Slashdot Mirror


The Power of Sewage

Eridanis writes ""The waste you flush down the toilet could one day power the lights in your home. So say researchers at Pennsylvania State University who last week revealed they have developed an electricity generator fuelled by sewage." Hey, it seems that EA will have to create a new building for Simcity!"

47 of 305 comments (clear)

  1. Just doin' my part.. by grub · · Score: 5, Funny


    Let me at it after a night of Fort Garry Dark Ale and I'll power a city of 50,000 for 2 full days.

    --
    Trolling is a art,
    1. Re:Just doin' my part.. by psichaotic · · Score: 3, Funny

      Man, sewerage is bad enough... Whats leftover from the waste? Super waste? and maybe you could do something with that... and then have super duper waste? So that eventually a leak in the pipes can wipe out half the city? Does this mean we will have to equip each house with high powered turd cannons to shoot last nights dinner into the sun?

    2. Re:Just doin' my part.. by Marc+Desrochers · · Score: 4, Funny

      So, are they going to wire the toilets to the power meter and reduce your rate accordingly?

    3. Re:Just doin' my part.. by RLW · · Score: 5, Funny

      The FDA needs to get with the Energy Department and add labeling that indicates the average Kw out put per serving on your favorite foods.

      Eventually 'Power Diets' (copyrighted by me here and now :-) will arrive; these will be geared toward symbiotic foods stuffs that eaten (and crapped) together produce the best power for you home. Yeah!

      Electric Bran Flakes! - the cereal that makes you regular and powers your day!

    4. Re:Just doin' my part.. by Shakrai · · Score: 3, Informative
      As yet his design is only producing a tenth of what he calculates its potential power output could be. Even so, if scaled up, this system would produce 51 kilowatts on the waste from 100,000 people, Logan says. He hopes to be able to boost its efficiency by increasing the surface area of the anodes or by finding more efficient anode material.

      Hmm... that works out to about 0.51 watts per person. If he attains his promised tenfold increase it's a whole 5.10 watts -- or just about enough to charge my cell phone.

      Not saying it isn't cool but where's the value in this? To quote another line from the article:

      Many developing countries urgently need sewage processing plants, for example, but they are prohibitively expensive, largely because they use so much power. Offsetting this cost by producing electricity at the same time could make all the difference, says Bruce Logan, who led the development team at Penn State.

      Do they really think producing a whole 5.10 watts from one person's output is going to do anything? True it'd be neat to see that electric folded back into the grid (that's 5.10 watts that doesn't have be generated by burning coal or gas) but is this really going to pay for itself? I'm willing to bet that most sewage treatment plants use more then 5.10 watts per person's amount of waste.

      --
      I want peace on earth and goodwill toward man.
      We are the United States Government! We don't do that sort of thing.
  2. America.. by msimm · · Score: 5, Funny

    The most powerful country ever!

    --
    Quack, quack.
    1. Re:America.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny
      "My opinion is subject to change without warning."

      Sen. Kerry? Is that you??

    2. Re:America.. by inteller · · Score: 5, Funny

      yes, but big fat americans can crap out bigger turds faster, so 1 american is equal to about 4 chinese.

    3. Re:America.. by msimm · · Score: 3, Insightful

      It looks like more people took offense to this then I'd imagined. I was joking, but think about it a little. Americans may not 'all be full of shit' but as a wealthy consumer nation I think it would be hard to argue that we don't produce a good deal of solid waste.

      Moderation +1
      60% Funny
      20% Overrated
      10% Flamebait
      Extra 'Funny' Modifier 0

      My extra karma modifier didn't even bother to take effect! You guys should be ashamed of yourselves. ;-)

      --
      Quack, quack.
  3. Well THAT explains... by goldspider · · Score: 4, Funny
    ...why the campus always smelled like shit!

    Seriously, I went to school there. I thought it was all of the surrounding farmland that contributed to the odor, but this is indeed news to me!

    --
    "Ask not what your country can do for you." --John F. Kennedy
  4. What if.. by Trystansr · · Score: 5, Funny

    you go on vacation or something? Would you have to pay someone to come over and use your bathroom to keep the fridge running?

    1. Re:What if.. by drooling-dog · · Score: 4, Funny

      I just want something I can shove up my ass to keep my laptop running...

  5. EA, eh? by Apostata · · Score: 4, Funny

    Quote: "Hey, it seems that EA will have to create a new building for Simcity!"

    Or at least have the raw materials for another of their games...

    --

    This wasn't just plain terrible, this was fancy terrible. This was terrible with raisins in it. - Dorothy Parker
  6. So much for... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    ..."clean" energy sources.

