Slashdot Mirror


Neowin interviews Ben Goodger, Justin Frankel

mr_tommy writes "Neowin has had the pleasure of talking to two prominent figures in the I.T. world. First, Ben Goodger, chief developer of the excellent browser Firefox, and secondly, Justin Frankel, creator of Winamp and many other products for Nullsoft. We've got Ben talking about Firefox, XUL, and the future at Mozilla; equally, Justin talks (humorously) about his past, Winamp, AOL, music, and what he's up to at the moment. Also, read on for some of his projects he thought about doing when he left Winamp, including setting up an interesting alternative to Windows 2000 based on Open Source software, similar to ReactOS."

80 comments

  1. GNAA interviews penisbird - sodomy reported by (GNAA)Zeikfried · · Score: -1, Troll
    LASTMEASURE: THE TRUE OPEN SOURCE ALTERNATIVE
    Zeikfried - Gnaa, Nigeria.
    In a world where one can get classed as +5, informative for simply being able to use google, and +5 funny for out and out slander against the Microsoft corporation, one could be forgiven for branding the elitist unfunny world of slashdot, and yes, the open source community as a whole, as a floundering stagnating mess.
    But in spite of the high cretin concentration throughout open source, but all is not yet lost, for there is a small highly skilled team of individuals determined to utilise the full potenial that this community offers, the dynamic darkies of the Gay Nigger Associaton of America.

    "This is degenerative behaviour, please stop." is the rallying cry for many in the OSDN camp (now a partly owned subsidiary of the KKK). But what IS LastMeasure? And how did it come to provoke such furious bouts of procrastination and anal masturbation among the forced celibates that bless our members with their -1, troll crowns? Reporter for Reuters Nigeria, and 4 time winner of the Golden Sphincter, Gary Niger, was sent in to investigate.
    "I must say I was pleasently surprised", enthused Gary with his trademark lisp. "I expected a band of negro savages, or worse still, a sourceforge project. But what I found was a group of individuals determined to help spread their ideals of sodomy and niggerdom to the masses, and I must say, though it flys in the face of my trademark press neutrality, I was instantly hooked."
    "But of course, in spite of my new found taste for the holy nigger seed, I would not deviate from my task of reporting the facts on LastMeasure. And it is, quite simply, nigtastic. Penisbird and goat-see have lovingly hand-crafted a javascript masterpiece, a triumph for capitalism, as readers of the communist open source "bastion" slashdot now have their gay porno viewing habits broadcasted to their colleagues and classmates, hopefully this will encourage them to finally stop eating and start working, and get their worthless jobs back from the curry eaters. Godspeed GNAA."

    With LastMeasure (currently at version 3.3), the proud patriots of the GNAA have dealt a crippling blow to the communist practices of the google toolbar and it's anti-american ways of blocking the victory of capitalism and the free market over terrorism.

    With LastMeasure, the dying world of the internet shock site has gained new vigour, allowing the benevolent rulers of our collective digital universe, Bob Goatse and Tubgirl, to be brought to many desktops throughout /.

    Wherever there is an unpatched YaBB clone fleecing money off ill-prepared webadmins. There is LastMeasure.

    Wherever there is a poorly prepared IRC server being used as a shell for the important task of bringing camwhoring and masturbation to the free world. There is LastMeasure.

    Wherever GNU/Linux is not being used to its FULL POTENTIAL. There is LastMeasure.

    Wherever a +5 is struck on the head of those who would use it against the greater good. There is LastMeasure.

    Whenever these ENEMIES OF FREEDOM gather, there will be LastMeasure, and the proudly gay negros of the Gay Nigger Association of America, your TRUE OPEN SOURCE ALTERNATIVE.

    FAQ:

    Q. I am a proud supporter of open source, and would like to be a regular user of LastMeasure. However I can't seem to gain the full effect of your wonderful software, what could I be doing wrong?
    A. While your zealotism is most welcome, it would appear that you are using the incorrect browser. Firefox and Opera are both major offenders, the GNAA recommend the Microsoft(TM) corporations Internet Explorer(TM) to halt the spread of communism, and to be able to use our software

  2. second post by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    come ON people, wake up

  3. Keeping A Close Eye on Justin by lotsofno · · Score: 4, Informative

    Justin actually updates his weblog regularly. It's well worth checking out just to see what he's been up to lately.

    Winamp Unlimited also does a good job of tracking down any online activities with the Nullsoft staff, or any Winamp/NS-related projects that might be brewing.

  4. Atticus Finch by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    is a nigger lover.

  5. Two people who have made an impact.... by Gopal.V · · Score: 4, Insightful

    As I listen to my CDs with Winamp and browse slashdot with FireFox 0.8 ... I've almost forgotten the people who made it possible... it's become second nature ... Thanks for reminding me :) Especially about the part about Justin Frankel using Vim... And maybe this was a first post ?... (but I did read the articles)

    1. Re:Two people who have made an impact.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait
      Especially about the part about Justin Frankel using Vim.

