Slashdot Mirror


SETI Finds Interesting Signal

Several readers sent in notes about an interesting signal discovered by SETI. No real evidence of Someone Out There, but not fully explainable either. Another reader submits a blurb suggesting that aliens should send spacemail, not signals: "Rutgers electrical engineering professor, Christopher Rose, has an article on Nature magazine's cover today describing the most efficient way for our civilization to be discovered by aliens. On this question of better to 'write or radiate', his conclusions: better not to send radio transmission, when physical media like DNA on an asteroid can declare a terrestrial presence. Similar to what motivated Voyager scientists to attach a plaque for the outbound trip. Rose has some great information payload sizes as examples (like the entire information equivalent for our global genome fitting on a 100 pound laptop!)."

23 of 816 comments (clear)

  1. Waste of time by LFS.Morpheus · · Score: 5, Funny

    No one's gunna pay attention to us until we have warp drive anyway.

    --
    The space unintentionally left unblank.
    1. Re:Waste of time by iggymanz · · Score: 5, Funny

      and then it will be some boring pointy eared guys with no sense of humor and alien chicks who are never in the mood

    2. Re:Waste of time by G00F · · Score: 5, Funny

      But at least the world will know of logical women.

      --
      The spirit of resistance to government is so valuable on certain occasions that I wish it to be always kept alive
    3. Re:Waste of time by JDWTopGuy · · Score: 4, Funny

      You know you're obsessed with Star Trek when you do what the parent post suggests... and you call cops "Klingons".

      --
      Ron Paul 2012
    4. Re:Waste of time by cujo_1111 · · Score: 4, Funny

      I just hate it when the Klingons have their cloaking turned on and look like shrubs on the side of the road...

      --
      If I point out that you are incorrect, making me a foe does not make you any more correct.
    5. Re:Waste of time by yppiz · · Score: 5, Funny
      As CBG from the Simpsons says:
      Inspired by the most logical race in the galaxy, the Vulcans, breeding will be permitted once every seven years. For many of you this will mean much less breeding, for me, much much more.
      --Pat / zippy@cs.brandeis.edu
    6. Re:Waste of time by mshurpik · · Score: 5, Funny

      Rose has some great information payload sizes as examples (like the entire information equivalent for our global genome fitting on a 100 pound laptop!).

      Great while we're at it, let's also send them a Macintosh floppy disk. To make it fun, nobody tell them if its big or little endian. Anyone in the universe up for some GACTAGATTGAC?

  2. DNA Over Signal by Jack9 · · Score: 4, Funny

    When dealing with the vastness of space, how can you advocate physical over transmission. The article does nothing to describe why sending an object with mass 1/1000000 the size of a planet that we would notice is somehow preferable to trying to boost a signal.

    --

    Often wrong but never in doubt.
    I am Jack9.
    Everyone knows me.
    1. Re:DNA Over Signal by Fishstick · · Score: 5, Funny

      >Why bother?

      Well, it's a feel-good PR thing and it probably cost next-to-nothing relative to the overall project and it maybe it helped get the project through appropriations.

      "Look, here's our interplanetary probe, and oh, we've engraved our likeness on a plaque with a greeting in case anyone finds it! *wink*"

      "Remarkable! What do you think aliens would do if they found it?"

      "Oh, it's likely that an intelligent alien civilization will want to find the makers of this probe and pay us a visit to share their knowledge. Isn't that nice!?"

      meanwhile, just outside the orbit of Neptune...

      "Hey Glargh, look at this..."

      "Oh, how cute -- another one of those 'hey, we are here please come visit' things. What should we do?"

      "You know standing order #412,323.443!"

      "Oh, right -- let's make it look like an accident. Hey, here's a nice, big asteroid in a goofy orbit between the 4th and 5th planet -- just a little nudge... there. Now, in about 100 orbital rotations or so, they'll get a visit they'll never forget!"

      "Glargh, its moments like these when it all seems worthwhile."

      --

      There is much cruelty in the universe, John.
      Yeah, we seem to have the tour map.

    2. Re:DNA Over Signal by Fjornir · · Score: 4, Funny

      Well... Just based on my personal experience I think it would take some really, really, good porn for me...

      --
      I want a new world. I think this one is broken.
  3. Tragic misunderstanding by girouette · · Score: 4, Funny

    Voyager scientists attach a plaque on the outbound trip - aliens attach a plague on the return trip.

  4. Hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    If this turns out to be an MP3, it looks like someone is gonna get sued (it would be filed as RIAA v. Zorack Doe)

  5. Finally! by GillBates0 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Pardon me while I step out to light up my giant "WELCOME TO EARTH" sign.