  7. slightly different approach.... by tanveer1979 · · Score: 4, Informative

    I am aware of Bio-Gas plants which are used in villages in India. The Animal waste is dumped into the "pit" Methane is released and it is used for cooking. But I guess this method is more efficent.
    Good for farms where lot of animal waste is there

    --
    My Aurora : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o91ZsGwJYyg
    FB : https://www.facebook.com/TanveersPhotography
    1. Re:slightly different approach.... by robslimo · · Score: 3, Informative

      If you have an all electric house (many do) then your central heat and air or baseboard heaters would get pretty close to that range. Add in hot water heaters and electric ranges, then YES, it's very easy to hit that kind of usage.

    2. Re:slightly different approach.... by qtp · · Score: 4, Informative

      Locate the plant where the waste is being treated, like they do already in Lithuania Germany and Oregon.

      You are already moving the sewage around as it is, so that expense is already there. The waste output of the biogas fermener is much safer than the sludge that existing sewage plants produce, and it can be further composted to produce safe, high quality, organic fertilizer.

      There are also existing farm waste facilities (as was previously discussed here on /.) and existing technology to tap land fills in the same manner. It's energy that can be easily converted to a usable, transportable form (electricity) that wopuld otherwise go to waste. The gasses that are being converted are greenhouse gasses (mostly methane) that are not readily sinkable, and the waste products from the fuel cell are only (easily sinkable) CO2 and water.

      The other implication of this technology that is less spoken about is that it decentralizes the source of energy away from the fossil fuel companies and spreads the profits closer to the community where the energy is being produced, either through lower costs for waste treatment, or through direct profit from the sale of the electricity if the facility is privately owned. This means lower costs for energy and lower trade deficit.

      It's a winning situation for those who live in communities that take advantage of this, and the only people who lose out are the energy companies.

      --
      Read, L
  8. Yes but... by paul_pick1 · · Score: 5, Funny
    The waste you flush down the toilet could one day power the lights in your home.

    Well, yes, but it would be pretty shitty lighting, wouldn't it?

    --
    http://www.switch2firefox.com/
  9. It seems Tom Lehrer was right... by Rexz · · Score: 5, Funny

    Life is like a sewer: what you get out of it depends on what you put into it.

  10. Electricity from Waste by eples · · Score: 5, Informative

    Something similar has been around since the 50's called "digesters" that use natural waste and the methane byproduct to power generators. It may have been invented at Penn State as well, but they are expensive so there are only about 20 of them around the country.

    --
    I'm a 2000 man.
    1. Re:Electricity from Waste by ross.w · · Score: 5, Informative

      IAAWWE (I am a wastewater Engineer)

      Actually most sewage plants have a digester in them (or several).

      Most Sewage Treatment Plants that have anaerobic digesters (the kind that produce methane) simply flare the gas off, because the quantity of gas produced doesn't warrant the expense of setting up to re-use it.

      Seafield Sewage Works in Edinburgh, Scotland does though. It was completed in 2000. If you fly into Edinburgh airport over the Firth of Forth, you can see a row of six large pink tanks near the docks. These are the digesters at Seafield. (The reasons why they are pink are complex and architectural, not functional).

      Bondi STP in Sydney used to re-use methane for generating power the 1960s, but the the technology was primitive, and the sulphides in the gas made the engines expensive to maintain and they were abandoned.

      Now in Australia, with green energy credits on offer, many water authorities are having another look at making use of their methane.

      --
      If my call is important, why am I talking to a recording?
    2. Re:Electricity from Waste by ross.w · · Score: 4, Funny

      You have no idea how descriptions of my work can kill dinnertime conversation.

      I have often found myself having business lunches and having to change the subject, having realised what we were loudly discussing in a crowded restaurant.

      --
      If my call is important, why am I talking to a recording?
    3. Re:Electricity from Waste by kfg · · Score: 4, Informative

      Digesters have been around for about 100 years. During WWII with gas rationing they became quite common, one version even coming on a trailer you could pull behind your car while collecting manure, and then run your car from.

      During the gas crunch of the 70s digesters popped up all over the place and there was hardly an issue of Mother Earth News that didn't have some new design/application of a digester featured in it showing how you could power your farm/homestead on shitty methane.

      There are still thousands, perhaps tens of thousands, of digesters scattered across Americas rural areas. Virtually all of them are built by the owners out of scrap materials for nearly nothing.

      Perhaps there are only 20 of this expensive commercial variety. A lot of companies like to make money by taking old ideas that people in general have forgotten about, plate them in chrome, and sell them as the latest technology for a premium price.