      Yeah that surprised me, I mean a coder quantifying their turds is normal but a coder using a text editor like Vim... Whoaa Far out. Most unusual.

    2. Re:Two people who have made an impact.... by MikeCapone · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Good point. Gratitude is the *least* we can do, that and constructive criticism to make good/great projects even better.

      And a few donations here and there are cool too, of course.

  6. Neo by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I thought he died at the end of the movie

  7. iPod Plugin by Will+Fisher · · Score: 5, Informative

    "I have an iPod, and I must say I do love the iPod (btw, the iPod Winamp plugin rules, too -- I can't stand iTunes, either)."

    To find out more about this, go to mlipod.sf.net

    --will
    mlipod developer

    1. Re:iPod Plugin by lotsofno · · Score: 3, Informative

      Winamp featured this iPod plug-in not too long ago in this hilarious article: Have Winamp, Will Travel.

      This seriously is an awesome plug-in. It does pretty much everything I want it do with my iPod (file/playlist transfers, syncing, media management, etc..), except integrated with the media library in Winamp, which I much prefer over iTunes' interface. It even has a few features that other apps like ephpod doesn't have. The ads are great, too.

    2. Re:iPod Plugin by Microlith · · Score: 1

      I'd be happy if it converted various non-alphabetic characters (like Japanese) to the proper Unicode encodings, and could display said unicode in the media library.

      Handling my iPod is about the only thing winamp doesn't do with my music collection (well that and rip, which is done by EAC and LAME.)

      This plugin is nice, unless you speak/read/understand non-european languages.

    3. Re:iPod Plugin by Will+Fisher · · Score: 1

      I'm afraid thats a limitation imposed on us by winamp.

    4. Re:iPod Plugin by Microlith · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Ogg uses unicode tags and those display fine (except in the media library.)

      So what's the difference between the reader in the playlist and main player, and the media library?

      Really it's quite sad, it'd be nice if winamp were... fixed.

  8. OMG FRANKEL IS DROPPING SHIT LIKE A PIGEON by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    smacking babies at they Christening. . .

  9. NSIS is pretty sweet by harikiri · · Score: 4, Informative
    I haven't to-date investigated what other alternatives there are for windows-based installers, but these nullsoft guys have made one available free.

    Definitely something useful for small developers who can't afford an installshield license.

    --
    Man watching 6 MSCE's around a sun box, looks alot like the opening scene's of 2001:space odyssey...
    1. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by the+unbeliever · · Score: 1

      Back before Thunderbird and Firefox had installer programs, I would actually create installers using NSIS to distribute it to my less than tech savvy friends. It even came with uninstall capabilities. It's pretty sweet.

    2. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by Richard_L_James · · Score: 2, Informative

      I did investigate purchasing alternative installers to NSIS for my own use, however I soon realised I couldn't find anything better in terms of cost and it's powerful functionality. If you download NSIS then I recommend downloading HM NIS Edit also as it's wizard is very useful for knocking up quick installs. Just in case any of these guys happen to see this post: "a very big thank you for these excellent tools".

    3. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by txsable · · Score: 3, Informative

      Don't forget InnoSetup (http://www.jrsoftware.org/). It's also free, and the source is available, and it's extrememly flexible and scriptable. Also, it doesn't advertise itself on the install window....

    4. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by Richard_L_James · · Score: 1
      Thanks for that... missed that one! Just been browsing through Jordan's website and some of the files. I agree another good low cost installer.

      it doesn't advertise itself on the install window....

      Hehe!! It is fairly faint :)

    5. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by Mitchell+Mebane · · Score: 1

      There's also Inno Setup.

      --

      The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet.
      --Aristotle
    6. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by killjoe · · Score: 1

      DOes it build MSI files yet?

      I really feel bad for people trying to develop for the windows platform. As soon as you put something out MS kicks the chair underneath your.

      --
      evil is as evil does
    7. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      NSIS doesn't advertise itself either. Use this directive:

      BrandingText " "
    8. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by bigwang · · Score: 1

      It was better when it was called PIMP. I was saddened to find out that they changed the name. =(

    9. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by anti-trojan · · Score: 1

      If you have a relatively small application, MSI is overkill. You have to include the up-to-date Windows installers too (2 different versions, ~1 MB each) to be sure. NSIS with LZMA solid compression whereas, creates a very small installer executable.

    10. Re:NSIS is pretty sweet by killjoe · · Score: 1

      If you are trying to automate rollouts via active directory they are very important.

      --
      evil is as evil does
  10. Holy shit... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Way too hard to find the legitimate links among the useless other ones - that's what google's for - for those of us who actually want to read the articles.

    Took me three passes (quick, closer, pedantic mouseovering) to find the Firefox guy interview link.