    --
    An Indian-American Hindu committed to non-violent thought/speech/action alarmed by the global explosion of radical Islam
  6. Re:send engineered DNA by jabex · · Score: 5, Funny

    Oh what are you thinking?!

    Everybody knows that if you send some genetically engineered organism into the vastness of space, it will only return far more advanced - and destroy us for sending it's ancestors to a dark and empty prison.

    Duh.

    --
    Like Teddy with an elephant gun.
  7. Re:SETI finds a signal? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Slashdotted my ass. We were never supposed to know about this. The government cover-up is underway.

  8. Re:face it by Wumpus · · Score: 4, Funny

    How true. Consider that the male image on Voyager had a teeny tiny penis, and it all starts to make sense.

    The other option is a return message on a plaque, depicting a male alien with really large reproductive organs. That'll tell us, more than almost anything else, what sort of mentality we're dealing with.

  9. When the signal was finally translated... by Colonel+Cholling · · Score: 5, Funny

    ...it read "PH1RST P0ST!!!"

    Don't worry, NASA scientists have already modded them down.

    --

    I am Sartre of the Borg. Existence is futile.
  10. Re:I for one... by ozbird · · Score: 4, Funny

    I for one welcome our new enigmatic radio-emitting hydrogen gas clouds.

  11. Decode.c: the signal decoded says... by mikep.maine · · Score: 4, Funny

    Hello Baltzar, Great news! No intelligent life on third planet, but I just saved a bundle on my space-car insurance. Tell the Gecko we'll be over for dinner, 10-4, over-and-out, later buddy, Bizstar84!zirc (no spam) nept.com

    --
    Mike www.sharecube.com
  12. Alien Message... DECODED! by Mulletproof · · Score: 4, Funny

    Dear Sir/Madam,

    Let me start by introducing myself. I am Sub-Commander Qulon Zarg, credit officer of the Trans Galactic Bank Ltd. I have a concealed business suggestion for you. Before the Pulson/Darius war our client Overlord Argus Vader who was with the Gandor Star Force and also business man made a numbered fixed deposit for 18 calendar months, with a value of Twenty millions Five Hundred Thousand Zerglian Dollars only in my branch. Upon maturity several notice was sent to him, even during the war early this year. Again after the war another notification was sent and still no response came from him. We later find out that the General and his family had been killed during the war in bomb blast that destroyed their entire planet. After further investigation it was also discovered that Overlord Argus Vader did not declare any next of kin in his official papers including the paper work of his bank deposit. And he also confided in me the last time he was at my office that no one except me knew of his deposit in my bank.

    So, Twenty millions Five Hundred Thousand Zerglian Dollars is still lying in my bank and no one will ever come forward to claim it. What bothers me most is that according to the to the laws of my country at the expiration 3 years the funds will revert to the ownership of the Episilon Prime Government if nobody applies to claim the funds. Against this backdrop, my suggestion to you is that I will like you as a foreigner to stand as the next of kin to Overlord Argus Vader so that you will be able to receive his funds.

    WHAT IS TO BE DONE:
    I want you to know that I have had everything planned out so that we shall come out successful. I have contacted an attorney that will prepare the necessary document that will back you up as the next of kin to Overlord Argus Vader, all that is required from you att his stage is for you to provide me with your Full Names and Address so that the attorney can commence his job. After you have been made the next of kin, the attorney will also fill in for claims on your behalf and secure the necessary approval and letter of probate in your favor for the move of the funds to an account that will be provided by you.There is no risk involved at all in the matter as weare going adopt a legalized method and the attorney will prepare all the necessary documents. Please endeavor to observe utmost discretion in all matters concerning this issue. Once the funds
    have been transferred to your nominated bank account we shall share in the ratio of 70% for me, 25% for you and 5% for any expenses incurred during the course of this operation. Should you be interested please send me your private phone and fax numbers for easy communication and I will provide you with more details of this operation. Your earliest response to this letter will be appreciated.

    Kind Regards,
    Sub-Commander Qulon Zarg

    --
    You need a FREE iPod Nano
  13. Re:Coral Cache Ineffective by NanoGator · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Here is an article that is un-slashdotted as of 0057 Universal Time. "

    You foolish humans and your 'universal' time. We from Persei Omicron 8 will smash you for your arrogance!

    --
    "Derp de derp."
  14. Re:I for one... by qcomp · · Score: 4, Funny
    I for one welcome our new intelligent extra terrestrial overlords!

    Did I miss something or is it the first time the overlords are supposed to be intelligent?
    That might be something to welcome indeed.

  15. Get a life, you people by Phishcast · · Score: 5, Funny

    You there, you must be almost thirty. Have you ever kissed a girl?