      Go to the library. See if they've got back issues of Mother Earth News from the 70s and 80s. Lots of good digesters ideas in there, although often a bit crudely implimented.

      The mere idea of excrement for fuel energy goes back to God only knows how long. It's certainly prehistoric. The Plains Indian relied on Buffalo Chips for fuel, and the Indian Indian still does today.

      Latrine Officer was one of the most important posts in Napoleon's army. His job? To retrieve human excrement. It was too valuable an energy source to waste. They used it to be able to make their own gunpowder as they traveled, which is one of the reasons that Napoleon's armies seemed to be able to pull off almost magical feats of translating themselves from one location to another and arrive ready to fight.

      Shit is energy. We know that. We've always known that. We've known that that energy can be extracted as natural gases and used to run combustion engines and turn electric generators for over a century. It's news so old it's boring.

      It's even a reasonably viable way to go about making energy, if you live on a small farm with lots and lots of animals producing lots and lots of shit you need to do something with.

      For city dwelling humans, well, it will never be anything more than a suppliment to other forms of energy. Something you can use because it's there, but nothing to be relied upon.

      Why? Well, how much did you shit today? Does that amount of shit convert into the electricity you used?

      Not even close.

      You'll need a lot of other animals who don't watch TV shitting for you as well. Like on a farm, say.

      And nevermind the fact that most of the shit (including human) is more valuable as a fertilizer (which is where much of the treated sewage is going right now) than it is as a fuel, so you're invoking the whole food for fuel argument. It may be better to burn that fuel we can't eat, or use for food production, and eat the fuel we can.

      KFG

  11. Not with my excrement... by dj245 · · Score: 5, Funny

    If they try this with my excrement without a proper licence, I'll sue! Licences for my intellectual property can be bought for just $699. Sure, its shit, but its my shit. I thought about it, and my efforts went into creating it. Bofh Link

    --
    Even those who arrange and design shrubberies are under considerable economic stress at this period in history.
  12. Eat your bean! by RDosage · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Dear, break out the refried beans, the lights are flickering again!"

  13. Shit Happens, but .... by BrownDwarf · · Score: 3, Interesting

    .... so do lots of other things. What happens when someone flushes a pint of paint thinner or weed killer or heavy metal organic compound down the old toilet?

  14. Out to make a buck by Nick+of+NSTime · · Score: 3, Funny

    This reeks of profiteering. We're to be overcome by the stench of people out to make a buck. We work our asses off while fat cats, flush with our hard-earned money, sit on their thrones and pooh-pooh the more environmentally sound ideas. I won't let them dump my money into their porcelain ideas.

  15. Reminds me of an article in Discover by MrPoopyPants · · Score: 5, Informative
    This article got me pretty excited about the future of waste/energy. I'd love to see those piles and piles of junk and biowaste turned into useful energy.

    The conspiracy theorist within me fears that these types of technologies will not take off because oil companies have so much power.

    1. Re:Reminds me of an article in Discover by teeker · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Yeah it was the thermal depolymerization (TDP) process...supposedly perfected by some company called Changing World Technologies...

      I thought that plant next to the turkey-processing place was supposed to be running by now..has anybody heard any follow up on that? You'd think it would be bigger news if it was operating as well as they said it would...

      --
      teeker
    2. Re:Reminds me of an article in Discover by the_2nd_coming · · Score: 3, Informative

      yeah, it was mentioned on Fox news by some Democrats complaining about how money was being "wasted" to turn Turkey parts into energy.

      AFAIK it works, and it works even better for stuf like oil sand, allowing the processing of the petrolium products from the sand which was never possable before.

      --



      I am the Alpha and the Omega-3
  16. Biomass by apoplectic · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Biomass technology (energy produced from waste) has been around since the 70's. Though more specific and more refined than its predecessors, there's nothing revolutionary about this.

  17. Biogas by GillBates0 · · Score: 3, Informative
    India's been using cow dung and other cattle waste to make biogas for a while now. The greatest benefit is that it's clean and a renewable energy resource.

    Biomass Energy is produced by burning the solid Biomass fuels (green plants, agricultural residues, carbonaceous waste, wood etc). Direct burning of Biomass in an efficient manner causes the energy loss. But through Gasification programme , Biomass is converted in to high quality of gaseous fuel through Gasifier power plants. In the Biomass Gasifier , Biomass (a solid fuel) is converted into gaseous fuel, called producer gas formed through a series of thermo chemical process. The producer gas mainly consists of carbon-monoxide, hydrogen and nitrogen gas. The gaseous fuel energy is used in several applications.