    1. Re:Holy shit... by challahc · · Score: 1

      It's really not that hard to tell which links to click. And I think the whole point of HTML is to link to other relevant pages, so that you don't have to look up everything.

      Way to call attention to your ADD.

      --
      01100010 01101001 01110100 01100101 00100000 01101101 01100101
  11. Some useful background information... by Richard_L_James · · Score: 4, Informative

    ... about Justin and Ben.

  12. Winamp poo plugin by raistphrk · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    "Professor Shatz, how much did I shat today?"

    So now you won't just know how much llama ass Winamp whoops, but also what came out of that ass.

  13. Seriously worried about Goodger by SimianOverlord · · Score: -1, Troll

    I'm not sure Ben Goodger is the type of guy I want running my favourite browser. His homepage (and the Firefox Texturiser default bookmark page) offers his extension "Magpie" (I'm not giving the URL) which should more accurately be called "MagPorn" or "Shagpie" perhaps.

    It is an extension to ease allow the downloading of particular file extensions to time stamped folders...particularly streamlined for the downloading of vast amounts of images from online picture galleries. Now what do you think *THAT'S* going to be used for?? Hmmm...I wonder...NOT!

    Mr Goodger is helping people degrade women. He is feeding abnormal psyches by helping them amass vast collections of pr0n. Women instinctively know which men are using porn. That's why you can't get a girlfriend. It's obvious in the way you look at them.

    Goodger is helping the violation of women, and I for one think it's morally degrading and physically disgusting. I don't know him, perhaps he's merely a naive, sweet young man. But he should stop development of this psychologically damaging extension.

    --
    Meine Schwester ist sehr, sehr reizvoll - Nietzsche
  14. MODS: RTFA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Justin does indeed measure his poo, look at his answer to the final question! it is ironic that the OP was surprised by a coder using Vim when he discloses this in the same interview. It never surprises me obvious you have to make something for the mods to get it.

  15. Professor Shatz by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    It is so ironic that Justin is joking about Professor Shatz given how full of sh*t he is. WinAmp an extension of Tom Pepper's Mac interface? C'mon!

  16. waitaminute by davejenkins · · Score: 3, Insightful

    ...make a well funded ($400M or more) startup that would develop something like ReactOS-- specifically, a win2k compatible (driver, application, UI, filesystem, everything) OS. You could base it on a lot of open source code, but make a commercial product....And do it all in 2 or 3 years.

    Riiiight. Commercial product off of OSS.
    Well, Red Hat has been trying that for 8 years now, and, while succesful, the desktop still gives them the willies. At that, RH is the only realy company to make OSS fly, and even that required "subscription" licence voodoo dealing with the GPL.

    Don't get me wrong-- I loved WinAmp back in the day. But making a W2K replacement just for the sake of it will never work financially-- what OEM would preload that? Which IHV would really REALLY risk pissing off MS just to save the few bucks they pay in royalties to MS?

    1. Re:waitaminute by harikiri · · Score: 3, Insightful
      Riiiight. Commercial product off of OSS.

      May I direct you to a few companies/products that seem to be doing well in this regard:

      I'm sure other slashdot readers can provide further examples. The trick with GPL-based OSS and generating revenue, is to provide value-add (which may be through commercial closed-source tools). Alternatively, the tried and true position is through services, which IBM and HP seem to have figured out.

      --
      Man watching 6 MSCE's around a sun box, looks alot like the opening scene's of 2001:space odyssey...
    2. Re:waitaminute by sangreal66 · · Score: 1

      Apple's MacOS X is not open source. Also, MySQL makes money off their commerical license which is non-GPL. A better example of a profitable GPL'd Open Source product would be Red Hat Linux.

    3. Re:waitaminute by CdBee · · Score: 3, Insightful

      If it was anyone else but Justin Frankel, I'd agree with you. What can I say - he makes things happen.

      --
      I have been a user for about 10 years. This ends Feb 2014. The site's been ruined. I'm off. Dice, FU
    4. Re:waitaminute by killjoe · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Mac OS X is based on open source. Open source saved them years of development time which is just what the parent poster was talking about.

      MySQL is able to sell commercial licenses because their product was GPLed which lead to it's widespread adoption.

      Red Hat makes most of their money off of support.

      I would also add to the list of the parent poster Novell. They in the end might end up making the most money off of open source (second most if you include IBM).

      --
      evil is as evil does
    5. Re:waitaminute by randombit · · Score: 1

      Except Qt was not an open source project turned commercial, it was a commercial project that they decided to give away under the GPL for those who want it. I'll admit that I don't know for sure (not exactly checking up on Trolltech's finances), but I would suspect that most of their revenue comes from licensing the code to people who want to write non-GPL Qt code (similiarly to MySQL in that respect).

      IPSO is based off Linux now, BTW.

