer cluster, and perhaps to list the revenue in 4Q2003.
    so i can't blame them - looks like a fair deal.

    1. Re:So, why did the sale happen so early? by LennyDotCom · · Score: 3, Insightful

      apple really wanted the PR of having the computer cluster

      No VT needed the PR probably more then Apple now they get grant money out the wazoo

      --
      http://Lenny.com
    2. Re:So, why did the sale happen so early? by despik · · Score: 4, Insightful

      but apple really wanted the PR of having the computer cluster, and perhaps to list the revenue in 4Q2003. so i can't blame them - looks like a fair deal.

      You fool. Apple wanted the PR, so they forced the G5s down VT's collective throat. Yeah, right.

      Why couldn't VT hold their horses?

      Because they had a deadline to meet if they wanted to make that Top CPUs list.

      --
      "I seem to have mastered a certain amount of control over physical reality."
  3. Re:an extra 512 megs??? by philbert26 · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Why oh why do companies use mail in rebates?

    So they can make money when people forget to send the form on time, or fill it in incorrectly.

    Several companies in the UK do the same for extended warranties. They say "pay lots of money and if your machine doesn't break, we'll refund it after five years". You typically get 30 days after the five years to get your money back, and most people will just forget.

  4. Re:Seems like no discount by gunnk · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Maybe some folks buy Apples without the educational discount because they aren't eligible for it and figure taking a couple of hundred dollars in discounts for which they don't qualify would be stealing.

    Honesty/Intregrity can mean paying list price sometimes.

    --
    Life is short: void the warranty.
  5. Re:Ironically... by gunnk · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Probably the only actual record the big mac can claim is the shortest time to obsolescence. Not to downplay the achievement though...

    Well, it's the fastest supercomputer ever built with off-the-shelf components and the number three fastest machine on the planet -- and that's before the upgrade.

    They will probably make quite a decent profit out of this, despite the $200 discount. They must have got pretty decent discount from apple for both bulk buying and promotion. And any self respecting geek will want one of these over a stock G5

    As someone else pointed out, these are refurbished by Apple and then sold through MacMall. VT isn't selling them, but traded them back in to Apple for credit towards the Xserves.

    --
    Life is short: void the warranty.
  6. Definintely charging for celebrity by mactari · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Apple's online store is charging $2399 for refurbed dual G5s, and the student store's price for a new dual G5 is $2699, $100 less than the MacMall refurbs from Tech. You can even take $26 more off for getting rid of the internal mode, which the supercomputer refurbs don't have either.

    Even if you add the extra 512 megs of RAM from Apple's site (where prices aren't the best), these Va Tech refurbs are only $100 less than what a student would spend on the same box new. Not to mention these 2 GHz duallies are rated as "Buy only if you need it - Approaching the end of a cycle" on the Macrumors buyers' guide page.

    So not a deal at all if you're a student (though I have to think students at Va Tech could get the inside track on the boxes -- anyone know?) and not a great price for a refurb if you're Joe Schmoe. And not a box with great longevity, relatively speaking, either, if Macrumors has the lifecycle pegged.

    Wait for a processor speed bump unless you're dying to own a little bit of celebrity.

    --

    It's all 0s and 1s. Or it's not.
  7. Re:Radeon 9600s in the servers by clf8 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Ok, everyone keeps calling these servers and wondering why they've got firewire and a nice video card. Apple sells XServe's if you want a pure server. Typically, these machines would be used by some media professional (layout, design, audio, movies, animation) for which these things make complete sense. These aren't XServe's, these are PowerMacs and as such should be loaded to the gill.

    VT didn't buy XServe's to start because there was no G5 version. Now that there is, they are, which over the long run the cooling and power expenses should more than compensate for any money lost on the computer swap deal. Oh yeah, and they've still got the 3rd fastest supercomputer in the world.