    Another reason not to eat beef! Let 'em live and generate shit...err energy.(Just kidding, it's a joke, laugh).

    --
    An Indian-American Hindu committed to non-violent thought/speech/action alarmed by the global explosion of radical Islam
  18. Old News for those in rural areas by backtick · · Score: 4, Informative

    http://www.energy.state.or.us/biomass/digester/dig estech.htm

    Lots of places have these; I see someone say "There are only a few in production" fairly often, but this is incorrect; there are more and more every year. Dairy farms are using them in large numbers, but the city of portland has a fairly large one (see http://www.energy.state.or.us/biomass/fuelcell.htm )
    that processes the residue from 82 million gallons of wastewater a day.

    As an example of the economics, see:
    http://www.eco-farm.org/sa/sa_dairy_synopsis _diges ter.html#eco

    Payback in 6 years. Not bad, considering lots of places give grants, as these help cut down on groundwater pollution. You can have payback in 3 years, and then start making money on the juice you sell.

  19. Another Version of This Concept by G4from128k · · Score: 4, Interesting

    We discussed a similar high temperature conversion in the past. This alternative process uses high temperature/high pressure water to crack a wide range of complex molecules into simpler stuff. It can convert sewage, toxic waste, and animal byproducts into a mix of combustible hydrocarbons, salts, and water.

    The new Microbial Fuel Cell method sounds interesting, but I bet it fails in the field. I'd bet that nasty substances (the odd pulse of heavy metals, detergents, or drain cleaner) would poison the microbial catalysts in this new fuel cell.

    --
    Two wrongs don't make a right, but three lefts do.
  20. Master Blaster Run Barter Town! by enrico_suave · · Score: 4, Funny

    heh... Mad Max 7 Way Beyond Thunderdome

    e,.

    --
    Build Your Own PVR/HTPC news, reviews, &
  21. Uh. by bad+enema · · Score: 5, Funny

    That idea sounds pretty shitty if you ask me.

  22. I work in the sewage industry and this is old news by Phelan · · Score: 3, Informative

    We have been making power with sewage for a very long time, methane harvesting to run generators has been around for years, plants can power their equipment plus sell some surplus...
    or with our product they can do it at a rate that is up to 60% more efficent...
    Shameless plug: Premier Agritech, Inc.

    --
    "Nimis exaltatus rex sedet in vertice - caveat ruinam!"
  23. Re:DILBERT was a prophet by Webmoth · · Score: 3, Funny

    "...Dilbert's Dream of passing IP packets via the sewer system..."

    Wouldn't that be IPoo packets?

    --
    Give me my freedom, and I'll take care of my own security, thank you.
  24. Reality check by Spamalamadingdong · · Score: 4, Insightful
    51 KW from 100,000 people = 0.51 W/capita.

    You're not going to run even one room light from this. You could use it to keep your cell phone and PDA charged, but you could probably do that just as well with generators in the soles of your shoes and gain mobility in the bargain.

    (Yeah, I know everyone's playing this for yucks. You can see me as a wet blanket or a straight man, your choice.)

  25. Conflict scenario... by moviepig.com · · Score: 3, Funny

    "Sewage power!"

    "Wind turbines!"

    "Sewage power!!!"

    "Wind turbines!!!"

    . . . - The Day the Shit Hit the Fan...

    --
    Seeing bad movies only encourages them. Watch responsibly
  26. Biogas is tripleplus good by Jeremiah+Blatz · · Score: 3, Informative

    First of all, it converts waste product into electricity. But secondly, instead of sewage decomposing into methane, it decomposes into C02, which is a much less effective greenhouse gas. Additionally, the resulting by-products make a good, smell-free compost.

    Here's a blurb about a biogas plant in Oregon

  27. Decentralize the power grid and generate your own by kenjib · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I would like to see all kinds of technologies that allow private parties to generate electricity become more prevalent. You can decentralize the power grid and open it up as a peer to peer trading network. It's the logic of the internet applied to the outdated logic of the power grid.

    Put solar, wind, sewage treatment, and other types of generators in your house. Use what you need and trade what you don't. If you've got a shortage then buy back what you need. In January, south africans can sell solar generated energy to russia. In june, russians can sell it back. Private and commercial ventures alike can create power in large amounts by any means and then sell it in the free market directly to end users and other public entities with large energy demands that are all then free to buy from the lowest cost sources.

    Hydrogen fuel cells will also help enable this by allowing the banking of energy for later use and/or trade. Superconductors can improve the efficiency of the whole system and help the private sector economics reach critical mass. Are all of these kinds of technologies going to inevitably converge toward an energy revolution? Between all the bits and pieces it really looks like something is going to come together...