    6. Re:waitaminute by xdeadbeef · · Score: 1

      making a W2K replacement just for the sake of it will never work financially-- what OEM would preload that? Which IHV would really REALLY risk pissing off MS just to save the few bucks they pay in royalties to MS?

      Ultimately, I think the quality of the win2k clone would either make or break it. If it really rocked, and was completely solid with room to improve in ways that MS doesn't care about, it could be very interesting. Also, it wouldn't have to be completely OSS, it could be even completely proprietary (not based on any GPL code, just BSD licensed and acquired).

    7. Re:waitaminute by MsGeek · · Score: 1
      Don't get me wrong-- I loved WinAmp back in the day. But making a W2K replacement just for the sake of it will never work financially-- what OEM would preload that? Which IHV would really REALLY risk pissing off MS just to save the few bucks they pay in royalties to MS?

      Considering how behind-schedule Microsoft is on Longhorn, I am of the opinion that this is the direction that MS itself is going to go eventually.

      Here's the picture as I see it developing: MS decides that the current Win32 version of Longhorn isn't going to work, after all. They take FreeBSD 5.x, (whatever the current rev of it is) kernel and all, and basically build a Microsoft-y GUI and a Win32 compatibility layer for it. Nothing is stopping MS from such a move, not even Apple basically doing the same thing with FreeBSD 4.x for MacOS X. Remember, the BSD license does not prevent code from being appropriated, assimilated, and re-released as a proprietary system.

      --
      Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
    8. Re:waitaminute by dasmegabyte · · Score: 1

      My Grendel cluster will beat your Beowulf cluster.

      Let me just say: as someone who has taken 16 credit hours in Old English literature, this is a hilarious sig. Though to be honest, the Beowulf cluster would beat both the Grendel cluster and the mother of all Grendel clusters...and then lose to the Dragon cluster, which I believe uses G5s.

      --
      Hey freaks: now you're ju
    9. Re:waitaminute by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Pst... Credit hours at one institution do not necessarily equal credit hours spent at another. Just say how many classes you took...

  17. You RUINED my LIFE: everyone MUST read this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I'll post this one a href="http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=109118&c id=9270617"> last time sos people can learn from my bad luck. If you're sick of it i apologize, but folk have to know. I changed it a bit so even if you've read before, you might want another look.

    Anyway, I'm a semi-regular slashdot reader, and I get mod points quite a lot. Monday was a pretty normal day for me in the IT department where I've worked for 2 years now. I'd finished my work, and am about to head to lunch when I cruise by Slashdot to see what stuff that matters there is, and I see I have mod points, right?

    So I set my threshold to -1(cause a good mod looks at it all, sometimes good stuff is dfown there), and go into a newish article, and start modding. I see a couple of stuff that ain't funny and mod that. I see a couple of funny gags about clippy so I mod them up. My boss comes in half way through, so I stop what I'm doing and turn round and talk to him. After a few moments, I can see he's looking at the screen.

    Now I hadn't really paid attention to where it was pointing, and it turns out it was on one of those GNAA posts. My boss asks me straight out, what the hells that, or something. I try to explain but he's not satisfied, he reads the word nigger and gay, and he's very dubious of me. He bumps it up to his superior. The next day, I'm sitting in a confrence room speaking to 3 senior boss's trying to explain how come I was viewing a race hate crime website in my work time. I say to them it was my lunchh break which they say is ok then i try to explain Slashdot's like the wild west, at a low level you get all sorts of crazy shit. I'm sweating like mad at this point.

    To cut the long short, by today Thursday, I'm out of a f*cking job. My boss thinks I was posting or reading that shit, and now I've got to find something else in this sh*tty job market. What the f am I going to put on my resume about my last job? I get no fucking refrence at all for 2 years work. My f*cking life has been totally ruined by these crapflooding bastards.

    If your reading this, you gnaa f****, F*CK OFF BACK TO KUROFIN. If your laughing to yourselfs remember that it is NOT A COMPUTER GAME!!. I am in the shed now because of you, and I hope in your dead hearts you will suffer for what you have done to me. i know loads of stuff and i have the skills to take you down.

    I also wanted to say if you're out ther and looking for a talented Perl programmers in the Michigan area, or you just feel sorry for my bad luck and want to get me in for a verbal or physical interview, reply here and I'll give you a contact address, and send you a resume. I am the victim of other people without my professional intergity, and I have leanrt my lesson. Please genuine offers only.

    1. Re:You RUINED my LIFE: everyone MUST read this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      As the author of the grandparent troll, I am willing to offer a sincere apology for any harm caused to your fragile spirit by my Open Source advocacy.
      To contact me:
      1. msg "Zeikfried" in #GNAA
      or, if you're an AIM user
      2. Contact me on my backup AIM account "goatseanusman"

      luv Zeik
      xxx

  18. Atari 800xl! by Ilgaz · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Of course. Another machine by Jay Miner and as usual the sound chip was really undocumented.

