Slashdot Mirror


Games That Raise the Heart Rate

The Rocky Mountain News is running an article by Kotaku's Brian Crecente entitled Fit to Play, about the effect that games with a workout component have on the health of the player. From the article: "...five years later and 100 pounds lighter, Jennsen is a video evangelist in the most 21st-century sense of the word, preaching the fat-melting, muscle-building power of video games to generations that have grown up holding joysticks."

11 of 51 comments (clear)

  1. Bussiness as usual: nothing to see here :p by tibike77 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    So instead of going to the gym and/or buying expensive fitness machines, you buy some peripherial and some game(/other nondescript software) that basically does the same.
    Same thing, only cheaper ?

    --
    By reading this signature you agree to not disagree with the post you just read.
    1. Re:Bussiness as usual: nothing to see here :p by bluGill · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Lets add it up:

      PS2: $150. DDR: $50. Good pad $100. total: $300. (Subtract the cost of a PS2 if you would have it anyway)

      Cheap Wal-mart treadmill/exercise bike: $400. Quality treadmill/bike: $1200.

      Simming pool: $6000. Home Spa: $3000. Sauna (build it yourself): $700. adds no value to your house

      Freeweights, dumbells, bars, various benches: $250.

      Racquetball court $4000.

      Gym membership: $7-$100/month. (the cheapest requires health insurance to cover some of the cost) Has all the above (except DDR) in high quality equipment. And for those who pay with Master Card it also has: Cute Girls working out next to you: priceless!

      The most important consideration is will you use it. If you won't go to the gym you are better off getting your own stuff - if you will use that. If you will go to the gym, then the gym is a better deal because you get so much more for so little money. Add it all up, and even a lifetime of membership won't pay for everything you use at the club. (if you use it all) Any there is no extra storage space needed for all of it.

      Of course some things are free. You can run on the sidewalk/road for nothing. Most parks have basketball hoops. If you don't mind rain/sun/snow.

  2. This is great and all... by Mitaphane · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...until some finds out the code for infinite stamina.

    Everything I know I learned from video games.

  3. As for me and my household... we will DDR by Jerf · · Score: 4, Insightful

    We just got into DDR this Christmas. Money is tight at the moment but the next scheduled luxury purchase is now a RedOctane dance mat, the soft $100 one. We have a cheaper one now and it is now ruining my score from false triggering (just sitting there with nobody on it, it fires) and not releasing the trigger correctly. (I'm on the verge of getting the easy AAA's in Light mode and starting to move up to Standard, but the pad makes that impossible.)

    I think the key is to avoid the Education Game Trap (it's quite similar); the quickest way to a crappy "educational" game is to take the same-old, same-old and bolt it on to one of the Stardard Generic Game Frameworks. "Answer this math question to advance one space closer to the end." Woohoo, mommy can I please play "Advance The Squares"?

    Similarly, I've seen people bolt a crappy racing game onto an exercise bike that in essense consisted of a line advancing forward that you had to stay ahead of, or lose. Woohoo, mommy can I please play "Finish The Boring Task In The Alloted Time"?

    DDR isn't trying to make you exercise, but if you expect to play at the higher levels, you'll be sweating.

    I'd also love to see a traditional car combat or 'kart' racing game that ran on a bike that you could turn, that used your pedaling as the acceleration with adjustable levels. See, the fun would be the cart game, the exercise the means to an end, instead of the explicit and boring goal.

    I thought I didn't like to exercise. Turns out it was the boredom of doing laps that was killing me (semi-literally).

    The real world works like this, too, after all, so this should hardly be a shock. Which is more fun, running a mile for no real reason, or a game of soccer, basketball, or water polo? Why do people insist that exercise has to be boring? That's really a relatively recent "innovation", you know. Maybe there's a reason that innovation has coincided with people dying due to lack of exercise?

    1. Re:As for me and my household... we will DDR by Cthefuture · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I agree with a lot of what you said. I do think part , or most, of the problem is more related to the fact that exercise is hard rather than boredom. It becomes much easier over time and less "boring." No matter the exercise.

      I love playing DDR (actually StepMania) for hours at a time though. I have those fancy RedOctane pads and they do work well. However, I ended up building my own hard pads that I could wear shoes on. You really need shoes to protect your shins and ankles (shin splints hurt). I still alternate between the soft and hard pads depending on my mood, but I use the hard pads with shoes most of the time because it lets me play longer without damaging anything (I also run and left weights).

      --
      The ratio of people to cake is too big
  4. suprise and shock by kevin-cs-edu · · Score: 2, Funny

    What about games that just make your heartrate go up from shock or anticipation, such as Doom III or Counter-Strike?

  5. Re:why not just going swimming? by X0563511 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Not everyone has access to a heated pool and lives in a warm environment all year round. I wouldn't be caught dead swimming in an unheated pool here during winter, it hits -20F at times.

    I prefer swimming in natural bodies of water, but that can be kind of hard with over 2 inches of ice on the surface.

    --
    For large sets, this will be our guide even unto death, for the LORD will work for each type of data it is applied to...
  6. Re:why not just going swimming? by Chemical+Serenity · · Score: 2, Funny


    Actually, if you tried swimming in an unheated pool at -20, you might be caught dead there. ;)
    </p>

    --
    "People will pay big bucks for the luxury of ignorance."
  7. Pads and Kilowatt by bippy · · Score: 2, Informative
    Red Octane sent me their pad to help me write the story for the Rocky and I really like it. The insert gives it a very nice feel and it seems to always trigger correctly. My pad seemed to move about a tad, despite the rubber backing, but that's probably because I'm such a spaz. I didn't get a chance to play with the Kilowatt, but it looks and sounds fantastic. I think it may become the first true blending of excercise equipment and gaming to hit the market. It's built like a high quality piece of equipment, so it costs quite a bundle. I've got a lot more about it in the article, the technology is pretty fascinating.

    Brian Crecente
    Editor
    Kotaku

  8. Why not an exergaming health club? by Teppy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'll tell you, this is a place I would attend daily. DDR is great fun - I've gotten so into it that I built my own studio, but doing it alone isn't as much fun as I'd imagine a health club setting.

  9. Re:Dead or Alive. (oh, wait wrong joystick) by JNighthawk · · Score: 2, Funny

    Why, no, I haven't stopped to consider my "a humorless clod." Thanks for asking, though.

    --
    Wheel in the sky keeps on turnin'.