  28. OT question: Why not dual flush toilets in USA? by tetranz · · Score: 4, Informative

    In my former part of the world, nearly all toilets in homes are dual flush to save water. They have two buttons, one gives a half flush, the other a full flush. Its not rocket science to figure out when you need which. An american visitor had not seen this before.

    Now that I live in the US, I wonder why such technology doesn't exist here. It seems like a much better way to save water than the problematic 'low flush' toilets common the US.

  29. Not a completely new idea by Stonent1 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    When I was a kid, my dad worked as a mechanic at a sewage treatment plant. After the sewage comes in, it passes through a system called a digester where it sat. The fumes which were collected were mostly methane gas, that was pumped into giant diesel engines that ran generators that ran the digestion system that ran the engines that ran the... Oh dear I've gone cross-eyed. There was still some solid waste left behind however. It was loaded into large spreaders and spread out on large fields and then flattened out to dry. Though about 90% of the stink had gone local residents still complained. So they came up with an industrial perfume called Roto-ban that was sprayed on top to cover up the smell. Shortly after more people complained about the smell from the perfume than the waste, so they stopped using it. What was left over was collected and sold as industrial fertilizer. You could not legally (in the US) use it to fertilize vegitation used for human consumption, but you could use it to fertilize food used for animal consumption (and then they could legally sell the animals as food). So basically HAHAHA (pointing) You eat turds!

  30. So that's where it goes... by uberdave · · Score: 3, Insightful

    You know, I've always figured there was a problem with all those calorie counting books. A single chocolate doughnut takes a half hour of aerobics to burn off. Riiight! Sure it does. Calories in=Calories out sure. The books all assume calories out=background metabolism+exercise. However, calories out=background metabolism +exercise+waste. They miss this third component.

    1. Re:So that's where it goes... by kfg · · Score: 3, Informative

      Yes, there is something woefully wrong with those books. They are oversimplified for their ignorant target market, oftentimes by members of that target market themselves who have no deep understanding whatsoever and are merely cribbing from other such books with no deep understanding.

      They do ignore waste, such as that found in excrement and the the heat put off by the body, but that's because that waste is of no interest to them.

      Nontheless they do manage to get some of the crude details right. Those charts ignore waste, but not by not taking it into account, rather by simply ignoring those calories not actually consumed by the body in producing useful energy.

      Yes, I can can power myself on my bicycle for half an hour at 15 mph or so on the fuel contained in a single chocolate donut. Three chocolate donuts will drive me at 25 mph for an hour or so. Substitute about three large bananas for each donut if you like. This is one of the reasons I prefer to bicycle rather than drive.

      The human body is an astoundingly wonderous device for turning hydrocarbons into mechanical energy. Just how wonderous can be seen from your own observation, a good deal of the chocolate donut ends up as waste in the urine and excrement, and yet I still drive my bicycle with what I've absorbed for half an hour.

      Pay no attention to those stupid calorie counting books. If you want to the know the real deal, explained in hard scientific fact, but written for the intelligent layman, go to your library where almost certainly find these works:

      Aerobics. The groundbreaking work itself, based on Dr. Kenneth Cooper's work with training in the military.

      Move on immediately to Covert Bailey's Fit or Fat . Covert is formerly a professional sports bum, and currently a Doctor of Exercise Physiology, with an absolutely wonderful way of expressing his knowledge for popular consumption. He's the Carl Sagan of exercise and diet. Read the book, but if your library has his tape series, watch them. If they don't, request them.

      From there go to the bicycling science books of Dr. Edmund Burke (also a Doctor of Exercise Physiology), the record holder for bicycling from Buffalo to Albany, NY (14 hours and some minutes. 320 or so miles). These are bit more hard core, but still intended for popular reading.

      Supplement with MIT Press's Bicycling Science and Engineering. This is a general lay scientific work on human power generation and the bicycle, the most efficient means of harnessing such power.

      If your interest is, or becomes, more in depth than these books cover they are full of references to the orginal studies they are based on.

      Then go buy yourself a bicycle, a treadle sewing machine, a wind up radio and a shakable flashlight. These are the most wonderous of all of man's creations so far. People are lazy, so they have spent most of their time developing technologies to avoid using their muscles, but if you combine high tech with muscle power you can accomplish amazing things, and all without foreign oil.

      Not to mention the benefits to strength, health, and general fitness.

      KFG

  31. Battery recharger? by mangu · · Score: 3, Funny

    If there was a battery you shoved up your ass for recharging, it would come in several sizes: A, AA, AAA, and AAAAAARGH!