    I remember I was almost shocked when I see a friend sampling sound with joystick port, only 10 or 20 lines of 6502 assembly.

    Maybe that pushed him into sound and assembly?

    I even remember the chips name, POKEY. One of the chips in computer history never got used in its all power.

  19. mp3 players by mgkimsal2 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It really does amaze me that nobody else has produced an mp3 player whose UI is even in the same league of decent as the iPod's -- don't get me wrong, the iPod's UI is nowhere near perfect and pisses me off now and then too --but everything else I've seen is just an order of magnitude worse. What gives?
    It's NOT THAT HARD PEOPLE.


    Two obvious points:

    1. Anyone doing anything similar to Apple is charged with 'ripping them off'.
    2. Anyone doing something *different* from Apple is making it 'too complex'.

    IT IS HARD, PEOPLE, to replicate something which people love on an emotional level, differentiate yourself enough so as to not be seen as just a knock-off, and yet have it be close enough to the original to be seen as 'good'.

    Frankly, most iPod people will *never* use anything else because, like pretty much all Apple-buying people, they've paid top dollar and will never think anything less expensive has any merit.

    I do not think the ipod interface is all that hot. Let me take that back - the *wheel* thing isn't. The visual interface is OK (not much you can do there) but I don't like the wheel. Tried both a regular and a 'mini' - can't use either of them very well.

    I'm speaking from the standpoint of a new neuros owner, so yes I'm biased, but so are pretty much all pro-iPod zealots (either reviewers who got theirs free or the early-adopter raving "Apple can do no wrong" crowd).

    WOW - one more thing I just noticed - an iPod owner criticizing Apple! He even says the interface 'pisses him off' now and then! What's wrong in paradise? Why doesn't he design a 'better' one if is so damn easy? He says himself IT'S NOT THAT HARD.

    1. Re:mp3 players by Will+Fisher · · Score: 5, Insightful

      so after justin frankel has already:
      Made media playback rock with winamp
      Made streaming media rock with shoutcast and NSV
      Revolutionised peer2peer software (gnutella)
      Made WASTE ('nuff said)
      Made an installer system that doesn't suck (nsis)
      and other smaller projects (jnetlib, safesex, mlipod, plush, etc etc)

      You want him to make a portable player?

      He's not superman, dude.

    2. Re:mp3 players by ajayvb · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I think Justin Frankel, more than anyone else has earned the right to say this.

      I've been using WinAmp for what, almost 6 years now, and the UI rocks. It is simple, uncluttered, and instinctive. I don't think iTunes or any others out there are half as good when it comes to organizing and playing music (my opinion, of course). The thing that iTunes is really good at is, you guessed it, when you want to buy stuff from their music store.

      Now, if I (who couldn't do a UI for nuts)were to say that...it'd be a different matter.

      The argument you are putting forth reeks of the OSS advocates, who say "if you don't like it, write it yourself!". Well ,some people have different things to do. If everyone who used software were to write their own, the world would have a hard time. After all, you can't eat your own code.

    3. Re:mp3 players by mgkimsal2 · · Score: 1

      Hey - he's the one saying 'IT'S NOT THAT HARD'. Granted, some of those projects have had a big impact on a lot of people. So have the myriad of companies who've developed various MP3 players. He was hoping to raise $400M to develop a win2k clone. If he *really* believes it 'easy' to develop a better mp3 player (one that doesn't 'piss him off' like he says his iPod does) then why not do it? There's more money to be made in an mp3 player than an open source win2k desktop clone (which surely the investors in a $400M enterprise would be looking for).

    4. Re:mp3 players by Tobias+Luetke · · Score: 1

      Gees what a wired post,

      First you accurse every ipod owner of becoming subjective or worse: narrow minded. Then you are suprised that the person you are quoting from is not.

      Ipod has a good interface and does what it does well but in 2 years it will look just as odd as a rio64 looks now or *gasp* a walkman.

    5. Re:mp3 players by jsebrech · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Frankly, most iPod people will *never* use anything else because, like pretty much all Apple-buying people, they've paid top dollar and will never think anything less expensive has any merit.

      I do not think the ipod interface is all that hot. Let me take that back - the *wheel* thing isn't. The visual interface is OK (not much you can do there) but I don't like the wheel. Tried both a regular and a 'mini' - can't use either of them very well.


      Just because the wheel doesn't work for you is no reason to assume it obviously must not work for anyone and that all the people buying ipod's are elitist fashion whores.

      And, yes, I do own an ipod. I like the wheel. I personally think the ipod is a superior mp3 player to anything out there. But you won't see me going around saying all neuros owners are contrarian low-budget poor-taste schmucks, because I know that isn't true and there are good reasons why someone might prefer a neuros over an ipod.

      WOW - one more thing I just noticed - an iPod owner criticizing Apple!

      Apparently you've never read the apple ipod support boards.

