Slashdot Mirror


The Subtle Tyranny Of Spreadsheets

pipingguy writes "I found this link on a CAD-related mailing list which questioned the current state of spreadsheet usage. Since using spreadsheets is often only one step away from PowerPoint mastery, I thought it worthy of submission." An excerpt: "The second distortion caused by conventional spreadsheets is more subtle. It's described in a 1980s paper, written by university researcher Jeffrey Kottemann and others concerning what they called 'Performance, Beliefs, and the Illusion of Control.' The paper described an experiment in which subjects were asked to perform a planning task using different tools, some of them with elaborate what-if capability and others without it." Yup, it's a ZD/Yahoo link, but it raises good questions."

16 of 554 comments (clear)

  1. Even more off-topic, by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    anyone else seen what Jon Katz is up to now :
    http://www.workingdogweb.com/Katz.htm :

    "Barbara: In preparing this interview, I read quite a bit about your book called Geeks: How Two Lost Boys Rode the Internet Out of Idaho which is the story of Jesse Dailey and his friend Eric Twilegar. In a sense, I saw some parallels between Jesse and your first Border Collie, Devon, as both were misfits or outcasts of a sort. Do you like writing about misfits and outcasts?

    Jon: You are very perceptive. Devon is to dogs what Jesse is to teenagers..They are both Lost Boys,"

    And his knowledgeability has *improved*

  2. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by T3hSHIT · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    In the year 2525
    If man is still alive.
    If woman can survive, they may find.

    In the year 3535
    Ain't gonna need to tell the truth, tell no lies.
    Everything you think, do and say, is in the pill you took today.

    In the year 4545
    Ain't gonna need your teeth, won't need your eyes.
    You won't find a thing to chew.
    Nobody's gonna look at you.

    In the year 5555
    Your arms hanging limp at your sides.
    Your legs got nothing to do.
    Some machine doing that for you.

    In the year 6565
    Ain't gonna need no husband, won't need no wife.
    You'll pick your son, pick your daughter too.
    From the bottom of a long glass tube. Whoa-oh

    In the year 7510
    If God's a-comin, he oughta make it by then.
    Maybe he'll look around himself and say.
    Guess it's time for the judgment day.

    In the year 8510
    God is gonna shake his mighty head.
    He'll either say.I'm pleased where man has been.
    Or tear it down and start again. Whoa-oh

    In the year 9595
    I'm kinda wonderin if man is gonna be alive.
    He's taken everything this old Earth can give.
    And he ain't put back nothing.Whoa-oh

    Now it's been ten thousand years
    Man has cried a billion tears.
    For what he never knew,
    now man's reign is through.

    But through eternal night.
    The twinkling of starlight.
    So very far away.
    Maybe it's only yesterday.

    In the year 2525
    If man is still alive.
    If woman can survive, they may find.

    In the year 3535
    26397

  3. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    In the year 2525
    If man is still alive.
    If woman can survive, they may find.

    In the year 3535
    Ain't gonna need to tell the truth, tell no lies.
    Everything you think, do and say, is in the pill you took today.

    In the year 4545
    Ain't gonna need your teeth, won't need your eyes.
    You won't find a thing to chew.
    Nobody's gonna look at you.

    In the year 5555
    Your arms hanging limp at your sides.
    Your legs got nothing to do.
    Some machine doing that for you.

    In the year 6565
    Ain't gonna need no husband, won't need no wife.
    You'll pick your son, pick your daughter too.
    From the bottom of a long glass tube. Whoa-oh

    In the year 7510
    If God's a-comin, he oughta make it by then.
    Maybe he'll look around himself and say.
    Guess it's time for the judgment day.

    In the year 8510
    God is gonna shake his mighty head.
    He'll either say.I'm pleased where man has been.
    Or tear it down and start again. Whoa-oh

    In the year 9595
    I'm kinda wonderin if man is gonna be alive.
    He's taken everything this old Earth can give.
    And he ain't put back nothing.Whoa-oh

    Now it's been ten thousand years
    Man has cried a billion tears.
    For what he never knew,
    now man's reign is through.

    But through eternal night.
    The twinkling of starlight.
    So very far away.
    Maybe it's only yesterday.

    In the year 2525
    If man is still alive.
    If woman can survive, they may find.

    In the year 3535
    18105

  4. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by T3hSHIT · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    In the year 2525
    If man is still alive.
    If woman can survive, they may find.

    In the year 3535
    Ain't gonna need to tell the truth, tell no lies.
    Everything you think, do and say, is in the pill you took today.

    In the year 4545
    Ain't gonna need your teeth, won't need your eyes.
    You won't find a thing to chew.
    Nobody's gonna look at you.

    In the year 5555
    Your arms hanging limp at your sides.
    Your legs got nothing to do.
    Some machine doing that for you.

    In the year 6565
    Ain't gonna need no husband, won't need no wife.
    You'll pick your son, pick your daughter too.
    From the bottom of a long glass tube. Whoa-oh

    In the year 7510
    If God's a-comin, he oughta make it by then.
    Maybe he'll look around himself and say.
    Guess it's time for the judgment day.

    In the year 8510
    God is gonna shake his mighty head.
    He'll either say.I'm pleased where man has been.
    Or tear it down and start again. Whoa-oh

    In the year 9595
    I'm kinda wonderin if man is gonna be alive.
    He's taken everything this old Earth can give.
    And he ain't put back nothing.Whoa-oh

    Now it's been ten thousand years
    Man has cried a billion tears.
    For what he never knew,
    now man's reign is through.

    But through eternal night.
    The twinkling of starlight.
    So very far away.
    Maybe it's only yesterday.

    In the year 2525
    If man is still alive.
    If woman can survive, they may find.

    In the year 3535
    1565

  5. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by T3hSHIT · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    16385

  6. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    19792

  7. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by T3hSHIT · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    18570

  8. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    29507

  9. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by T3hSHIT · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    25914

  10. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    5647

  11. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    13767

  12. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    26693

  13. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    1931

  14. The Power of SHIT (Society Harbors Internet Terror by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Behold the Power of SHIT!

    Society harbors Internet Terrorists!!

    Examples: GNAA, CLIT, Trollkore!!

    VOTE TODAY!
    17224

  15. Re:what really, really, annoys me.... by REBloomfield · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    so i get -1, and the two above me, posted at exectly the same time don't? 'tis a conspiracy :)

  16. Idiot mods by Dan+East · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How is this redundant? This post was made 8 minutes before the post rated Insightful that referred to the Edward Tufte PowerPoint story SlashDot covered before.

    Dan East

    --
    Better known as 318230.