    6. Re:mp3 players by mgkimsal2 · · Score: 1

      BUT this is someone who generally *does* write/build things themselves, and furthermore probably has more than enough ability to do it. Rather than complaining that no one else is doing it 'good enough' (although god knows there are dozens trying), if he really believes IT IS NOT THAT HARD, then demonstrate.

      I believe he probably would come to a different conclusiong.

      It's probably NOT THAT HARD to build something *HE* would use, but IT IS THAT HARD to build a physical device to be sold at the consumer level. Anticipating everyone's needs/wants/desires in hardware is a lot harder because you can't flip a few bytes, recompile and say 'download the new version'.

      I'm actually normally against the 'DIY' attitude that most OSS people spout, primarily because, as you say, people have better things to do with their time. BUT, for someone in his position, who probably *could* do something better (at least to address the issues he has with things), and with a winning track record, to simply bad mouth everyone else's attempts *AND* tell people 'IT IS NOT THAT HARD' reeks of arrogance. Maybe he's earned that in your mind, i dunno, but not in mine.

    7. Re:mp3 players by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My God, you are a fucking idiot.

    8. Re:mp3 players by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Stop whining.

    9. Re:mp3 players by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Just because the wheel doesn't work for you is no reason to assume it obviously must not work for anyone

      That would be excellent advice for Apple and iPod lovers in general.
    10. Re:mp3 players by mgkimsal2 · · Score: 1

      Just because the wheel doesn't work for you is no reason to assume it obviously must not work for anyone and that all the people buying ipod's are elitist fashion whores.

      Read the post again. Nowhere do I say that it obviously doesn't work for anyone. On the contrary - it's selling, and must work for some people.

      However, read comments (or listen to comments) by iPod owners about other players. Invariably, they will end-up bashing the other player, on 'ease of use' or 'intuitiveness' or something else. The wheel is indicative of that, as it's the most different design element in comparison with other players.

      No, I don't read Apple support boards. Most of my Apple owning friends claim that you don't *need* support with Apple products because "they just work", but that's another story.

      I didn't say iPod owners were elitist fashion whores.

      My whole point on this was that the subject of the article was stating that IT IS NOT HARD to build an MP3 player that would be superior to the iPod. I certainly do not believe it is not hard - in fact, I believe it would be very difficult. 'Superior' is obviously relative, but combining all the good features of all the players out there into one unit hasn't happened yet, and won't for a long time (if ever).

      My point wasn't criticizing Apple or the iPod, but I was criticizing the backseat hardware designer attititude displayed by the subject of the article.

    11. Re:mp3 players by xdeadbeef · · Score: 1

      "IT IS HARD, PEOPLE, to replicate something which people love on an emotional level, differentiate yourself enough so as to not be seen as just a knock-off, and yet have it be close enough to the original to be seen as 'good'."

      But you're missing the point. A decent UI should be somewhat usable (in control and speed) and somewhat powerful. Many portable devices these days are neither. Getting a decently fast, decently usable UI that is decently powerful is EASY. If you spend any time on it, anyway. Trying to replicate the iPod's UI is not what was meant.

    12. Re:mp3 players by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I agree that iTunes is bloated and doesn't behave well by default (at least in Windows). I agree that Winamp is way better than iTunes as a music player, etc, etc.

      But I also believe that Justin Frankel was completely frustrated for not being able to take Winamp even further. Try foobar2000. Don't give up after you see the interface (most new users are scared by the absence of skins :-O ) Try using it for some days. Check some third-party plugins and some alternative formatting strings. And, even more important, its audio capabilities. It has built-in support for every major lossy audio format out there (MP3, Ogg Vorbis, Musepack, AAC, etc) and also features ReplayGain, proper dither, supports all major tagging systems properly and it's completely customizable.

      BTW, foobar2000 is developed by Peter Pawlowski that once worked for Nullsoft (Winamp's current default output plugins were made by him - check the about box). I guess he just got tired of Nullsoft/AOL corporate inertia.

  20. I can help by W32.Klez.A · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    email me at lysol(at)meatox.net

  21. Official GNAA Response by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    Hi, my name is Penisbird, one of the founding members of the Gay Nigger Association of America (one of the larger endowed members).

    I really regret what has happened to you. As a token of my sincereness, I would like to offer you a programming posistion for our new recruitment and dating website.

    If you are interested, you can take a look at www.gnaa.us and stop by our IRC channel #GNAA on irc.metawire.org.

  22. OT: Mysterious headline by tfbastard · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I swear I had to read the headline three times before I could read Ben's name correctly.

    All that came up was "badger". That joke has gone too far.

    Sorry Ben! Love the browser you work on though.

  23. Good ol' troll! So reliable! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Yes!

  24. Usability whining from Winamp author! What next? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    > It really does amaze me that nobody else has
    > produced an mp3 player whose UI is even in the
    > same league of decent as the iPod's

    I haven't used an Ipod so can't comment on it, but HONESTLY, is this the guy who did Winamp speaking?! That ugly nonsense of UI, with non-standard microscopic buttons (chained!) and almost no keyboard shortcuts and next-to-unusable selection behavior in the song list and so many usability quirks I don't even know where to start? Man, it's laughable.

  25. funny definition of prominent by SuperBanana · · Score: 0, Troll
    Neowin has had the pleasure of talking to two prominent figures in the I.T. world. First, Ben Goodger, chief developer of the excellent browser Firefox, and secondly, Justin Frankel, creator of Winamp and many other products for Nullsoft.

    Aside from occasionally coming up with some cute, trendy toy to piss off AOL, could someone explain how exactly Justin Frankel is "prominent" in the "IT world"?

    1. Re:funny definition of prominent by IncohereD · · Score: 1

      Aside from occasionally coming up with some cute, trendy toy to piss off AOL, could someone explain how exactly Justin Frankel is "prominent" in the "IT world"?

      Anyone who went to university in the last 5 years has probably had WinAmp on their computer for at least 50% of that time. And a lot of them 100%.

      Not to mention that Gnutella was the first non-centralized P2P protocol, and although it didn't work out all that well in the end, it provided a starting point for research in the real world.

      And WASTE is just awesome.

    2. Re:funny definition of prominent by rkaa · · Score: 1

      I too find the use of "prominent" unsuitable in this context. Ben Goodger and a handful friends merely nicked the work of hundreds of Mozilla developers and testers. "We're standing on the shoulders of a Giant" Goodger wrote - with his head in the sky and an unusually clouded vision. Firefox code isn't optimized like he claims. All optimization has till now happened in the Seamonkey code first. Firefox' contribution to "new" is mostly hype, headlines and funny name changes. Oh.. and new graphics! They are nice. But they don't make Firefox faster. If Firefox is at all measurably faster it's because they ripped out fat features and intestines alike. But the diet smell of politics and stopwatches. "Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain". "We've slimmed it down - Now reinstall it!"

      Cause as it turns out: An equal amount of implants are required to compensate for the digital liposuction. You loose some, you win some. Rejoice: Even the GO-button is an extention now! Firefox "developers" most innovative contribution to the browser is a tool to repair broken installations. Broken by the very "extentions" needed to replace the features they ripped out. Lucky end user. He now has to update not only the browser, but also a shitload of addons for each upgrade. Or of course pay the price: Bugs galore.

      Less isn't more, Ben Goodger. Less is just bloody less.

  26. Mod Parent +1 Funny by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It is too bad that what should be +1 Funny was modded -1 Flamebait because the other mods can't read the article.

  27. Wix XML Installer is comparable as well... by networkGhettoWhore · · Score: 1

    The Wix Project which was the first project to be released by microsoft as free code, is an XML based windows installer suite. This is a good alternative to Nullsoft's if you are looking for something a little more hands on.

    The project can be found at http://wix.sourceforge.net

    --
    Natural Selection: self-destruction of the poor and lazy
  28. New XUL features by pherthyl · · Score: 1

    I can't wait until they have a well documented standalone XUL runtime. I would love to have more info on using XUL as a cross-platform GUI toolkit.

    Also, does XUL have any vector capabilities? Or does this solely depend on the underlying graphics system's support?

    1. Re:New XUL features by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      no... but you could use svg with it.. since it's XML as well

  29. Re:Usability whining from Winamp author! What next by xdeadbeef · · Score: 1

    ...almost no keyboard shortcuts... You're kidding me?

  30. New XUL features-Books. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Then I recommend getting the book. As well as looking at the online o'rielly book.

  31. MS already did unix... by sp0rk173 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    And they fudged it. Xenix, my (wo?)man. I honesty think microsoft has invested too much time and money into their own API's to ditch the core of it now. And if they do take FreeBSD's code, i'm not sure how that would be a bad thing. FreeBSD will live on. Microsoft will (for a change) have a solid code base. If MS feeds patches back in, great. The FreeBSD coders won't submit crap code (forgoing any kind of "fuck you, open source bitches!" code). If MS sends nothing back, meh - big deal.

    One thing that people seem to never realize (or just plain ignore) about FreeBSD is that it's all about research and putting out a good, rock-solid OS. They don't want to take over the world and displace the big boys.

    Look what you've did, you've gone and pulled me off topic.

  32. Comparable mp3 player UI by sp0rk173 · · Score: 1

    I don't know if you've used the Rio Karma before, but it has a fairly intuitive UI. All the navigating is pretty much down with it's sexy little red nipple. It's actually kind of a turn on to use. It's all one-finger navigation, hierarchical menus with the most used menus at the top (it's not per-use based and dynamic, they're statically placed, but the placement seems pretty intelligent). I even broke the little scrolly wheel dealie on the side, and it still is completely usable just with that one nipple do-dad. Of course, it could be that I payed over $300 bucks for it, so i feel obligated to like it. I've used an iPod before and...i wasn't really that impressed.

    And the karma plays FLAC, WMA, and ogg along with mp3. It's a nice little machine. Go buy one today! *thumbs up, tongue in cheek*

    But seriously, it is a nice little machine.

    Oh, and i do realize this has nothing really to do with it's parent, but i thought i'd throw it out there. A comprable product DOES exist. You don't have to just buy an iPod.

  33. Re:Usability whining from Winamp author! What next by dytin · · Score: 1

    ...and almost no keyboard shortcuts...

    Maybe you're thinking of Winamp3? Because Winamp2/5 has plenty of keyboard shortcuts. Winamp5 even has unviversal shortcuts. Justin Frankel had nothing to do with Winamp3.

  34. Downhill from MS WXP? by leandrod · · Score: 1

    I wonder what he meant that it is all downhill from MS WXP...

    Does he mean he thinks MS 'quality' has gone down -- never touched MS WXP, but I know some usually quite reliable people who vouch MS WXP is less stable than MS W2K on white boxen -- and he expects for some reason -- which? -- to get even worse?

    Or is it about DRM, Treacherous Computing and the such?

    --
    Leandro Guimarães Faria Corcete DUTRA
    DA, DBA, SysAdmin, Data Modeller
    GNU Project, Debian GNU/Lin
    1. Re:Downhill from MS WXP? by 0racle · · Score: 1

      XP is 2000, only with an optional new UI. Anyone who likes 2000 and hates XP is talking about the UI and hasn't realized you can turn it off, or they don't know what they're talking about at all.

      --
      "I use a Mac because I'm just better than you are."
    2. Re:Downhill from MS WXP? by leandrod · · Score: 1
      > XP is 2000

      NT.

      Choose Not True or MS WNT, both will make sense.

      There are new drivers, new modules, new bug fixes besides the UI. All these could introduce regressions.

      --
      Leandro Guimarães Faria Corcete DUTRA
      DA, DBA, SysAdmin, Data Modeller
      GNU Project, Debian GNU/Lin
  35. Winamp's UI: Warning I will go into Tangents by tyrione · · Score: 1

    Compared to say the straight-forward CDPlayer.app for NeXTSTEP I always thought WinAmp was crap, but compared to Microsoft was 24K crap.

    Interviewing a person who programs the application that competes with another application to give objective, indifferent,non-emotionally tied observations is like asking Steve Jobs to compare NeXT to Apple.

    If you can't guess already, all the sleekness and class of computer styling went into NeXT, unfortunately at a time when people couldn't appreciate its grace.

    Now we get a advice about UI design from someone who definitely wouldn't be in the same class as a Keith Ohlfs, but I guess if you can't reach Keith Olhfs for commentary I guess a programmer will do.

    Personally, peer2peer doesn't turn my crank, nor does any audio application. I own a home stereo for that crap. If I'm on the go its called a car stereo. If it's bipedal than its a portable player.

    What do all these items have in common? None of them involve overkill software that doesn't KISS.

    Simplicity in form and function are two Mech. Engineering principles that are embedded within the iPod's design paradigm. If you can't see that than the odds are you wouldn't know how to distinguish one suit that is made by Gucci and another one straight off the rack from The Men's Wearhouse. You don't see the hero of Firefox or WinAmp gracing the cover of TIME Magazine, or GQ or various high profile marketing campaigns. You either have an innate ability to create style or you just cheaply copy it and nitpick it as being technologically inferior because it lacks certain "features" only a tech nerd considers important.

    Ask your girlfriend, if you have one, or better yet a wife if she gives a rat's rear about Ogg Vorbis or all the extra crap littered inside WinAmp, XMMS and myriad other players.

    The odds are not in your favor they will, unless of course she's a female extension of yourself that lives and breathes programming.

    Personally, I don't graze for women in the same profession I am in. It just isn't good business.

    On a side note as both an Mech. Engineer and a developer, what the hell is with the Visualizer module in so many players? If I'm listening to Halford or Judas Priest, Iron Maiden, Queensryche, RUSH or what have you I sure as hell am not Siddin' out to a Visualizer. Whatever floats your boat I suppose.

  36. A little bit of clarification about winamp history by kiberovca · · Score: 1

    Before you all continue talking about how winamp is great and all, I think you should know that the history is not so nice. Especially when Justin Frankel says "In 1997 I ported AMP (a free mp3 decoder at the time)". AMP code was free for non-commercial use, but...

    Check out this and this and this.

    What Frankel "forgot" to mention is that Nullsoft made money without even mentioning that they used AMP code, and only after they got sued, Nullsoft "admitted" that they used "a bit of AMP code" which just so happens that it's an important part of the decoder thingie...

    So, all is well in corporate world... :|

    --
    Eric: "What're quantum mechanics?"
    Rincewind: "I don't know. People who repair quantums, I suppose."